MoneyGeek ranked the leading auto insurance firms based on factors like affordability, customer satisfaction and more to help you find the best car insurance policy in Kentucky for your requirements. Factors such as driving record, age and location all play a part in deciding your auto insurance costs, so it’s a great idea to obtain quotes from multiple carriers to find the best coverage and cheapest rates. MoneyGeek's rankings demonstrate a potential savings of $1,427 when comparing car insurance costs from the best companies in Kentucky.
The Best Cheap Car Insurance in Kentucky for 2021
- Home
- Insurance
- Shop for Car Insurance
- The Best Affordable Car Insurance in Kentucky for 2021
Cheapest Car Insurance Companies and Quotes in Kentucky
MoneyGeek rated the most affordable car insurance providers in Kentucky based on collision and comprehensive coverage for average drivers. Multiple individualized factors play a role in your ability to find cheap auto insurance in the state. Try to compare car insurance quotes and average annual rates from several different companies to get an idea of the cost you’ll need to pay.
Average Comprehensive and Collision Rates in Kentucky
- CompanyAnnuallyMonthly
- 1. USAA$785$65
- 2. State Farm$872$73
- 3. GEICO$874$73
- 4. Kentucky Farm Bureau$1,006$84
- 5. Allstate$1,250$104
- 6. Travelers$1,310$109
- 7. Progressive$1,575$131
- 8. Nationwide$2,145$179
- 9. MetLife$2,212$184
These prices are the approximate rates for the average driver. Each provider analyzes driver-related factors differently while creating packages and determining their prices. For instance, some companies consider driving records, student grades and vehicle safety features to provide deep discounts. Therefore, you should ideally shop around to find suitable coverage options and the best rates for your budget.
Ensure you're getting the best rate for your auto insurance. Compare quotes from the top insurance companies.

Cheapest Liability Car Insurance in Kentucky
Kentucky law prohibits drivers from operating a vehicle in the state if they do not have proper auto insurance. Failure to comply may lead to the revocation of vehicle registration, fines and up to 90 days of imprisonment. Some drivers choose liability-only coverage. The state minimum requirement is $25,000 for bodily injuries per person, $50,000 for bodily injuries per accident and $25,000 for property damage. Generally, State Farm policyholders in Kentucky have the most affordable annual premiums, with an average cost of $428 per year. Meanwhile, its higher option of 50/100/50 coverage has an average annual premium of $511.
Average Cost for Liability Coverage
- CompanyAnnuallyMonthly
- 1. USAA$369$31
- 2. State Farm$428$36
- 3. GEICO$493$41
- 4. Kentucky Farm Bureau$529$44
- 5. Allstate$722$60
- 6. Travelers$760$63
- 7. Progressive$902$75
- 8. Nationwide$1,325$110
- 9. MetLife$1,621$135
The Best Car Insurance Companies in Kentucky for 2021
To arrive at company scores out of 100, MoneyGeek gave equal weight to industry reports like J.D. Power’s U.S. Car Insurance Study and AM Best’s financial strength rating, while also integrating unique pricing data.
You can use MoneyGeek’s ratings to help select the best car insurance provider in Kentucky for your individual requirements.
3
5
While USAA scores highly in many areas, this provider is only available to military members, veterans and their families.
Market Share by Company
The National Association of Insurance Commissioners’ annual report shows the three auto insurance companies in Kentucky who insure the most drivers are State Farm, Kentucky Farm Bureau and Progressive. The table below shows how much of the market each of the companies insures in the state.
- CompanyMarket Share
- 1. State Farm22.5%
- 2. Kentucky Farm Bureau18.9%
- 3. Progressive9.3%
- 4. GEICO6.9%
- 6.5%
- 6. Allstate6.1%
- 7. USAA5.0%
- 8. Nationwide2.3%
- 9. Shelter1.9%
- 1.9%
Ensure you're getting the best rate for your auto insurance. Compare quotes from the top insurance companies.

