The Hartford has the lowest average general liability rate in New Jersey at $132 a month, 17% below the $160 state average. ERGO NEXT is $5 behind at $137, followed by Thimble at $147, biBERK at $148 and Simply Business at $158. These averages are for a New Jersey business with one to four employees and limits of $1 million per occurrence and $2 million aggregate.
The Hartford also has the lowest rate for more New Jersey business types than any other insurer, though ERGO NEXT isn’t far behind. Of the 403 business types I analyzed, The Hartford has the lowest rate for 144, ERGO NEXT for 115, biBERK for 89 and Thimble for 17. Here’s where each one tends to come in lowest:
- The Hartford: Office-based professional, creative and healthcare businesses, including photographers ($28 a month), financial advisors ($56) and dental practices ($257)
- ERGO NEXT: Food, beauty and hands-on trade businesses, including estheticians ($35 a month), pizza restaurants ($100) and HVAC contractors ($370)
- biBERK: Every cleaning and fitness business type I analyzed, including yoga studios ($31 a month), house cleaners ($125) and gyms ($127)
- Thimble: Construction trades, including land surveyors ($155 a month), electrical contractors ($367) and general contractors ($379), each 32% to 35% below the average for their trade
Your general liability premium also depends on your headcount, claims history and the limits you choose. Since the cheapest insurer changes from one business type to the next, get quotes from the insurers that are cheapest for your trade, using the same limits on each quote.








