Healthy Paws vs. Figo Pet Insurance


Healthy Paws vs. Figo Pet Insurance: Key Takeaways
blueCheck icon

Figo provides more affordable pet insurance rates for most age categories, charging $30 per month for middle-aged cats and $52 for dogs. Healthy Paws costs more at $59 for cats and $136 for dogs in the same age range.

blueCheck icon

Healthy Paws provides better customer experience than Figo, backed by its high Trustpilot and BBB ratings for its responsive customer service and fast claim processing.

blueCheck icon

Figo offers broader pet insurance coverage than Healthy Paws, featuring shorter waiting periods, up to 100% reimbursement and coverage for exam fees, routine care and other pet owner benefits through its optional add-ons.

Is Healthy Paws or Figo Pet Insurance Better?

Healthy Paws ranks sixth nationally for pet insurance for both dogs and cats, placing two spots ahead of Figo. That said, the better choice between the two depends on what you value most when choosing coverage for your pet.

  • Affordability: Healthy Paws ranks sixth nationally for dog insurance, two spots ahead of Figo. For cats, Figo ranks fifth and places one position above Healthy Paws.
  • Customer Experience: Healthy Paws excels in customer satisfaction for both dogs and cats, ranking fifth nationally. In comparison, Figo places seventh in our rankings.
  • Coverage: Figo takes the lead when comparing pet insurance coverage options, ranking fifth nationally for both dogs and cats. Healthy Paws trails by one spot.
Data filtered by:
Overall Score
CatHealthy Paws68
DogHealthy Paws68

How We Decided the Winning Pet Insurance Provider

Compare Pet Insurance Rates

Get the best rate for your pet's coverage needs. Compare quotes from top pet insurance companies.

Learn more about the best pet insurance options for your pet across different situations:

Healthy Paws and Figo Comparison by State

Healthy Paws ranks as the best pet insurance company for dogs when compared to Figo, with Healthy Paws leading in 38 states, while Figo wins in 12. For cats, Figo is the better option, outperforming Healthy Paws in 29 states.

Data filtered by:
Select
AlabamaCatHealthy Paws
AlabamaDogHealthy Paws
AlaskaCatFigo
AlaskaDogFigo
ArizonaCatFigo
ArizonaDogHealthy Paws
ArkansasCatFigo
ArkansasDogFigo
CaliforniaCatHealthy Paws
CaliforniaDogHealthy Paws
ColoradoCatFigo
ColoradoDogHealthy Paws
ConnecticutCatFigo
ConnecticutDogHealthy Paws
DelawareCatFigo
DelawareDogHealthy Paws
FloridaCatFigo
FloridaDogHealthy Paws
GeorgiaCatHealthy Paws
GeorgiaDogFigo
HawaiiCatHealthy Paws
HawaiiDogFigo
IdahoCatFigo
IdahoDogHealthy Paws
IllinoisCatFigo
IllinoisDogHealthy Paws
IndianaCatHealthy Paws
IndianaDogHealthy Paws
IowaCatHealthy Paws
IowaDogFigo
KansasCatFigo
KansasDogHealthy Paws
KentuckyCatHealthy Paws
KentuckyDogHealthy Paws
LouisianaCatFigo
LouisianaDogHealthy Paws
MaineCatHealthy Paws
MaineDogHealthy Paws
MarylandCatHealthy Paws
MarylandDogHealthy Paws
MassachusettsCatFigo
MassachusettsDogHealthy Paws
MichiganCatFigo
MichiganDogHealthy Paws
MinnesotaCatFigo
MinnesotaDogFigo
MississippiCatHealthy Paws
MississippiDogHealthy Paws
MissouriCatFigo
MissouriDogHealthy Paws
MontanaCatHealthy Paws
MontanaDogHealthy Paws
NebraskaCatFigo
NebraskaDogFigo
NevadaCatFigo
NevadaDogHealthy Paws
New HampshireCatFigo
New HampshireDogHealthy Paws
New JerseyCatHealthy Paws
New JerseyDogFigo
New MexicoCatFigo
New MexicoDogFigo
New YorkCatHealthy Paws
New YorkDogHealthy Paws
North CarolinaCatHealthy Paws
North CarolinaDogHealthy Paws
North DakotaCatFigo
North DakotaDogHealthy Paws
OhioCatHealthy Paws
OhioDogHealthy Paws
OklahomaCatFigo
OklahomaDogHealthy Paws
OregonCatHealthy Paws
OregonDogHealthy Paws
PennsylvaniaCatHealthy Paws
PennsylvaniaDogHealthy Paws
Rhode IslandCatFigo
Rhode IslandDogHealthy Paws
South CarolinaCatFigo
South CarolinaDogHealthy Paws
South DakotaCatFigo
South DakotaDogHealthy Paws
TennesseeCatHealthy Paws
TennesseeDogHealthy Paws
TexasCatHealthy Paws
TexasDogHealthy Paws
UtahCatFigo
UtahDogHealthy Paws
VermontCatFigo
VermontDogFigo
VirginiaCatHealthy Paws
VirginiaDogHealthy Paws
WashingtonCatHealthy Paws
WashingtonDogHealthy Paws
West VirginiaCatFigo
West VirginiaDogFigo
WisconsinCatFigo
WisconsinDogHealthy Paws
WyomingCatFigo
WyomingDogFigo

