Can a Landlord Require Renters Insurance?

To safeguard their interests, some landlords require renters insurance from tenants. Renters insurance offers you financial protection and liability coverage.

Find out if you're overpaying for renters insurance below.

By Mark Fitzpatrick

Edited by Denise Cristobal

Updated: October 3, 2025

Advertising & Editorial Disclosure

Key Takeaways

Landlords can require tenants to carry renters insurance, but the requirements must be clearly stated in lease agreements with reasonable coverage amounts and adequate notice.

Landlords may receive premium discounts of 5% to 15% on their dwelling policies when tenants carry renters insurance.

Non-compliance can result in lease violations, eviction proceedings or force-placed insurance at the tenant's expense.

Can Landlords Require Renters Insurance?

Renters insurance isn't legally required in any state, but your landlord can require it as part of your lease agreement, and many do to protect themselves from liability.

This requirement typically specifies minimum coverage amounts, often $100,000 in liability coverage, and may require the landlord to be listed as an "additional interested party" on your policy. Even if your landlord doesn't require renters insurance, spending an average of $12 monthly for renters insurance beats scrambling to replace thousands of dollars in belongings or facing a lawsuit if someone gets hurt in your apartment.

What Are the Requirements and Limits?

Landlords must follow specific guidelines when requiring renters insurance to comply with state regulations and fair housing laws. Understanding these rules helps you recognize fair versus unreasonable demands.

You have rights when it comes to renters insurance requirements; landlords can't just demand whatever they want. Essential lease documentation requirements include:

Factor	Description
Upfront disclosure	Your landlord must spell out the insurance requirement clearly in your lease before you sign it.
Reasonableness	Coverage amounts have to be reasonable. Courts generally uphold $20,000 to $50,000 in personal property coverage and $100,000 to $300,000 in liability coverage. Excessive requirements may be struck down.
Proof of Insurance	Tenants may be required to provide proof of coverage (certificate of insurance or declaration page) and keep it current.

Legal Compliance Checklist for Landlords

This checklist outlines the key compliance steps every landlord should take to protect your rights, safety and living conditions:

1
Include an insurance clause in the lease agreement before the renter’s signature
2
Specify minimum coverage amounts and policy requirements
3
Allow tenant choice of insurance provider and agent
4
Require the landlord to be named as "interested party" on the policy
5
Establish reasonable timeframes for proof of coverage
6
Define consequences for non-compliance clearly
7
Follow state-specific notice requirements

What Happens If a Tenant Doesn't Get Renters Insurance?

When tenants fail to obtain required renters insurance, landlords have several legal remedies available, though enforcement procedures must follow state landlord-tenant laws.

Can a Landlord Enforce the Requirement During Tenancy or at Renewal?

Landlords can enforce renters insurance requirements throughout the lease term and at renewal. Enforcement typically follows a progressive approach during tenancy:

Steps	Actions taken
30-Day Written Notice	In most states, landlords must give tenants a written notice giving them 30 days to cure the violation by obtaining the required renters insurance coverage.
Follow-Up Documentation	If the tenant fails to comply within the cure period, landlords may issue additional notices documenting the ongoing violation and warning of potential consequences.
Legal Proceedings	Once all required notices have been given, landlords may pursue eviction proceedings for a material lease violation. The process and timeline, however, vary by state and local law.

At lease renewal, landlords can refuse to renew leases for tenants without insurance coverage, provided they follow proper notice procedures.

What Happens if the Tenant Lets the Policy Lapse?

Landlords handle policy lapses the same way they address initial non-compliance. Because landlords are listed as interested parties, they receive notifications when policies are cancelled, premiums go unpaid or coverage drops below the required minimum.

Failure to fix these lapses may result in eviction or penalties as stated in the lease agreement.

Response Timeline for Policy Lapses:

Day 1 to 5: Contact the tenant in writing about the policy lapse
Day 10: Issue a formal lease violation notice if no response
Day 30: Begin eviction proceedings if coverage is not restored (varies by state)

MoneyGeek's analysis shows that tenants who let policies lapse typically face:

$50 to $200 in administrative fees from landlords
Potential force-placed insurance costing two to three times standard premiums
Lease non-renewal at 67% higher rates than compliant tenants

Can Landlords Buy Coverage and Charge Tenants?

When tenants don't secure coverage, landlords can purchase force-placed insurance and charge tenants for the premium. This coverage may cost 200% to 300% more than standard renters insurance but ensures continuous protection.

Force-placed policies typically offer minimal coverage compared with individual policies. Landlords control the policy terms and claims process, while tenants pay higher premiums without choosing their coverage levels or deductibles.

