Best and Cheapest Multi-Car Insurance Quotes


Enter your ZIP code to get started

Shield

Free. Simple. Secure.

Banner image
ByMark Fitzpatrick
Edited byCasie McCoskey
ByMark Fitzpatrick
Edited byCasie McCoskey

Updated: May 20, 2024

Advertising & Editorial Disclosure

Bundling multiple cars into a single insurance policy can unlock notable savings. Insurers often reward this consolidated approach with tempting discounts. Typically, you can include three to five vehicles in such a package, making it an economical choice for households juggling multiple cars.

MoneyGeek's findings: Farmers provides a notable multi-car discount, but GEICO often emerges as the most budget-friendly choice for many. For the most personalized savings, consider comparing quotes from a variety of providers.

Table of Contents
Key Takeaways

barChart icon

On average, multi-car discounts save drivers 52% or $736 annually when insuring two cars on one policy.

car icon

Farmers offers the most significant multi-car discount, but GEICO has the cheapest multi-car rates overall.

coins2 icon

Insuring multiple vehicles on the same policy allows you to stack coverages and discounts. It may also allow you to have one deductible.

Why Trust MoneyGeek? We gathered data from Quadrant Information Services and state insurance departments to determine the average cost of a multi-car insurance policy. We also consulted various reputable sources to analyze the pros and cons of getting a multi-car insurance policy versus multiple individual policies.

766,080Quotes Analyzed
 
16Companies Compared
 
900ZIP Codes

The Cheapest Car Insurance Companies for Multiple Car Insurance Policy

MoneyGeek found that GEICO and Nationwide offer the cheapest multi-car insurance:

  • GEICO: $1,407 (52% discount vs. two single drivers cost)
  • Nationwide: $1,417 (52% discount vs. two single drivers cost)

GEICO provides the cheapest multi-car insurance rate among the two options, which makes it an appealing choice for budget-conscious individuals seeking a multi-car insurance policy discount. Both GEICO and Nationwide offer up to 52% discounts if you insure more than one car under the same policy. Meanwhile, Farmers offer a whopping 93% discount for multi-car insurance ($1,460) vs. single driver ($2,821) cost.

GEICOMulti-Car Insurance Cost$1,407Two Single Driver Cost$2,143Discount52%
NationwideMulti-Car Insurance Cost$1,417Two Single Driver Cost$2,157Discount52%
State FarmMulti-Car Insurance Cost$1,426Two Single Driver Cost$2,075Discount46%
FarmersMulti-Car Insurance Cost$1,460Two Single Driver Cost$2,821Discount93%
ProgressiveMulti-Car Insurance Cost$1,555Two Single Driver Cost$2,530Discount63%
TravelersMulti-Car Insurance Cost$1,656Two Single Driver Cost$2,321Discount40%
AllstateMulti-Car Insurance Cost$1,685Two Single Driver Cost$2,543Discount51%

Finding the most cost-effective multi-car insurance policy is crucial for maximizing savings in a household with two cars and two drivers. MoneyGeek's research has identified two publicly available insurance companies that offer competitive rates for multi-car insurance, making it convenient to insure two cars on one policy.

However, it's essential to remember that the decision should not be based solely on the initial premium cost. Other factors, such as coverage options, customer service quality, available discounts and claim settlement processes, also play a significant role in choosing the right multi-driver car insurance provider.

These rates are averages for a married couple with two identical Toyota Camrys, so the cheapest car insurance company for you may be different. The cheapest way to get car insurance for your household is usually to add separate drivers to one policy.

In a household with two cars and two drivers, you may find that the cheapest car insurance company offers the most significant multiple-car discount. To get the best savings, compare car insurance quotes for two cars and two drivers on one policy.

Cheapest Car Insurance Companies for Multiple Car Insurance Policy by State

The table below shows that GEICO and Nationwide frequently present the most affordable premiums across states.

Notice the impressive discounts each insurer offers for multi-car policies compared to two single-car insurances. For instance, Farmers in Florida grants a substantial 231% discount for multi-car coverage.

However, always remember that the "cheapest" coverage isn't necessarily the best. Weigh affordability against the coverage quality and service the insurer provides to guarantee the best value for your state-specific multi-car insurance.

