Best Pet Insurance


Best Pet Insurance Companies Overview

For most dogs and cats, Pumpkin is our best pick, scoring 4.70 out of 5 on service, affordability and coverage. It makes buying, managing and claiming easy, and its urgent pay service can get eligible claims paid faster. You also don’t pay extra for exam fees, hereditary conditions, prescription medications or alternative treatments, and the average rate runs 35% below the national benchmark.

However, the following providers may be a better choice than Pumpkin if you’re looking for the cheapest coverage, direct vet payment or policy flexibility:  

  • ASPCA: I recommend ASPCA if you need broad coverage at the lowest price, with an average rate of $29 per month, which is 38% below the national benchmark. Its base plan extends coverage to exam fees, dental illnesses, behavioral issues and alternative treatments, so you’re covered for these veterinary expenses without purchasing separate add-ons.
  • Pets Best: Pets Best may be a good fit if you want to reduce how much you pay upfront for a covered veterinary bill. Its Vet Direct Pay feature can send claim payments directly to licensed veterinarians after you submit a completed claim and signed veterinarian reimbursement release, so you only need to cover your deductible, coinsurance and any non-covered expenses at checkout.
  • Lemonade: Lemonade is worth considering if you want highly customizable policies. You can choose from four deductibles, five annual limits, four reimbursement rates and six optional add-ons, giving you more ways to tailor your coverage, premium and out-of-pocket costs to your needs.

Compare my recommended providers side by side across costs, service strengths and coverage features below.

4.70
$31
Urgent pay service for same-day reimbursements, smooth claims process with consistently fair claim decisions
14-day waiting period for orthopedic conditions, standalone wellness plans for dogs and cats
4.66
$29
Responsive customer support during the buying process, option for direct vet payment
Coverage for curable pre-existing conditions, 14-day waiting period for knee and ligament issues
4.66
$32
Service for paying licensed vets directly on request, transparent pricing during quotes process
Accident waiting period between 0 and 3 days based on state, waiver for orthopedic waiting period
4.51
$40
Fast claim approvals and payments, smooth billing and renewals experience
No waiting period for accidents, multiple coverage add-ons for various pet health needs

Best Pet Insurance for Dogs

Pumpkin is the best pet insurance company for dogs overall, with customer service features that simplify policy management and claims so you have more time to focus on your pet’s care. It also has a short 14-day waiting period for orthopedic conditions, which is valuable for medium-sized (35 to 50 lbs) and large-sized (50 to 100 lbs) dogs that have a higher risk of ligament and joint problems. Pets Best is a strong alternative if you want the added benefit of direct vet payment and the lowest rate, averaging $40 per month, 34% below the national average.

However, the best insurer may change depending on your dog’s life stage, as puppies, young dogs, middle-aged dogs and senior dogs can have different coverage needs.

  • Puppies and young dogs: Pets Best is my pick for most puppies and young dogs since its base plan covers hereditary and congenital conditions that may develop as dogs age. It also has a short accident waiting period of zero to three days, which can benefit active younger dogs that frequently play outdoors or interact with other animals and may be more likely to experience accidental injuries. Pumpkin is a good alternative for puppies and young dogs at higher risk of orthopedic conditions because it has a short 14-day orthopedic waiting period, along with excellent customer experience.
  • Middle-aged dogs: I recommend Pumpkin for most middle-aged dogs because it covers curable pre-existing conditions after your dog has been symptom- and treatment-free for 180 days. It also provides cancer coverage if the disease develops before your dog reaches its senior years. Pets Best may be more suitable if you prioritize a lower premium, averaging $40 per month, 34% below the national benchmark.
  • Senior dogs: Pets Best is my recommendation for most senior dogs because it combines high annual limits with direct vet payment for eligible expensive conditions, such as cancer and chronic diseases. AKC can be a good choice if your senior dog already has pre-existing conditions and you want coverage for them after a year of continuous enrollment, while MetLife is an affordable alternative if you’re considering its group policy and want eligible pre-existing conditions to receive coverage.
Pets Best