How We Decided the Winning Pet Insurance Provider by State

Healthy Paws vs. Figo Pet Insurance Cost

Figo is cheaper than Healthy Paws across six pet insurance cost categories: kittens, puppies, young cats, young dogs, middle-aged cats and middle-aged dogs, providing up to 76% savings for kitten coverage. Healthy Paws only offers lower rates for senior pets.

Data filtered by:
Select
KittensFigo$1076%
Young CatsFigo$1640%
PuppiesFigo$2156%
Young DogsFigo$3032%
Middle Aged CatsFigo$3049%
Middle Aged DogsFigo$5262%
Senior CatsHealthy Paws$6338%
Senior DogsHealthy Paws$11536%

How We Decided the Winning Pet Insurance Provider

Healthy Paws vs. Figo Pet Insurance Cost by State

Figo offers the cheapest pet insurance in all 50 states for kittens, puppies, and young and middle-aged pets. Healthy Paws is more affordable than Figo across the country for senior cats and senior dogs.

Data filtered by:
Middle Aged Dogs
AlabamaFigo$3962%
AlaskaFigo$5162%
ArizonaFigo$6462%
ArkansasFigo$3562%
CaliforniaFigo$6662%
ColoradoFigo$6662%
ConnecticutFigo$6062%
DelawareFigo$5262%
FloridaFigo$5962%
GeorgiaFigo$4762%
HawaiiFigo$5362%
IdahoFigo$5262%
IllinoisFigo$6562%
IndianaFigo$4762%
IowaFigo$4462%
KansasFigo$4762%
KentuckyFigo$4162%
LouisianaFigo$4262%
MaineFigo$6461%
MarylandFigo$5261%
MassachusettsFigo$6762%
MichiganFigo$5262%
MinnesotaFigo$5462%
MississippiFigo$4562%
MissouriFigo$4162%
MontanaFigo$4462%
NebraskaFigo$4762%
NevadaFigo$5462%
New HampshireFigo$6162%
New JerseyFigo$5962%
New MexicoFigo$4662%
New YorkFigo$5762%
North CarolinaFigo$4762%
North DakotaFigo$4062%
OhioFigo$4862%
OklahomaFigo$4462%
OregonFigo$6562%
PennsylvaniaFigo$5562%
Rhode IslandFigo$4562%
South CarolinaFigo$4962%
South DakotaFigo$4662%
TennesseeFigo$4862%
TexasFigo$5562%
UtahFigo$5062%
VermontFigo$4962%
VirginiaFigo$5662%
WashingtonFigo$6062%
West VirginiaFigo$4562%
WisconsinFigo$5662%
WyomingFigo$4862%

How We Decided the Winning Pet Insurance Provider by State

Healthy Paws vs. Figo Pet Insurance Discounts

Figo offers three pet insurance discounts for households with multiple pets, military members and those with eligible memberships. Healthy Paws doesn't offer discounts that lower your rate.

Multiple pets

None.

5% off for insuring two or more pets.

Military

None.

Active duty military members and veterans get 5% off pet insurance.

Membership

None.

Costco members who enroll through the Costco program save 15%.

Healthy Paws vs. Figo Pet Insurance Customer Experience

Healthy Paws outperforms Figo in customer service, ranking fifth nationally to Figo's seventh. Trustpilot scores back this up: Healthy Paws earns a 4.1 out of 5 versus Figo's 3.6, and the Better Business Bureau rates Healthy Paws A+ against Figo's B. Reddit sentiment also leans toward Healthy Paws, with 20% positive mentions compared to 17% for Figo.

    trustSeal icon
    Healthy Paws vs Figo Trustpilot ratings

    Healthy Paws scores higher on Trustpilot with a 4.1 out of 5 rating compared to Figo's 3.6 out of 5. Pet owners praise both companies for fast claim processing and easy-to-use apps, but Healthy Paws reviewers highlight quicker reimbursement times while Figo customers report more claim denials and longer processing delays.