AlabamaCompanyNationwideMulti-Car Insurance Cost$1,122Two Single Driver Cost$1,734.29Discount55%
AlaskaCompanyState FarmMulti-Car Insurance Cost$1,099Two Single Driver Cost$1,605.00Discount46%
ArizonaCompanyGEICOMulti-Car Insurance Cost$945Two Single Driver Cost$2,075.23Discount120%
ArkansasCompanyGEICOMulti-Car Insurance Cost$978Two Single Driver Cost$1,803.75Discount84%
CaliforniaCompanyProgressiveMulti-Car Insurance Cost$1,328Two Single Driver Cost$2,393.41Discount80%
ColoradoCompanyGEICOMulti-Car Insurance Cost$939Two Single Driver Cost$1,772.44Discount89%
ConnecticutCompanyGEICOMulti-Car Insurance Cost$981Two Single Driver Cost$1,670.25Discount70%
DelawareCompanyState FarmMulti-Car Insurance Cost$1,609Two Single Driver Cost$2,018.00Discount25%

When choosing the cheapest car insurance companies for a multiple-car insurance policy by state, you should consider several factors to ensure you get the best coverage at an affordable price. Here are some key considerations:

    discount icon

    Multi-Car Discount

    Inquire about the multi-car insurance discount offered by each insurance provider. This discount can yield substantial savings when insuring multiple vehicles under the same policy.

    loanReview icon

    Coverage Flexibility

    Check if the insurance company allows you to customize coverage for each vehicle based on individual needs. Some insurers may offer flexibility in coverage options for multiple cars.

    homeInsurance icon

    Bundling Discounts

    If you have other insurance policies (e.g., home, renters) with an insurance provider, ask about bundling discounts for adding multiple car insurance policies.

    checkList icon

    Policy Consolidation

    Consolidating all vehicles and drivers under one multi-car policy can simplify administration and potentially result in cost savings.

    female icon

    Additional Driver Discounts

    Inquire about discounts for adding multiple drivers to the same policy, especially if they are low-risk drivers or have good driving records.

    shakingHands icon

    Multi-Policy Discount

    Some insurance companies may offer discounts for insuring multiple cars and drivers on one policy, incentivizing customers to consolidate all their insurance needs with one provider.

    usMap icon

    Local Underwriting

    Check if the insurance company underwrites policies locally in your state, which may lead to more tailored coverage options and competitive rates.

    pin icon

    Regional Premium Differences

    Be aware that insurance premium rates can vary by region within a state. Compare rates for different regions to ensure you get the best deal.

    signupBonus icon

    State-Specific Incentives

    Some states may have unique incentives or programs that promote multi-car insurance or offer discounts for specific policy configurations.

    car2 icon

    Claims Process for Multiple Cars

    Understand how the claims process works when dealing with multiple cars on the same policy. Efficient handling of claims for all vehicles is crucial during stressful situations.

california icon
MONEYGEEK EXPERT TIP

California law mandates that insurance companies provide a 20% discount to good drivers. If all drivers under the multi-car policy qualify, this can lead to substantial savings.

The Best Car Insurance Company for Multiple Cars

Even if an insurance company offers the lowest price, that doesn’t always mean they are the best. The best insurance companies have high customer service scores and superior financial stability with affordable rates. In this case, the companies with the two lowest rates are not MoneyGeek’s top picks for best multi-car insurance policies.

MoneyGeek recommends Travelers and State Farm as the best car insurance companies for two or more cars and drivers. These companies may not offer the lowest rates, but they do offer robust discounts.

In the table presented, we based scoring on a scale of 0 to 100. This comprehensive evaluation takes into account several crucial factors to provide a thorough view of each company. Specifically, we consider the stability of the insurance provider, customer satisfaction ratings, efficiency and fairness in the claims process, the range and scope of coverage options and the affordability of their policies. This scoring system aims to offer a clear and concise overview, assisting you in making an informed decision when choosing an insurance provider.

Travelers

Average Annual Premium: $1,656

Travelers offers standard car insurance discounts like bundling, multi-car and safe driving, along with unique ones such as new vehicle and loyalty. Hybrid drivers might also enjoy an alternative energy discount, showcasing Travelers' diverse offerings. Its customer satisfaction rating surpasses the industry average, making it a great choice.

