No single pet insurance works best for every Michigan pet owner, but MoneyGeek's analysis of 18 major insurers identified the five best pet insurance that earned top marks across affordability, customer experience and coverage:
- Pumpkin: Best Pet Insurance Overall
- Lemonade: Best for Boxers, Burmese and Siamese Cats
- Pets Best: Best Pet Insurance Coverage Options and Terms
- ASPCA: Best for Bull Mastiffs
- Figo: Best for Caucasian Shepherd Dogs, Rough Collies and Australian Mists
These five companies earned their rankings in Michigan by providing rates that stays competitive against the state average, a service experience that holds up from enrollment through claims and coverage terms that don't fall short when a real health event occurs. The table below summarizes each insurer's overall value based on your pet's needs.









