Compare Rates and Save on Auto Insurance

widget-location-pin

The best car insurance company depends on your needs and background. Erie is the most affordable option for minimum coverage. GEICO is the cheapest for a full coverage policy and drivers with tickets. State Farm is the cheapest for drivers with DUIs, and American Family is the most affordable for drivers with accidents. Teens will find the cheapest rates from Nationwide. For excellent service, Acuity is the best. USAA is the cheapest for military families.

MoneyGeek Logo IconCheapest + BestCar InsuranceGreen Bay
2023

Cheapest and Best Car Insurance in Green Bay

Cheapest Minimum Liability Car Insurance in Green Bay

The following car insurance providers are the cheapest options for minimum coverage in Green Bay:

  • Erie: $204 per year
  • Nationwide: $230 per year

Dairyland is the most expensive company, charging an average of $882 per year. As of October 2022, the cheapest auto insurance company in Wisconsin is Erie, which charges an average of $239 per year. This is slightly more than what Erie charges in Green Bay, showing that your location can affect your car insurance rates.

Company
Annual Premium
Monthly Premium

Erie

$203

$17

Erie

$204

$17

Nationwide

$226

$19

State Farm

$227

$19

Nationwide

$230

$19

GEICO

$234

$19

State Farm

$241

$20

GEICO

$252

$21

Erie

$252

$21

GEICO

$254

$21

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$264

$22

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$275

$23

State Farm

$289

$24

Progressive

$292

$24

Nationwide

$297

$25

West Bend Mutual

$312

$26

Progressive

$313

$26

Western National

$313

$26

Western National

$324

$27

Acuity

$325

$27

Farmers

$328

$27

IMT Insurance Company

$331

$28

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$332

$28

West Bend Mutual

$333

$28

Travelers

$346

$29

Acuity

$347

$29

Travelers

$362

$30

Farmers

$364

$30

Farmers

$379

$32

Progressive

$379

$32

West Bend Mutual

$379

$32

Travelers

$381

$32

AAA

$383

$32

IMT Insurance Company

$389

$32

AAA

$409

$34

Chubb

$433

$36

Acuity

$434

$36

American Family

$434

$36

American Family

$437

$36

Nationwide

$468

$39

American Family

$473

$39

GEICO

$481

$40

GEICO

$487

$41

AAA

$493

$41

Chubb

$503

$42

Western National

$509

$42

Nationwide

$509

$42

State Farm

$523

$44

GEICO

$530

$44

Allstate

$533

$44

Allstate

$539

$45

Kemper

$554

$46

State Farm

$571

$48

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$574

$48

IMT Insurance Company

$577

$48

Kemper

$581

$48

Erie

$594

$50

Allstate

$596

$50

Erie

$600

$50

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$606

$51

Kemper

$622

$52

IMT Insurance Company

$627

$52

American Family

$636

$53

Nationwide

$637

$53

Travelers

$638

$53

Travelers

$648

$54

American Family

$664

$55

Chubb

$685

$57

AAA

$687

$57

Progressive

$715

$60

American Family

$716

$60

State Farm

$717

$60

West Bend Mutual

$719

$60

West Bend Mutual

$734

$61

Travelers

$746

$62

Erie

$760

$63

IMT Insurance Company

$763

$64

AAA

$769

$64

Acuity

$778

$65

Allstate

$786

$65

Progressive

$789

$66

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$801

$67

Dairyland

$802

$67

Farmers

$805

$67

Allstate

$816

$68

Farmers

$816

$68

West Bend Mutual

$867

$72

Dairyland

$882

$74

Chubb

$895

$75

Acuity

$912

$76

Farmers

$937

$78

AAA

$941

$78

Allstate

$966

$81

Progressive

$994

$83

IMT Insurance Company

$1,005

$84

Dairyland

$1,033

$86

Chubb

$1,054

$88

Acuity

$1,110

$92

Western National

$1,114

$93

Kemper

$1,205

$100

Kemper

$1,228

$102

Western National

$1,249

$104

Chubb

$1,398

$117

Kemper

$1,445

$120

Dairyland

$1,872

$156

Western National

$1,935

$161

Dairyland

$2,118

$176

Dairyland

$2,523

$210

Drivers in Wisconsin opting for minimum coverage will only get bodily injury liability, property damage liability and uninsured motorist coverage. The state’s minimum coverage limits are:

  • $25,000 bodily injury liability per person
  • $50,000 bodily injury liability per accident
  • $10,000 property damage liability per accident
  • $25,000 uninsured motorist coverage per person
  • $50,000 uninsured motorist coverage per accident

These limits represent the total amount the insurer will cover. For instance, the state’s bodily injury coverage limits mean that the insurer will pay a maximum of $25,000 for medical injuries of each passenger, up to $50,000 per accident. If the medical costs of an accident you cause exceed these limits, you’ll need to pay for them out of your own pocket.

