Auto Insurance
5/5
Affordability
4.5/5
Claims Ratings
5/5
User Satisfaction
5/5
Financial Stability
Compare the Cost of Toyota 86 Insurance by Model Year and Company
Compare Rates
Ensure you're getting the best rate. Review quotes from a top insurance company.
It pays to shop around and compare rates when looking for an insurance policy for your Toyota 86. This is a great way to secure the best deal because different insurers can have different insurance rates for the same car. The cheapest insurance company can change depending on the model year of your car.
Key Takeaways for Toyota 86 Insurance
It costs $1,629 per year on average to insure a Toyota 86. This is $202 higher than the rate for the average car model.
The cost to insure a Toyota 86 can change by as much as $1,066 per year depending on the company.
The cost of insurance for a Toyota 86 can change by as much as $110 per year, depending on how old your car is, with older cars fetching cheaper rates.
How Much It Costs to Insure a Toyota 86 and the Cheapest Company
Your choice of insurer can significantly affect your insurance rates. On average, you’ll pay $1,629 per year to insure a Toyota 86, but costs can vary depending on your provider.
Based on our analysis, GEICO offers the cheapest widely available insurance at $1,261.
USAA is another affordable option if you have a military background. Their policy costs $1,184 yearly. That’s $1,066 cheaper than Allstate, which offers the most expensive policy at an average of $2,251.
The Average Annual Cost of Toyota 86 Insurance by Company
To conduct this analysis, MoneyGeek compared insurance quotes from multiple car insurance companies using a 40-year-old male sample driver profile. The driver has 100/300/100 liability insurance with comprehensive and collision coverage.
The Average Cost to Insure a Toyota 86 by Company
Scroll for more
- CompanyAverage Annual Rates
- 1.$1,184
- 2.$1,261
- 3.$1,445
- 4.$1,685
- 5.$1,703
Compare Auto Insurance Rates
Ensure you're getting the best rate for your auto insurance. Compare quotes from the top insurance companies.
Is a Toyota 86 Expensive to Insure?
Car insurance companies use several factors to determine the cost of car insurance for any given car. This includes theft rates, the car’s value and more.
A Toyota 86 is designated as a sports car. Sports cars are more expensive to insure because their drivers are seen to be more likely to engage in risky driving behaviors, making them more likely to file a claim.
The Best Car Insurance Company for a Toyota 86
Cost shouldn’t be your only consideration when looking to buy Toyota 86 insurance. Though it is a crucial factor, it's still best to consider other factors.
MoneyGeek’s rating system, which is based on factors like customer satisfaction and financial stability, found that:
- USAA is the best car insurance company for a Toyota 86, but is only available for military members and their families.
- GEICO is the second-best insurance provider for a Toyota 86 and is available to all drivers.
1
USAA
Score:99
2
GEICO
Score:88
3
Progressive
Score:84
4
Nationwide
Score:81
5
State Farm
Score:80
6
Allied
Score:NaN
7
Allstate
Score:69
How Much It Costs to Insure a Toyota 86 by Model Year
Older versions of a Toyota 86 tend to be cheaper to insure because as a car’s value depreciates, collision and comprehensive insurance also become less expensive.
For instance, a 2020 Toyota 86 costs an average of $1,684 per year to insure. In comparison, a 2017 model is $110 cheaper, at an average of $1,574 annually.
Here are the average insurance costs for the Toyota 86 by model year:
- 2017 Toyota 86: $1,574 per year
- 2018 Toyota 86: $1,620 per year
- 2019 Toyota 86: $1,656 per year
- 2020 Toyota 86: $1,684 per year
Different insurers may offer cheaper rates depending on the car’s model year. At an average of $1,129 annually, USAA offers the cheapest insurance for the 2020 Toyota 86.
You can scroll to your car’s model year to see how rates between insurers vary.
The Average Cost to Insure a Toyota 86 by Model Year
Scroll for more
- CompanyAverage Annual Rates (2020 model)Average Annual Rates (2019 model)Average Annual Rates (2018 model)Average Annual Rates (2017 model)
- 1.$1,129$1,158$1,193$1,240
- 2.$1,271$1,266$1,260$1,252
- 3.$1,509$1,476$1,435$1,381
- 4.$1,653$1,669$1,690$1,717
- 5.$1,758$1,730$1,694$1,648
How Expensive Is It to Insure a Toyota 86 Compared to Other Cars?
Compared to other car models, the cost of insurance for the Toyota 86 is on the expensive side. On average, you pay $1,629 per year for coverage. This is roughly $202 per year more than the average insurance cost for other car models.
How Much It Costs to Insure a Toyota 86 for 16- to 25-Year-Olds
Your age can significantly affect the cost of insurance for a Toyota 86. Younger drivers can pay significantly more for car insurance given their inexperience.
On average, an 18-year-old will pay $5,316 per year to insure a Toyota 86. A 40-year-old driver will pay roughly $3,688 per year less for the same car.
Teen drivers and their parents can often save money by being on the same policy, as it can be very expensive for a teen to buy a policy for themselves.
You can use the table below to see the average cost to insure a Toyota 86 by driver age.
The Average Cost to Insure a Toyota 86 by Driver Age
Scroll for more
- AgeAverage Annual Rates
- 16$6,816
- 17$6,038
- 18$5,316
- 19$3,808
- 20$3,399
How Does Location Affect the Cost of Toyota 86 Insurance?
The costs referenced in this article are based on a national average. Keep in mind that your location can significantly affect your car insurance rates. You can use our state page analysis to learn more about car insurance costs in each state.
FAQs About Toyota 86 Insurance
Your car’s model can have a big impact on your car insurance rates, but it’s just one of many factors. Learn more about insuring a Toyota 86 with these questions.
Read More About Car Insurance
Auto Insurance
About Mark Fitzpatrick
