Pumpkin Pet Insurance Review


Pumpkin Pet Insurance Review: Key Takeaways
blueCheck icon

Pumpkin ranks first in cat insurance affordability and third for dogs, with monthly premiums starting at $20 for cats and $46 for dogs.

blueCheck icon

Customers rate it highly, placing it third nationally for overall experience, supported by an A+ BBB rating and positive Trustpilot feedback.

blueCheck icon

For coverage, Pumpkin sits 11th nationwide and offers wide accident and illness protection plus an optional preventive care package.

Pumpkin Pet Insurance Ratings

Pumpkin’s pet insurance scores 4.15 out of 5 for cats and 3.70 for dogs in MoneyGeek’s analysis. It performs especially well on affordability, ranking first nationwide for cat coverage.

The company places 11th for coverage options and has a 14-day waiting period for accidents, which is in line with most competitors.

Data filtered by:
Dog
Coverage1.6611
Overall Score3.77
Affordability4.143
Customer Experience4.373
pet icon
WHO IS PUMPKIN PET INSURANCE BEST FOR?

Pumpkin ranks among the best pet insurance options for cat owners looking for affordable premiums. It also offers broad coverage that includes hereditary conditions, alternative therapies, and exam fees at no extra cost.

Still, its accident coverage comes with a waiting period, which may not work for pet owners who need immediate financial protection.

Explore the best pet insurance choices for your pet:

Pumpkin Pet Insurance Ratings by State

You can get Pumpkin pet insurance anywhere in the U.S. For cats, it ranks second in 16 states and first nationwide for affordability. Its dog coverage lands more in the middle, with fifth place as its highest ranking in six states. 

While it’s not the best pet insurance overall, both cats and dogs benefit from Pumpkin’s strong third-place customer experience rating nationwide.

Data filtered by:
Overall Score
Dog
Alaska3.75
Arizona3.78
California3.78
Colorado3.77
Connecticut3.76
Delaware3.75
Florida3.76
Georgia3.78
Hawaii3.77
Idaho3.77
Illinois3.77
Maine3.76
Massachusetts3.77
Michigan3.77
Minnesota3.78
Nevada3.76
New Hampshire3.78
New Jersey3.78
New York3.76
Ohio3.76
Oregon3.77
Pennsylvania3.77
Texas3.77
Utah3.76
Virginia3.77
Wisconsin3.77
Indiana3.757
Iowa3.758
Kansas3.757
Louisiana3.756
Maryland3.755
Mississippi3.757
Montana3.755
Nebraska3.757
North Carolina3.757
North Dakota3.755
Oklahoma3.757
Rhode Island3.756
South Dakota3.755
Tennessee3.756
Vermont3.756
West Virginia3.758
Wyoming3.758
Alabama3.86
Arkansas3.86
Kentucky3.86
Missouri3.87
New Mexico3.87
South Carolina3.856
Washington3.857

Pumpkin Pet Insurance Comparison

Check how Pumpkin stacks up against other pet insurers below.

