The best workers’ comp insurer for your Michigan business depends on what you’ll pay each month and how much help you’ll get after an injury. How much weight to give each one comes down to how often your employees could get hurt and how long they might need to recover:

  • Choose the best insurer if your employees do remodeling, restoration or home improvement work, or drive all day for courier or medical transport runs, since those jobs carry some of Michigan’s highest rates and one fall or crash can mean months of treatment. (Compare the Best Insurers)
  • Choose the cheapest insurer if your employees do translation, tax preparation or counseling work, since injuries in that kind of work tend to be minor and rare. (See the Cheapest Insurers)

Best Workers’ Comp Insurance Companies in Michigan

For most Michigan small businesses, The Hartford is the best workers’ comp insurance company, scoring 4.51 out of 5 and averaging $95 a month per employee, 16% below the $112 state average. Every policy it writes includes voluntary compensation and other coverage extras at no added cost, and injured employees get nurse case managers and a network of more than 1 million providers. ERGO NEXT follows at 4.41 out of 5 with the highest-rated customer service of the insurers we compared, and biBERK places third at 4.25 out of 5, mainly on affordability, since it sells directly and adds a waiver of subrogation at no charge in Michigan.

The Hartford and ERGO NEXT are nearly tied in Michigan, with average rates less than a dollar apart. Pick The Hartford if you want more coverage built into the policy and nurse support through a long recovery, or ERGO NEXT if you want to buy online in minutes and share proof of coverage at no extra cost.

Best Overall and for Healthcare and Retail
4.51
$95
Voluntary compensation added to every policy at no extra cost; nurse case managers
Contractors
4.41
$94
Buy online in about 10 minutes; blanket waiver of subrogation added from your account
Food Service and Manufacturing
4.25
$99
No-charge waiver of subrogation in Michigan; sells commercial auto and a BOP directly
24/7 Nurse Triage
4.03
$110
Nurse triage hotline for injury reports; loss control services
Transportation Businesses
4.01
$111
Workers’ comp from partner insurers alongside its own commercial auto

The cards below explain who each of our top three picks fits best and where each one falls short.

The Hartford

The Hartford: Best Overall, Best for Healthcare and Retail

On The Hartford's site
checkmarkpros
  • Nurse case managers for injured employees

  • Voluntary compensation included at no cost

  • 10% off business auto

  • Cheapest for most healthcare and retail

closecons
  • Pricey for construction and transportation

  • Higher liability limits cost extra

COMPANY HIGHLIGHTS

The Hartford is the best workers’ comp insurer in Michigan for most small businesses, because it pairs the most complete coverage of the insurers we compared with an average of $95 a month per employee, 16% below the state average. It fits clinics, care agencies and shops best, with the lowest rate for 44 of 49 healthcare business types and 26 of 39 retail types. Michigan lets you direct an injured employee’s care for the first 28 days, and The Hartford’s network of more than 1 million providers and its nurse case managers can get a grocery stocker with a torn shoulder to the right specialist during that window. Every policy also includes voluntary compensation for volunteers and workers Michigan’s law doesn’t cover, and you can save 10% on business auto when it’s paired with a workers’ comp policy. Where it falls short is price for contractors and transportation businesses, where its rates run 46% and 44% above the category averages, so compare ERGO NEXT for construction work or Progressive Commercial for transportation.

Read Our Review: The Hartford Business Insurance Review

ERGO NEXT

ERGO NEXT: Best for Contractors

On ERGO NEXT's site
checkmarkpros
  • Highest-rated customer service

  • Buy online in about 10 minutes

  • Free certificates of insurance

  • Lowest statewide average rate

closecons
  • Commercial auto only through GEICO

  • Blanket waivers only, usually at added cost

COMPANY HIGHLIGHTS

ERGO NEXT is the best choice for Michigan contractors, scoring 4.41 out of 5 on strong affordability and the highest-rated customer service of the insurers we compared. It has the lowest statewide average at $94 a month per employee and the lowest rate for 35 of 45 construction business types, which makes it a strong fit for trade contractors who work under general contractors. Because a Michigan general contractor can be held responsible for an uninsured subcontractor’s workers, an electrical contractor will usually need proof of coverage before starting a job, and with ERGO NEXT you can buy a policy online in about 10 minutes and share a certificate at no extra cost. If your crew shrinks over Michigan winters, its pay-as-you-go billing through more than 100 payroll partners charges premium on the payroll you actually run. Where it falls short is bundling and contract add-ons, since its commercial auto comes through GEICO and its waiver of subrogation is blanket only and usually raises your premium, so compare biBERK if you want both policies from one insurer and a waiver at no charge.

