What Is the Average Cost of Auto Insurance?

The average cost of car insurance is $1,424 per year. But that’s just an average. How much car insurance costs for you will be determined by a variety of factors, and MoneyGeek’s data can give you an idea of what to expect based on your profile.

By  
  |  
Reviewed by    |  

Car insurance rates vary based on many factors such as location, driving record and even credit score. Different insurers will weigh certain aspects more heavily than others. That’s why it’s always a good idea to get at least two to three quotes from insurance carriers to weigh your options more accurately.

MoneyGeek's analysis of car insurance rates across the country highlights that good drivers pay an average of $1,424 per year for a policy with 100/300/100 liability insurance and comprehensive and collision coverage. Individual rates may vary significantly depending on your level of coverage, vehicle and other factors.

Loading...

Average Cost of Auto Insurance Summary

The average costs of car insurance depend, in part, on how you pay: annually or monthly. The figures below are based on the average annual premium, but be aware that drivers may pay more if they opt for monthly payments. This is because there’s usually a discount for paying in full. That’s why it’s essential to get a personalized quote to understand your options fully.

Average Car Insurance Rates

Scroll for more

swipe icon

Average Car Insurance Costs by Company - Major Insurers

One of the most important factors determining the cost of car insurance is the average by company. Of the companies widely available across the country:

  • USAA is the cheapest, costing $883 per year on average.
  • MetLife, the most expensive: It costs $1,686 per year on average for the same driver.

The price difference shows the importance of getting quotes from multiple insurers.

The Average Cost of Major Insurers - From Cheap to Expensive

Scroll for more

swipe icon

Average Car Insurance Costs by Company - Midsized Insurers

Certain insurance companies don’t have national availability, but still make up a large share of the car insurance market for the states in which they’re available. These mid-sized insurance companies range from affordable — such as Erie, which costs an average of $934 per year — to expensive, such as Allied Insurance, a Nationwide subsidiary which costs an average of $1,633 per year.

The Average Cost of Midsized Insurers - From Cheap to Expensive

Scroll for more

swipe icon

Average Car Insurance Costs by State

The requirements and coverage types for car insurance vary by state, which can impact the costs. Michigan — the highest-cost state ($5,471 annually) — recently required drivers to carry at least $20,000 in liability protection for bodily injury (a maximum of $40,000 per incident) and $10,000 for property damage. On July 1, 2020, the state enacted sweeping changes to its auto insurance requirements, which may serve to lower costs for car insurance there. In Maine — the lowest-cost state ($607 annually) — the minimum required for liability coverage is $50,000 per person, $100,000 per accident for bodily injury and $25,000 for property damage.

Average State Premiums by Payment Option

Scroll for more

swipe icon

How Average Car Insurance Rates by State Have Changed Over Time

At a national level, car insurance rates have been fairly stable over the last half decade. From 2015 to 2021, average car insurance rates have only increased by 2.7%; in other words, less than $50. In fact, in the last year car insurance rates have fallen by 2.2%.

But changes in car insurance rates are not uniform, and certain states have seen large changes over the last five years. The five states that have seen the biggest decrease in car insurance rates in recent years are New Jersey, Arkansas, Illinois, Oregon and Connecticut. All five of these states saw average car insurance rates fall by at least 23%.

States With the Biggest Decreases in Rates - Last Six Years

Scroll for more

swipe icon
  • State
    % Rate Decrease (2015-2021)
  • New Jersey
    -30%
  • Arkansas
    -25%
  • Illinois
    -25%
  • Oregon
    -24%
  • Connecticut
    -23%

Conversely the states with the largest increase in insurance rates over the last six years are Montana, Louisiana, Florida, Nevada and Missouri. All of these states saw their average insurance rates increase by 19% or more.

States With the Biggest Increases in Rates - Last Six Years

Scroll for more

swipe icon
  • State
    % Rate Increase (2015-2021)
  • Montana
    37%
  • Louisiana
    34%
  • Florida
    25%
  • Nevada
    23%
  • Missouri
    19%

Average Car Insurance Costs by Age

Age is another factor that can impact the cost of insurance. For example, a less experienced teen driver could cost as much as $5,318 per year to insure by themselves.