Pumpkin vs. AKC
• Dogs: 3.70 vs. 4.30
• Cats: 4.15 vs. 3.85
AKC beats Pumpkin on coverage, but Pumpkin costs less and matches it on customer service.
Pumpkin vs. ASPCA
• Dogs: 3.70 vs. 3.85
• Cats: 4.15 vs. 3.35
ASPCA charges less for dogs, but Pumpkin wins on cat affordability and customer experience.
Pumpkin vs. Embrace
• Dogs: 3.70 vs. 2.55
• Cats: 4.15 vs. 2.30
Pumpkin costs less than Embrace and delivers better overall experience for both dogs and cats.
Pumpkin vs. Fetch
• Dogs: 3.70 vs. 2.70
• Cats: 4.15 vs. 2.95
Fetch edges ahead on coverage, but Pumpkin wins on price and customer service for both pets.
Pumpkin vs. Figo
• Dogs: 3.70 vs. 3.60
• Cats: 4.15 vs. 3.80
Figo provides more coverage options, but Pumpkin costs less and scores higher on customer satisfaction.
Pumpkin vs. Hartville
• Dogs: 3.70 vs. 3.50
• Cats: 4.15 vs. 3.90
Hartville offers slightly more coverage, yet Pumpkin wins on price and customer experience.
Pumpkin vs. Lemonade
• Dogs: 3.70 vs. 4.50
• Cats: 4.15 vs. 4.25
Lemonade dominates with higher scores across affordability and coverage, while Pumpkin trails on coverage strength.
Pumpkin vs. Liberty
• Dogs: 3.70 vs. 2.65
• Cats: 4.15 vs. 2.30
Pumpkin beats Liberty on price, customer experience and overall performance.
Pumpkin vs. MetLife
• Dogs: 3.70 vs. 3.05
• Cats: 4.15 vs. 2.40
Pumpkin scores much higher on customer service and affordability, making it the stronger choice overall.
Pumpkin vs. Nationwide
• Dogs: 3.70 vs. 2.50
• Cats: 4.15 vs. 2.65
Nationwide lags on affordability and coverage, while Pumpkin delivers better value for both pets.
Pumpkin vs. Pets Best
• Dogs: 3.70 vs. 4.05
• Cats: 4.15 vs. 3.80
Pets Best edges ahead on coverage, but Pumpkin costs less and scores higher on customer service.
Pumpkin vs. Rainwalk
• Dogs: 3.70 vs. 4.05
• Cats: 4.15 vs. 3.95
Rainwalk wins on coverage and customer service, but Pumpkin leads on affordability, especially for cats.
Pumpkin vs. Spot
• Dogs: 3.70 vs. 3.75
• Cats: 4.15 vs. 4.15
Spot offers stronger customer service and coverage, while Pumpkin costs less overall.

How Much Does Pumpkin Pet Insurance Cost?

Pumpkin pet insurance averages about $46 per month ($548 per year) for dogs and $20 per month ($238 per year) for cats. Your actual rate can vary based on factors like your location, your pet’s breed and the coverage you choose.

Cat$20$32$238$37937%
Dog$46$60$548$72324%

Pumpkin Pet Insurance Rates by State

Pet insurance rates vary by state based on veterinary costs and local claim patterns. For cats, Pumpkin offers the most affordable pet insurance in Arkansas at $13 monthly, while Massachusetts has the highest rate at $26. Dog coverage follows the same pattern, with Arkansas offering the cheapest premiums at $31 compared to Massachusetts at $59.

Data filtered by:
Dog
Arkansas$31$368
Alabama$34$403
North Dakota$35$421
Missouri$36$433
Kentucky$36$434
Louisiana$37$442
Montana$38$459
Oklahoma$38$458
Iowa$39$461
Mississippi$39$466
West Virginia$40$474
Rhode Island$40$477
New Mexico$41$484
South Dakota$41$485
North Carolina$41$489
Georgia$41$495
Nebraska$42$496
Indiana$42$497
Kansas$42$497
Ohio$42$503
Tennessee$42$507
Wyoming$43$509
Vermont$43$510
South Carolina$44$521
Utah$44$523
Alaska$45$534
Maryland$45$538
Idaho$46$549
Michigan$46$550
Delaware$46$552
Hawaii$46$554
Nevada$48$569
Minnesota$48$569
Pennsylvania$48$571
Texas$49$580
Virginia$49$586
Wisconsin$49$588
New York$50$597
New Jersey$52$620
Florida$52$621
Connecticut$53$626
Washington$53$631
New Hampshire$53$637
Maine$56$666
Arizona$56$668
Illinois$57$680
Oregon$57$682
Colorado$58$690
California$58$694
Massachusetts$59$707

Pumpkin Pet Insurance Rates by Breed

Pumpkin's premiums change based on your pet's breed. Cat owners pay around $17 monthly for British Longhairs but $35 for Abyssinians. Dog premiums start at $19 for small mixed breeds under 20 pounds and reach $103 for Scottish Terriers. These price differences happen because some breeds face more health problems and need costlier veterinary care.

