In Tallahassee, Florida, State Farm offers the cheapest minimum and full coverage car insurance policies. Nationwide is the most economical option for families with teens. Mercury provides the best customer service, and State Farm is the best overall insurer, balancing price and service quality. The best fit for you hinges on individual preferences and coverage needs.
Cheapest and Best Car Insurance in Tallahassee, FL (2024)
State Farm offers Tallahassee's cheapest minimum coverage at $534 per year. It also has the best blend of affordability and service, with a MoneyGeek score of 85 out of 100.
Updated: November 19, 2024
Advertising & Editorial Disclosure
Cheapest and Best Car Insurance in Tallahassee
Why Trust MoneyGeek? We analyzed 127,836 quotes in Florida from nine companies, used six sources and conducted original research to rate the cheapest companies and develop a scoring system for Tallahassee insurance providers based on ZIP codes in the city only. Our scores are based on affordability, customer satisfaction, claims experience, coverages offered and financial stability.
These rates reflect the cheapest car insurance quotes in Tallahassee, FL, as of July 2024.
Cheapest Minimum Coverage Car Insurance in Tallahassee
MoneyGeek found that State Farm offers the cheapest car insurance with minimum coverage in Tallahassee. These are the most affordable options:
- State Farm: $534 per year
- GEICO: $595 per year
Meanwhile, Farmers provides the most expensive minimum coverage policy, with an average annual rate of $1,236. The $702 difference between the cheapest and most costly carriers illustrates the significant savings from shopping around for car insurance.
- 22-29
- 30-59
- 60 +
- Full Coverage
- Minimum Coverage
State Farm | $534 | $45 |
GEICO | $595 | $50 |
Travelers | $606 | $50 |
Mercury | $650 | $54 |
Nationwide | $807 | $67 |
Allstate | $866 | $72 |
Progressive | $943 | $79 |
Direct General Insurance | $1,160 | $97 |
Farmers | $1,236 | $103 |
State Minimum Liability Requirements
In all cities in Florida, car owners must adhere to the state-mandated minimum insurance coverages. These are the required limits:
- $10,000 property damage liability per accident
- $10,000 personal injury protection (PIP) per person
If you're at fault in an accident, and your minimum coverage policy includes $10,000 for property damage per accident, any cost beyond that amount will need to come from your pocket.
Cheapest Full Coverage Car Insurance in Tallahassee
MoneyGeek found that State Farm provides the cheapest full coverage car insurance in Tallahassee.
- State Farm: $1,223 per year
- Travelers: $1,321 per year
Farmers offers the most expensive full coverage policy in Tallahassee, with an annual premium of $2,632. The price difference of $1,409 between the cheapest and the most costly options highlights the importance of comparison shopping to save money. Full coverage policies are pricier than minimum coverage because they provide comprehensive and collision insurance that protect against a wider range of incidents.
- 22-29
- 30-59
- 60 +
- Full Coverage
- Minimum Coverage
State Farm | $1,223 | $102 |
Travelers | $1,321 | $110 |
GEICO | $1,477 | $123 |
Progressive | $1,597 | $133 |
Nationwide | $1,657 | $138 |
Allstate | $1,826 | $152 |
Mercury | $1,842 | $154 |
Direct General Insurance | $2,424 | $202 |
Farmers | $2,632 | $219 |
Do You Need Full Coverage in Florida?
Full coverage policies feature increased liability limits. They also encompass both comprehensive and collision insurance:
Collision Insurance: This provision protects against damage to your car when it collides with another vehicle or an object like a tree or light pole. It also covers rollover accidents and pothole damage.
Comprehensive Insurance: This insurance pays for non-collision-related damage to your automobile, such as that caused by theft, vandalism, fires, severe weather conditions or being hit by an animal.
For drivers with new cars, full coverage insurance is advisable to protect their substantial investment. In contrast, for owners of older vehicles, the cost of additional coverage may not justify the added expense, given the vehicle's value. When gauging how much car insurance you need, it’s important to weigh the pros and cons of increased coverage against the risk of being underinsured.
Cheapest Car Insurance in Tallahassee After a Driving Offense
MoneyGeek found that State Farm is the cheapest company for drivers with a poor driving record in Tallahassee.
- Speeding Ticket: State Farm ($1,375 per year)
- At-Fault Accident: State Farm ($1,488 per year)
- DUI: State Farm ($1,375 per year)
Other companies have significantly higher rates for these incidents. Nationwide has the highest cost for drivers with a DUI at $3,665 per year. Farmers is the most expensive after an at-fault accident and a speeding ticket, costing $3,983 and $3,307 per year, respectively. These rates show how driving infractions can impact car insurance rates, underscoring the importance of maintaining a clean driving record.