Best Pet Insurance for Puppies and Young Dogs: Pets Best

checkmarkpros
  • Cheapest option for puppies and young dogs

  • Covers hereditary conditions in the base plan

  • Accident waiting period between 0 and 3 days

closecons
  • Add-ons for exam fee and physical therapy coverage

COMPANY HIGHLIGHTS

Pets Best offers the best pet insurance for puppies and young dogs with hereditary and congenital health risks because its base accident and illness plan covers these conditions. The company also has the lowest average rate at $19 per month, 58% below the national benchmark. This combination of coverage and pricing can be valuable for breeds prone to hereditary conditions, such as Dachshunds with intervertebral disc disease (IVDD) and French Bulldogs with brachycephalic obstructive airway syndrome (BOAS), because these conditions can develop as dogs age and may be excluded as pre-existing conditions if signs or symptoms appear before enrollment.

If your French Bulldog puppy develops BOAS after the waiting period, treatment can cost $3,437 to $13,749, with a midpoint of $8,593. With a $500 deductible and 80% reimbursement rate, Pets Best would reimburse about $6,474, so your out-of-pocket cost would be $2,119, equivalent to roughly 28.4 years of $19 monthly premiums.

Pets Best keeps its accident waiting period short, from zero to three days depending on your state. After that, your puppy or young dog is covered for surgeries, hospital stays and emergency vet visits that follow an accident. That’s a real plus if your dog plays hard outdoors or with other animals, since those dogs get hurt more often.

Pumpkin

Best Pet Insurance for Middle-Aged Dogs: Pumpkin

checkmarkpros
  • Covers curable pre-existing conditions

  • Dental illness coverage in the base plan

  • Can provide same-day reimbursements

closecons
  • Limited options for adjusting policy limits

COMPANY HIGHLIGHTS

Mild, temporary upper respiratory infections and urinary tract infections (UTIs) are common health issues in dogs that can be curable. As my recommendation for most adult dogs, Pumpkin can cover these conditions under its base plan if they recur after your dog has been symptom- and treatment-free for 180 days.

Pumpkin also provides coverage for dental illnesses that develop after enrollment, including periodontal disease, which is among the most common medical conditions in dogs over age 3. You can be reimbursed for treatments such as medically necessary dental surgeries, prescribed medications, post-operative care and teeth cleanings prescribed to treat a covered illness without purchasing an optional add-on.

If your middle-aged dog is diagnosed with cancer after the applicable waiting period, Pumpkin’s base accident and illness policy can cover expensive treatments such as surgery, radiation and chemotherapy. Its urgent pay service, Pumpkin Now, also helps reduce the amount you pay out of pocket at checkout by providing same-day reimbursements for eligible claims submitted at the vet during service hours, as long as your bank supports real-time payments.

Pets Best

Best Pet Insurance for Senior Dogs: Pets Best

checkmarkpros
  • No upper age limits or breed restrictions

  • Direct vet pay option for lower upfront costs

  • Most affordable provider for senior dogs

closecons
  • Less streamlined process for submitting claims

COMPANY HIGHLIGHTS

Pets Best leads as the best pet insurance provider for senior dogs, offering the lowest average rate of $63 per month, 60% below the national benchmark. It covers cancer treatments and chronic condition management if conditions such as lymphoma, arthritis or kidney disease develop after the waiting period, with coverage for veterinary expenses such as diagnostic testing, prescription medications, surgeries, hospitalizations and emergency care. It also offers an unlimited annual limit, so you won't reach an annual coverage cap if your senior dog needs repeat vet visits during the policy year.

Additionally, Pets Best offers Vet Direct Pay, which can send approved claim payments directly to your veterinarian and limit the amount you pay upfront to your annual deductible, co-insurance and other non-covered expenses. If your senior dog is diagnosed with lymphoma after the 14-day waiting period, treatment can cost $3,639 to $18,198, making direct vet payment particularly useful for managing a large veterinary bill at the time of treatment. Pets Best also has no upper age limit for enrollment, so you can purchase a policy and access these benefits for your senior dog regardless of age.