Data filtered by:
Select
Select
British Longhair$17$203
Bombay$17$201
Norwegian Forest cat$17$201
Ragdoll$17$207
Birman$19$224
Devon Rex$19$224
Russian Blue$19$224
Siamese$19$224
Tonkinese$19$224
Small Mix (Under 20 pounds)$19$227
Serengeti$19$234
Australian Mist$21$255
Small Mix (11-25)$22$260
Chihuahua$22$260
Small Mix (10 and less pounds)$22$265
Small Mix (0-20)$22$265
Small Mix (1-10 pounds)$23$272
Mixed breed Small (up to 20lbs when full grown)$23$270
Cavapoo$23$280
Cockapoo$23$280
Havanese$23$280
Jack Russell Terrier$23$280
Maltipoo$23$280
Morkie$23$280
Papillon$23$280
Shiba Inu$23$280
Shih Tzu$23$280
Welsh Springer Spaniel$23$280
Mixed Breed Small (>10 lbs)$24$279
Mixed Breed Small (11-30 lbs)$24$292
Bengal$24$288
Small Mix (11-30)$26$308
Burmese$26$309
Chinchilla$26$309
Cornish Rex$26$309
Himalayan$26$309
Munchkin$26$309
Savannah$26$309
Scottish Fold$26$309
Siberian$26$309
Snowshoe$26$309
Small Mix (25 and less pounds)$26$311
American Eskimo$27$316
American Hairless Terrier$27$316
Australian Shepherd$27$316
Australian Silky Terrier$27$316
Basenji$27$316
Border Collie$27$316
Cavachon$27$316
Dachshund$27$316
German Spitz$27$316
Husky$27$316
Japanese Chin$27$316
Japanese Spitz$27$316
Lhasa Apso$27$316
Maltese$27$316
Miniature Poodle$27$316
Puggle$27$316
Puli$27$316
Schnoodle$27$316
Shetland Sheepdog$27$316
Yorkshire terrier$27$316
Small Mix (22 pounds or less)$27$326
Toy Mix (10 and less pounds)$28$335
Mixed Breed Medium (31-50 lbs)$28$335
British Shorthair$30$354
Maine Coon$30$354
Persian$30$354
Medium Mix (20-55 pounds)$30$359
Medium Mix (31-59 pounds)$31$370
Medium Mix (26-50 pounds)$31$375
Alaskan Husky$32$377
American Foxhound$32$377
Bearded Collie$32$377
Collie$32$377
Coton De Tulear$32$377
English Foxhound$32$377
English Toy Terrier$32$377
German Pinscher$32$377
Goldendoodle$32$377
Harrier$32$377
Labradoodle$32$377
Medium Mix (20-70 pounds)$32$377
Miniature Dachshund$32$377
Miniature Pinscher$32$377
Miniature Schnauzer$32$377
Pekingese$32$377
Pomeranian$32$377
Siberian Husky$32$377
Toy Poodle$32$377
West Highland White Terrier$32$377
Medium Mix (31-50 pounds)$32$377
Groodle$32$384
Mixed Dog (21-50 pounds)$33$399
Large Mix (51-110 pounds)$34$411
Abyssinian$35$416
Balinese$35$416
Domestic Shorthair$35$416
Exotic Shorthair$35$416
Sphynx$35$416
Fox Terrier$36$425
Miniature Fox Terrier$37$440
Affenpinscher$37$447
Alsation$37$447
Australian Cattle Dog$37$447
Australian Kelpie$37$447
Australian Terrier$37$447
Beagle$37$447
Belgian Shepherd Malinois$37$447
Bichon Frise$37$447
Border Terrier$37$447
Briard$37$447
Brussels Griffon$37$447
Chow Chow$37$447
Clumber Spaniel$37$447
Dingo$37$447
English Pointer$37$447
English Setter$37$447
English Springer Spaniel$37$447
Field Spaniel$37$447
Finnish Lapphund$37$447
Great Pyrenees$37$447
Hungarian Vizsla$37$447
Icelandic Sheepdog$37$447
Irish Terrier$37$447
Italian Greyhound$37$447
Italian Spinone$37$447
Keeshond$37$447
Komondor$37$447
Large Mix (Over 70 pounds)$37$447
Norfolk Terrier$37$447
Norwegian Elkhound$37$447
Norwich Terrier$37$447
Old English Sheepdog$37$447
Peruvian Hairless Dog$37$447
Petit Basset Griffon Vendeens$37$447
Pointer$37$447
Standard Schnauzer$37$447
Tibetan Terrier$37$447
Vizsla$37$447
Welsh Corgi Cardigan$37$447
Welsh Terrier$37$447
Whippet$37$447
Wire Fox Terrier$37$447
Giant Mix (111 pounds+)$37$447
Large Mix (51-100 pounds)$38$449
Large Mix (61+ pounds)$38$450
Medium Mix (23-70 pounds)$38$451
Mixed Breed Large (51-90 lbs)$38$449
Large Mix (55-90 pounds)$38$459
Akita$39$464
Borzoi$39$464
Boston Terrier$39$464
Cairn Terrier$39$464
Cavalier King Charles Spaniel$39$464
Cocker spaniel$39$464
German Shepherd$39$464
German Shorthaired Pointer$39$464
Pembroke Welsh Corgi$39$464
Pug$39$464
Saluki$39$464
Samoyed$39$464
Welsh Corgi Pembroke$39$464
Foxhound$40$477
Mixed Breed$40$483
Mixed Dog (51-90 pounds)$40$478
Giant Mix (110 pounds+)$41$489
Large Mix (60-109 pounds)$41$489
Medium Mix (26-59 pounds)$41$489
Small Mix (0-25)$41$489
Mixed Dog (91 pounds+)$42$504
Smooth Collie$43$509
Giant Mix (100 pounds+)$44$518
Bracco Italiano$45$534
Basset Fauve de Bretagne$45$533
Rough Collie$45$535
Golden Retriever$45$545
Afghan Hound$46$548
Greyhound$46$548
Labrador Retriever$46$548
Soft Coated Wheaten Terrier$46$548
Standard Poodle$46$548
Corgi$47$562
Airedale Terrier$49$587
Alaskan Malamute$49$587
Basset Hound$49$587
Central Asian Shepherd Dog$49$587
Gordon Setter$49$587
Irish Setter$49$587
Kangal Shepherd Dog$49$587
Pitbull$49$587
Portuguese Water Dog$49$587
Rhodesian Ridgeback$49$587
Tibetan Mastiff$49$587
Weimaraner$49$587
Petit Basset Griffon Vendeen$51$614
American Bulldog$53$635
American Staffordshire Terrier$53$635
Bull Terrier$53$635
Estrela Mountain Dog$53$635