State Farm

Average Annual Premium: $1,426

State Farm provides popular auto insurance discounts such as bundling, multi-vehicle and safe driving. It also offers anti-theft, defensive driving and airbag discounts. Notably, young drivers can benefit from discounts for completing a driver's education course before 21 and maintaining good academic standing.

TravelersMoneyGeek Score (out of 100)93Multi-Car Insurance Cost$1,656Two Single Driver Cost$2,321
State FarmMoneyGeek Score (out of 100)93Multi-Car Insurance Cost$1,426Two Single Driver Cost$2,075
ProgressiveMoneyGeek Score (out of 100)93Multi-Car Insurance Cost$1,555Two Single Driver Cost$2,530
GEICOMoneyGeek Score (out of 100)92Multi-Car Insurance Cost$1,407Two Single Driver Cost$2,143
FarmersMoneyGeek Score (out of 100)92Multi-Car Insurance Cost$1,460Two Single Driver Cost$2,821
NationwideMoneyGeek Score (out of 100)92Multi-Car Insurance Cost$1,417Two Single Driver Cost$2,157
AllstateMoneyGeek Score (out of 100)92Multi-Car Insurance Cost$1,685Two Single Driver Cost$2,543
Loading...

Best Car Insurance Company for Families

State Farm offers tailored insurance benefits. Emergency Road Service handles issues like flat tires while they cover car rental costs during repairs. Families insuring multiple vehicles get a discount, as do households with good-studying teens. This provider rewards safe driving habits and modern car safety features with additional discounts.

mglogo
MoneyGeek Top Pick: Multi-Car for Family
GEICO

Average Annual Premium: $2,936

GEICO is great for families with young drivers due to its competitive premiums and array of discounts, including good student and defensive driving course reductions. A big relief for parents, it offers accident forgiveness, preventing rate hikes after a first at-fault incident. Additionally, GEICO's efficient claims processing and stellar customer service ensure prompt assistance for families.

Data filtered by:Results filtered by:
Age:
Age:16
GEICOBest Score (Out of 100)84Family Premium$2,936Individual Premium$5,463Increase in Premium46%
State FarmBest Score (Out of 100)84Family Premium$3,055Individual Premium$3,732Increase in Premium18%
NationwideBest Score (Out of 100)84Family Premium$2,718Individual Premium$5,108Increase in Premium47%
TravelersBest Score (Out of 100)83Family Premium$3,436Individual Premium$5,622Increase in Premium39%
ProgressiveBest Score (Out of 100)82Family Premium$3,454Individual Premium$7,481Increase in Premium54%
AllstateBest Score (Out of 100)81Family Premium$3,292Individual Premium$6,583Increase in Premium50%
FarmersBest Score (Out of 100)81Family Premium$3,562Individual Premium$8,864Increase in Premium60%

Insuring teens and young drivers, especially those under 25, can be expensive. Their limited driving experience and statistically higher risk of accidents often result in steeper premiums. Including them in your existing policy can significantly increase costs, making it essential to explore options and discounts tailored for this age group.

When securing multi-car insurance for a family, several factors come into play:

  • Coverage Needs: Determine the coverage each vehicle requires. Newer cars driven by young drivers might benefit from comprehensive and collision coverage, given the higher accident risk.
  • Driver Profiles: Recognize that teens and young drivers often face higher premiums due to their limited driving experience. Their age, grades and driving history can influence rates.
  • Teen-Specific Discounts: Explore discounts tailored for young drivers, such as good student rewards or discounts for completing defensive driving courses.
  • Added Services: Given the inexperience of young drivers, consider coverages like roadside assistance for unforeseen events like flat tires or lockouts.
  • Insurer Reputation: Prioritize insurers known for accommodating young drivers and offering excellent claim services.
  • Comparison Shopping: Always gather and compare quotes from multiple providers, emphasizing those with favorable terms for households with young drivers.

Securing family car insurance can yield substantial savings. Having a separate policy for your teen might cost an extra thousand dollars. Consolidating car insurance in one multi-car policy ensures affordability and protection.

How Does Multi-Car Insurance Work?

Multi-car insurance is a policy that allows you to insure multiple cars with a single provider. It's a policy for multiple vehicles bundled into one plan. Typically, up to four cars garaged at the same address can be covered. Even if a teen is studying out-of-state, you can include their car if they park it at the home address and retain that permanent address.