Cheapest Full Coverage Car Insurance in Green Bay

The most affordable car insurance companies for full coverage in Green Bay are:

  • GEICO: $481 per year
  • Nationwide: $509 per year

Dairyland offers the most expensive full coverage policies, costing an average of $2,118 per year. As of October 2022, GEICO also is the cheapest full coverage car insurance company in Wisconsin, charging an average of $567 per year. This is more expensive than the cost in Green Bay, demonstrating that your location influences your car insurance rates.

Company
Annual Premium
Monthly Premium

Erie

$203

$17

Erie

$204

$17

Nationwide

$226

$19

State Farm

$227

$19

Nationwide

$230

$19

GEICO

$234

$19

State Farm

$241

$20

GEICO

$252

$21

Erie

$252

$21

GEICO

$254

$21

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$264

$22

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$275

$23

State Farm

$289

$24

Progressive

$292

$24

Nationwide

$297

$25

West Bend Mutual

$312

$26

Progressive

$313

$26

Western National

$313

$26

Western National

$324

$27

Acuity

$325

$27

Farmers

$328

$27

IMT Insurance Company

$331

$28

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$332

$28

West Bend Mutual

$333

$28

Travelers

$346

$29

Acuity

$347

$29

Travelers

$362

$30

Farmers

$364

$30

Farmers

$379

$32

Progressive

$379

$32

West Bend Mutual

$379

$32

Travelers

$381

$32

AAA

$383

$32

IMT Insurance Company

$389

$32

AAA

$409

$34

Chubb

$433

$36

Acuity

$434

$36

American Family

$434

$36

American Family

$437

$36

Nationwide

$468

$39

American Family

$473

$39

GEICO

$481

$40

GEICO

$487

$41

AAA

$493

$41

Chubb

$503

$42

Western National

$509

$42

Nationwide

$509

$42

State Farm

$523

$44

GEICO

$530

$44

Allstate

$533

$44

Allstate

$539

$45

Kemper

$554

$46

State Farm

$571

$48

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$574

$48

IMT Insurance Company

$577

$48

Kemper

$581

$48

Erie

$594

$50

Allstate

$596

$50

Erie

$600

$50

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$606

$51

Kemper

$622

$52

IMT Insurance Company

$627

$52

American Family

$636

$53

Nationwide

$637

$53

Travelers

$638

$53

Travelers

$648

$54

American Family

$664

$55

Chubb

$685

$57

AAA

$687

$57

Progressive

$715

$60

American Family

$716

$60

State Farm

$717

$60

West Bend Mutual

$719

$60

West Bend Mutual

$734

$61

Travelers

$746

$62

Erie

$760

$63

IMT Insurance Company

$763

$64

AAA

$769

$64

Acuity

$778

$65

Allstate

$786

$65

Progressive

$789

$66

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$801

$67

Dairyland

$802

$67

Farmers

$805

$67

Allstate

$816

$68

Farmers

$816

$68

West Bend Mutual

$867

$72

Dairyland

$882

$74

Chubb

$895

$75

Acuity

$912

$76

Farmers

$937

$78

AAA

$941

$78

Allstate

$966

$81

Progressive

$994

$83

IMT Insurance Company

$1,005

$84

Dairyland

$1,033

$86

Chubb

$1,054

$88

Acuity

$1,110

$92

Western National

$1,114

$93

Kemper

$1,205

$100

Kemper

$1,228

$102

Western National

$1,249

$104

Chubb

$1,398

$117

Kemper

$1,445

$120

Dairyland

$1,872

$156

Western National

$1,935

$161

Dairyland

$2,118

$176

Dairyland

$2,523

$210

When you purchase full coverage car insurance, you will get comprehensive and collision coverage.

  • Collision Insurance: This covers vehicle damages due to at-fault accidents and helps you repair or replace your vehicle.
  • Comprehensive Insurance: This will pay for the repair or replacement of your vehicle if it’s damaged in a non-accident incident like theft, vandalism and natural weather events.

It might not be worth getting full coverage for an older vehicle since the policy may cost more than the vehicle’s value.

Cheapest Car Insurance in Green Bay After a Driving Offense

MoneyGeek found that the following car insurance providers will be the most suitable for drivers with these violations:

  • Speeding ticket: GEICO ($598 per year)
  • At-fault accident: American Family ($664 per year)
  • DUI: State Farm ($621 per year)

Dairyland is the most expensive insurer for various driving violations, charging an average of $3,466 per year for accidents, $2,714 per year for a DUI and $3,191 per year for a speeding ticket.