Read Our Review: ERGO NEXT Business Insurance Review

biBerk

biBERK: Best for Food Service and Manufacturing

checkmarkpros
  • Free waiver of subrogation in Michigan

  • Sells commercial auto and a BOP directly

  • Optional owner coverage

  • Cheapest for food service and manufacturing

closecons
  • Below-average customer service

  • Below-average coverage

COMPANY HIGHLIGHTS

biBERK is the best choice for Michigan restaurants, food producers and manufacturers, scoring 4.25 out of 5 mainly on affordability. It has the lowest average rate for food and beverage businesses at $39 a month per employee, 19% below the category average, and for manufacturers at $138, 15% below average. It fits owners who want to buy directly from the insurer without a broker. For example, a metal fabrication shop whose customer contract requires a waiver of subrogation can add one at no charge, since biBERK only charges for waivers in four other states. It also sells commercial auto, a BOP and umbrella coverage in Michigan, so a food manufacturer with delivery trucks can keep its main policies with one insurer. Where it falls short is service and coverage, both below average, so compare The Hartford if you’d rather pay about $3 more a month per employee for nurse case managers and coverage extras built into every policy.

Read Our Review: biBERK Business Insurance Review

Cheapest Workers’ Comp Insurance in Michigan

ERGO NEXT has the cheapest workers’ comp insurance in Michigan at $94 a month per employee, 16% below the $112 state average, with The Hartford close behind at $95. The cheapest policy makes the most sense when serious injuries are unlikely and most claims heal quickly, as in an optometry practice. It’s a riskier bet for remodeling crews or employees who drive all day, where one fall from a ladder or a highway crash can mean months of treatment and lost wages. A machine shop shows why paying a little more can be worth it. The Hartford charges about $1 more a month per employee than ERGO NEXT there, but its nurse case managers can guide a machinist through a long recovery from a hand injury.

ERGO NEXT
$94
$1,133
16%
The Hartford
$95
$1,137
16%
biBERK
$99
$1,182
12%
Nationwide
$110
$1,322
2%
Progressive Commercial
$111
$1,333
1%
Thimble
$112
$1,341
Less than 1%

Your industry affects your price more than any statewide average, because insurers set a rate for each job classification per $100 of payroll. Across the 408 business types we compared, ERGO NEXT has the lowest rate for 144, mostly construction trades, cleaning crews and repair work. The Hartford wins 128, led by medical practices, shops and office-based services like consulting and finance. biBERK wins 113, mostly restaurants, gyms and recreation businesses, and Progressive Commercial wins 14, most of them driving jobs such as courier and taxi services. Find your industry below to see which insurer charges the least for your kind of work.

How to Get the Best Workers’ Comp Insurance in Michigan

Good workers’ comp coverage in Michigan starts with knowing who you have to cover and how insurers will classify their work. These seven steps walk you through Michigan’s rules, from your first quote to your renewal.

Best Workers’ Compensation Insurance in Michigan: Bottom Line

The Hartford is the best workers’ comp insurer for most Michigan small businesses, especially healthcare practices and shops that want coverage extras built in and nurse support after a serious injury. ERGO NEXT is the strongest pick for contractors and for owners who want to buy online quickly and share proof of coverage before a job starts. biBERK fits restaurants, food producers and manufacturers that want a free waiver of subrogation and their other business policies from the same insurer. Compare quotes from at least two of these using the same payroll and classifications, and choose the one that fits how your employees work and how they could get hurt.

Best Workers' Comp Insurance in Michigan Chart
mglogo icon
WANT TO LEARN MORE ABOUT OTHER BUSINESS INSURANCE TYPES?