What Is the Average Cost of Car Insurance in Kentucky?
Several unique factors determine your auto insurance premium. MoneyGeek computed the typical cost of 100/300/100 comprehensive and collision insurance for a male driver who is 40 years old and drives a Toyota Camry without any violations on his record. Your average annual rate may be more or less than these Kentucky numbers depending on your age, coverage level, location and driving history.
- Average Driver: $1,405
- DUI: $2,597
- Speeding Ticket: $1,683
- Poor Credit Score: $2,836
- Seniors: $1,499
- Students: $3,509
Cheapest Car Insurance for Drivers With a DUI in Kentucky
A DUI in Kentucky can affect more than just car insurance rates. Even a first time DUI can mean jail time, fines, substance program requirements, ignition interlock and license suspension. In Kentucky, Insurance Institute for Highway Safety, 1,722 people died in car crashes involving alcohol from 2009-2018 and 1.4% of Kentucky drivers admit to driving after drinking too much in the last 30 days. The table below provides an estimate of the monthly premium the average driver can expect to pay with a DUI on their driving record in Kentucky.
Average Car Insurance Rates With a DUI
- CompanyAnnuallyMonthly
- 1. State Farm$939$78
- 2. USAA$1,256$105
- 3. Allstate$1,620$135
- 4. Progressive$1,839$153
- 5. Kentucky Farm Bureau$2,228$186
- 6. GEICO$2,261$188
- 7. Travelers$2,277$190
- 8. Nationwide$4,171$348
- 9. MetLife$5,439$453
A conviction for DUI can stay on your driving record for five years and a commercial license for ten years. Find out the true cost, besides an increase of insurance premiums with our guide outlining the true cost of receiving a DUI.
Cheapest Car Insurance With Tickets in Kentucky
Speeding and distracted driving tickets can affect your chances of getting cheap car insurance in Kentucky. Receiving tickets is a sign to insurance companies that you may be a risky driver. The table below shows the average monthly auto insurance premium for the average driver with a speeding or distracted driving ticket.
Average Car Insurance Rates With a Ticket
- CompanyAnnuallyMonthly
- 1. State Farm$939$78
- 2. USAA$965$80
- 3. GEICO$968$81
- 4. Kentucky Farm Bureau$1,006$84
- 5. Allstate$1,457$121
- 6. Travelers$1,539$128
- 7. Progressive$2,128$177
- 8. Nationwide$2,432$203
- 9. MetLife$2,993$249
Currently, the law bans cell phone use for teens but allows calls to be made by drivers 18 and older. However, a bill is being considered to outlaw hand-held cell phone use for all drivers and drivers who are caught will receive higher fines for each offense. Distracted driving is more than using cell phones, it also includes grooming, eating, drinking and talking or interacting with other passengers. It's important to take steps to prevent distracted driving so that you can be safe on the road.
Cheapest Car Insurance Companies in Kentucky for Drivers With Bad Credit
Auto insurance companies may use credit scores to predict the odds someone will file a claim, according to a study by the Federal Trade Commission. The average in Kentucky is 692, slightly lower than the national average of 703. Depending on your credit score, you may still qualify for the best and cheapest car insurance rates in Kentucky. The following table provides estimates of what drivers in Kentucky can expect to pay in auto insurance if they have a low credit score.
Average Car Insurance Rates for Drivers With Bad Credit
- CompanyAnnuallyMonthly
- 1. USAA$1,520$127
- 2. State Farm$1,682$140
- 3. GEICO$1,873$156
- 4. Allstate$2,039$170
- 5. Travelers$2,366$197
- 6. Progressive$2,527$211
- 7. Kentucky Farm Bureau$3,029$252
- 8. Nationwide$3,096$258
- 9. MetLife$5,700$475
It can be helpful to find ways to improve your credit score so you can qualify for the most affordable car insurance with the best coverage.