The average cost of car insurance greatly decreases from age 16 to 30, at which point car insurance rates tend to remain steady until slightly rising in a driver’s senior years.

Average Car Insurance Premiums by Age

Scroll for more

swipe icon
  • Age
    Individual Premium
  • $5,318
  • $4,621
  • $3,997
  • $2,789
  • $2,465
  • $1,957
  • $1,818
  • $1,648
  • $1,543
  • $1,402
  • $1,267
  • 40
    $1,246
  • $1,179

Average Costs by Coverage Type - Full Coverage vs. Liability-Only

The amount of coverage you decide on will depend on the state you live in and your unique needs. Typically, more coverage is more expensive.

  • Liability-only insurance costs an average of $898 per year.
  • A full coverage policy with the same liability limits costs an average of $1,311 per year.

Liability-only car insurance coverage tends to cost the least, but getting only the minimum comes with risks. For example, you won’t be covered for damage to your vehicle with liability-only coverage — you’d only be covered for any damage that you do to another person’s car. That’s why full coverage (comprehensive and collision) is generally a better option for many drivers.

Car Insurance Premiums by Coverage Level

Scroll for more

swipe icon
  • Payment Cycle
    50/100/50 Liability-only
    50/100/50 w/ Comprehensive and Collision
    100/300/100 w/ Comprehensive and Collision
  • Monthly
    $75
    $109
    $119
  • 6-Month
    $449
    $656
    $712
  • Annual
    $898
    $1,311
    $1,424

Average Car Insurance Costs by Car Model

Certain car models can be extremely expensive to insure, but most car models will alter a driver’s rates by less than a few hundred dollars per year. For example, the top selling sedan (Toyota Camry), truck (Ford F-150) and SUV (Toyota RAV4) models in the country all cost our sample driver an average of $1,266 to $1,414 to insure.

On the other hand, sports cars and electric car models can be much more expensive to insure than the average car. MoneyGeek found that the most expensive car to insure is a Nissan GT-R. The cheapest car model to insure is a Honda CR-V.

Model
2020 Average Annual Premium

Nissan GT-R (Most expensive model to insure)

$3,096

Toyota Camry (Top-selling Sedan)

$1,414

Ford F-150 (Top-selling Truck)

$1,269

Toyota RAV4 (Top-selling SUV)

$1,266

Honda CR-V (Cheapest model to insure)

$1,172

Average Car Insurance Costs With Tickets or Accidents

Your accident and ticket history is another factor insurance companies consider when setting rates and determining if they can insure you.

  • A driver with a clean record pays an average of $1,424 per year for car insurance.
  • The same driver with a ticket on their record pays an average of $1,836 per year.
  • If that driver were at-fault for an accident, he pays an average of $2,237 per year.

There are things that can combat increases or lower the costs to your car insurance after an accident. In some states, attending traffic school can get violation points taken off your record. That, in turn, can impact your premiums. And, depending on the insurer, you may get a break if it’s your first violation. It’s worth discussing your options with your insurance agent.

Car Insurance Premiums With Tickets and Accidents

Scroll for more

swipe icon
  • Payment Cycle
    Rate After A Ticket
    Rate After An Accident
  • Monthly
    $153
    $186
  • 6-Month
    $918
    $1,119
  • Annual
    $1,836
    $2,237

Average Car Insurance Costs If You Have Bad Credit

In most states, your credit score can impact your auto insurance rates. The exceptions to this rule are Hawaii, Massachusetts and California, where this practice is not allowed. But for those who live elsewhere in the U.S., even having just average credit can increase your costs more than, for example, having a moving violation, according to research from Consumer Reports.

Raising your score can help you get lower car insurance rates and access other benefits. So it’s something to keep an eye on if you’re planning on taking out a new policy soon.

Car Insurance Premiums for Drivers With Poor Credit
  • Payment Cycle
    Poor Credit
  • Monthly
    $223
  • 6-Month
    $1,335
  • Annual
    $2,671

Average Car Insurance Costs If You Have a DUI

If you have a DUI on your driving record, that can significantly increase your rates, as insurance companies take it as a sign that the driver is high-risk.

  • The average annual cost of car insurance across the board was $1,424.
  • The cost for someone with a DUI was $2,879. That’s more than double the average.

