State Farm offers the cheapest car insurance after a DUI at $192 per month, followed by Travelers at $236 per month and National General at $249. State Farm's rates are 43% cheaper than average, while GEICO charges $334 monthly, creating a $142 monthly difference or $1,704 annual savings.
DUI drivers can also secure quality coverage through Progressive at $251 monthly and AIG at $295.
Careful insurer selection can mean paying $2,299 or $4,012 annually for comparable coverage.