Looking for the right car insurance company? Our in-depth reviews use data, expert analysis and customer feedback to compare prices, service quality and claims experience among top national insurers. Use our ratings to make a confident, informed choice.
Car Insurance Reviews
Updated: April 22, 2025
Advertising & Editorial Disclosure
Key Takeaways
Car insurance quotes vary depending on how you shop — online, through agents or directly from providers — even for the same coverage.
No one auto insurance company is best for everyone. Your driver profile, location and coverage needs determine the right fit.
The cheapest insurer in one state might not be the cheapest in another. Comparing state-specific options can help you find better local deals.
Car Insurance Company Reviews
Car Insurance Company Comparisons
Compare top-rated car insurance providers based on price, coverage options, customer satisfaction and digital tools. Whether you focus on affordability, claims experience or special features, our side-by-side reviews can help you quickly spot the differences. Find the company you're considering to see how it stacks up.
Insurance Providers | Scores | Bottom Line |
|---|---|---|
State Farm vs GEICO | 92 vs 88 | State Farm outperforms GEICO across affordability, satisfaction, and overall score, making it the stronger choice in this comparison. |
State Farm vs Travelers | 92 vs 85 | State Farm is more affordable and scores higher overall, but Travelers has slightly better claims service for those prioritizing support. |
State Farm vs Nationwide | 92 vs 83 | State Farm outperforms Nationwide across the board, offering better satisfaction, lower rates, and a higher overall score. |
State Farm vs Progressive | 92 vs 74 | State Farm offers significantly better value than Progressive, with higher satisfaction, lower premiums, and a much stronger overall score. |
State Farm vs Allstate | 92 vs 72 | State Farm clearly outperforms Allstate across the board with better satisfaction, lower rates, and a much higher overall score. |
State Farm vs Farmers | 92 vs 64 | State Farm wins easily, offering much lower premiums and stronger satisfaction than Farmers, which scores lowest in affordability. |
GEICO vs Travelers | 88 vs 85 | GEICO slightly edges out Travelers with better pricing and a higher overall score, though both companies are close on satisfaction. |
GEICO vs Nationwide | 88 vs 83 | GEICO outperforms Nationwide in affordability, satisfaction and overall score, making it the stronger option across the board. |
GEICO vs Progressive | 88 vs 74 | GEICO offers better value overall, with stronger satisfaction and far better affordability than Progressive, plus a lower annual premium. |
GEICO vs Allstate | 88 vs 72 | GEICO outperforms Allstate across the board — it’s more affordable, has higher satisfaction, and costs over $200 less per year. |
GEICO vs Farmers | 88 vs 64 | GEICO clearly beats Farmers with better scores, lower premiums, and significantly stronger affordability — a more balanced choice overall. |
Travelers vs Nationwide | 85 vs 83 | Travelers slightly edges out Nationwide in satisfaction and overall score, though both offer nearly identical affordability and premium costs. |
Travelers vs Progressive | 85 vs 74 | Travelers outperforms Progressive across all key metrics, offering higher satisfaction and better affordability at a lower annual premium. |
Travelers vs Allstate | 85 vs 72 | Travelers offers stronger satisfaction and affordability than Allstate, with a $159 cheaper premium and a higher overall performance score. |
Travelers vs Farmers | 85 vs 64 | Travelers significantly outperforms Farmers across the board — offering better value, higher satisfaction, and a $256 lower annual premium. |
Nationwide vs Progressive | 83 vs 74 | Nationwide offers a lower premium and better value overall, but Progressive slightly edges ahead in customer satisfaction. |
Nationwide vs Allstate | 83 vs 72 | Nationwide outperforms Allstate overall, offering better affordability and a lower premium, though satisfaction scores are nearly the same. |
Nationwide vs Farmers | 83 vs 64 | Nationwide has a much higher overall score and far better affordability, while Farmers only slightly leads in satisfaction. |
Progressive vs Allstate | 74 vs 72 | Progressive narrowly edges out Allstate on score, affordability and satisfaction, though both rank low overall among national insurers. |
Progressive vs Farmers | 74 vs 64 | Progressive outperforms Farmers in overall score and affordability, while Farmers slightly leads in satisfaction but has the highest premium. |
Allstate vs Farmers | 72 vs 64 | Allstate outperforms Farmers in cost and overall score, but Farmers edges ahead slightly in customer satisfaction despite higher premiums. |
Our Best and Cheapest Car Insurance Reviews
If you're looking for the best car insurance, we've reviewed top providers for different driver types — from full coverage to high-risk drivers and young adults. Check our expert rankings to find insurers with the best mix of price, service and reliability. Start with the category that fits your situation to see your top option.