Best Pet Insurance for Cats

Ranking as the best pet insurance for cats overall, Pumpkin stands out for customer experience, with digital tools that can expedite claim reviews and provide same-day reimbursements, helping reduce the amount you may need to pay your vet upfront. Its base plan also covers exam fees, behavioral treatments, alternative therapies and prescription food in addition to veterinary care for accidents and illnesses. ASPCA may make more sense if you prioritize the lowest premium, averaging $18 per month, 44% below the national benchmark.

That said, the best provider for you may vary based on your cat’s age, since kittens and young cats, middle-aged cats and senior cats have different health risks and coverage needs.

  • Kittens and young cats: Pumpkin is our choice for most kittens and young cats. Its base plan pays to treat parasitic infections like hookworms and roundworms, which are common at this age, and its wellness plans cover flea, tick and heartworm prevention and vaccinations. Want a faster start? Pets Best has an accident waiting period of just zero to three days, which suits curious, social kittens that get into scrapes.
  • Middle-aged cats: Pumpkin wins for most middle-aged cats, since its base plan covers dental illnesses such as gingival hyperplasia and periodontal disease, both common in adult cats. On a tighter budget, ASPCA averages $18 a month, which is 44% under the national average.
  • Senior cats: For most senior cats, we pick Pumpkin. It offers high annual limits for chronic conditions and an urgent pay service that gets eligible claims reimbursed faster. If you’d rather have broad base coverage for less, ASPCA averages $42 a month, 50% below the national benchmark.
Pumpkin

Best Pet Insurance for Kittens and Young Cats: Pumpkin

checkmarkpros
  • Covers treatments for parasites

  • Wellness plans for parasite prevention

closecons
  • 14-day waiting period for accident coverage

COMPANY HIGHLIGHTS

Gastrointestinal (GI) parasitism is a common problem for cats, with prevalence reaching as high as 75% in kittens depending on the type of parasite. Ranking as the best pet insurance for kittens and young cats, Pumpkin offers a base accident and illness policy that provides coverage for parasitic infections, including heartworms, roundworms and other intestinal and external parasites. If your kitten develops intestinal worms after the 14-day waiting period, Pumpkin can cover treatments such as antiparasitic medications and deworming, treatments such as antiparasitic medications and deworming, even if your kitten missed a scheduled vaccine or dose of preventive medication.

Pumpkin also has optional wellness plans with annual benefits for parasite prevention and fecal testing, helping you prevent parasitic infections and identify intestinal worms before they cause health problems in your kitten or young cat.

Pumpkin

Best Pet Insurance for Middle-Aged Cats: Pumpkin

checkmarkpros
  • Covers dental disease treatments in the base policy

  • Covers curable pre-existing conditions after 180 symptom-free days

closecons
  • Only two reimbursement rate options available

COMPANY HIGHLIGHTS

Pumpkin is my recommendation for most middle-aged cats because it covers treatments for dental illnesses in the base plan rather than limiting coverage to dental injuries. This coverage matters for middle-aged cats because dental diseases affect 50% to 90% of cats older than 4 years of age. Pumpkin’s base policy can cover cleanings and other treatment related to stage 1 to 4 periodontal disease, tooth extractions and treatment related to other dental illnesses, such as FORLs, gingival hyperplasia and stomatitis.

Pumpkin also provides coverage for curable pre-existing conditions after 180 symptom-free days. This can benefit cats that develop recurring respiratory infections after enrollment. If your cat had a mild infection before enrollment that recurred after being symptom- and treatment-free for 180 days, Pumpkin can treat the recurrence as a new illness and cover eligible treatments, from the veterinary exam used to diagnose the infection to the prescription medications needed to treat it.