Cheapest Car Insurance Companies in Kentucky for Seniors
In Kentucky, 16.3% of traffic fatalities in 2017 were caused by drivers ages 65 and older. Many states have specific driving and renewal rules for seniors. However, Kentucky is not one such state. Even without restrictions, seniors should use caution when driving to maintain safety; Always wear a seatbelt, only driving during clear conditions and avoid consuming substances that will impair your driving (check with a health care professional for guidance about taking certain medications and driving). The table below shows the average cost per month that seniors can expect to pay for auto insurance in Kentucky.
Average Car Insurance Rates for Seniors
- CompanyAnnuallyMonthly
- 1. State Farm$836$70
- 2. USAA$861$72
- 3. Kentucky Farm Bureau$1,027$86
- 4. GEICO$1,067$89
- 5. Allstate$1,329$111
- 6. Travelers$1,578$132
- 7. Progressive$1,798$150
- 8. MetLife$2,121$177
- 9. Nationwide$2,233$186
Slowed reaction times, reduced vision and certain medications can impair a senior’s ability to drive, resulting in increased chances of getting a ticket or into an accident. To maintain eligibility for the cheapest auto insurance rates in Kentucky, seniors can do things like drive a safe vehicle and take a safe driving class.
Cheapest Car Insurance for Students in Kentucky
According to the Kentucky Transportation Cabinet, teenagers make up around 6% of all the state's drivers but are involved in close to 18% of all collisions. The state requires parents of drivers under 18 years old to sign a statement saying they are liable in case of an accident. Teenagers will need to be added to the family insurance plan when they get their intermediate driver's license. Kentucky, in its manual A Parent's Guide for First Time Drivers, has an essential tip for parents: Be as involved in the learning process as possible.
Kentucky has a pretty straightforward rule for college students: whether they're from Kentucky or from out-of-state, they don't need to change their insurance or registration while going to school in Kentucky. They just need to carry their student identification card with them whenever they drive.
Both high school and college students may be eligible for discounts to make the auto insurance more affordable: good student, being away at college more than 100 miles from home, driving a safe car and maintaining a clean driving record all help reduce the cost of insurance. Consider the following estimates when looking for auto insurance for a young driver in Kentucky.
Average Car Insurance Rates for Students
- CompanyAnnuallyMonthly
- 1. Allstate$2,253$188
- 2. State Farm$2,603$217
- 3. GEICO$3,042$254
- 4. Progressive$4,294$358
- 5. Nationwide$5,864$489
Insurance Rate Information for Military Drivers and Veterans
If you're a veteran or one of the 31,000+ active-duty military personnel living in Kentucky, always compare prices on auto insurance and ask for a military discount to save money. Bundling policies with the same carrier can also cut costs. Veterans may also be eligible for reduced rates on car insurance.
Whether living in Kentucky or deployed out of state, military members can register their vehicles with proof of insurance by mailing the fees to the County Clerk's office in your hometown. Military personnel can also renew online for a small fee. The following table showcases what active-duty members and veterans can expect to pay for auto insurance in Kentucky.
Average Rates for Kentucky service members
50 years$1,087
50 years$1,064
Car Insurance in Kentucky: What You Need to Know
Unless you register a vehicle as either salvage or a classic motor vehicle project — which means it isn't fit for the road — you need to register your car in Kentucky. Inoperable cars that remain on your property do not need to be insured, but drivers should notify the state that a car is out of commission. Vehicles used seasonally do not have to be insured year-round, but motorists have to turn in their license plates to the county clerk to avoid fines when the car is not in use.
Proof of Insurance in Kentucky
Kentucky insurers provide motorists with proof of coverage in the form of a paper insurance card or an electronic version. Drivers will likely need to show this card when:
- The driver registers the vehicle
- A police officer requests it
- They are in an accident
Minimum Liability Insurance Requirements in Kentucky
Here is the minimum amount of coverage drivers in Kentucky must maintain:
- $25,000 for injuries per person
- $50,000 for injuries per accident
- $25,000 for property damage
Alternatively, a Kentucky motorist may carry a policy with a single limit of $60,000.
