Updated: November 20, 2025

Advertising & Editorial Disclosure

Best Small Business Insurance: Fast Answers

Below we have summarized which business insurance companies ranked at the top for each of our rating categories (Click each category to learn more about the winners).

Best By Rating Category:

Best By Coverage Type:

You can also click industry and state to learn more about the best companies at the factor level. 

To ensure you make the most informed business insurance decision, we've also answered frequently asked questions related to picking the best company that you need to know.

Which company has the cheapest small business insurance?

Which types of insurance are best for a small business?

How much does small business insurance cost?

What is the best way to buy business insurance coverage?

Best Small Business Insurance Companies

 Overall, the top 5 best small business insurance companies in order are The Hartford, NEXT Insurance, Simply Business, Nationwide and Thimble. Each offer a balance of affordability, good customer service and solid coverage options that can match you depending on your particular business's needs. Click each provider name below to jump to our reviews of each to learn if they are the top small business insurer for you.

Best Small Business Insurer
Best Small Business Insurance Award
MG Score (Out of 5)
Average Monthly Rate

Best Cheap Small Business Insurance Overall

4.70

$85

Best Small Business Insurance Customer Experience

4.60

$100

Best Small Business Insurance Coverage Options

4.48

$97

Best Small Business Insurance For Part-Time Freelancers

4.48

$102

Best Small Business Insurance For Gig Workers

4.45

$94

How Did We Determine These Scores?

Get Matched To The Best Small Business Insurer For You

Select your industry and state to get a customized quote from your top small business insurance match.

Industry
State
The Hartford

The Hartford: Best Cheap Small Business Insurance Overall

*on The Hartford
checkmarkpros
  • Most affordable small business insurance rates

  • Best rated claims process by customers

  • Best overall small business for pet, tech, and contractor-based companies

closecons
  • Business insurance not offered in Hawaii or Alaska

  • Not as strong of a digital experience compared to competition

COMPANY HIGHLIGHTS

For most small businesses with 20 or less employees and under $2 million in annual revenue, The Hartford is the top option. The company is also the most affordable small business insurer on our list ($85/mo on average with 23% in savings) and has the 2nd best customer reputation in the nation with the top claims, agent service score and over 200+ years of experience to back them up. If you are in specialized professional services like accountants, tech, and lawyers you'll find tailored plans built specially for your profession, covering many items that other insurers won't.

NEXT

NEXT Insurance: Best Small Business Insurance Customer Experience

*on NEXT Insurance
checkmarkpros
  • Top customer experience in the nation

  • Best digital experience among all providers studied

  • Great tailored coverage type and amount matching system

  • Lowest workers' comp and commercial auto insurance rates

closecons
  • Some coverages offered by third-party partners

  • Not as extensive coverage options as larger insurers

COMPANY HIGHLIGHTS

NEXT rounds out our number two spot our best small business insurance provider list primarily due to their customer service reputation and ease of buying and policy management. In our study of the company's digital processes through forums and personal experiences of our team, we found that they are seamless, buying took well under 10 minutes and an agent wasn't required, and managing a policy or making claims was easy according to actual customers. They also sport the lowest rates for workers' comp ($69/mo) and commercial auto ($137/mo through Progressive) on average for most smaller companies.

Simply Business

Simply Business: Best Small Business Insurance Coverage Options

checkmarkpros
  • Largest selection of coverage options through their provider network

  • Great digital quote experience

  • Third cheapest overall provider in the nation

closecons
  • Is an aggregator that matches you with coverage, not a direct provider

  • Varied customer experience reputation after buying due to their business model

COMPANY HIGHLIGHTS

Simply Business has the largest partner collection on the internet, allowing you to find personalized coverage with almost any provider in the US. They are also within our top 5 for affordability making them a cost-effective option also. While customer experiences will vary after you buy, Simply Business earned high ratings from customers of 4.6 out 5 stars with many praising them for their agent service, easy transitions after buying and their willingness to accept those that were denied by other insurers.