Providers don't restrict coverage just to family; roommates or anyone living with you can be added, particularly if they also drive your vehicle. However, specific terms can vary by provider.

What Does Multi-Car Insurance Cover?

It's a single policy that covers several vehicles, streamlining your insurance.

Fundamentally, every car under this policy needs to meet the minimum car insurance requirements, primarily liability-only coverage. This ensures coverage for any damages you may cause in an accident.

State-mandated coverages may include:

Required Coverage
    injury icon

    Bodily Injury

    This coverage pays for injuries that you, as the at-fault driver, might cause to others in an accident. It can cover medical expenses, lost wages and even legal fees if a lawsuit ensues.

    houseRebuild icon

    Property Damage

    This coverage pays for damages you cause to someone else's property while driving. Typically, you use it for damages to other vehicles, but it can also cover damages to structures, like fences or buildings.

    carAccident icon

    Uninsured Motorist

    Not all drivers on the road have insurance, despite it being a legal requirement in many states. Uninsured motorist coverage compensates you if you're in an accident with such a driver who is at fault. It covers medical expenses and, in some cases, property damage. Notably, this coverage is not mandated in all states.

Drivers might choose more than liability-only coverage for enhanced protection against unforeseen expenses. Some optional coverages may not apply to all cars on a policy, allowing tailored protection.

    carInsurance icon

    Comprehensive

    Comprehensive coverage pays for damages to your vehicle caused by events that aren't collision-related. This can include theft, vandalism, natural disasters or hitting an animal.

    accident2 icon

    Collision

    As the name suggests, collision coverage pays for damages to your vehicle resulting from a collision, whether with another vehicle or an object like a tree or lamppost.

    ignition icon

    Road Assistance

    This coverage offers help when you experience a breakdown on the road. Services can include jump-starting a battery, tire changes, lockout assistance or towing to the nearest mechanic.

    giveMoney icon

    Rental Reimbursement

    If your car is undergoing repairs due to a covered insurance claim, this coverage pays for the cost of renting a vehicle in the interim. It's a handy option for ensuring continuity in your daily routines.

Deciding which cars to insure with comprehensive or collision insurance versus those with liability-only coverage depends on several factors:

  • Value of the Car: Newer, more valuable vehicles typically benefit from comprehensive and collision coverage. Older cars, especially those whose value is less than the deductible plus the additional premium for the coverage, might be better off with just liability.
  • Loan/Lease Status: The lender usually requires comprehensive and collision coverages if a car is leased or financed.
  • High-Risk Areas: Consider where and how often you drive the car. A car parked on city streets or driven frequently may benefit from comprehensive coverage to protect against theft or vandalism. A vehicle used on busy highways might warrant collision coverage.
  • Personal Financial Situation: If you can't afford to replace or repair a car out-of-pocket, comprehensive and collision coverage might be a good investment.
  • Age and Condition: Older cars, or those in poor condition, might not justify the cost of comprehensive or collision insurance.
  • Deductible: If you can afford a higher deductible, it might be worth adding these coverages as the premium costs could be lower.

Ultimately, it's about balancing the cost of premiums with the potential out-of-pocket costs and the value or importance of the car to you.

mglogo icon
MONEYGEEK EXPERT TIP

Liability-only insurance covers damages to others that you're responsible for. It includes:

  • Bodily Injury: Pays for medical expenses, lost wages and pain and suffering for others if you cause an accident.
  • Property Damage: Covers repair or replacement costs of someone else's property (like their car) if you're at fault.

All states require some form of liability insurance, with the exception of New Hampshire and Virginia. However, drivers are still responsible for the damages they cause and might need to prove their financial responsibility after an accident.

Pros and Cons of Getting a Multi-Car Insurance Policy

A multi-car insurance policy offers a convenient way to cover multiple vehicles under one plan, often leading to discounts and streamlined management. However, it's not always the best fit for everyone. While bundling can mean reduced premiums and less paperwork, it may also mean higher premiums if your policy includes a driver with a poor driving record.

