The Best Cheap Car Insurance for Drivers Under 25

Younger drivers sometimes struggle to find low-cost auto insurance coverage. Rates can vary significantly among young adults, particularly those aged 20–25. For example, the average 20-year-old pays $2,465 for a full coverage policy, while someone who’s 25 pays $1,402. Fortunately, affordable plans are available if you know what to look for. MoneyGeek analyzed quotes for young drivers across the country to help you find the best rates for car insurance under 25.

By  
  |  
Reviewed by    |  

While car insurance tends to be even more expensive for teen drivers, many young adults have trouble finding affordable rates well into their 20s. Even though drivers aged 20–25 typically have some experience behind the wheel, their car insurance premiums are still higher than older drivers. Fortunately, several strategies can help you find the best rates for car insurance under 25.

Loading...

How Much Is Car Insurance for Someone Under 25?

A 25-year-old purchasing car insurance usually pays higher rates than someone older, but premiums can vary dramatically between companies. It isn’t unusual for the same driver to find sample rates that differ by several hundred dollars. Comparing quotes is crucial to finding cheap full coverage insurance for drivers under 25.

According to MoneyGeek’s research, an average full coverage policy for a 20-year-old driver is $2,465 per year, while the same insurance plan costs a 25-year-old driver $1,402 per year.

Average Cost of Car Insurance for Drivers Under 25

Scroll for more

swipe icon

MoneyGeek analyzed auto insurance quotes for drivers under 25 and older than 20 across all 50 states to determine average rates.

Car Insurance Costs By State for Drivers Under 25

Local laws and regulations can have a big impact on car insurance rates, meaning that rates are different across states. Population density, the number of accidents in a given area, access to street parking, and other factors can also affect rates from state to state or even ZIP code to ZIP code.

For example, a 20-year-old may pay as much as $7,576 per year for car insurance in Michigan and as little as $1,022 for the same policy in Hawaii.

Average Annual Insurance Premiums By State and Age

Scroll for more

swipe icon
  • State
    20-Year-Old
    21-Year-Old
    22-Year-Old
    23-Year-Old
    24-Year-Old
    25-Year-Old
  • $2,103
    $1,721
    $1,554
    $1,393
    $1,302
    $1,214
  • $2,228
    $1,795
    $1,662
    $1,509
    $1,400
    $1,314
  • $2,304
    $1,736
    $1,609
    $1,454
    $1,339
    $1,212
  • $2,104
    $1,665
    $1,544
    $1,399
    $1,316
    $1,207
  • $2,614
    $2,033
    $1,938
    $1,802
    $1,697
    $1,597
  • $2,583
    $2,038
    $1,888
    $1,725
    $1,634
    $1,493
  • $2,736
    $2,206
    $2,026
    $1,757
    $1,590
    $1,429
  • $2,512
    $2,006
    $1,839
    $1,660
    $1,545
    $1,413
  • $3,102
    $2,451
    $2,240
    $1,967
    $1,808
    $1,655
  • $3,649
    $3,052
    $2,782
    $2,528
    $2,363
    $2,125
  • $3,906
    $2,903
    $2,668
    $2,412
    $2,250
    $2,039
  • $1,022
    $1,003
    $1,006
    $993
    $993
    $993
  • $1,259
    $1,058
    $951
    $863
    $794
    $763
  • $1,350
    $1,132
    $1,085
    $915
    $869
    $823
  • $2,581
    $2,014
    $1,867
    $1,706
    $1,600
    $1,399
  • $1,344
    $1,124
    $1,044
    $907
    $833
    $749
  • $1,802
    $1,423
    $1,316
    $1,191
    $1,102
    $1,002
  • $2,948
    $2,305
    $2,148
    $1,914
    $1,749
    $1,568
  • $6,545
    $5,129
    $4,734
    $4,315
    $4,076
    $3,796
  • $2,647
    $2,241
    $1,516
    $1,389
    $1,334
    $1,247
  • $5,049
    $3,676
    $3,342
    $2,866
    $2,644
    $2,383
  • $1,301
    $1,045
    $963
    $856
    $790
    $699
  • $7,576
    $6,004
    $5,553
    $5,081
    $4,755
    $4,320
  • $2,807
    $2,360
    $2,207
    $1,959
    $1,839
    $1,646
  • $2,210
    $1,835
    $1,632
    $1,481
    $1,406
    $1,312
  • $2,342
    $1,850
    $1,724
    $1,511
    $1,406
    $1,263
  • $2,182
    $1,798
    $1,643
    $1,372
    $1,226
    $1,080
  • $1,053
    $934
    $915
    $895
    $878
    $850
  • $1,409
    $1,163
    $1,081
    $972
    $895
    $800
  • $1,452
    $1,158
    $1,087
    $972
    $901
    $826
  • $1,515
    $1,198
    $1,118
    $1,027
    $962
    $834
  • $3,149
    $2,544
    $2,393
    $2,141
    $2,003
    $1,734
  • $2,370
    $2,013
    $1,899
    $1,614
    $1,500
    $1,287
  • $2,901
    $2,457
    $2,275
    $1,999
    $1,850
    $1,750
  • $6,587
    $5,252
    $4,951
    $4,473
    $4,211
    $3,561
  • $1,541
    $1,141
    $1,045
    $955
    $895
    $800
  • $1,942
    $1,549
    $1,438
    $1,304
    $1,216
    $1,111
  • $2,127
    $1,662
    $1,534
    $1,353
    $1,250
    $1,142
  • $2,962
    $2,411
    $2,263
    $2,029
    $1,857
    $1,665
  • $3,872
    $3,124
    $2,898
    $2,506
    $2,320
    $2,033
  • $2,309
    $1,813
    $1,689
    $1,510
    $1,417
    $1,386
  • $1,514
    $1,284
    $1,213
    $1,057
    $984
    $882
  • $2,122
    $1,618
    $1,476
    $1,294
    $1,197
    $1,091
  • $2,126
    $1,645
    $1,542
    $1,450
    $1,369
    $1,211
  • $2,424
    $1,896
    $1,736
    $1,518
    $1,398
    $1,264
  • $1,500
    $1,173
    $1,096
    $993
    $931
    $808
  • $1,766
    $1,332
    $1,250
    $1,125
    $1,073
    $933
  • $1,963
    $1,629
    $1,497
    $1,322
    $1,211
    $1,075
  • $1,896
    $1,450
    $1,313
    $1,202
    $1,119
    $1,009
  • $2,209
    $1,515
    $1,414
    $1,249
    $1,168
    $1,036
  • $1,551
    $1,259
    $1,212
    $1,093
    $1,046
    $876

