The Cheapest Car Insurance in New Jersey (June 2023)

Plymouth Rock is the cheapest insurance provider for residents of New Jersey. NJM and GEICO also offer low rates, depending on the profile and type of driver.

The best auto insurance providers in New Jersey balance cost and customer service quality.

The following carriers offer the cheapest average auto insurance premiums, according to the state minimum requirements:

• Plymouth Rock: $476 per year
• GEICO: $478 per year

MoneyGeek’s research revealed that Foremost is the priciest provider in New Jersey, with its minimum coverage policy costing roughly $2,321 per year.

With minimum coverage, you are protected against damages or injuries you inflict on others. Damage to your own vehicle, however, isn’t included. Full coverage, which includes comprehensive and collision coverage, can cover the cost to repair your car.

On average, auto insurance companies with the cheapest full coverage rates in the Garden State are the following:

• Plymouth Rock: $907 per year
• NJM: $940 per year

Foremost provides the most expensive full coverage quotes in the Garden State at $4,386 each year.

Purchasing comprehensive and collision insurance is typically more expensive. In comparison with Plymouth Rock's minimum coverage at $476 per year, a full coverage policy costs $431 more at $907 per year.

Although full coverage is usually the more expensive option, it provides a much more robust level of financial protection compared to a minimum coverage policy. Damages to your vehicle from collisions or flooding are covered with a full coverage policy.

The amount of car insurance you need significantly affects the cost of your annual premium. MoneyGeek obtained quotes from insurers using a sample full coverage policy with the following liability limits:

• $100,000 bodily injury per person
• $300,000 bodily injury per accident
• $100,000 property damage per accident

Drivers in New Jersey who want to reduce their overall cost and select a lower liability limit, drop comprehensive and collision coverage or increase their deductible. Note that these cost-saving practices may be riskier if you find yourself in an accident.

Although many insurance providers have online quote tools, it may take up to 15 minutes to input all the required personal information. When you’re comparing rates for multiple insurers, this process can take time.

MoneyGeek’s auto insurance calculator only requires a few personal details to quickly generate your estimated auto insurance quote. Simply input your driving record, gender and age to receive a personalized quote. Our tool serves as a starting point for New Jersey drivers looking for the cheapest auto insurance rates.

Age is one of the biggest factors affecting car insurance rates in New Hampshire. MoneyGeek found that GEICO, Plymouth Rock or NJM offer the cheapest options, depending on what age group you and your family belong to.

These auto insurance companies provide the most affordable policies for teens on their family policy:

• GEICO: $2,059 per year for male teens and $1,919 per year for female teens
• Travelers: $2,743 per year for male teens and $2,469 per year for female teens

Foremost has the priciest quotes for teens, costing $4,635 per year for a female teen and $5,186 per year for a male teen. Both rates are for a 16-year-old on their parent’s policy.

With teens' car insurance rates decreasing with age, 19-year-old drivers can expect to get the lowest rates. New Jersey's cheapest provider for 19-year-old males is Travelers ($1,877).

Adding a teen to your family’s policy is significantly less expensive than purchasing an individual policy for them, and without parental or a guardian's consent to co-sign, most teens under the age of 18 cannot legally get their own auto policy. Cost-wise, for example, adding your son to your family policy instead of purchasing an individual policy could save an average of $2,854 per year.

To reduce your car insurance rate as a young driver, you can opt for an insurer that offers discounts. Companies like Allstate, Progressive, State Farm and Travelers provide discounts for students who live away from home. These insurers, in addition to GEICO, also offer good student discounts.

Auto insurance companies that provide the cheapest full coverage rates for New Jerseyans in their 20s are:

• Plymouth Rock: $983 per year
• NJM: $1,202 per year

With policies that cost $5,096 annually, Foremost offers the most expensive policies for full coverage in the Garden State.

Drivers in their 20s typically pay higher premiums compared with middle-aged drivers due to higher accident frequency and a greater incidence of moving violations. MoneyGeek’s research found that young drivers might pay roughly $76 more for the cheapest coverage.

Senior drivers in New Jersey may obtain the cheapest full coverage policies from the following insurers:

• NJM: $824 per year
• Plymouth Rock: $901 per year

Foremost offers the most expensive premium to senior drivers aged 60+, costing an average of $4,263 per year.

Auto insurance premiums tend to be more expensive for drivers in their 70s and 80s. Compared with senior drivers, middle-aged drivers in the state pay $83 more per year.

Senior drivers in New Jersey might be able to obtain a discount with providers like Allstate, GEICO, NJM and Mercury. Weighing different insurer preferences is one way to choose the cheapest provider.

Drivers with a violation on their record usually pay more for auto insurance. In New Jersey, drivers with a speeding ticket or DUI on their driving record will get the cheapest insurance from Plymouth Rock. Drivers with an at-fault accident will find the most affordable insurance from NJM.