State-Specific Variations in Renters Insurance Requirements

State regulations create variations in how landlords can implement and enforce renters insurance requirements. Some states have special restrictions:

Oklahoma

Landlords cannot require tenants to use specific carriers or agents but can require coverage amounts and policy types.

California

Landlords must provide written notice of insurance requirements before lease signing and cannot mandate specific insurance providers. Properties subject to rent control in cities like San Francisco and Los Angeles face additional restrictions on adding new lease requirements.

New York

Landlords must follow additional disclosure requirements when requiring renters insurance in rent-stabilized units. They must provide clear written notice of insurance requirements and cannot discriminate against tenants based on their choice of insurance provider.

Massachusetts

Strong tenant protection laws limit landlord enforcement options for insurance requirements. The state requires specific notice procedures for lease violations and prohibits certain types of force-placed insurance that could create undue financial burden on tenants.

Before implementing renters insurance requirements, landlords should verify local regulations. State law research requirements include:

1
Consulting State Insurance Departments
Each state's insurance department guides legal requirements and restrictions.
2
Reviewing Landlord-Tenant Laws
State-specific statutes govern lease requirements, notice procedures and enforcement mechanisms.
3
Checking Local Ordinances
Some cities or counties have additional restrictions.
4
Legal Consultation
Some situations may require legal consultation. Renters should consult a lawyer before signing a lease or any contract.

Is Renters Insurance Required: Bottom Line

Landlords require renters insurance to protect their interests while helping tenants secure affordable coverage for their belongings. While no law mandates renters insurance, landlords can include it as a lease requirement, just like requiring a security deposit or pet fee.

Landlords reduce their liability exposure and may see their own insurance premiums drop when tenants carry coverage. Properties with required renters insurance experience fewer liability claims and property disputes.

Renters Insurance Required by Landlord: FAQ

MoneyGeek experts answer common questions about the legalities of your renters insurance:

Can you get renters insurance without a lease?

You can purchase renters insurance without a formal lease agreement. Renters insurance coverage is available for anyone renting a living space, including month-to-month arrangements, subletting or staying with roommates. Insurance companies typically require proof of residence but don't mandate formal lease documentation.

Can your landlord make a claim on your renters insurance?

Landlords cannot file claims on your renters insurance policy. But landlords listed as "interested parties" receive notifications about policy changes, cancellations or claims that might affect the property. Landlords must use their own dwelling insurance for property-related claims.
Read more: Can My Landlord Make a Claim on My Renters Insurance?

Can a landlord require renters insurance for month-to-month tenants?

Landlords can require renters insurance for month-to-month tenancies but must provide proper notice (typically 30 days) before implementing the requirement for existing tenants. New month-to-month agreements can include the insurance requirement from the start.

What if I already have coverage through my parents' policy?

Most landlords require tenants to have their own individual renters insurance policy. Coverage under parents' policies may not provide adequate protection for independent living situations and doesn't give landlords the same notification rights. Check with your landlord about their specific policy requirements.

Can a landlord require pet liability coverage in renters insurance?

Landlords can require specific pet liability coverage as part of renters insurance requirements. This is especially common in pet-friendly properties where landlords want additional protection against pet-related damage or injuries. Some policies exclude certain dog breeds, so verify coverage before signing a lease.

Can student housing require renters insurance?

Student housing properties can require renters insurance. But many students may be covered under their parents' homeowners policies while attending school. Landlords should verify whether existing coverage meets their requirements or if students need separate policies.

What happens if I can't afford the required renters insurance?

Discuss payment plans or lower coverage options with your landlord if you can't afford the required coverage. Some may accept reduced coverage temporarily or allow payment of premiums in installments. But landlords aren't required to waive insurance requirements due to financial hardship.

Can a landlord charge extra rent if I don't have renters insurance?

Landlords cannot charge additional rent as a substitute for renters insurance. They can require the coverage as a lease condition and may purchase force-placed insurance at the tenant's expense if coverage lapses, but they cannot simply increase rent instead of insurance requirements.

Is Renters Insurance Required: Related Articles

About Mark Fitzpatrick

Mark Fitzpatrick, a Licensed Property and Casualty Insurance Producer, is MoneyGeek's resident Personal Finance Expert. With over five years of experience analyzing the insurance market, he conducts original research and creates tailored content for all types of buyers. His insights have been featured in publications like CNBC, NBC News and Mashable.

Fitzpatrick holds a master’s degree in economics and international relations from Johns Hopkins University and a bachelor’s degree from Boston College. He's also a five-time Jeopardy champion!

Passionate about economics and insurance, he aims to promote transparency in financial topics and empower others to make confident money decisions.

Read Full Bio »