Compare the Best and Cheapest Car Insurance Companies by State
Car insurance rates and coverage options vary by state, as do the best companies. Compare top-rated insurers where you live with our state-by-state breakdown. This guide helps you find the right provider in your area, whether you want the cheapest rates, best service or certain coverage.
Hover over the map to see data for a state
What to Look for in Auto Insurance Companies
When choosing an auto insurer, look beyond price to reliable coverage and service when needed. Here are the key factors to compare when evaluating car insurance companies:
Financial strength
Check the company’s ability to pay claims by reviewing ratings from third-party agencies like AM Best. A high rating means the insurer is financially stable.
Customer satisfaction
Check feedback from actual policyholders and third-party review sites like J.D. Power. High marks for claims handling and customer service are good signs.
Coverage options
Some insurers offer more flexible or robust coverage choices than others, such as gap insurance, accident forgiveness or rideshare coverage. Make sure the company covers your needs.
Prices, discounts and special programs
Compare base rates and discounts for bundling, safe driving, students and more. Some insurers also offer usage-based programs that adjust rates based on your driving habits and mileage.
Digital tools and policy management
A well-rated app or online account system can make it easier to pay bills, file claims or manage your policy. This helps tech-savvy drivers or those who prefer self-service.
How to Find the Best Car Insurance for You
Selecting the right car insurance means evaluating your needs, understanding coverage options and comparing providers. Follow these steps to make an informed decision that fits your situation.
1. Find Out How Much Car Insurance You Need
The right amount of car insurance depends on your state's minimum requirements, your budget and how much financial risk you're willing to take. Most states require minimum coverage, but that often isn't enough to protect you financially after a serious accident. Consider adding comprehensive and collision coverage if you drive a newer or more valuable car.
Drivers with savings or assets may want higher limits to avoid paying out of pocket. Don't forget uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage — it's helpful in states with many uninsured drivers.
Use MoneyGeek's calculator below to estimate how much coverage you need.
Determine How Much Car Insurance You Need
Take our four-step quiz to learn the required and optimal level of car insurance for you.
Enter Your ZIP Code
Please enter a valid US ZIP Code
2. Research Costs and Discounts
Insurance costs vary widely between companies, even for the same coverage. Research rates from multiple insurers and check what discounts each offers.
Common savings include bundling, safe driving, good student and vehicle safety discounts. Some companies offer usage-based programs that reward low mileage or careful driving. Understanding the full cost picture — not just the base rate — helps you find better value.
3. Find the Best Companies for Your Driver Profile
Insurance providers assess risk differently, so identify companies that fit your driver profile. With insurers offering good student discounts or teen programs, young drivers can find cheap rates. High-risk drivers with past infractions may benefit from companies specializing in nonstandard auto insurance. By choosing insurers that match your profile, you can get more personalized coverage and potentially better rates.
Best Car Insurance Company Matcher
Find the car insurance provider that fits your personal needs and preferences
Basic Details
Select...
30-65
Clean
4. Compare Multiple Providers Through Different Channels
Car insurance quotes vary by company and how you shop. Compare across multiple channels:
- Online comparison sites: View various quotes at once, but may not include every insurer
- Captive agents: Represent one company and offer personalized help
- Independent or broker agents: Work with multiple insurers to find your best match
- Individual provider websites: Offer instant quotes but show only one company's pricing
MONEYGEEK EXPERT TIP
Different methods can yield different rates due to pricing models, exclusive discounts or how your information is processed. Get quotes from at least two sources for accurate comparisons and ensure your coverage levels and driver details stay consistent. This helps you make an apples-to-apples comparison and find the best deal.
5. Repeat Your Research and Comparison Regularly
Car insurance rates change over time — and so can your needs. Insurers update their pricing models, and new competitors enter the market. Life changes like moving, buying a new car, improving your credit or adding a driver can affect your premium.