Nationwide

Nationwide: Best Small Business Insurance For Part-Time Freelancers

checkmarkpros
  • Unique tailored E&O plans to part-time freelancers not offered by other providers

  • Specialty insurer for anyone in agricultural business areas

  • Offers extensive learning resources to help small businesses

  • Above average customer experience in J.D. Power's commercial insurance study

closecons
  • Not available in Alaska, Hawaii, Louisiana, and Oklahoma

  • Least affordable provider on our list

COMPANY HIGHLIGHTS

While not in our top three best cheap small business insurers, Nationwide sets itself apart for specific types of businesses, specifically those who are part-time freelancers and those in agriculture/natural resource areas. Those who work under 26 hours can get cheaper policies for professional liability insurance (E&O) with $0 deductible plans available for certain industries. Nationwide also maintains itself as the #1 largest provider for agricultural business insurance, has tailored AgriChoice farm policies, and their on-site claims handling makes it the best specialist for the industry.

Thimble

Thimble: Best Small Business Insurance For Gig Workers

checkmarkpros
  • Offers the most flexible coverage timelines

  • Easy and fast online application and buying process

  • 2nd cheapest business insurance provider overall

  • 3rd cheapest workers' comp insurance

closecons
  • Not a very extensive coverage selection suite

  • No phone agent service (only through email)

  • Cyber liability can't be bought as a standalone policy

COMPANY HIGHLIGHTS

Thimble rounds out the end of our top business insurer list for small business as a gig worker specialist with an extremely online focused experience. They are the only provider to offer short term policies for as little as by the hour, and for those typically only needing coverage during contracts, events or other temporary work ventures, it is the perfect fit. However, while many customers have a pleasant experience buying a policy, many report issues with getting a hold of customer service to manage their policy or file a claim due to their email only communication requirement.

Best Small Business Insurance By Coverage Type

For those searching for general liability, workers' comp (tied with NEXT) and BOP insurance, The Hartford is the top affordable option. However, small businesses needing commercial auto and professional liability insurance will find a better experience with NEXT.

Coverage Type
Best Small Business Insurer
MG Score (Out of 5)
Average Monthly Rate

The Hartford

4.64

$83

NEXT Insurance and The Hartford

4.58

$69 and $70 respectively

NEXT Insurance

4.73

$72

The Hartford

4.72

$115

NEXT Insurance

4.6

$137

Best Small Business Insurance By Industry

At the by industry scale, The Hartford still comes out on top as the best small business insurance company. While this is the case, the provider does not win for every commercial area and NEXT, Coverdash, Simply Business, biBerk and Nationwide could suit you better.

Below we summarize how each of these small business insurance companies rank proportionally to how many industries they won:

  1. The Hartford: They are the best business insurance provider in 42 industries, particulary for those in pet, tech, and contract work.
  2. NEXT Insurance: NEXT wins as the best business insurer in 23 industries and is top option to those in lawn/landscaping businesses, professional services, and hospitality-based areas.
  3. Nationwide: The company wins 7 industries overall with its best offerings standing out for retail, restaurant and construction related businesses.
  4. Simply Business: 3 industries are best covered by Simply Business's insurance products and is the ideal option if you are a startup, a spa owner or an electrician.
  5. Coverdash: While they only win two industries for the best business insurance coverage, food company owners will find the right coverage with them for a good price.
  6. biBerk: biBerk is the best option for commercial insurance coverage only for veterinary businesses nationwide.

