Best Homeowners Insurance Companies in New York


New York's Top Home Insurance Companies: Key Takeaways
blueCheck icon

State Farm is the best home insurance provider in New York, earning a 4.8 out of 5 rating from our review team.

blueCheck icon

Main Street America, Chubb, Farmers and Nationwide rank high for homeowners insurance in New York based on affordable rates, strong customer service and reliable coverage.

blueCheck icon

The best insurer for your home depends on your coverage needs, budget and preferred features like claims service or discount availability.

New York homeowners pay rates below the national average. MoneyGeek analyzed premiums, J.D. Power satisfaction scores and coverage options from major insurers to find the best home insurance companies in New York.

What Are the Best Home Insurance Companies in New York?

State Farm is our top pick in New York, with the lowest premiums in the state and above-average customer satisfaction. Main Street America, Chubb, Farmers and Nationwide fill out the rest of the top five. Chubb leads on premium coverage, and Farmers and Nationwide lean on local agents.

State Farm

4.8

$980

Most New York homeowners

Main Street America

4.6

$1,250

Comprehensive add-ons

Chubb

4.5

$2,137

Customer satisfaction

Farmers

4.5

$1,414

Policy customization

Nationwide

4.4

$1,359

Financial stability

*Our ratings consider various combinations of coverage levels, home features and homeowner details to identify the best overall options. Rankings may differ based on your profile.

State Farm

State Farm

MoneyGeek Rating
4.8/ 5
5/5Affordability
4.6/5Customer Experience
4.6/5Coverage
  • J.D. Power Customer Satisfaction Score

    657/1,000
  • Average Annual Premium

    $980
Main Street America Insurance

Main Street America Insurance

MoneyGeek Rating
4.6/ 5
4.8/5Affordability
4.2/5Customer Experience
4.7/5Coverage
  • J.D. Power Customer Satisfaction Score

    N/A
  • Average Annual Premium

    $1,250
Chubb

Chubb

MoneyGeek Rating
4.5/ 5
4.2/5Affordability
5/5Customer Experience
5/5Coverage
  • J.D. Power Customer Satisfaction Score

    677/1,000
  • Average Annual Premium

    $2,137
Farmers

Farmers

MoneyGeek Rating
4.5/ 5
4.6/5Affordability
4.6/5Customer Experience
3.9/5Coverage
  • J.D. Power Customer Satisfaction Score

    631/1,000
  • Average Annual Premium

    $1,414
Nationwide

Nationwide

MoneyGeek Rating
4.4/ 5
4.7/5Affordability
4.5/5Customer Experience
3.1/5Coverage
  • J.D. Power Customer Satisfaction Score

    641/1,000
  • Average Annual Premium

    $1,359

Best New York Home Insurance by City

Main Street America and Farmers tie for market leadership in New York. Main Street America ranks best in Albany, Buffalo, East Meadow and Syracuse. Farmers leads in Brooklyn, La Fayette, Queens Village and Yonkers. State Farm offers the best rates in Cooperstown and Rochester. Chubb provides top coverage in New York City.

AlbanyMain Street America Insurance$824
BrooklynFarmers$1,340
BuffaloMain Street America Insurance$750
CooperstownState Farm$1,024
East MeadowMain Street America Insurance$1,386
La FayetteFarmers$785
New YorkChubb$3,053
Queens VillageFarmers$1,114
RochesterState Farm$930
SyracuseMain Street America Insurance$640
YonkersFarmers$861

Cheapest New York Home Insurance Companies

New York homeowners pay $1,554 a year on average, 55% less than the $3,467 national figure. Within the state, though, prices differ a lot. State Farm is the cheapest at $980 a year, 37% under the state average, according to our look at the state’s most affordable home insurance. Main Street America is next at $1,250, 20% below average. At the other end, Allstate charges 36% more than the national average, so compare quotes before you buy.

Cheapest Home Insurers in New York Chart

Guide to Finding the Best New York Home Insurance Company

Picking home insurance in New York comes down to three questions: what you can afford, what coverage you need and how much service you expect. Get quotes from several insurers and weigh each one against those three.

  • insurance2 icon

    Compare Quotes Strategically

    Collect quotes from three to five insurers. Top New York providers charge anywhere from $980 to $2,137 a year. Don’t let price make the decision for you. A rock-bottom policy can hide gaps you find only when you file a claim after a storm or another covered loss.

  • find icon

    Check Customer Satisfaction Metrics

    Check complaint rankings at the New York State Department of Financial Services, then compare J.D. Power scores. Top New York providers run from 631 to 677, and the industry average is 642. Pay the most attention to recent reviews about how insurers handled claims after storms, since those show you what happens when something goes wrong.

  • house2 icon

    Evaluate Coverage Needs

    Set your coverage by what it would cost to rebuild, not by what your home would sell for. Building costs in New York jump after floods and hurricanes, so ask your insurer about extended replacement cost. Then see what your wind and hail deductible would cost you, and decide whether you need flood insurance.

  • checkList icon

    Match Service Preferences to Provider Strengths

    If you’d rather handle everything on your phone, look at Lemonade, Hippo and Root. If you want to sit down with a person, State Farm, Allstate and Farmers have local agents. Choose the style that fits you, and you won’t pay for service you skip.

newYork icon
NEW YORK HOME INSURANCE RISKS

Floods cost New York more than $1 billion in 2021, according to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, which makes flooding a major threat to homes across the state. Your homeowners policy covers plenty of damage, but not flood. For that, you need a separate flood policy. Your homeowners policy may also set a named-storm deductible at 1% to 5% of your home’s insured value, and it has to spell that out.

Compare Home Insurance Rates

Get the best rate for your insurance. Compare quotes from the top insurance companies.

Top-Rated Home Insurance Companies in New York: FAQ

Not sure how to pick a New York home insurer? The FAQ below answers the questions readers ask most.

Our Methodology: Determining the Best New York Home Insurers

New York homeowners deal with tornado risks, hurricane exposure and fluctuating construction costs. Our ranking system weighs affordable premiums, quality coverage and reliable claims handling.

We scored insurers across three factors:

Affordability (55%): We compared rates for identical coverage across major providers and evaluated discount availability.

Customer satisfaction (30%): J.D. Power ratings, Trustpilot reviews and app feedback reveal how insurers handle claims after storms damage your home. 

Coverage options (15%): We assessed add-on availability, including water backup protection and inland flood options for New York's risks.

Our Sample Profile

Rates reflect a homeowner aged 41-60 with good credit and no prior claims insuring a 2,500-square-foot home built in 2000. Coverage includes $250,000 dwelling coverage, $125,000 personal property coverage, $200,000 personal liability coverage and a $1,000 deductible.

Your rates will vary based on your home's age, location, claims history and credit score.

About Mark Fitzpatrick


Mark Fitzpatrick, Licensed P&C Insurance Expert, MoneyGeek

Mark Fitzpatrick is a licensed Property and Casualty (P&C) Insurance Producer and MoneyGeek's resident expert in insurance and economics. In nearly a decade covering the insurance market at LendingTree and MoneyGeek, he's analyzed hundreds of carriers and millions of rates across auto, home, renters, health and life insurance.

His work has appeared in The Washington Post, The New York Times and NPR. He draws on independent cost and consumer experience data, and no insurance company partnerships affect his recommendations.

Mark studied at Boston College and later earned a master's in economics and international relations from Johns Hopkins University. He worked in financial risk management at State Street before joining MoneyGeek. He's also a five-time “Jeopardy!” champion.


Sources