Bad driving records can greatly impact your rates. The cheapest company rates for poor records will still be more expensive than the most affordable rates for safe drivers.

Company
Annual Premium
Monthly Premium

Erie

$203

$17

Erie

$204

$17

State Farm

$250

$21

State Farm

$250

$21

Erie

$252

$21

Erie

$253

$21

Erie

$255

$21

State Farm

$265

$22

State Farm

$265

$22

State Farm

$273

$23

GEICO

$277

$23

State Farm

$290

$24

GEICO

$298

$25

Nationwide

$298

$25

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$299

$25

Erie

$304

$25

Erie

$305

$25

Nationwide

$305

$25

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$310

$26

Western National

$313

$26

Western National

$313

$26

Western National

$313

$26

Erie

$318

$27

State Farm

$319

$27

State Farm

$319

$27

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$320

$27

Western National

$324

$27

Western National

$324

$27

Western National

$324

$27

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$332

$28

GEICO

$336

$28

State Farm

$349

$29

Progressive

$366

$31

GEICO

$369

$31

Nationwide

$370

$31

Nationwide

$375

$31

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$378

$31

IMT Insurance Company

$382

$32

Erie

$383

$32

Progressive

$387

$32

Nationwide

$390

$33

West Bend Mutual

$393

$33

Farmers

$395

$33

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$405

$34

GEICO

$405

$34

West Bend Mutual

$421

$35

West Bend Mutual

$433

$36

Chubb

$433

$36

Chubb

$433

$36

Chubb

$433

$36

American Family

$434

$36

Progressive

$435

$36

Progressive

$436

$36

American Family

$437

$36

AAA

$444

$37

Farmers

$445

$37

Travelers

$447

$37

Nationwide

$449

$37

IMT Insurance Company

$452

$38

Farmers

$453

$38

Nationwide

$453

$38

Farmers

$461

$38

West Bend Mutual

$463

$39

Progressive

$463

$39

Travelers

$464

$39

GEICO

$465

$39

Travelers

$467

$39

Farmers

$472

$39

American Family

$473

$39

AAA

$475

$40

Nationwide

$475

$40

IMT Insurance Company

$478

$40

GEICO

$480

$40

West Bend Mutual

$482

$40

Travelers

$485

$40

Acuity

$495

$41

Farmers

$503

$42

Chubb

$503

$42

Chubb

$503

$42

Chubb

$503

$42

Travelers

$504

$42

American Family

$505

$42

American Family

$505

$42

American Family

$507

$42

American Family

$507

$42

Progressive

$507

$42

Western National

$509

$42

Western National

$509

$42

Western National

$509

$42

Travelers

$515

$43

Acuity

$523

$44

Farmers

$524

$44

Travelers

$530

$44

West Bend Mutual

$530

$44

Farmers

$531

$44

Travelers

$535

$45

American Family

$538

$45

American Family

$538

$45

Farmers

$546

$45

AAA

$552

$46

Nationwide

$553

$46

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$558

$46

IMT Insurance Company

$566

$47

West Bend Mutual

$568

$47

IMT Insurance Company

$569

$47

State Farm

$570

$48

State Farm

$570

$48

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$573

$48

AAA

$574

$48

Kemper

$580

$48

GEICO

$582

$49

Travelers

$585

$49

AAA

$588

$49

Erie

$594

$50

GEICO

$598

$50

Progressive

$598

$50

Erie

$600

$50

Allstate

$602

$50

Kemper

$608

$51

Allstate

$611

$51

State Farm

$617

$51

State Farm

$621

$52

State Farm

$621

$52

Allstate

$623

$52

Allstate

$631

$53

Nationwide

$631

$53

American Family

$636

$53

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$640

$53

Acuity

$652

$54

Kemper

$653

$54

Acuity

$659

$55

GEICO

$662

$55

American Family

$664

$55

Progressive

$668

$56

Kemper

$669

$56

State Farm

$671

$56

IMT Insurance Company

$673

$56

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$673

$56

IMT Insurance Company

$674

$56

GEICO

$679

$57

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$680

$57

West Bend Mutual

$680

$57

Progressive

$682

$57

Nationwide

$684

$57

Chubb

$685

$57

Chubb

$685

$57

Allstate

$685

$57

Chubb

$685

$57

Acuity

$690

$57

GEICO

$704

$59

Allstate

$711

$59

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$714

$59

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$716

$60

American Family

$716

$60

AAA

$716

$60

IMT Insurance Company

$722

$60

Kemper

$725

$60

Erie

$728

$61

Erie

$734

$61

Allstate

$741

$62

Kemper

$751

$63

American Family

$753

$63

American Family

$753

$63

Allstate

$755

$63

Nationwide

$759

$63

Erie

$760

$63

Acuity

$770

$64

Kemper

$771

$64

State Farm

$782

$65

State Farm

$782

$65

American Family

$782

$65

American Family

$782

$65

Nationwide

$812

$68

Acuity

$815

$68

AAA

$817

$68

Nationwide

$819

$68

GEICO

$822

$68

Kemper

$837

$70

American Family

