Finding the right auto insurance in Broken Arrow, OK, depends on your needs and preferences. State Farm is the most affordable insurer for full coverage and those with at-fault accidents, speeding tickets or DUIs.
Allstate is the cheapest option for teens on family policies, and Shelter is the top choice for quality service.
Cheapest and Best Car Insurance in Broken Arrow








Cheapest Minimum Liability Car Insurance in Broken Arrow
The following companies offer the cheapest minimum coverage auto insurance in Broken Arrow:
- State Farm: $299 per year
- Progressive: $299 per year
Home State Insurance Group is the most expensive auto insurer in Broken Arrow, with an annual cost of $647. Conversely, State Farm is Oklahoma’s least expensive car insurance provider, averaging $233 annually. This makes Broken Arrow's auto insurance more expensive than the Oklahoma average.
In Oklahoma, state law dictates the liability limits for minimum coverage insurance. It includes bodily injury and personal property damage at 25/50/25, or:
- $25,000 bodily injury liability per person
- $50,000 bodily injury liability per accident
- $25,000 property damage liability per accident
This insurance only covers damages to others. Any injuries to you, your passengers or your vehicle aren't covered.
In Oklahoma, if you're found at fault in an accident and have minimum coverage, your insurance company covers medical costs for each person in the other vehicle up to $25,000. The total maxes out at $50,000 per accident. Anything beyond this comes out of your pocket.
Cheapest Full Coverage Car Insurance in Broken Arrow
The cheapest full coverage auto insurance in Broken Arrow are
- State Farm: $700 per year
- Mercury: $835 per year
According to MoneyGeek's data, Home State Insurance Group is the priciest provider of full-coverage car insurance in Broken Arrow, averaging $1,478 per year. State Farm has the cheapest full coverage car insurance in Oklahoma, at $718 per year. Since State Farm’s cost in Broken Arrow is even lower than the state average, the city may be among the more affordable places for car insurance in the state.
Full coverage auto insurance increases your liability coverage and adds comprehensive and collision coverage to your policy.
- Collision Insurance: Pays for damage to your vehicle after a collision, regardless of who is at fault
- Comprehensive Insurance: Covers damage to your car from non-collision incidents, like a storm, fire or vandalism
Comprehensive and collision coverage may not be worth the cost for older vehicles, as the insurance costs may outweigh how much the car is worth.
Cheapest Car Insurance in Broken Arrow After a Driving Offense
MoneyGeek's analysis found the following companies are the cheapest auto insurers for drivers with traffic infractions in Broken Arrow:
- Speeding ticket: State Farm ($782 per year)
- At-fault accident: State Farm ($846 per year)
- DUI: State Farm ($782 per year)
If you're cited for a speeding ticket, accident or DUI, you can expect to pay the highest yearly premiums with Shelter ($1,743 for a ticket or $2,258 for an accident) and Oklahoma Farm Bureau ($2,159 for a DUI). Even the most competitive rates may be significantly higher after an offense compared to drivers with clean records.
The cost of auto insurance in Broken Arrow can vary depending on the infraction. For example, State Farm, the cheapest insurer for drivers with less-than-stellar records, charges an average of $846 per year to insure drivers with at-fault accidents and $782 per year for those with DUIs or speeding tickets.
Although premiums are higher for drivers with a bad record, there are still affordable insurance companies available.
Cheapest Car Insurance in Broken Arrow for Teens and Their Families
The most affordable insurers for teens on family policies are:
- Allstate: $2,145 per year for male teens; $2,021 per year for female teens
- Progressive: $2,296 per year for male teens
- State Farm: $2,059 per year for female teens
Farmers is the most expensive insurer for Broken Arrow teens, charging $2,975 for male teens and $2,808 for female teens per year.
16-year-old male drivers in Broken Arrow typically pay more for auto insurance than their female counterparts. With Allstate, the difference is $124. This gap closes by early adulthood.
Adding a teen to their family’s coverage is generally cheaper than getting them a separate policy.
A 16-year-old male or female teen with an individual premium will pay at least $4,000 more than on a family plan. For teens looking for the cheapest car insurance, shopping around for several rates and taking advantage of discounts can help save money.
Cheapest Car Insurance in Broken Arrow for Military Drivers
Our analysis found the following companies to be the cheapest auto insurers for active or veteran military and their families in Broken Arrow:
- USAA: $602 per year
- State Farm: $700 per year
The above rates are for full coverage policies. USAA also ranks first for minimum coverage at $219 per year, while State Farm is second at $299 annually.
How to Compare Cheap Broken Arrow Car Insurance Quotes Online
Getting car insurance quotes in Broken Arrow, OK, can take up to 15 minutes or more per quote. You may also have to provide a ton of very personal information to each provider.
MoneyGeek's car insurance calculator can help make the process easier and quicker. With just your age, vehicle type, coverage level and driving record, you can get an estimate of your car insurance costs immediately.
Auto Insurance Calculator
See how the Average Annual Auto Insurance Rates vary with the options chosen.
Average Annual Auto Insurance Rates
Click the section of the wheel in your price range to see options.
low end
on average
high end
Click an insurer below to visit their review page or continue to your personalized quote.
Best Car Insurance in Broken Arrow: Summary
The best car insurance for you depends on your needs and background. The best car insurance companies in Broken Arrow, OK, are:
- Best overall: State Farm (MoneyGeek score 76 out of 100)
- Best for service: Shelter (MoneyGeek score 68 out of 100)
- Best cheap insurance: State Farm (MoneyGeek score 78 out of 100)
The overall MoneyGeek score may vary based on the weighting of factors in each category.
USAA is technically Broken Arrow's highest-ranked car insurance company, with a MoneyGeek score of 85 out of 100. However, since it's only available to military members and their families, we excluded it from our general list.
Best Overall Car Insurance in Broken Arrow
The best companies for car insurance in Broken Arrow are:
- State Farm: MoneyGeek score 76 out of 100 ($700 per year)
- GEICO: MoneyGeek score 68 out of 100 ($892 per year)
State Farm and GEICO emerged as the winners among the nine insurance providers we examined, with excellent customer satisfaction and affordability ratings.
USAA is the top insurer for military personnel and their families, with 85 out of 100 MoneyGeek ratings. MoneyGeek's USAA auto insurance review provides further information on the provider's activities.
How was this MoneyGeek score calculated?