>>Back To Top

AccountantsThe Hartford111
Ad AgencyThe Hartford111
Auto RepairNationwide224
AutomotiveNEXT Insurance111
BakeryThe Hartford111
BarberNEXT Insurance111
Beauty SalonNEXT Insurance111
Bounce HouseThe Hartford111
CandleNEXT Insurance111
CannabisThe Hartford111
CateringNEXT Insurance111
CleaningNEXT Insurance611
Coffee ShopCoverdash263
Coffee ShopNationwide324
Computer ProgrammingThe Hartford111
Computer RepairNEXT Insurance111
ConstructionNationwide324
ConstructionHiscox146
ConsultingThe Hartford111
ContractorThe Hartford111
CourierThe Hartford111
DJNEXT Insurance111
DaycareThe Hartford111
DentalNEXT Insurance111
Dog GroomingThe Hartford111
DroneThe Hartford111
EcommerceNEXT Insurance111
ElectricalThe Hartford111
ElectricalSimply Business252
EngineeringNEXT Insurance111
ExcavationThe Hartford111
FloristNEXT Insurance111
FoodCoverdash263
Food TruckNEXT Insurance111
Funeral HomeThe Hartford111
GardeningNEXT Insurance111
HVACThe Hartford511
HandymanThe Hartford111
Home-basedNEXT Insurance111
Home-basedNEXT Insurance111
HospitalityNationwide224
JanitorialNEXT Insurance111
JewelryThe Hartford111
Junk RemovalThe Hartford111
Lawn/LandscapingNationwide224
LawyersThe Hartford111
ManufacturingThe Hartford111
MarineThe Hartford111
MassageNationwide224
Mortgage BrokerThe Hartford111
MovingThe Hartford111
NonprofitThe Hartford111
PaintingThe Hartford511
Party RentalThe Hartford111
Personal TrainingThe Hartford111
Pest ControlThe Hartford111
PetThe Hartford111
PharmacyThe Hartford111
PhotographyNEXT Insurance111
Physical TherapyThe Hartford111
PlumbingThe Hartford111
Pressure WashingThe Hartford111
Real EstateNEXT Insurance111
RestaurantNationwide224
RetailNationwide224
RoofingNEXT Insurance111
RoofingThe Hartford111
SecurityNEXT Insurance111
Snack BarsThe Hartford111
SoftwareThe Hartford111
Spa/WellnessSimply Business252
Speech TherapistThe Hartford111
StartupSimply Business252
Tech/ITNEXT Insurance111
Tech/ITThe Hartford111
TransportationThe Hartford111
TravelThe Hartford111
Tree ServiceNEXT Insurance111
TruckingThe Hartford111
TutoringNEXT Insurance111
VeterinarybiBERK225
Wedding PlanningNEXT Insurance111
WeldingThe Hartford111
WholesaleThe Hartford111
Window CleaningThe Hartford111

Best Small Business Insurance by State

At the state level, NEXT Insurance comes out on top as the best small business insurer with top rankings in 34 out of 50 states and The Hartford is the next in line with wins in 16 out of 50 states. However, both providers tie in multiple states including Illinois, Indiana, Kentucky, Maryland, Montana, Nebraska, Nevada and Wisconsin. The Hartford tends the be the most affordable commercial insurance provider overall even in states where it does not the top overall option, but NEXT wins out in many areas due to its superior customer service and industries covered.

>>Back To Top

AlabamaThe Hartford123
AlaskaNEXT Insurance212
ArizonaNEXT Insurance312
ArkansasNEXT Insurance312
CaliforniaNEXT Insurance312
ColoradoThe Hartford123
ConnecticutNEXT Insurance412
DelawareNEXT Insurance312
FloridaNEXT Insurance312
GeorgiaThe Hartford123
HawaiiNEXT Insurance212
IdahoNEXT Insurance412
IllinoisNEXT Insurance512
IllinoisThe Hartford123
IndianaNEXT Insurance412
IndianaThe Hartford123
IowaThe Hartford123
KansasThe Hartford123
KentuckyNEXT Insurance412
KentuckyThe Hartford123
LouisianaNEXT Insurance312
MaineNEXT Insurance212
MarylandNEXT Insurance412
MarylandThe Hartford123
MassachusettsNEXT Insurance212
MichiganNEXT Insurance412
MinnesotaNEXT Insurance312
MississippiNEXT Insurance312
MissouriNEXT Insurance312
MontanaNEXT Insurance512
MontanaThe Hartford123
NebraskaNEXT Insurance412
NebraskaThe Hartford123
NevadaNEXT Insurance412
NevadaThe Hartford123
New HampshireNEXT Insurance412
New JerseyNEXT Insurance312
New MexicoThe Hartford123
New YorkNEXT Insurance312
North CarolinaNEXT Insurance312
North DakotaNEXT Insurance312
OhioNEXT Insurance412
OklahomaThe Hartford123
OregonNEXT Insurance412
PennsylvaniaNEXT Insurance312
Rhode IslandNEXT Insurance312
South CarolinaNEXT Insurance412
South DakotaNEXT Insurance412
TennesseeNEXT Insurance412
TexasNEXT Insurance312
UtahNEXT Insurance412
VermontNEXT Insurance412
VirginiaNEXT Insurance412
WashingtonThe Hartford123
West VirginiaNEXT Insurance312
WisconsinNEXT Insurance512
WisconsinThe Hartford223
WyomingThe Hartford123

How Get the Best Small Business Insurance

Finding the best business insurance can be confusing for smaller firms, so we created this step-by-step guide to finding the top choice for your company.