- 22-29
- 30-59
- 60 +
- Full Coverage
- Minimum Coverage
- Accident
- DUI
- Speeding
State Farm | $1,375 | $115 |
Travelers | $1,843 | $154 |
Allstate | $1,890 | $157 |
Nationwide | $1,952 | $163 |
Progressive | $2,166 | $180 |
Direct General Insurance | $2,424 | $202 |
Mercury | $2,649 | $221 |
GEICO | $2,926 | $244 |
Farmers | $3,307 | $276 |
In Tallahassee and many cities, car insurance rates escalate with the severity of a driving offense to offset the higher risk insurers take on. For instance, drivers with a single speeding ticket pay an average annual premium of $2,895, while those with a DUI face around $3,275 per year — a notable difference of $380. Individuals with driving infractions should diligently compare insurance rates to ensure they secure the most cost-effective coverage.
Cheapest Car Insurance in Tallahassee for Teens and Their Families
MoneyGeek found that Nationwide offers the cheapest car insurance for teens in Tallahassee. These are the two lowest-priced providers for full coverage:
- Nationwide: $2,866 per year for female teens and $3,228 per year for male teens
- State Farm: $3,332 per year for female teens; GEICO: $3,930 per year for male teens
These rates provide insight into the cost of insuring a family with two parents and a teenager. Progressive has the highest annual rate for female teens in Tallahassee at $5,119, underscoring the importance of comparison shopping for policies, especially with teen drivers who are considered higher risk. With a price difference of $2,253 between the cheapest and most costly options for female teens, it's clear there can be significant savings by choosing the right insurer.
- 16
- 17
- 18
- 19
- 20
- 21
- 22
- 23
- 24
- 25
- Female
- Male
Nationwide | $2,866 | $4,972 |
State Farm | $3,332 | $3,234 |
GEICO | $3,882 | $4,159 |
Allstate | $4,000 | $14,498 |
Travelers | $4,280 | $7,275 |
Farmers | $4,911 | $10,992 |
Progressive | $5,119 | $6,996 |
In Tallahassee, teens seeking car insurance could face financial hurdles. An individual teen policy costs about $8,205 per year, significantly more expensive than the $4,394 premium when added to a family plan. Insurers typically quote higher rates for teens due to their perceived inexperience and higher risk of accidents, which statistically increase claims. Teens may also struggle to secure an individual policy independently, as their lack of credit history and financial stability often requires a co-signer — most commonly a parent or guardian. A joint family car insurance policy is a more economical and feasible choice for young drivers.
Cheapest Car Insurance in Tallahassee for Military Drivers
MoneyGeek found that State Farm offers the cheapest car insurance for military backgrounds in Tallahassee.
- State Farm: $1,223 per year
- Travelers: $1,321 per year
Although USAA is not included in this analysis of Tallahassee insurers, it is known for providing competitive rates on a national level. It conducts business in Florida and provides services that cater specifically to the needs of active-duty military members.
- 22-29
- 30-59
- 60 +
- Full Coverage
- Minimum Coverage
State Farm | $1,223 | $102 |
Travelers | $1,321 | $110 |
GEICO | $1,477 | $123 |
Progressive | $1,597 | $133 |
Nationwide | $1,657 | $138 |
Allstate | $1,826 | $152 |
Mercury | $1,842 | $154 |
Direct General Insurance | $2,424 | $202 |
Farmers | $2,632 | $219 |
Car Insurance Companies in Tallahassee
Company | Address | Phone | Website |
---|---|---|---|
McKee Insurance Agency | 1701 Hermitage Blvd Suite 201, Tallahassee, FL 32308 | (850) 224-6055 | |
Waterhouse Insurance and Financial Services | 2880 Apalachee Pkwy, Tallahassee, FL 32301 | (850) 412-1099 | |
Fuqua Insurance Agency | 1836 Hermitage Blvd, Tallahassee, FL 32308 | (850) 386-2300 | |
Brigit Smallridge - State Farm Agent | 2930 Wellington Cir #201, Tallahassee, FL 32309 | (850) 385-2165 | |
Demont Insurance Agency, Inc. | 3375 Capital Cir NE Building I, Tallahassee, FL 32308 | (850) 942-7760 | |
Quality Insurance Of Tallahassee | 1225 S Monroe St, Tallahassee, FL 32301 | (850) 224-6250 | |
Doug Croley Insurance Services | 2814 Remington Green Cir, Tallahassee, FL 32308 | (850) 386-1922 | |
GreatFlorida Insurance - Joe Altenburg | 2522 Capital Cir NE STE 4, Tallahassee, FL 32308 | (850) 523-0605 | |
McGinniss Himmel Insurance Agency | 2367 Centerville Rd, Tallahassee, FL 32308 | (850) 329-6996 |
How to Compare Cheap Tallahassee Car Insurance Quotes Online
Finding the best car insurance rates in Tallahassee is essential for savings. However, comparing quotes from multiple companies can take more than an hour.
