Can You Have Homeowners and Renters Insurance at the Same Time?
Updated: July 30, 2024
Advertising & Editorial Disclosure
There may not technically be any legal restriction on carrying both homeowners insurance and renters insurance simultaneously, but virtually no situations would require this. Homeowners insurance is designed for individuals who live in their home as their primary residence, while renters insurance is meant for those leasing a property. If you own a home and rent it out while renting another place for your living space, you need both renters and landlord insurance.
Homeowners insurance covers the structure of the home and personal belongings, while renters insurance covers personal belongings and liability for tenants.
You cannot have homeowners and renters insurance simultaneously for the same living situation.
Homeowners renting out their property need landlord insurance, as it covers tenant-related risks.
Homeowners insurance covers the structure of the home, personal belongings, and liability, while renters insurance only covers personal belongings and liability for the tenant.
Homeowners need to protect their investment in the property's structure, while renters only need to safeguard their personal possessions. Both types of insurance offer financial protection, but knowing the differences between homeowners insurance and renters insurance will help ensure you have the appropriate coverage for your living situation while avoiding potential coverage gaps and unexpected costs.
Aspect | Homeowners Insurance | Renters Insurance |
|---|---|---|
Coverage for Structure | Covers the physical structure of the home, including walls, roof and built-in appliances. | Does not cover the structure. |
Coverage for Personal Belongings | Covers personal belongings inside the home and, in some cases, items outside the home. | Covers personal belongings within the rental property and sometimes items outside the rental. |
Liability Coverage | Provides liability coverage for accidents that occur on the property and damage caused to others. | Provides liability coverage for accidents and damage caused by the tenant. |
Additional Living Expenses | Covers additional living expenses if the home becomes uninhabitable due to a covered event. | Covers additional living expenses if the rental becomes uninhabitable due to a covered event. |
Coverage for Detached Structures | Includes coverage for detached structures like garages and sheds. | Does not cover detached structures. |
Typical Exclusions | Earthquakes, floods, wear and tear and maintenance issues. | Earthquakes, floods, wear and tear and maintenance issues. |
Deciding whether to get renters or homeowners insurance depends on your specific living situation. Each type of insurance offers unique benefits tailored to different needs and circumstances.
If Your Primary Residence Is a Home You Own: Homeowners Insurance
When you own your home and live there as your primary residence, homeowners insurance is essential for safeguarding your investment. This type of policy not only covers the structure of your home against various types of damage but also provides financial security against unforeseen events. Homeowners insurance will help you afford repairs or rebuilding without incurring significant out-of-pocket expenses. Additionally, it offers liability coverage, ensuring you are protected from potential legal and medical costs if someone gets injured on your property.
If Your Primary Residence Is a Home You Rent: Renters Insurance
If your primary residence is a home you rent, renters insurance is crucial for protecting your personal property and mitigating financial risks. Unlike homeowners insurance, renters insurance focuses on covering your belongings against theft, fire and other covered events. It also provides liability protection, which kicks in if you accidentally damage someone else's property or if someone gets injured while visiting you.
If You Own a Home and Rent It Out: Landlord Insurance
When you own a home and rent it out, instead of having both homeowners insurance and renters insurance, what you need is landlord insurance. This provides specific protections that cater to the unique needs of renting out your property, including property damage, liability and loss of rental income. It provides comprehensive coverage for tenant-related incidents and ensures financial protection as a landlord.
Since renters and home insurance both apply to your primary residence, it's typically not possible to have both. However, you may have either of these and landlord insurance if you have an investment property.
For example, if you own a home that you live in and a second home that you rent out, you'll need both home insurance and landlord insurance — one for each property. If you're renting the home you live in but also have an investment property, you'll need renters insurance to cover your own belongings in your rental and landlord insurance to cover your investment property that's being rented out to someone else.
Purchasing homeowners or renters insurance involves several steps. Finding the best homeowners insurance or renters insurance ensures that you are adequately protected against the risk of financial loss in case of an incident.
Whether you own your home or rent, having the right insurance coverage can provide peace of mind and financial security.
Determine the type and amount of coverage you require based on your living situation. For homeowners, consider the cost of rebuilding your home (not the market value), personal belongings and liability coverage. Renters should focus on the value of their personal belongings and liability protection.
Look for insurance companies that offer the type of coverage you need. Check their reputation, customer reviews and financial stability. For both homeowners and renters, it's beneficial to choose a provider known for reliable customer service and efficient claims processing.
Compare home insurance quotes or renters insurance quotes from multiple providers to compare prices and coverage options. Pay attention to deductibles, coverage limits and any additional benefits or discounts offered. Homeowners might look for discounts related to home security systems, while renters could find savings for bundling with other policies.
Carefully review the terms and conditions of each policy. Ensure that you understand what is covered, any exclusions and the claims process. For homeowners, verify coverage for natural disasters; for renters, confirm coverage for off-premises belongings.
Speak with an insurance agent to get professional advice and clarify any doubts. An agent can help tailor the policy to your specific needs and explain any complex terms. For homeowners, discuss additional coverage for valuable items; renters should ask about coverage for temporary housing if needed.
Once you have chosen the best policy, complete the application process. Make sure all your details are accurate and up-to-date. Homeowners should ensure the policy covers the full replacement cost of the home, while renters should confirm the policy includes liability coverage.
Regularly review your insurance policy to ensure it still meets your needs and update your coverage if you make significant changes to your home or acquire valuable items. Renters should also reassess their coverage annually to reflect any changes in their living situation or possessions.
We've addressed some frequently asked questions about home and renters insurance to help clarify when and why you might need both types of coverage.
No, you cannot have homeowners insurance and renters insurance simultaneously for the same living situation. Homeowners insurance is for those who live in the home they own, while renters insurance is for those who lease a property.
In this case, you would need landlord insurance for the property you own (assuming you are renting it out to someone else) and renters insurance for the property you are renting, if that's where you live. If the home you own is vacant, consider vacant home insurance. Each policy covers the specific needs of the respective property and living situation.
Moving can impact your insurance coverage, as you'll need to update your address and coverage details with your insurance providers. Ensure that your homeowners insurance covers your new residence and consider renters insurance if you are moving into a rental property.
About Mark Fitzpatrick
Mark Fitzpatrick is a Licensed Property and Casualty Insurance Producer and MoneyGeek's Head of Insurance. He has analyzed the insurance market for over five years, conducting original research and creating personalized content for every kind of buyer. He has been quoted in several insurance-related publications, including CNBC, NBC News and Mashable.
Fitzpatrick earned a master’s degree in economics and international relations from Johns Hopkins University and a bachelor’s degree from Boston College. He is passionate about using his knowledge of economics and insurance to bring transparency around financial topics and help others feel confident in their money moves.