A DUI can stay on your driving record for years, and the exact length of time will depend on the state in which you live. For many reasons, not only insurance rates, you need to avoid a DUI.

Car Insurance Premiums With a DUI
  • Payment Cycle
    Rate After DUI
  • Monthly
    $240
  • 6-Month
    $1,440
  • Annual
    $2,879

Other Factors That Impact Cost

The way insurance companies calculate the costs of insuring any given person is usually based on a wide variety of unique factors. Here’s a breakdown of some of those other aspects you should be aware of and how those can influence your cost of getting car insurance:

Vehicle Type

Your car’s make, model and year all impact how much you’ll pay in insurance costs. For example, a classic car would come with special requirements as those have a different kind of value than a typical vehicle. On the other hand, a car that’s rated highly for safety and can qualify for eco-friendly discounts can lower your car insurance costs.

Gender

Your gender can be another factor that influences your rates. In general, this rule only applies to drivers under 21. Among those younger drivers, men tend to pay more than women. But, after that, things tend to even out.

Insurance History

Those who have a gap in coverage are generally seen as being less credible, or safe, from the perspective of car insurance companies. So it’s essential to make sure that you have at least the minimum required insurance for your vehicle at all times to avoid inflated rates.

Your ZIP Code

Where you live can have a significant impact on your rates as well. For example, more dense population areas and those with higher crime rates tend to be more expensive. On the other hand, more sparsely populated areas or places with lower crime rates can help you get a better deal.

Annual Mileage

The more you drive, the more opportunities there are for an accident or other damages. So your rates will vary depending on your annual mileage as well.

Deductible Amount

Opting for a higher deductible will lower your monthly costs and vice versa. Keep in mind that if you need to file a claim, you will have to pay more. If you choose a higher deductible, it’s important to have that amount saved, if possible, to lessen potential financial shock later on.

Claims History

Can insurance companies tend to assume that those who have had claims filed in the past are more likely to do so in the future. In general, having fewer claims under your belt is better for getting a lower rate.

Number of Drivers in Household & Marriage Status

Having more drivers in your household will cost more, but it can also lower your overall costs, per driver, if your insurer offers a multi-driver discount. That’s in comparison to each driver getting their own policy. Marital status also impacts your rates as single people tend to pay more than married individuals.

Some factors are hard to control when it comes to the cost you’ll pay for car insurance, such as your age and where you live. Since insurance companies weigh many factors when determining your premium, it’s good to control the elements you can, such as not getting tickets or DUIs and maintaining good credit. Knowing the average cost of car insurance in your state can help you make an educated decision when you shop for the best rate.

Loading...

Expert Advice: Factors That Influence the Cost of Auto Insurance

  1. Why does the average cost of car insurance change so much depending on what state you live in?
  2. My insurance rates seem much more expensive than average. What factors could be driving that?
  3. Insurance companies give me very different quotes. Why is the average cost of car insurance so different between insurance companies?
Dr. Zachary Moore
Dr. Zachary Moore

Assistant Professor of Marketing at the University of Louisiana at Monroe

Chris Miller
Chris Miller

Instructor of Accounting at the University of Indianapolis

Laura Sendldorfer
Laura Sendldorfer

Financial Advisor & Insurance Specialist at Offit Advisors

Joseph F. Eschleman, CIMA®
Joseph F. Eschleman, CIMA®

President of Towerpoint Wealth

Michael Omansky
Michael Omansky

Associate Professor, Felician University, School of Business and Information Sciences

Dr. Cara Peters
Dr. Cara Peters

Professor of Marketing at Winthrop University

Scott W. Hegerty
Scott W. Hegerty

Associate Professor of Economics at Northeastern Illinois University

Roc Starks
Roc Starks

Associate Teaching Professor at Bowling Green State University, CIC, CRM, ARM, MBA

Ali Zeytoon-Nejad, Ph.D
Ali Zeytoon-Nejad, Ph.D

Visiting Assistant Teaching Professor at Wake Forest University, School of Business

Raj Iyengar
Raj Iyengar

Ph.D., CPA, CMA, Professor and Chair of the Department of Accounting at North Carolina Central University

