The best renters insurance companies in Massachusetts are Amica, The Andover Companies and Lemonade. Two of the three are New England mutuals (Amica in Rhode Island, The Andover Companies in Massachusetts), with Lemonade the only mobile-first option. Amica edges the group on customer experience while pricing within $4 of the state's cheapest option.
We scored 11 Massachusetts providers on the same $20,000 policy for good-credit renters, and these three scored highest.