Is Pumpkin Pet Insurance Expensive?

Pumpkin ranks first in affordability for cats and third for dogs in our study, making it among the most competitive options available. Use the filterable table below to see how costs change based on your pet's age and your preferred deductible, annual limit and reimbursement rate.

Data filtered by:
Dog
Middle Aged
$500
$5,000
80%
$63$75312%

Pumpkin Pet Insurance Discounts

Pumpkin a few pet insurance discounts to lower your rate, including multiple pets and veterinary staff discounts.

Multiple pets
10%
Enroll more than one pet with Pumpkin
Veterinary staff
Not specified
Work as a staff at a veterinary clinic

Pumpkin Pet Insurance Customer Service Reviews and Ratings

Pumpkin ranks third nationally for customer service with cats and dogs. The company earns high marks from the Better Business Bureau and strong ratings on Trustpilot. Reddit users show mixed experiences, with most praising Pumpkin's responsive support team and helpful representatives. Some customers report concerns about claim approval processes and slower response times during busy periods.

    trustSeal icon
    Pumpkin Trustpilot Reviews

    Pumpkin earns a 4.8 out of 5 rating on Trustpilot from verified customers who rate its service and claims handling. Most policyholders report positive experiences with Pumpkin's coverage and support team. Trustpilot collects verified reviews to give consumers honest feedback about companies.

    trustSeal icon
    Pumpkin Better Business Bureau Rating

    Pumpkin holds an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau. The A+ grade is BBB's top rating, showing Pumpkin meets its standards for trust and resolves customer complaints effectively. This rating indicates the company follows ethical business practices and addresses customer concerns professionally.

Pumpkin Pet Insurance Reddit Sentiment

Pumpkin shows strong Reddit sentiment with 79% positive feedback from our analysis of 14 comments. Users left 11 favorable reviews compared to three negative ones. Happy customers frequently mention responsive customer service and clear policy language. 

Some users mention claim denials and coverage gaps, leading to mixed experiences with Pumpkin’s claims process. Overall, the feedback is mostly positive but still varies from one customer to another.