To accelerate the process, utilize MoneyGeek's car insurance calculator. By inputting your age, driving record, credit score, desired coverage and other pertinent details, you'll receive a tailored rate estimate that considers key factors influencing car insurance premiums in Tallahassee.
Car Insurance Calculator
MoneyGeek's car insurance calculator will give you a customized estimate of your auto insurance cost. It's free to use, requires no personal information and we won't send you any spam.
Rates updated:
Dec 06, 2024
Although MoneyGeek partners with some of the companies we recommend, our content is written and reviewed by an independent team of writers, editors and licensed agents. Learn more about our editorial policies and expert editorial team.
Best Car Insurance in Tallahassee: Overview
Finding the best auto insurance hinges on how you prioritize service, cost, coverage and other essential factors. MoneyGeek’s research utilizes distinct criteria for each category and has identified top insurers in Tallahassee catering to diverse preferences:
- Best overall: State Farm (MoneyGeek score 85 out of 100)
- Best for service: Mercury (MoneyGeek score 83 out of 100)
- Best cheap: State Farm (MoneyGeek score 87 out of 100)
State Farm is the preferred choice for overall value and affordability, showcasing robust service and cost-effectiveness. Mercury stands out for exceptional service, ideal for those prioritizing customer experience. State Farm is the best cheap option and successfully balances low-cost premiums without compromising on service quality. These tailored options offer insights for consumers seeking both comprehensive coverage and budget-friendly policies.
Overall Best Car Insurance in Tallahassee
MoneyGeek found that State Farm is the leading option for the best car insurance in Tallahassee with superior offerings.
- State Farm: MoneyGeek score of 85 out of 100 ($1,223 per year)
- Mercury: MoneyGeek score of 81 out of 100 ($1,842 per year)
State Farm distinguishes itself with an outstanding blend of customer satisfaction and affordability, marking its reputation for providing high-quality full coverage policies. The insurer's leading scores in these aspects are the foundation of its high MoneyGeek score.
State Farm's impressive MoneyGeek score is primarily bolstered by top-notch affordability and excellent claims handling. The company includes roadside assistance and rental car and/or travel reimbursement in its policy offerings.
State Farm's roadside assistance covers the cost of mechanical labor at the breakdown site for up to one hour. Customers also benefit from the rental car and/or travel reimbursement coverage, which handles car rental expenses up to the chosen limit if your vehicle is inoperable due to a covered collision or comprehensive claim. These coverages underscore the practical and financial value State Farm provides to policyholders, reinforcing its optimal balance of affordability, satisfaction and comprehensive care.
- Ranks first in the city for affordability, with an average annual premium of $1,223 for full coverage
- Ranks second in the city for general customer satisfaction
- Offers rental car/travel reimbursement and roadside assistance
- Ranks fourth in the city for claims handling
- Does not offer OEM and gap insurance
MoneyGeek ranks Tallahassee's top car insurers by prioritizing customer satisfaction and cost-effectiveness. We also weigh claims processing, coverage options and insurer stability.
Best Car Insurance in Tallahassee for Customer Service
In Tallahassee, MoneyGeek found that Mercury offers the best car insurance in terms of customer service. Mercury is renowned for excellence in customer satisfaction, claims handling and broad coverage offerings, without considering rate factors.
- Mercury: MoneyGeek score of 83 out of 100 ($1,842 per year)
- State Farm: MoneyGeek score of 75 out of 100 ($1,223 per year)
Mercury distinguishes itself at the forefront of the industry, notably through its exceptional satisfaction and claims processing scores. The company's solid ratings in these factors are pivotal to its high MoneyGeek score. Mercury’s commitment to customer experience and reliable claim support is reflected in its status as the top choice for Tallahassee drivers seeking quality car insurance.