$838

$70

American Family

$838

$70

IMT Insurance Company

$846

$71

State Farm

$847

$71

Erie

$863

$72

Allstate

$865

$72

IMT Insurance Company

$868

$72

Kemper

$868

$72

Erie

$870

$73

Acuity

$872

$73

West Bend Mutual

$880

$73

Travelers

$882

$74

IMT Insurance Company

$883

$74

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$894

$75

Chubb

$895

$75

Chubb

$895

$75

Chubb

$895

$75

GEICO

$912

$76

Allstate

$916

$76

Travelers

$917

$76

AAA

$918

$76

West Bend Mutual

$920

$77

AAA

$923

$77

Progressive

$923

$77

Nationwide

$925

$77

Progressive

$932

$78

Erie

$935

$78

Travelers

$939

$78

West Bend Mutual

$941

$78

AAA

$941

$78

Allstate

$946

$79

Travelers

$949

$79

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$950

$79

Allstate

$953

$79

Travelers

$981

$82

GEICO

$982

$82

Allstate

$985

$82

Nationwide

$985

$82

Travelers

$986

$82

Nationwide

$993

$83

Travelers

$1,007

$84

AAA

$1,010

$84

Farmers

$1,012

$84

IMT Insurance Company

$1,012

$84

West Bend Mutual

$1,016

$85

AAA

$1,026

$85

Acuity

$1,031

$86

GEICO

$1,033

$86

West Bend Mutual

$1,039

$87

Dairyland

$1,052

$88

Chubb

$1,054

$88

Chubb

$1,054

$88

Chubb

$1,054

$88

IMT Insurance Company

$1,059

$88

Farmers

$1,069

$89

Travelers

$1,079

$90

Travelers

$1,083

$90

IMT Insurance Company

$1,091

$91

Progressive

$1,095

$91

Farmers

$1,107

$92

Erie

$1,109

$92

West Bend Mutual

$1,110

$93

Western National

$1,114

$93

Western National

$1,114

$93

Western National

$1,114

$93

Progressive

$1,116

$93

Acuity

$1,122

$93

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$1,123

$94

AAA

$1,127

$94

Progressive

$1,139

$95

Farmers

$1,144

$95

Allstate

$1,149

$96

Farmers

$1,153

$96

Allstate

$1,160

$97

Nationwide

$1,162

$97

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$1,165

$97

IMT Insurance Company

$1,167

$97

Dairyland

$1,167

$97

Farmers

$1,186

$99

Allstate

$1,191

$99

Allstate

$1,213

$101

West Bend Mutual

$1,229

$102

Farmers

$1,230

$102

GEICO

$1,233

$103

Farmers

$1,240

$103

Dairyland

$1,243

$104

AAA

$1,244

$104

Western National

$1,249

$104

Western National

$1,249

$104

Western National

$1,249

$104

AAA

$1,261

$105

Dairyland

$1,263

$105

Kemper

$1,264

$105

Dairyland

$1,285

$107

Farmers

$1,287

$107

Kemper

$1,287

$107

Acuity

$1,311

$109

Progressive

$1,323

$110

Dairyland

$1,324

$110

West Bend Mutual

$1,332

$111

IMT Insurance Company

$1,339

$112

GEICO

$1,342

$112

Dairyland

$1,364

$114

Dairyland

$1,393

$116

Chubb

$1,398

$117

Chubb

$1,398

$117

Chubb

$1,398

$117

IMT Insurance Company

$1,419

$118

Kemper

$1,446

$121

Acuity

$1,452

$121

Kemper

$1,452

$121

Allstate

$1,489

$124

Progressive

$1,490

$124

Dairyland

$1,506

$125

Kemper

$1,515

$126

AAA

$1,534

$128

Progressive

$1,569

$131

West Bend Mutual

$1,573

$131

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$1,574

$131

Acuity

$1,607

$134

Acuity

$1,694

$141

Acuity

$1,694

$141

AAA

$1,704

$142

Kemper

$1,705

$142

Kemper

$1,743

$145

Kemper

$1,749

$146

Progressive

$1,757

$146

IMT Insurance Company

$1,775

$148

West Bend Mutual

$1,807

$151

Western National

$1,935

$161

Western National

$1,935

$161

Western National

$1,935

$161

Acuity

$1,974

$164

Kemper

$2,068

$172

Acuity

$2,093

$174

AAA

$2,110

$176

Dairyland

$2,390

$199

Acuity

$2,435

$203

Dairyland

$2,714

$226

Dairyland

$2,819

$235

Dairyland

$3,058

$255

Dairyland

$3,170

$264

Dairyland

$3,191

$266

Dairyland

$3,246

$270

Dairyland

$3,336

$278

Dairyland

$3,466

$289

Premiums usually increase more for severe violations. MoneyGeek found that a Green Bay driver with a speeding ticket will pay an average of $198 more than a driver with no violations, while a driver with a DUI will pay around $391 more. By shopping around, drivers can still find the cheapest car insurance for poor driving records.

Cheapest Car Insurance in Green Bay for Teens and Their Families

MoneyGeek found that the following companies offer the cheapest car insurance for teen drivers on a family policy:

  • Nationwide: $791 per year for female teens; $864 per year for male teens
  • GEICO: $1,085 per year for female teens; $1,163 per year for male teens

Kemper is Green Bay’s most expensive insurance provider for teens, charging an average of $3,994 per year for females and $4,934 per year for males. As demonstrated by the $73 price difference charged by the cheapest insurer, providers may charge higher rates to insure male teens due to increased risk. This difference usually subsides in early adulthood.