  1. 1

    Determine the best small business insurance types for you

    Before you start looking for the best small business insurance company, you need to figure out what coverage is right for you. Below we've given heuristics to simplify this coverage type selection process:

    • General liability insurance: All small businesses need this coverage, regardless of business industry, since it covers liabilities arising from property or bodily injury damages from products and services.
    • Workers' comp insurance: Required for all businesses with employees and if you are a 1099 employee (except for Texas).
    • Professional liability insurance (E&O/Professional Indemnity): If you do service work in relation to contracts, this essential coverage protects your company from liabilities coming from claims of negligence and not following through with obligations.
    • Commercial auto insurance: Required in all states if you use vehicles for business, for each vehicle you use for commercial purposes.
    • Commercial property insurance: Often required for commercial leases and financing ventures and particularly useful to cover valuable items that are always held as a specific location. Can be bundled as part of a BOP policy.
    • Business interruption coverage (business income): Often bundled in a BOP insurance policy, all businesses with a risk of shutdown that you can't afford should get this coverage.
    • Cyber insurance: If you handle customer data through your computer and/or online, you should get cyber insurance to cover liabilities and losses from data breach.
    • Liquor liability insurance: All businesses that sell alcohol are required to get this coverage.
  2. 2

    Figure out the right small business insurance coverage limits

    Getting the right limits for the best business insurance types is a question of the magnitude of risk in your industry for claims for covered items. For example, you may want less professional liability insurance coverage as a cleaner versus if you were a construction contractor due to the varying potential financial risk for businesses and customers. We recommend speaking to an independent agent on the subject, but as a very general recommendation, we've outlined the following:

    • Any liability coverage policies: Liability policies with $1 million per occurance/claim and $2 million in aggregate generally work for most small businesses. For auto policies $1 million combined single limit liability insurance covers most businesses for all possible issues.
    • Property coverages: You should cover your items up to their replacement value for completely new and comparable property.
    • Business interruption: Enough coverage to cover you for 3 months of interrupted operations is completely necessary while 6 months can make sense in high-risk weather areas.
    • Cyber insurance: $500,000 to $1 million in limits is generally recommended for most small businesses
  3. 3

    Reasearch costs and providers to narrow down your best list

    Get a yardstick for how much you'll actually save with insurers by getting average commercial insurance costs for your business profile and researching savings methods available to you. However, cost is not everything, and looking into customer reputations for buying, policy management, and claims helps you get a more comprehensive view. Also, ensure that the providers you pick for your final best small business insurer list have the coverages you need and tailored options that make them a unique fit.

  4. 4

    Compare multiple business insurance quotes

    To get the best small business insurance pricing possible, ensure you compare at least five company's quotes for apples-to-apples coverage. Depending on the method, your rates will vary also, so split your quote methodology between agents, online comparison sites and provider websites.

  5. 5

    Repeat this buying process annually

    The right insurance coverage for your small business currently may not be ideal as your company as it grows. So, to keep ensuring you get the best small business insurance, review your policies, ensure your provider is up to date with any changes, and keep researching options over time.

Best Small Business Insurance Company: Bottom Line

Overall, The Hartford, NEXT and Simply Business offer the best small business insurance in the U.S. with affordable rates and excellent service. While these are top choices, do your due diligence by conducting cost and company research and comparing numerous providers to find the best option.

Best Small Business Insurance Companies Chart

About Mark Fitzpatrick


Mark Fitzpatrick headshot

Mark Fitzpatrick, a Licensed Property and Casualty Insurance Producer, is MoneyGeek's resident Personal Finance Expert. With over five years of experience analyzing the insurance market, he conducts original research and creates tailored content for all types of buyers. His insights have been featured in publications like CNBC, NBC News and Mashable.

Fitzpatrick holds a master’s degree in economics and international relations from Johns Hopkins University and a bachelor’s degree from Boston College. He's also a five-time Jeopardy champion!

He writes about economics and insurance, breaking down complex topics so people know what they're buying.


sources
Copyright © 2025 MoneyGeek.com. All Rights Reserved