pros
#1 in affordability
#3 in customer satisfaction
Roadside assistance coverage available
Offers rideshare insurance and rental car or travel reimbursement
cons
Limited coverage choices
Below-average claims management cost
COMPANY HIGHLIGHTS
In Broken Arrow, State Farm can be an excellent option for auto insurance. It provides affordable premiums, excellent customer service and a variety of discounts. Because of this, its MoneyGeek score is the highest in the city.
At $700 annually, it's the third-cheapest auto insurance provider in Broken Arrow. State Farm offers roadside assistance add-on coverage for $9 per year. This helps policyholders in case of a breakdown with towing, mechanical labor, items delivery (battery, fuel, tire and oil) and locksmith labor for up to one hour.
State Farm also offers discounts, including a multi-car discount for insuring multiple cars, an anti-theft discount for having a safety device in your car and a safe driving discount for being insured by State Farm for three years without a violation.
Best Car Insurance in Broken Arrow for Customer Service
These companies balance affordability and customer service in Broken Arrow:
- Shelter: MoneyGeek score 68 out of 100 ($1,267 per year)
- State Farm: MoneyGeek score 58 out of 100 ($700 per year)
Shelter is the top-rated company for customer satisfaction and claims processing, boasting superior service over nine other insurers. Unfortunately, its premiums are comparatively high.
How as this MoneyGeek score calculated?

pros
Offers new car replacement coverage
Offers gap insurance
#1 for claims management
#2 for customer satisfaction
cons
Below-average affordability score
Lacks accident forgiveness coverage
Lacks Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) coverage
COMPANY HIGHLIGHTS
Drawing on J.D. Power and the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) customer complaint index, we found that Shelter offers excellent services and efficient claims management.
The company also offers new car replacement coverage for cars bought within the last year and with fewer than 15,000 miles on the odometer. If you’re in an accident and your car is totaled, Shelter replaces the car with a new one of the same year, make and model. Additionally, it offers gap insurance to cover the difference between a totaled vehicle payout and a loan amount still owed on a car loan.
Best Cheap Car Insurance Companies in Broken Arrow
In Broken Arrow, the top companies offer excellent service and affordable pricing. You need to look at minimum coverage insurance to get the most affordable pricing. Our top picks are.
- State Farm: MoneyGeek score 78 out of 100 ($299 per year)
- Progressive: MoneyGeek score 78 out of 100 ($299 per year)
The cheapest Broken Arrow minimum coverage insurance plans may be the cheapest — but you get what you pay for. These plans provide limited liability coverage, so if you're at fault in an accident, the insurance pays for very little and, even then, only for the other vehicle's occupants. It won't pay for your expenses.
How was this MoneyGeek score calculated?

pros
Offers roadside assistance coverage
#1 in affordability
#3 in customer satisfaction
cons
Below average claims management score
Lacks unique coverages
COMPANY HIGHLIGHTS
State Farm ranks #1 for affordability and #3 for customer satisfaction. The company stands out among its competitors by offering low premiums and a range of discounts. From discounts on factory-installed daytime running lights (DRLs) to those for good driving records, young drivers who maintain good grades and those who take defensive driving courses, State Farm's discounts can make it an affordable choice.
Average Cost of Car Insurance in Broken Arrow
MoneyGeek's analysis showed that, on average, Broken Arrow residents pay $1,033 annually for full coverage car insurance.
This is $6 lower than the state's average of $1,040 and $225 less than the national average of $1,265 as of October 2022. This policy covers up to $100,000 in bodily injury liability per person, $300,000 for bodily injury liability per accident and $100,000 for property damage liability per accident. Broken Arrow's lower population density, fewer car accident claims and reduced crime rate contribute to the lower cost of car insurance.
About Mark Fitzpatrick