Company
Family Plan Annual Premium
Individual Plan Monthly Premium

Nationwide

$475

$1,035

Nationwide

$487

$1,108

Nationwide

$497

$1,370

Nationwide

$514

$1,494

Travelers

$527

$1,102

Nationwide

$539

$1,176

Nationwide

$543

$1,294

Nationwide

$558

$1,270

Nationwide

$561

$1,402

Nationwide

$564

$1,230

Travelers

$567

$1,152

Nationwide

$584

$1,330

GEICO

$598

$1,411

GEICO

$614

$983

GEICO

$617

$1,001

Travelers

$648

$1,521

Travelers

$658

$1,377

GEICO

$663

$1,573

State Farm

$665

$2,283

GEICO

$679

$1,087

Travelers

$680

$1,423

GEICO

$691

$1,121

GEICO

$704

$1,272

Nationwide

$709

$2,388

Nationwide

$718

$2,779

Travelers

$721

$1,657

Travelers

$722

$1,467

GEICO

$725

$1,175

GEICO

$726

$1,419

GEICO

$727

$1,163

Travelers

$730

$1,738

State Farm

$741

$2,542

Nationwide

$762

$2,786

Nationwide

$764

$2,107

State Farm

$767

$2,568

Travelers

$776

$1,576

State Farm

$778

$3,081

Nationwide

$783

$3,206

Nationwide

$791

$3,258

State Farm

$809

$2,775

Nationwide

$811

$2,353

Nationwide

$812

$3,140

GEICO

$816

$4,664

GEICO

$822

$2,341

GEICO

$832

$4,597

State Farm

$833

$3,344

GEICO

$838

$4,630

Travelers

$840

$1,938

Travelers

$845

$1,941

Travelers

$849

$2,251

GEICO

$862

$2,427

Nationwide

$864

$3,771

State Farm

$869

$2,908

GEICO

$876

$2,064

Allstate

$878

$3,764

Allstate

$878

$3,764

Travelers

$885

$2,657

Nationwide

$886

$3,628

GEICO

$902

$2,142

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$919

$2,442

State Farm

$922

$3,650

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$955

$2,537

State Farm

$957

$4,345

State Farm

$958

$3,846

State Farm

$961

$3,214

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$965

$2,436

Allstate

$994

$1,541

Allstate

$994

$1,541

Travelers

$996

$2,297

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$997

$2,909

Travelers

$1,004

$2,717

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$1,018

$2,704

Farmers

$1,021

$1,421

Allstate

$1,027

$1,922

Allstate

$1,027

$1,922

State Farm

$1,028

$4,057

Allstate

$1,034

$1,603

Allstate

$1,034

$1,603

Progressive

$1,037

$1,691

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$1,039

$2,623

Allstate

$1,061

$1,757

Allstate

$1,061

$1,757

Farmers

$1,067

$1,539

Allstate

$1,081

$1,676

Allstate

$1,081

$1,676

Travelers

$1,082

$3,262

GEICO

$1,085

$8,761

Progressive

$1,086

$1,705

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$1,100

$3,191

State Farm

$1,100

$4,984

Progressive

$1,112

$2,337

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$1,120

$3,123

Farmers

$1,120

$2,180

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$1,127

$3,616

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$1,130

$2,852

Allstate

$1,134

$2,121

Allstate

$1,134

$2,121

Allstate

$1,144

$2,379

Allstate

$1,144

$2,379

Progressive

$1,148

$1,873

Allstate

$1,154

$4,947

Allstate

$1,154

$4,947

GEICO

$1,163

$8,124

Progressive

$1,182

$2,151