For drivers in New Jersey with a speeding ticket, the following companies offer the most affordable policies:

• Plymouth Rock: $1,025 per year
• GEICO: $1,059 per year

Foremost offers the highest annual premium at $4,856 per year.

Our research shows that drivers in New Jersey with a speeding ticket will pay an average of $191 more for car insurance than those with a clean driving history.

The following auto insurance companies offer the cheapest rates to drivers after an at-fault accident:

• NJM: $968 per year
• Plymouth Rock: $1,177 per year

The most expensive provider is Foremost with policies that start at $9,679 per year.

New Jersey auto insurance quotes can be $1,227 more expensive for drivers who are found at fault following an accident.

Those with a DUI on their record may get the cheapest policies from the following providers:

• Plymouth Rock: $1,025 per year
• NJM: $1,105 per year

State Farm offers the most expensive estimates for drivers with DUI — a policy can cost roughly $10,536 annually.

Drivers in New Jersey with a DUI will pay approximately $1,611 more per year than those with a clean driving record.

The cheapest car insurance companies in New Jersey for drivers with poor credit are:

• NJM: $1,603 per year
• Plymouth Rock Assurance: $1,914 per year

With Hanover, policyholders with poor credit will pay the most, at approximately $9,553 per year for a full coverage policy.

In New Jersey, drivers with good credit will pay approximately $1,704 less per year for car insurance than those with poor credit.

Drivers with poor credit tend to pay more expensive rates since they’re more likely to file a claim. Although some states don’t permit insurers to consider a driver’s credit history when assessing rates, New Jersey allows this.

Improving your credit standing is a solid way to secure a cheaper premium. You can also compare insurer’s rates or maximize common discounts to obtain the cheapest policy.

The cheapest auto insurance companies in New Jersey for sports car drivers are:

• GEICO: $1,131 per year
• Travelers: $1,147 per year

Foremost charges the most expensive premiums at around $4,398 per year. Car insurance for drivers of sports vehicles can be more expensive since repairs and replacement parts tend to cost more.

In New Jersey, it’s $396 more expensive to insure a Toyota Camry LE than a sports car.

Although MoneyGeek used a Ford Mustang as a sample car, the annual premium cost generally varies per car model. Sports, electric and luxury vehicles tend to cost more to insure than other types of cars, but otherwise, your car’s model shouldn’t significantly impact your rates.

Plymouth Rock is the cheapest insurance company that offers full coverage for military members and veterans. Its average annual premium costs $907.

USAA is also available to military personnel in New Jersey and across the U.S. And you may consider getting a policy with GEICO to take advantage of its military discounts.

The city in which you live in New Jersey, and even your ZIP code, can have a significant impact on the cost of your auto insurance. Those who live in high-risk neighborhoods, such as ones with increased crime rates, tend to pay more for auto insurance.

Jersey City residents with an NJM policy pay an average of $1,161 per year, making it the cheapest city in New Jersey for car insurance. Elizabeth is the second-cheapest city, with the average cost of $1,236 per year for a Plymouth Rock car insurance policy.

All New Jersey drivers must have the minimum coverage which includes bodily injury liability, property damage liability, personal injury protection, and uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage. Understanding how much coverage you need ensures you’re sufficiently protected.

New Jersey law requires that all drivers have car insurance, either a basic policy or a standard policy. MoneyGeek’s rates were based on the standard policy requirement for 2023, which included bodily injury liability, property damage liability, personal injury protection and uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage. Although purchasing basic coverage is less expensive, you’ll pay more out of pocket if you get in an accident and be financially at risk from an at-fault accident.

To avoid paying high costs if you get in an accident, you can purchase more liability coverage for added protection.

MoneyGeek recommends drivers increase their limits to $100,000 in bodily injury liability insurance per person, $300,000 in bodily injury liability insurance and $100,000 in property damage insurance per accident. Doing so offers extensive financial protection in the event of an at-fault accident.

Full coverage includes comprehensive and collision insurance, which provides a much greater level of financial protection. With collision insurance, damages to your car that involve collisions with trees, walls, fences or other objects are covered. Comprehensive insurance pays for non-collision incidents like natural disasters, fire, theft, vandalism and a cracked windshield on your car.

If you own a valuable car, we encourage purchasing full coverage, even if it isn’t required.

Though no alternative to car insurance in New Jersey is available, drivers may be able to purchase a basic car insurance policy that includes less coverage. A basic policy includes the following coverages and limits:

• $5,000 property damage liability per accident
• $15,000 personal injury protection per person or per accident

Bodily injury liability, collision and comprehensive coverage are available as optional add-ons with some insurers. Though a basic plan may cost less, you won’t be covered for costs if you’re found at fault in an accident.

MoneyGeek always recommends purchasing the maximum amount of coverage that fits within your budget, to avoid paying high out-of-pocket costs if you get into an accident.

Those comparison shopping for car insurance may have questions about affordability and quality between providers. MoneyGeek answered the most commonly asked questions to help you gain a better grasp of auto insurance in New Jersey.