Workers’ comp pays for your own employees’ injuries, but it won’t help if a customer slips in your store, a client blames your advice for a loss or one of your vehicles injures another driver. These Michigan guides cover the other policies small businesses usually add:

Michigan Workers' Compensation Insurance FAQs

How We Determined the Best and Cheapest Workers’ Comp Insurers in Michigan

We compared estimated workers’ comp rates from eight insurers that cover Michigan small businesses: biBERK, Chubb, ERGO NEXT, Hiscox, Nationwide, Progressive Commercial, The Hartford and Thimble. The data spans 408 business types in 25 industry categories, and all rates are monthly estimates per employee.

MoneyGeek scores: We rate each insurer from 1 to 5 in three areas and weight them into one overall score.

  • Affordability (55%): Per-employee pricing for the most common job classification in each industry, based on average payroll.
  • Customer experience (35%): The buying process (20%), such as getting a quote, price accuracy and sales help; policy management (30%), such as payroll reporting, audits, billing and safety support; and claims (50%), such as reporting speed, adjuster help, access to medical care, wage-loss payments and how disputes are resolved.
  • Coverage options (10%): How complete the coverage is (35%), endorsements and flexibility (25%), which industries can buy it (20%), and policy terms, limits and exclusions (20%).

Averages and savings: Michigan’s $112 monthly average per employee is the simple mean of the eight insurers’ statewide rates. Each industry average is the mean of their rates in that industry, and each business-type average is the mean of the insurers with a rate for that type. Savings compare a rate with the average at the same level, so statewide rates are measured against the state average, industry rates against their industry average and business-type rates against their business-type average. Rates by business size are averaged across all industry categories. We round dollar amounts and percentages to whole numbers and show the difference in cents when two rates round to the same dollar.

Featured industries and tables: We chose the six industries in the cheapest section from the sectors with the most small employers in the SBA’s 2026 Michigan small business profile, favoring industries where workers’ comp is a major cost. Each table lists up to 15 common business types, or all of them when a category has 15 or fewer. Business-type rates cover seven of the eight insurers, since Chubb doesn’t have rates at that level.

Coverage and requirements: Details on claims support, waivers of subrogation, pay-as-you-go billing and bundled policies come from each insurer’s own materials. Michigan rules come from the Workers’ Disability Compensation Agency, the Compensation Advisory Organization of Michigan, the Michigan Compiled Laws and the other state sources linked on this page.

Our figures are estimates, not quotes. Your premium depends on your CAOM classifications, payroll, claims history and the insurer you pick. MoneyGeek works with some of these insurers through our matching tool, but they don’t influence our rankings or recommendations. See our advertising disclosure and full business insurance methodology for details.

About Angelique Palenzuela-Cruz


Angelique Palenzuela-Cruz, Business Insurance Writer, MoneyGeek

Angelique Palenzuela-Cruz is a Business Insurance Content Writer at MoneyGeek, where she specializes in general liability, workers’ compensation and professional liability insurance. Her work helps small business owners understand how these policies apply to coverage, including risks like customer injuries, employee injuries, professional mistakes, client contract terms and industry-specific coverage requirements.
She primarily covers service-based businesses where liability and employee coverage decisions are especially important, including cleaning, consulting, beauty and wellness, childcare, education, fitness, food service, pet care, repair and maintenance, and other professional services.
Before joining MoneyGeek, Angelique spent nearly 12 years at Guthrie-Jensen Consultants, one of Southeast Asia’s largest management training firms, where she advanced from Training Consultant to Managing Consultant. In that role, she worked with business clients to assess operational needs, develop training programs and present performance analyses to executive decision-makers. She also helped establish Gladwin Training Consultancy, where she served in learning solutions and client service roles.
Her background gives her practical context for writing about how businesses operate, manage client expectations, structure teams and make risk decisions. At MoneyGeek, she applies that experience to business insurance content, connecting coverage to actual business needs.

LinkedIn: linkedin.com/in/ma-angela-cruz

Email Contact: angelique.palenzuela@moneygeek.com


Sources