Farmers

$1,192

$2,421

State Farm

$1,208

$5,475

State Farm

$1,210

$4,777

Progressive

$1,219

$1,912

Progressive

$1,226

$2,000

Travelers

$1,229

$4,598

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$1,242

$3,464

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$1,245

$3,830

GEICO

$1,250

$7,143

Kemper

$1,251

$1,717

State Farm

$1,257

$5,697

State Farm

$1,263

$6,495

Travelers

$1,272

$3,821

Progressive

$1,275

$2,703

Progressive

$1,290

$2,360

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$1,316

$4,222

Farmers

$1,321

$2,078

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$1,327

$4,938

Progressive

$1,351

$2,119

Farmers

$1,370

$1,907

Farmers

$1,373

$3,070

Farmers

$1,400

$1,948

Farmers

$1,401

$2,318

State Farm

$1,402

$6,277

Farmers

$1,422

$2,768

Farmers

$1,430

$6,045

Farmers

$1,436

$3,318

Farmers

$1,441

$2,078

Kemper

$1,460

$1,935

Progressive

$1,474

$7,749

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$1,482

$4,299

Farmers

$1,483

$3,011

Farmers

$1,487

$2,145

Kemper

$1,491

$2,277

Kemper

$1,492

$2,047

Progressive

$1,511

$3,849

Farmers

$1,519

$6,596

Allstate

$1,523

$10,866

Allstate

$1,523

$10,866

Travelers

$1,543

$5,905

Kemper

$1,563

$2,145

Progressive

$1,589

$3,339

Travelers

$1,589

$4,792

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$1,595

$4,899

State Farm

$1,604

$7,182

State Farm

$1,612

$8,194

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$1,616

$4,688

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$1,635

$5,808

Progressive

$1,652

$8,775

Farmers

$1,658

$7,005

Progressive

$1,702

$10,093

Progressive

$1,714

$9,012

Farmers

$1,732

$8,909

Progressive

$1,736

$4,473

Farmers

$1,772

$7,697

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$1,816

$7,080

Kemper

$1,819

$2,411

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$1,820

$6,468

Progressive

$1,823

$3,864

Kemper

$1,831

$2,792

Farmers

$1,852

$9,845

Progressive

$1,874

$9,955

Progressive

$1,876

$11,162

Kemper

$1,906

$2,524

Kemper

$1,941

$2,574

Kemper

$2,257

$2,988

Kemper

$2,287

$3,571

Kemper

$2,344

$3,098

Kemper

$2,772

$3,663

Kemper

$2,809

$4,378

Kemper

$2,878

$4,652

Kemper

$3,551

$5,714

Kemper

$3,641

$5,884

Kemper

$3,994

$8,831

Kemper

$4,497

$7,237

Kemper

$4,934

$10,870

If you buy a personal policy as a teen driver, you may have to pay higher rates. Based on MoneyGeek’s data, a 16-year-old male driver in Green Bay pays an average of $3,203 more per year for their own policy vs. being included on their parent’s plan. You can shop around and compare rates to find the cheapest car insurance for teens.

Cheapest Car Insurance in Green Bay for Military Drivers

The cheapest car insurance companies for active-duty soldiers or veterans are:

  • USAA: $459 per year
  • GEICO: $481 per year

The most affordable minimum coverage insurers providing cheap military car insurance are USAA (around $364 per year) and GEICO (around $369 per year).