Pumpkin

Best Pet Insurance for Senior Cats: Pumpkin

checkmarkpros
  • Covers alternative therapy and prescription food in the base plan

  • Urgent pay service for same-day reimbursements

  • No upper age limits

closecons
  • Limited policy flexibility

COMPANY HIGHLIGHTS

For senior cats, Pumpkin is our best pick. Its base accident and illness policy covers eligible chronic conditions with no extra add-ons, including prescription food and supplements for illnesses like kidney disease and diabetes. It also pays for acupuncture and physical rehabilitation to manage the pain and stiffness of arthritis.

There’s no upper age limit, so an older cat can still enroll, though pre-existing conditions stay excluded. Pumpkin Now can get you reimbursed the same day: it fast-tracks claims over $500 submitted during service hours and deposits the money if your bank supports real-time payments. That matters with something like hyperthyroidism, which can cost $515 to $5,156 to treat, since the reimbursement lets you pay your vet right away.

Best Pet Insurance for Exotic Pets

ASPCA is my recommendation for horse owners looking for pet insurance. It covers treatments for accidents, colic and illnesses that occur after the 14-day waiting period, and also offers optional wellness plans that cover routine tests and vaccinations. MetLife is a good alternative if you own birds, reptiles or small mammals like rabbits or ferrets, since it offers coverage for these exotic pets along with service features that let you get quotes over the phone and manage your account from your device.

ASPCA

Best Pet Insurance for Horses: ASPCA

checkmarkpros
  • 14-day waiting period for colic, ligament and tendon issues

  • Covers tooth extractions and dental illness treatments

  • Optional wellness plans for vaccinations and routine tests

closecons
  • Doesn’t cover arthritis or degenerative joint disease

  • Excludes alternative treatments from coverage

COMPANY HIGHLIGHTS

ASPCA is the only pet insurer in my analysis that covers horses, offering coverage that takes effect after 14 days for accidents, colic, illnesses, and ligament and tendon conditions. Its base plan includes examinations, prescription medications, hereditary conditions, cancer treatments, surgeries and hospitalizations without needing optional add-ons. ASPCA also covers dental treatments such as tooth extractions and dental cleaning or floating when prescribed for an eligible condition, which is particularly relevant because dental problems are common in horses due to chewing and grazing.

You can add an ASPCA wellness plan for your horse, which pays toward routine care such as the Coggins test (a blood test for equine infectious anemia) and shots for tetanus, rabies and equine herpesvirus. How much you get back each year depends on the tier you pick. Catching problems early and keeping infectious diseases away saves your horse from more serious trouble later.

MetLife

Best Pet Insurance for Exotic Pets: MetLife

checkmarkpros
  • Covers a wide range of exotic animals

  • No waiting period for accidents

closecons
  • Need to call for quotes

  • Not available in all states

COMPANY HIGHLIGHTS

MetLife offers the best pet insurance for exotic pets, including birds, ferrets, rabbits, pigs, small mammals and reptiles. The company provides accident coverage with no waiting period, so accident-related care, such as exams, diagnostic testing, treatments and medications, is eligible for coverage if your exotic pet gets injured after enrollment. MetLife also provides digital tools that make it easy and convenient to manage your policy online, as well as responsive customer support, which is particularly important because you need to call to get an exotic pet quote or learn more about its coverage.

How to Buy the Best Pet Insurance for Your Companion

Buying pet insurance starts with understanding what your pet may need coverage for, then finding a policy that can pay for those treatments at a price you can afford. Dogs, cats and exotic pets generally have different health risks, so the best provider for one animal may not be ideal for another. Follow the steps below to purchase a policy that matches your pet’s potential veterinary needs and your budget.

  1. 1
    Identify your pet's specific health risks

    Start with your vet. Share your pet’s breed, age, weight and lifestyle, then ask what health problems to watch for. A vet might warn you about joint trouble in a big dog, dental or urinary issues in a cat or colic in a horse.

  2. 2
    Determine how much coverage you need

    Start with the risks your vet flagged, and decide which expenses you want your policy to cover. Then pick a deductible, an annual limit and a reimbursement rate that match what your pet might cost and what you can afford.