Mercury stands out for its exceptional satisfaction and claims handling, which greatly influence its high MoneyGeek score. The company lacks rental car and/or travel reimbursement, but it does offer roadside assistance. Mechanical breakdown insurance is a noteworthy option from Mercury, which is appealing due to its cost coverage for many unexpected repairs.
- Ranks first in the city for general customer satisfaction
- Ranks first in the for claims handling
- Offers mechanical breakdown insurance and roadside assistance
- Does not offer rental car and/or travel reimbursement or gap insurance
MoneyGeek ranks Tallahassee car insurance by focusing on customer satisfaction and claims processing. Coverage options and insurer stability are also essential factors.
Best Cheap Car Insurance in Tallahassee
MoneyGeek found that State Farm offers the best cheap car insurance in Tallahassee. This score highlights a company's commitment to affordability, claims handling proficiency and customer satisfaction.
- State Farm: MoneyGeek score of 87 out of 100 ($534 per year)
- Mercury: MoneyGeek score of 85 out of 100 ($650 per year)
State Farm stands out in Tallahassee for its cost-effective approach to car insurance. Key factors like an exceptional affordability score and robust claims handling contribute significantly to its leading MoneyGeek score. This scoring reflects the premium for a minimum coverage policy, showcasing State Farm as the top choice for budget-conscious drivers seeking reliable coverage.
State Farm leads the pack with stellar affordability and claims handling scores, contributing heavily to its high MoneyGeek score. With an average annual premium of $534, the average driver pays little each year for minimum coverage. State Farm appeals to budget-conscious drivers by offering discounts like an anti-theft system and new vehicle savings.
State Farm demonstrates a wide array of discounts, proudly offering all the most common: bundling, multiple car and safe driving. The company rewards drivers with savings for completing defensive driving courses, incentivizing safe and responsible driving. Its new vehicle discount provides savings for owners of newer vehicles, combining financial relief with the peace of mind that comes from driving a current model.
- Offers common discounts for bundling, multiple car and safe driving
- Ranks first in the city for affordability, with an average annual premium of $534 for minimum coverage
- Ranks second in the city for general customer satisfaction
- Ranks second in the city for financial stability
- Ranks fourth in the city for claims handling
MoneyGeek ranks Tallahassee's best car insurance by focusing on affordability, customer satisfaction, claim processes, coverage options and insurer stability.
Average Cost of Car Insurance in Tallahassee
In Tallahassee, Florida, the average car insurance cost is $1,782 per year. This premium is notably lower by $610 than the average car insurance cost in Florida of $2,392. The state average is also higher by $611 than the national average of $1,781.
Various factors influence car insurance premiums, such as driving history, vehicle type and coverage levels. However, location remains a significant determinant. Geographic factors contribute to premium variance — regions that experience heavy traffic congestion, higher accident rates or elevated risk of natural disasters tend to have higher insurance costs. For instance, within Florida, Gainesville has the cheapest city premium at $1,699, while Hialeah has the most expensive at $3,233, a difference of $1,212. You may find even more favorable insurance rates in areas with lower traffic density, like non-urban locations.
Brandon | $2,650 |
Cape Coral | $1,868 |
Clearwater | $2,273 |
Coral Springs | $2,635 |
Davie | $2,567 |
Fort Lauderdale | $2,605 |
Gainesville | $1,699 |
Hialeah | $3,233 |
Hollywood | $2,724 |
Jacksonville | $2,113 |
Lakeland | $2,015 |
Lehigh Acres | $1,980 |
Miami | $3,041 |
Miami Gardens | $2,961 |
Miramar | $2,556 |
Orlando | $2,146 |
Palm Bay | $1,899 |
Pembroke Pines | $2,508 |
Pompano Beach | $2,696 |
Port St. Lucie | $2,009 |
Spring Hill | $2,152 |
St. Petersburg | $2,382 |
Tallahassee | $1,782 |
Tampa | $2,855 |
West Palm Beach | $2,826 |
About Mark Fitzpatrick
Mark Fitzpatrick is a Licensed Property and Casualty Insurance Producer and MoneyGeek's Head of Insurance. He has analyzed the insurance market for over five years, conducting original research and creating personalized content for every kind of buyer. He has been quoted in several insurance-related publications, including CNBC, NBC News and Mashable.
Fitzpatrick earned a master’s degree in economics and international relations from Johns Hopkins University and a bachelor’s degree from Boston College. He is passionate about using his knowledge of economics and insurance to bring transparency around financial topics and help others feel confident in their money moves.