Company
Annual Premium
Monthly Premium

USAA

$196

$16

USAA

$203

$17

Erie

$203

$17

Erie

$204

$17

Nationwide

$226

$19

State Farm

$227

$19

Nationwide

$230

$19

GEICO

$234

$19

State Farm

$241

$20

USAA

$242

$20

GEICO

$252

$21

Erie

$252

$21

GEICO

$254

$21

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$264

$22

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$275

$23

State Farm

$289

$24

Progressive

$292

$24

Nationwide

$297

$25

West Bend Mutual

$312

$26

Progressive

$313

$26

Western National

$313

$26

Western National

$324

$27

Acuity

$325

$27

Farmers

$328

$27

IMT Insurance Company

$331

$28

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$332

$28

West Bend Mutual

$333

$28

Travelers

$346

$29

Acuity

$347

$29

Travelers

$362

$30

Farmers

$364

$30

Progressive

$379

$32

Farmers

$379

$32

West Bend Mutual

$379

$32

Travelers

$381

$32

AAA

$383

$32

IMT Insurance Company

$389

$32

AAA

$409

$34

Chubb

$433

$36

Acuity

$434

$36

American Family

$434

$36

American Family

$437

$36

USAA

$451

$38

USAA

$459

$38

Nationwide

$468

$39

American Family

$473

$39

GEICO

$481

$40

GEICO

$487

$41

AAA

$493

$41

Chubb

$503

$42

Western National

$509

$42

Nationwide

$509

$42

State Farm

$523

$44

GEICO

$530

$44

Allstate

$533

$44

Allstate

$539

$45

Kemper

$554

$46

State Farm

$571

$48

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$574

$48

IMT Insurance Company

$577

$48

Kemper

$581

$48

USAA

$582

$49

Erie

$594

$50

Allstate

$596

$50

Erie

$600

$50

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$606

$51

Kemper

$622

$52

IMT Insurance Company

$627

$52

American Family

$636

$53

Nationwide

$637

$53

Travelers

$638

$53

Travelers

$648

$54

American Family

$664

$55

Chubb

$685

$57

AAA

$687

$57

Progressive

$715

$60

American Family

$716

$60

State Farm

$717

$60

West Bend Mutual

$719

$60

West Bend Mutual

$734

$61

Travelers

$746

$62

Erie

$760

$63

IMT Insurance Company

$763

$64

AAA

$769

$64

Acuity

$778

$65

Allstate

$786

$65

Progressive

$789

$66

Auto-Owners Insurance Co

$801

$67

Dairyland

$802

$67

Farmers

$805

$67

Allstate

$816

$68

Farmers

$816

$68

West Bend Mutual

$867

$72

Dairyland

$882

$74

Chubb

$895

$75

Acuity

$912

$76

Farmers

$937

$78

AAA

$941

$78

Allstate

$966

$81

Progressive

$994

$83

IMT Insurance Company

$1,005

$84

Dairyland

$1,033

$86

Chubb

$1,054

$88

Acuity

$1,110

$92

Western National

$1,114

$93

Kemper

$1,205

$100

Kemper

$1,228

$102

Western National

$1,249

$104

Chubb

$1,398

$117

Kemper

$1,445

$120

Dairyland

$1,872

$156

Western National

$1,935

$161

Dairyland

$2,118

$176

Dairyland

$2,523

$210

How to Compare Cheap Green Bay Car Insurance Quotes Online

The process of getting an online quote in Green Bay will require you to enter a lot of personal information and may take 15 minutes or more per insurer. To save time and effort, you can use MoneyGeek’s car insurance calculator. This gives you an estimate of your car insurance costs depending on factors like age, desired coverage level, driving history and vehicle type.

Auto Insurance Calculator

See how the Average Annual Auto Insurance Rates vary with the options chosen.

Wisconsin
Female
30-65
Clean

Average Annual Auto Insurance Rates

Click the section of the wheel in your price range to see options.

low end

on average

high end

Click an insurer below to visit their review page or continue to your personalized quote.

USAA
AAA

Best Car Insurance in Green Bay: Summary

The best car insurance company will fit your needs and profile. MoneyGeek found that the following companies offer the best car insurance in Green Bay:

  • Best overall: Acuity (MoneyGeek score of 83 out of 100)
  • Best for service: Acuity (MoneyGeek score of 78 out of 100)
  • Best cheap: Erie (MoneyGeek score of 84 out of 100)

MoneyGeek scores may change as factors might be weighted differently in each category. Acuity is also the best car insurance company in Wisconsin.

USAA is the top option for military drivers, with a MoneyGeek score of 85 out of 100.

Best Overall Car Insurance in Green Bay

Based on MoneyGeek’s analysis, the following companies are the best options for car insurance in Green Bay:

  • Acuity: MoneyGeek score of 83 out of 100 ($912 per year)
  • Erie: MoneyGeek score of 81 out of 100 ($600 per year)

Acuity ranked highly for customer satisfaction and available coverage. These scores show that the company offers good customer support and handles customer complaints well.

USAA is the best option for military families. The company received a MoneyGeek score of 85 out of 100.

