Car Insurance Reviews | Best Companies 2025

Out of all national car insurance providers, Travelers offers the most balanced experience, with the second-most affordable rates, second-best customer experience and fourth-best coverage options nationwide. The company has the most affordable full coverage rates for most drivers and offers unique coverage add-ons for new car replacement, accident forgiveness and ridesharing.

Travelers car insurance ranges from $46 to $1,084 monthly, depending on your driving profile. The company ranks first for full coverage affordability and third for minimum coverage policies. Use our filterable table below to see where Travelers ranks for your profile.

Travelers earned second place for customer satisfaction with consistently high ratings. The company stands out in our multi-platform analysis of social media, online review forums and discussion forums like Reddit with the highest rating in that category among nationally available insurers.

Compared to other national providers, Travelers offers new car replacement (1 of 3 national companies), rideshare coverage (1 of 5 national companies) and accident forgiveness (1 of 4 national companies). Travelers' new car replacement coverage lasts five years of ownership, much longer than the typical one to two years that other insurers offer.

GEICO earns the second spot for the best car insurance companies due to its affordability. However, the company is weaker in customer service and has the smallest add-on selection on our list.

Depending on your driving profile, car insurance rates with GEICO range from $40 to $574 per month. The company ranks first for minimum coverage affordability and second for full coverage policies. Use our table below to see where GEICO ranks for your profile.

GEICO's strongest point is its agent service, but when we researched sentiment through multiple platforms, including social media, it was mixed and leaned negative. Below, you can review how its customer service stacks up nationally in all areas we studied.

Overall, GEICO has fewer than average add-on selections, with three (the national average is four), including roadside assistance and rental reimbursement as standard options. Its third option is unique (1 of 5 national insurers) and is called mechanical breakdown insurance, which serves as a cheaper version of a car warranty that covers you if your vehicle breaks down on its own.

Amica earned our third spot among the top auto insurance providers mainly due to its generally affordable rates and reputation for being a best-in-class customer service provider. Senior drivers will find the best experience overall with the company.

Overall, Amica ranks fourth for affordability compared to national companies, earning the fourth-place and fifth-place spots for full coverage and minimum coverage policies, respectively. Rates with the company range from $41 to $585 monthly on average. Use our table below to see if Amica is among the top five most affordable providers for your profile.

Amica earned the top rank overall for customer experience, with the highest agent service score and best overall customer satisfaction score in J.D. Power's Auto Insurance Study. It was also the only widely available company with very positive customer sentiment on social media and forums like Reddit.

Amica offers standard coverage options like rental reimbursement and roadside assistance as part of its add-on portfolio. However, it uniquely offers rideshare insurance coverage (1 of 5 national companies) and auto glass coverage (1 of 2 national companies).

While Progressive is more expensive on average than all of the providers on our list, it offers a superior coverage selection and a top-five customer experience to compensate. This earned it our fourth spot for the best car insurance companies.

Progressive car insurance rates rank sixth for full coverage affordability and eighth for minimum coverage. Premiums with the company range from $74 to $666 per month, depending on your profile. See below if Progressive is the most affordable option for your profile.

Progressive earned the third-highest overall agent service ranking, has a strong Google business rating, but has mixed reception in our multi-platform analysis including social media.

Progressive has an extensive selection of coverage options, including standard options like roadside assistance and unique options such as a diminishing deductible (1 of 3 national providers) and custom equipment/parts coverage (1 of 2 national providers) for vehicles. The company also offers mechanical breakdown insurance, which few providers offer (1 of 5 national providers).

While at the bottom of our list, State Farm has balanced rankings for overall affordability and customer service. The company also has tailored discount programs like Steer Clear that can reduce rates significantly for drivers under 25.

While State Farm offers more expensive full coverage rates, those looking for minimum liability policies will get rates that are the fourth most affordable in the nation. Depending on your driver profile, you can pay as low as $41 for coverage. Use our table below to see whether State Farm is affordable for you.

State Farm had many positive customer experiences with its agents, which is unsurprising given that it has the largest agent network in the nation. However, customers on other platforms complained about the inflexibility of getting coverage due to its agency-only model and issues with claims processing.

Like GEICO, State Farm has limited car insurance add-on options, including roadside assistance, rental reimbursement and rideshare insurance.