Susan Hume, PhD
Susan Hume, PhD

Associate Professor Finance at The College of New Jersey

Dr. Brian Routh
Dr. Brian Routh

Assistant Professor of Accounting at Meredith College, School of Business

Suman Banerjee
Suman Banerjee

Associate Professor of Finance, School of Business at Stevens Institute of Technology

Michael McGuinness
Michael McGuinness

Associate Professor, Economics and Business at Saint Anselm College

Ryan Stueber
Ryan Stueber

Agency Founder of PNW Insurance Group

Dr. Chandan Kumar Jha
Dr. Chandan Kumar Jha

Assistant Professor of Finance, Madden School of Business, Le Moyne College

John Espenschied
John Espenschied

Agency Owner of Insurance Brokers Group

John Forlines III
John Forlines III

Professor of Economics at Duke University

Jing Ai
Jing Ai

Professor of Finance, Risk Management and Insurance at the University of Hawaiʻi

Madhuparna Kolay, Ph.D.
Madhuparna Kolay, Ph.D.

Associate Professor of Finance, Pamplin School of Business Administration, University of Portland

Dr. Brock Zehr
Dr. Brock Zehr

Associate Professor Business & Economics at Huntington University

David Hart
David Hart

Executive in Residence at Oklahoma Wesleyan University

Derek-Dion Lee
Derek-Dion Lee

Assistant Professor of Finance at Ohio Northern University

 Matthew Hall
Matthew Hall

Assistant Professor of Marketing, College of Business at Oregon State University

Joseph R. Stasio
Joseph R. Stasio

Associate Professor, Marketing at Merrimack College

Pavel Yakovlev, Ph.D.
Pavel Yakovlev, Ph.D.

Associate Professor of Economics, Palumbo Donahue School of Business at Duquesne University

Thomas W. Hall
Thomas W. Hall

Associate Professor of Finance and Economics at Christopher Newport University

Nicole McConlogue
Nicole McConlogue

Assistant Professor and Clinic Director, WVU College of Law

Biwei Chen
Biwei Chen

Assistant Professor of Economics at Binghamton University

Benjamin Pugsley
Benjamin Pugsley

Assistant Professor of Economics at the University of Notre Dame

Barry Choi
Barry Choi

Personal Finance and Travel Expert at MoneyWeHave.com

Dr. Joseph G. Eisenhauer
Dr. Joseph G. Eisenhauer

Dean of the College of Business Administration at the University of Detroit Mercy

Dr. Jose Mendoza
Dr. Jose Mendoza

Assistant Professor in Marketing, Jack Welch College of Business & Technology at Sacred Heart University

Chase Reid
Chase Reid

Lecturer in Finance at Elon University

Art Rossetti
Art Rossetti

Insurance Agent at Gateway Insurance Group

Christopher J. Marquette
Christopher J. Marquette

Assistant Professor of Finance at Millikin University

John Lapointe
John Lapointe

Vice President at Lapointe Insurance

Justin Yoshizawa
Justin Yoshizawa

Mercury Insurance Director of Product Management

Dr. Kip Pirkle
Dr. Kip Pirkle

Entrepreneur and Consultant

William Martin
William Martin

Associate Professor of Marketing at Eastern Washington University

Li Cai
Li Cai

Associate Professor of Finance at IIT Stuart School of Business

Dr. Debra J. Dean
Dr. Debra J. Dean

President & CEO at Dean Business Consulting, LLC

John Alpers
John Alpers

Assistant Professor of Business, Carson-Newman University

Dr. Ying Zhen
Dr. Ying Zhen

Associate Professor of Business and Economics at Wesleyan College

Dr. James Weisel
Dr. James Weisel

Professor of Accountancy at Georgia Gwinnett College

Dr. Kelly Carter
Dr. Kelly Carter

Associate Professor of Finance at the Earl G. Graves School of Business and Management at Morgan State University

Talaya Scott
Talaya Scott

Accounting Professor at Milwaukee Area Technical College

About the Author


expert-profile

Devon Delfino is an independent journalist based in the Pacific Northwest. Her personal-finance coverage has been featured in publications such as the L.A. Times, Teen Vogue, Mashable, MarketWatch, CNBC and USA Today, among others.


sources