Alternatives to Insurance in Kentucky
Kentucky drivers have the option of self-insuring their vehicles. They must file paperwork with the Executive Director of Insurance, showing they can pay claims if needed, and must also deposit cash or hold property they can liquidate to pay for a claim. Typically, you will also need to provide a list of vehicles to be self-insured and make a security payment via a surety bond.
Self-insurance does not provide extra protection if you are at fault. You also will end up paying out of pocket should a claim be made — and a large claim can wipe out your savings.
How Much Coverage Do You Need in Kentucky?
Insurance experts generally recommend coverage of $100,000/$300,000 for bodily injury liability. You should also consider comprehensive and collision coverage. Comprehensive covers damage caused by events other than a traffic collision, such as inclement weather. Collision coverage will pay to fix your vehicle if it’s involved in an accident. Speak with an insurance professional to determine if you need these coverages for your vehicle.
Explore average rates for your city.
Expert Advice on Finding Cheap Car Insurance in Kentucky
To help you find trustworthy and accurate insight on car insurance in Kentucky, MoneyGeek collected expert advice from proven professionals. The views and sentiments expressed are those of the individual contributor.
- What are the key factors drivers in Kentucky should look for when searching for the best auto insurance coverage?Jonathan Handy
Coverage, coverage, coverage! Price, price, price! Drivers should get the appropriate level of coverage for their particular situation and should shop around for the best deal. I generally recommend choosing auto insurance from a major provider.
- What steps can drivers in Kentucky take to find affordable car insurance?Malcolm Robinson
The internet is a great source. Search for something like "best price car insurance Kentucky" and all sorts of comparison tools pop up.
Jonathan HandyI think the best thing drivers can do is call and receive quotes from a variety of companies. Even amongst the top providers, coverage costs can vary substantially. A quick internet search should yield a variety of auto insurance companies – call them, obtain quotes, compare costs across similar coverage levels, and then choose the cheapest. Make sure to ask questions and understand the coverage fully – the worst time for a surprise is right after a major accident.
- How do regulations and rules in Kentucky impact insurance pricing and how consumers might shop for coverage?Malcolm Robinson
State regulations require drivers to have insurance; there is no opting out like with health or life insurance. State regulators also determine what a minimum coverage package should look for. This will effectively put a floor on how low insurance premia can be. My advice, again, search the web for comparison information. This is so much easier than when I first got car insurance and the tools that we have today did not exist.


Ensure you're getting the best rate for your auto insurance. Compare quotes from the top insurance companies.

sources
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. "Sobering Facts: Alcohol-Impaired Driving State Facts Sheets." Accessed January 14, 2021.
- Experian. "2019 Consumer Credit Review." Accessed March 11, 2020.
- Federal Trade Commission. "Credit-Based Insurance Scores: Impacts on Consumers of Automobile Insurance." Accessed March 11, 2020.
- Governing: The Future of States and Localities. "Military Active-Duty Personnel, Civilians by State." Accessed January 18, 2021.
- Kentucky Government. "Driver’s License & ID Cards." Accessed March 11, 2020.
- Kentucky.gov. "Mandatory Insurance." Accessed January 18, 2021.
- Legal Beagle. "How Long Does a DUI Stay on Your Record in Kentucky?." Accessed January 18, 2021.
- Lexington Herald Leader. "If your teen drives another teen, they are far more likely to die. Here’s why.." Accessed January 18, 2021.
- NOLO. "Kentucky First-Offense DUI." Accessed March 11, 2020.
- National Association of Insurance Commissioners. "2018 Market Share Reports." Accessed January 18, 2021.
- National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. "Traffic Safety Facts." Accessed January 14, 2021.
- WDRB.com. "Kentucky lawmakers working on tougher penalties for distracted driving." Accessed March 11, 2020.