Even if you're happy with your current provider, review your policy and compare quotes yearly. Staying proactive ensures you get the best deal and aren't overpaying just because you've stayed with the same insurer.
Car Insurance Reviews: Bottom Line
This page provides expert-backed reviews, comparisons and tools to help you find the best and cheapest car insurance. Rates, service and coverage vary widely between companies — and between drivers. By getting quotes from multiple sources, understanding what coverage you need and comparing providers regularly, you can make smarter, more confident decisions on auto insurance.
Auto Insurance Reviews: FAQ
Have more questions about car insurance reviews or how to compare providers? These answers to common questions can help you navigate the process easily.
How can I tell if a car insurance company is reliable?
Look for third-party ratings from sources like J.D. Power, AM Best and the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC). High customer satisfaction and financial strength scores are strong indicators of a trustworthy insurer.
Why do car insurance quotes vary between companies?
Insurers use different formulas to assess risk, so prices for the same driver and coverage vary widely. Comparing quotes from multiple providers is key to finding the best rate.
Do online car insurance reviews reflect real customer experiences?
Many reviews include expert analysis and customer feedback. Look for patterns — if multiple reviewers mention the same issue (like poor claims service), it’s likely a real concern.
How often should I compare car insurance providers?
Comparing insurers once a year is a good rule of thumb, especially if your circumstances change. Also, compare quotes if your premium increases or you’re buying a new vehicle.
Is it better to buy insurance online or through an agent?
There’s no single answer. Buying online is quick and convenient, while agents offer personalized advice. Trying both and comparing results can help you decide what works best.
Car Insurance Reviews: Our Methodology
How We Review Car Insurance Companies
Our car insurance reviews use MoneyGeek's data-driven scoring system, which evaluates companies' customer satisfaction, affordability, claims service, coverage options and financial strength. We use data from trusted industry sources, including Quadrant Information Services, J.D. Power, AM Best and the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC).
Why Our Reviews Apply Nationwide
Car insurance rates and service quality vary by state, so we examined how each company performed across different regions and driver profiles. The highest-ranked companies consistently earned strong MoneyGeek scores nationwide — making our recommendations useful whether you live in a large city or a small town.
Our Data Sources and Sample Size
We analyzed more than 83,000 quotes from 46 insurers across 473 ZIP codes. Customer satisfaction and claims ratings came from benchmarks like J.D. Power, NAIC and AM Best.
Our Driver Profile
To calculate average rates, we used a standard driver profile:
- 40-year-old male
- Clean driving record
- Full coverage (100/300/100 liability, comprehensive and collision with a $1,000 deductible)
- 2010 Toyota Camry LE
- 12,000 miles driven annually
We adjusted this profile for different scenarios — such as younger or older drivers, high-risk histories, military background or low mileage — to reflect a broader range of consumers.
How We Score Each Company
Each insurer receives a composite MoneyGeek score (out of 5) based on these weighted factors:
- 55% affordability — Premiums from Quadrant Information Services, benchmarked across competitors
- 15% customer satisfaction — Ratings from J.D. Power and complaint data from NAIC
- 15% coverage options — Availability of essential coverages like roadside assistance, rental car reimbursement or gap insurance
- 10% claims experience — Insights from J.D. Power Claims Study and CRASH Report Card
- 5% financial stability — Based on AM Best financial strength ratings
We adjust weightings depending on the audience. For example, we may weigh affordability higher for budget-focused drivers, while claims handling may take priority for others. In some cases, standout coverage features also inform our qualitative assessments.
About Mark Fitzpatrick
Mark Fitzpatrick, a Licensed Property and Casualty Insurance Producer, is MoneyGeek's resident Personal Finance Expert. With over five years of experience analyzing the insurance market, he conducts original research and creates tailored content for all types of buyers. His insights have been featured in publications like CNBC, NBC News and Mashable.
Fitzpatrick holds a master’s degree in economics and international relations from Johns Hopkins University and a bachelor’s degree from Boston College. He's also a five-time Jeopardy champion!
Passionate about economics and insurance, he aims to promote transparency in financial topics and empower others to make confident money decisions.