    trustSeal icon
    Healthy Paws vs Figo BBB ratings

    Healthy Paws maintains an A+ BBB rating compared to Figo's B rating. The A+ rating indicates Healthy Paws consistently meets BBB standards and resolves customer concerns, while Figo's B rating stems from 88 complaints filed against the business.

    trustSeal icon
    Healthy Paws vs Figo Pet Insurance Reddit sentiment

    Healthy Paws holds 20% positive feedback from 40 total comments, while Figo garners 17% positive sentiment from 12 comments. Reddit users praise Healthy Paws for responsive customer service and fast claim processing, but criticize the company for sharp premium increases on senior pets, with many reporting rates doubling or tripling. Figo draws criticism for high upfront pricing and claim denials, with several users reporting rates doubled within the first renewal year.

Healthy Paws vs. Figo Pet Insurance Coverage

Figo offers better pet insurance coverage for dogs and cats than Healthy Paws, ranking fifth nationally while Healthy Paws ranks sixth. Figo requires shorter waiting periods for accidents, illnesses and orthopedic conditions, plus it provides up to 100% reimbursement on top of covering curable pre-existing conditions after 12 months of being symptom-free.

Diagnostics
Fractures and broken bones
Lacerations and bite wounds
Parasite treatment

X

X

Digestive illnesses
Hereditary conditions
Congenital conditions
Chronic conditions

$250, $500, $1,000

$100, $250, $500, $750

Unlimited

$5,000, $10,000, Unlimited

70%, 80%, 90%

70%, 80%, 90%, 100%

15 days for illnesses and accidents, 12 months for hip dysplasia

1 day for accidents, 14 days for illnesses, six months for orthopedic conditions

Age restrictions

Only insures pets up to age 14

No upper age limits for enrollment

Pre-existing conditions

Pre‑existing conditions are permanently excluded

Curable pre-existing conditions may be covered after 12 symptom-free months

Coverage varies by state and policy terms. Always review your specific policy documents to understand exact coverage terms, exclusions and limitations.

Healthy Paws vs. Figo Pet Insurance Add-ons

If you want to extend your base coverage to include preventive care and other benefits, Figo offers several optionals add-ons, while Healthy Paws keeps coverage simple with its standard accident and illness policy.

With Figo, you can choose from four add-ons:

  • Wellness Powerup: Comes in Basic and Plus tiers, covering routine exams, dental cleaning, spaying/neutering, vaccines, microchipping or health certificates and deworming.
  • Exam Fee Coverage: Reimburses vet exam fees for covered accidents and illnesses.
  • Extra Care Pack: Provides reimbursement for lost-pet advertising, vacation cancellation costs due to pet illness, boarding fees, third-party property damage liability and final respects services.
  • Alternative Care, Rehabilitation and Physical Therapy Riders: Covers behavioral consultations, alternative therapies, rehabilitation or physical therapy.

Healthy Paws vs. Figo Pet Insurance: Bottom Line

The right pick between Healthy Paws and Figo for pet insurance comes down to what you need. Healthy Paws works well for pet owners who value reliable customer service and claims support, backed by high BBB and Trustpilot ratings and positive feedback from Reddit users. Figo suits those who want broader coverage, with up to 100% reimbursement and shorter waiting periods than Healthy Paws.

Compare other major pet insurance companies to determine the best choice for your pet:

Healthy Paws vs. Figo Pet Insurance Comparison: FAQ

Compare Healthy Paws and Figo pet insurance through these common questions:

Which is better: Healthy Paws or Figo pet insurance?

How do Healthy Paws and Figo compare on coverage and exclusions?

Is Healthy Paws or Figo cheaper for pet insurance?

What are the main differences between Healthy Paws and Figo pet insurance?

Is Healthy Paws or Figo better for puppies and kittens?

About Mark Fitzpatrick


Mark Fitzpatrick headshot

Mark Fitzpatrick, a Licensed Property and Casualty Insurance Producer, is MoneyGeek's resident Personal Finance Expert. He has analyzed the insurance market for over five years, conducting original research for insurance shoppers. His insights have been featured in CNBC, NBC News and Mashable.

Fitzpatrick holds a master’s degree in economics and international relations from Johns Hopkins University and a bachelor’s degree from Boston College. He's also a five-time Jeopardy champion!

He writes about economics and insurance, breaking down complex topics so people know what they're buying.


sources
Copyright © 2026 MoneyGeek.com. All Rights Reserved