Pumpkin Pet Insurance Coverage

Pumpkin offers pet insurance coverage for dogs and cats. Pet owners can customize policies by choosing different coverage levels and adding optional riders to match their budget and their pet's health requirements.

Prescription food and supplements
Covered when tied to an eligible illness or condition
Coverage for accidents and illnesses
Includes diagnostics, treatments, surgery, hospitalization, prescription medications, behavioral care, dental illnesses, hereditary and congenital conditions, parasite infections and more
Enrollment restrictions
No breed restrictions or upper age limits
14 days for illness and accident coverage
80% or 90%
$100 to $1,000
Pre-existing conditions
Not covered; curable conditions may be eligible after 180 symptom-free days, except knee and hind leg ligament conditions
$5,000, $10,000, $20,000, Unlimited

*Coverage varies by state and policy terms. Always review your specific policy documents and consult your insurance provider to understand exact coverage terms, exclusions, limitations and waiting periods before enrollment.

Pumpkin Pet Insurance Coverage Add-Ons

Pumpkin offers a non-insurance wellness package that reimburses routine wellness services like vaccinations, dental cleanings and annual exams.

Pumpkin Wellness Club
Members can choose between Essential and Premium wellness plans, which covers wellness exams, essential vaccines, parasite screening tests and spay/neuter procedures

Is Pumpkin Pet Insurance Good: Bottom Line

Pumpkin charges $46 monthly for dog insurance and $20 for cat coverage on average. The company ranks third nationally for customer experience and maintains high Trustpilot and BBB ratings. Pet owners can select accident-only or comprehensive accident and illness plans, with optional wellness add-ons available for preventive care coverage.

Browse through our review guides for the top pet insurance companies for your pet:

Pumpkin Pet Insurance Review: FAQ

We’ve addressed some frequently asked questions about Pumpkin pet insurance below:

Is Pumpkin pet insurance worth it in 2025?

What do Reddit users really think about Pumpkin pet insurance?

Does Pumpkin cover pre-existing conditions for pets?

Can I get a discount for insuring multiple pets with Pumpkin?

Is Pumpkin pet insurance available in my state?

How We Rated Pumpkin Pet Insurance

Pet insurance shopping feels overwhelming with so many options available. We analyzed how Pumpkin performs across the following key areas:

Affordability (50% of score): We gathered premium quotes for various pet breeds, ages and coverage levels. Available discounts were factored in to reflect costs pet owners would pay.

Customer Experience (30% of score): Real customer opinions from platforms like Trustpilot and Reddit were analyzed to gauge satisfaction levels with Pumpkin's service.

Coverage Options (20% of score): We examined policy benefits, available add-ons and overall coverage breadth to assess how well plans meet diverse pet owner needs.

Our analysis used standardized quotes for a 6-year-old Labrador Retriever and 7-year-old Ragdoll with $500 deductible, $5,000 annual limit and 80% reimbursement rate.

About Connor Bolton


Connor Bolton headshot

Connor Bolton is Senior SEO and Content Manager at MoneyGeek, where he leads the business and pet insurance editorial teams. As editorial lead for both verticals, Connor sets the research framework, data standards, and content structure that his writers execute, directly authoring in-depth guides himself and reviewing all team content for accuracy and practical value before it goes live. With over four years evaluating insurance products across personal, commercial, and specialty lines, he brings cross-vertical knowledge to every guide the team produces.

Connor architected MoneyGeek's insurance research infrastructure across all major verticals including auto, home, renters, life, health, business, and pet, building systems for pricing analysis, provider-level research, customer experience evaluation, and coverage analysis with AI support. The infrastructure includes over 6 million data points for business insurance across 408 industry areas, all 50 states, and 16 vehicle types, and over 5 million pet insurance profiles across 18 major providers and hundreds of breed and age combinations. Connor's insurance cost research and his team's work has been cited by the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, Allstate, Liberty Mutual, CBS News, Forbes and LegalZoom.

Beyond the data, Connor stays connected to how the market actually operates, drawing on direct conversations with underwriters and carrier liaisons at Ethos, The Hartford, NEXT Insurance, Nationwide, and State Farm, and monitoring business and pet owner communities including Reddit, to inform how he interprets findings and frames guidance for real buyers.

He is the direct editorial contact for methodology questions at connor@moneygeek.com and can be found on LinkedIn.


Sources