Acuity

pros

Ranked highly for customer satisfaction

Good score for available coverages

Offers full glass coverage, rental car or travel reimbursement and roadside assistance

cons

Doesn’t provide accident forgiveness coverage

Lower score in affordability

COMPANY HIGHLIGHTS

Acuity has high scores for customer satisfaction and available coverage options. It provides many rare and common coverages, including full glass coverage, roadside assistance and rental car or travel reimbursement.

Full glass coverage can help you in the event of damage to your vehicle’s windshield or windows. It waives your comprehensive deductible if you need to replace or repair these items. You can add roadside assistance to your policy to get help in case your vehicle breaks down. This coverage will cover the cost of towing and labor.

The company also offers rental car or travel reimbursement coverage that can help you pay for a rental car, bus fares, taxi costs or other transportation expenses when you can’t drive your vehicle due to a covered loss.

Best Car Insurance in Green Bay for Customer Service

Setting costs aside, the following insurance companies offer the best customer service in Green Bay:

  • Acuity: MoneyGeek score of 78 out of 100 ($912 per year)
  • Chubb: MoneyGeek score of 76 out of 100 ($1,054 per year)

Acuity ranked second-highest for claims management and customer satisfaction, but you will pay a higher price for good service with this company since it offers more expensive policies compared to other insurers.

Acuity

pros

High score for claims management

Good customer satisfaction rating

Offers full glass coverage, new car replacement and gap insurance

cons

Doesn’t provide deductible modification

More expensive than other insurers

COMPANY HIGHLIGHTS

In addition to ranking highly for claims management and customer satisfaction, Acuity offers policyholders various rare and common coverages.

You can add full glass coverage to your policy with this company. This coverage can help you avoid paying the deductible in case you need to repair or replace your vehicle’s windows and windshield.

Gap insurance coverage will pay the difference between your car’s value and the remaining loan amount if you total it due to an accident. The company also offers new car replacement coverage that will pay for a brand-new vehicle of the same make and model if you destroy yours in an accident.

Acuity’s high customer satisfaction scores are based on the J.D. Power study and customer complaint index. Its ranking shows that its customers have few complaints about the provider’s service.

Best Cheap Car Insurance Companies in Green Bay

MoneyGeek analyzed various minimum coverage policies in Wisconsin and found the following insurers offering the best cheap car insurance in Green Bay:

  • Erie: MoneyGeek score of 84 out of 100 ($204 per year)
  • Acuity: MoneyGeek score of 82 out of 100 ($347 per year)

Purchasing minimum coverage is typically not expensive, but you should know that it won’t offer you sufficient liability coverage or protect you against the cost of vehicle damage in an accident.

Erie

pros

An affordable minimum coverage policy costs an average of $204 per year

Offers safe driving, bundling and automatic payment discount

High score for affordability

Excellent score for customer satisfaction

cons

Scored poorly for available coverages

Doesn’t offer good student or paperless discounts

COMPANY HIGHLIGHTS

Erie’s policies are the cheapest among its competitors in Green Bay, making it the best option for affordable minimum coverage policies. Since it also ranks high for satisfaction, you won’t have to worry about having a difficult time dealing with the company when you have questions or concerns.

The company provides various ways to lower your premiums through common and rare discounts. You can earn a discount on your policy for being an accident-free driver. You might also qualify for a discount by getting multiple types of policies with the company. There’s also a rare discount for setting up automatic payments, which comes with the added benefit of knowing you’ll never miss a payment.

Besides these discounts, you can also lower your insurance costs if you have daytime-running lights installed in your vehicle or an electronic tracking device.

Read MoneyGeek's Erie Auto Insurance Review

Average Cost of Car Insurance in Green Bay

The average cost of car insurance in Green Bay is $790 per year for a full coverage policy, which is $212 less than the average cost of car insurance in Wisconsin and $475 less than the national average. The policyholder’s location greatly affects car insurance costs.

These rates are for a full coverage policy with $100,000 bodily injury liability per person, $300,000 in bodily injury liability per accident and $100,000 in property damage liability per accident.

About Mark Fitzpatrick


Mark Fitzpatrick headshot

Mark Fitzpatrick is a senior content director at MoneyGeek with over five years of experience analyzing the insurance market, conducting original research and creating content that can be personalized for every buyer. He has been quoted on insurance topics in several publications, including CNBC, NBC News and Mashable.

Mark earned a master’s degree in Economics and International Relations from Johns Hopkins University and a bachelor’s degree from Boston College. He is passionate about using his economics and insurance knowledge to bring transparency around financial topics and help others feel confident in their money moves.