Westfield is the cheapest car insurance in Pennsylvania at $20 per month if you only need minimum coverage, $27 below the state average of $47, but Travelers’ $30 rate is worth the extra $10 for better service.
Travelers provides the cheapest full coverage at $68 per month, $49 under Pennsylvania’s average of $117 per month. Across Pennsylvania, full coverage costs $70 more a month than minimum coverage on average, while at Travelers the difference is only $38.
Travelers also carries the second-highest MoneyGeek score (which weighs price alongside service and coverage) among the five providers at 4.83/5, behind only Erie Insurance’s 4.85/5, and its customer service score ranks second to Erie’s, so claims are more likely to go smoothly.
If your full coverage policy is currently with Nationwide, Erie Insurance, Donegal or Westfield, switching to Travelers saves you $9 to $34 a month or $108 to $408 a year.