Multi-Car Insurance Policy

plusSign icon

Pros

  • Savings Potential: Adding a second car to an existing policy is cheaper than getting two individual car insurance policies. The average savings of a multi-car policy is about $500 per year.
  • Convenience: Handling all insurance issues with the same company is more straightforward than dealing with multiple companies.
  • Single Claims Deductible: Some insurance companies offer one claim deductible for multiple cars. If you damage both vehicles on one policy, you’ll only pay one deductible to fix both.
  • Stackable Coverages: You may be able to stack coverages, which combine coverage limits for multiple cars on the same policy, offering increased protection if you are involved in an accident.
minusSign icon

Cons

  • Higher Premiums for Risky Drivers: If any driver under the policy has a poor driving record, it can result in higher premiums for all vehicles covered.
  • Single Claim Can Raise Rates: If one driver on the policy files a claim, the entire policy might see a rate increase, affecting all drivers, regardless of who was at fault.
  • Discount Limitations: All drivers and vehicles must meet certain criteria to qualify for discounts. For example, if one driver doesn't have a clean record, the entire policy might miss out on a 'good driver' discount.
  • Potential Complications During Renewal: If one driver has multiple claims or traffic violations, it could affect the renewability of the entire policy.

How To Get Multi-Car Insurance Quotes

Though getting multi-car insurance quotes is similar to getting a quote for just one car, there are some key differences. Gather the needed information before getting quotes so you’re ready to compare prices with multiple insurance companies.

1
Gather Information

With two or more drivers, you’ll need the personal information of both, including full names, garaging addresses of the cars, driver’s license numbers, dates of birth and marital statuses. Necessary information for both vehicles includes the VIN, current mileage and trim package.

2
Decide Your Coverages

Your coverage needs may vary with each car insured. Typically, providers will allow you different coverage levels for each car. Determine how much coverage you need before moving on to the next step. MoneyGeek recommends purchasing more than your state minimum liability insurance to protect your finances in the event of an at-fault accident.

3
Get Quotes

Whether you gather quotes online or through an agent, get at least three from different insurance companies. Use the same coverage limits with all companies, even if you choose different coverages for each car.

4
Compare Quotes

After getting your quotes, compare them to see which is the best. Review price, coverage and discount offerings, financial stability and customer reviews to help make your decision.

5
Purchase a Policy

Once you’ve determined the best insurance company, it’s time to purchase a multi-car insurance policy. Your insurance company can walk you through buying car insurance online after you receive a quote. If you’re working with an agent, they can help finalize your purchase.

Limitations of a Multi-Car Insurance Policy

Insuring multiple cars on a single policy can often be a savvy financial decision. However, it may not be the best move if:

  • You live with someone with a checkered driving history
  • You own a classic car
  • Not everyone who wants to join the policy lives with you

If someone you live with has a bad driving record, it might be cheaper to get a separate policy for your car. Insurance policies for drivers with poor driving records usually cost more.

A multi-car policy may not be the best way to insure a classic car. Such vehicles often demand their own dedicated insurance policy to protect them appropriately.

Classic car insurance policies offer perks that standard multi-car insurances often overlook. Coverage can include "Agreed Value" (where you and the insurer agree on the car's value in advance), specialized repair or restoration shop options and protection for automotive memorabilia and spare parts. Such exclusive features ensure your cherished classic receives the specialized care and coverage it needs, which might not be available within a general multi-car policy.

For a multi-car policy, all cars must be at the same address. If you have cars at different places, you need separate policies.

Frequently Asked Questions

What company offers the cheapest multi-car policy?
Is it cheaper to insure multiple cars under one policy?
How much can insuring under one policy can save me?
Can I have different coverage levels under one multi-car policy?
Do both cars in a multi-car policy have to be at the same address?

About Mark Fitzpatrick


Mark Fitzpatrick headshot

Mark Fitzpatrick has analyzed the property and casualty insurance market for over five years, conducting original research and creating personalized content for every kind of buyer. Currently, he leads P&C insurance content production at MoneyGeek. Fitzpatrick has been quoted in several insurance-related publications, including CNBC, NBC News and Mashable.

Fitzpatrick earned a master’s degree in economics and international relations from Johns Hopkins University and a bachelor’s degree from Boston College. He is passionate about using his knowledge of economics and insurance to bring transparency around financial topics and help others feel confident in their money moves.