Which Company Has the Cheapest Car Insurance for Drivers Under 25?

According to our research, GEICO generally has the cheapest car insurance rates for drivers under 25, with one notable exception — Allstate has lower average rates for 20-year-old drivers. Companies set their rates to attract specific target markets, which is why State Farm, Allstate and GEICO all charge different rates.

Cheapest Car Insurance Companies By Age

Scroll for more

swipe icon
  • Age
    Company
    Premium
  • 20
    Allstate
    $2,180
  • 21
    GEICO
    $1,695
  • 22
    GEICO
    $1,562
  • 23
    GEICO
    $1,369
  • 24
    GEICO
    $1,293
  • 25
    GEICO
    $1,207

Note that the rates in the chart above are for a full coverage insurance policy, which includes liability, comprehensive, and collision coverages. Liability-only coverage is less expensive than full coverage insurance, but it does not provide any financial protection if your vehicle is stolen or damaged.

What Is the Best Car Insurance for New Drivers Under 25?

A driver under 25 who isn’t still paying off their car may consider purchasing liability-only insurance to keep costs low. Choosing liability coverage means you avoid paying for comprehensive or collision insurance. However, keep in mind that you’ll have to cover repairs to your car out-of-pocket if you’re at fault in an accident.

If you buy liability-only insurance, consider signing up for additional coverages to protect your finances, such as uninsured or underinsured motorist (UI/UIM) coverage or personal injury protection (PIP) insurance.

tip icon
MONEYGEEK EXPERT TIP

If you don’t have the money on hand to replace your car tomorrow or if you’re still making payments on your vehicle, MoneyGeek recommends purchasing full coverage insurance.

New drivers may also benefit from using a driver tracking app offered by their insurance company. These apps allow providers to track your driving behavior and reward safe driving with lower rates.

What Is the Cost of Car Insurance for Females and Males Under 25?

Insurance companies use statistics to calculate premiums, meaning that each driver’s rates are affected by markers like age and gender. Women tend to have lower rates than men — especially for drivers under 25 — because women are statistically in fewer accidents and receive fewer traffic tickets than men.

Keep in mind that several states have made it illegal for policy providers to use gender to determine insurance rates, including California, Hawaii, Massachusetts, Michigan, Montana, North Carolina and Pennsylvania. Drivers in these seven states won’t see a difference in premiums based on gender.

Average Cost of Car Insurance By Gender

Scroll for more

swipe icon

There are multiple ways to lower your insurance rates, regardless of your gender:

  • Utilize student discounts, which helps student drivers with good grades save on their rates
  • Find other savings opportunities, such as bundling discounts or group affiliation discounts
  • Stay on your parent’s policy
  • Keep a clean driving record

Why Is Car Insurance so Expensive for Drivers Under 25?

Each insurance company has its own unique rating system, which is why premiums can vary by hundreds of dollars or more each year for the same driver. However, they all have some basic factors they consider when determining your rates, including age, location and driving history.

Key Takeaways

female

Age: Younger drivers have less experience on the road and are statistically more likely to be in an accident. This risk is why younger drivers pay more for insurance.

house

Location: Local laws, state regulations, weather, crime rates and population density are all affected by location and impact your premiums.

carInsurance

Driving history: If you’ve been in an accident or gotten a ticket in the past few years, your insurance rates will likely be high relative to someone with a clean driving record.

Is Cheap Full Coverage Insurance Available for Drivers Under 25?

Full coverage insurance is almost always required by lenders, meaning drivers making payments on their vehicles should expect to carry a full coverage policy. While these plans may seem expensive, there are ways to find affordable rates.

Much of what impacts your insurance rate is within your control, such as your driving record and car model. Staying accident-free and purchasing a car that’s cheap to insure can lead to significant savings.

Several discounts are also available to young drivers, such as bundling discounts, good student discounts and away-from-home discounts for college students. Confirm that all available discounts are applied to your policy when you sign up for a plan.

Methodology

For this analysis, MoneyGeek used sample insurance data for drivers between 20–25 years of age. You can read more about MoneyGeek's premium pricing methodology here.

Learn More About Auto Insurance

About the Author


expert-profile

Rachael Brennan is a professional freelance writer who has worked in the insurance industry for more than a decade, earning her P&C license in all 50 states and her Life, Health and AD&D license in New York and the surrounding states. Her writing has been published on websites like Adweek, Glamour and Cracked. You can follow her on Twitter @rachaelbwriter.