    Here’s what each term means. Your deductible is what you pay yourself, usually each policy year, before the insurer starts paying. The annual limit is the most the policy pays in a policy year. The reimbursement rate is the share of eligible bills the insurer covers once you’ve met the deductible.

    Expect expensive or recurring care? A higher annual limit or reimbursement rate shifts more of the bill to the insurer, though your premium will likely climb. Our pet insurance coverage needs calculator can give you a place to start.

  3. 3
    Research pet insurance providers

    Start by finding insurers that cover your kind of pet, then read their online sample policies to see which conditions, treatments and services they include. Dogs and cats get the most choices, and horses and exotic pets get far fewer, so your species shapes your shortlist.

    Then match each policy to your pet’s risks. See whether it covers hereditary conditions, cancer, dental illnesses, chronic conditions, prescriptions and anything else your vet flagged.

  4. 4
    Read customer reviews

    Want to know how an insurer treats customers? Read the reviews. They reveal how it handles claims, billing, policy changes and support in ways its policy documents and website won’t. Browse Trustpilot, the Better Business Bureau (BBB) and Reddit, and trust patterns over single reviews. Look closely at comments about slow claims, reimbursement delays, coverage disputes, premium hikes and support, since those decide how fast you get paid back.

  5. 5
    Get quotes

    Ask several providers for quotes with the same deductible, annual limit and reimbursement rate, so the premiums are comparable. Mix the terms, and a quote can look cheaper just because it has a higher deductible or a lower limit or rate.

    Then check what each base accident and illness plan includes: exam fees, prescription medications, hereditary conditions and dental illnesses. Providers that sell these as add-ons can end up costing more than a pricier-looking plan that includes them.

How We Chose the Best Pet Insurance Companies

We looked at 18 major pet insurers to find the best ones for affordable pricing, reliable service and coverage for pet-specific health risks.

We priced the same standardized pet profiles across every insurer:

  • Providers analyzed: 18 major pet insurers
  • Pet profiles analyzed: Over 67,000
  • Standard profile: A 6-year-old Labrador Retriever (dogs) and a 7-year-old Ragdoll (cats)
  • Geography: All U.S. states and Washington, D.C.
  • Breeds covered: Mixed breeds and purebreds
  • Policy baseline: $500 deductible, $5,000 annual limit and 80% reimbursement

Then we scored each insurer in three weighted categories:

  • Affordability (50%): How low each insurer’s price runs for that $500 deductible, $5,000 limit and 80% reimbursement policy, across breeds and states.
  • Customer experience (30%): How well each insurer treats pet owners from first quote to final claim. Buying counts for 30%, policy management for 30% and claims for 40%, and each has its own subscores.
  • Coverage options and terms (20%): What each insurer covers and how it words the terms. Core coverage counts for 30%, flexibility and customization for 25%, policy terms and conditions for 23% and breed-specific and pet health risk coverage for 22%.

About Ritchel Mendiola


Ritchel Mendiola, Pet Insurance Writer

Ritchel Mendiola is a Pet Insurance Content Writer at MoneyGeek. She produces coverage guides, provider comparisons and cost analyses so pet owners can understand their options and avoid overpaying.

Ritchel spent over four years as a News and Feature Writer at Asian Journal Publications, where she reported for the Asian Journal newspaper and Balikbayan Magazine, conducted interviews and covered media events. At MoneyGeek, she covers policy terms, exclusions, waiting periods and reimbursement structures the way she treated news facts. They're sourced, verified and reported accurately rather than summarized from marketing copy.

She joined MoneyGeek in late 2021 in the loans vertical and moved to pet insurance content, which she now leads. Her published work includes provider comparisons, breed-specific cost guides, age-specific coverage analyses and state-level pricing studies, all from the vertical's 5 million pet insurance profiles across 18 major providers and all U.S. states.

LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/rianmendi/

Contact Email: ritchel.mendiola@moneygeek.com


Sources