Best and Cheapest Renters Insurance in Massachusetts 2026


Key Takeaways: Massachusetts Renters Insurance
blueCheck icon

Massachusetts renters pay $177 a year on average, $5 below the US figure, with eight of 11 providers below the state average.

blueCheck icon

The top three on our MoneyGeek scoring are Amica, The Andover Companies and Lemonade, while Safety Insurance leads on price alone.

blueCheck icon

The cheapest carrier changes depending on your coverage level, credit profile and city, so pulling two or three quotes is worth the time.

Compare Insurance Rates

Ensure you are getting the best rate for your insurance. Compare quotes from the top insurance companies.

Top 3 Cheapest Renters Insurance Companies in Massachusetts

Provider
MoneyGeek Score (out of 5)
Average Monthly Premium
Average Annual Premium

4.9

$12

$141

The Andover Companies

4.8

$12

$146

4.8

$12

$144

The best renters insurance companies in Massachusetts are Amica, The Andover Companies and Lemonade. Two of the three are New England mutuals (Amica in Rhode Island, The Andover Companies in Massachusetts), with Lemonade the only mobile-first option. Amica edges the group on customer experience while pricing within $4 of the state's cheapest option.

We scored 11 Massachusetts providers on the same $20,000 policy for good-credit renters, and these three scored highest.

Our ratings consider combinations of coverage levels and renter details, weighing affordability at 50%, customer experience at 40% and add-on coverage options at 10%. Rankings may differ by profile.

Our base profile is adult renters aged 26 to 64 with good credit, no claims in the past five years, carrying $20,000 in personal property and $100,000 in liability with a $500 deductible, replacement cost included, for an apartment or condo.

Amica leads on service, scoring a perfect 5.0 on customer experience against Safety Insurance’s 4.2. The $4 annual premium over Safety’s $137 rate buys you Amica’s claims handling, five optional endorsements and a $100-a-year credit toward a future Amica homeowners policy (up to $500 if you buy within five years).

The Andover Companies, at $146 a year, pairs agent-only sales with the widest add-on roster in the top three, making it the pick for renters who want to customize coverage around pet liability, water backup or scheduled electronics. Lemonade comes in at $144 and takes the opposite path: replacement cost is included in the standard policy rather than as a paid add-on, which makes it the cheapest option at $250,000 in personal property and for anyone rebuilding credit.

Read more to learn about our renters insurance methodology.

Compare the Top 3 Massachusetts Renters Insurance Providers

Amica

Amica

Best for Massachusetts Renters

MoneyGeek Rating
4.9/ 5
5/5Affordability
5/5Customer Experience
4.4/5Coverage
  • J.D. Power Renters Insurance Customer Satisfaction Score

    689/1,000
  • Average Annual Premium

    $141
  • Average Monthly Premium

    $12
The Andover

The Andover

MoneyGeek Rating
4.8/ 5
4.9/5Affordability
4.6/5Customer Experience
5/5Coverage
  • J.D. Power Renters Insurance Customer Satisfaction Score

    Not rated
  • Average Annual Premium

    $146
  • Average Monthly Premium

    $12
Lemonade

Lemonade

MoneyGeek Rating
4.8/ 5
4.9/5Affordability
4.6/5Customer Experience
4.6/5Coverage
  • J.D. Power Renters Insurance Customer Satisfaction Score

    674/1,000
  • Average Annual Premium

    $144
  • Average Monthly Premium

    $12

Who Has the Cheapest Renters Insurance in Massachusetts?

Safety Insurance ranks as the cheapest Massachusetts renters insurer at $137 a year, about $11 a month and $45 below the national average. The five cheapest providers sit within $9 of each other, so your pick comes down less to sticker price than to what each one adds: Amica leads on service, Lemonade pays replacement cost without an add-on and The Andover Companies carries the widest list of endorsements.

That matters because 52% of Massachusetts renters put 30% or more of their income toward housing, nearly double the 27% owner share, with the tightest squeeze on Cape Cod (60%) and in Boston (51%). Even small renters insurance savings add up: dropping from Chubb’s $281 to Safety’s $137 keeps $144 a year in your pocket.

Provider
Average Monthly Premium
Average Annual Premium
Annual Difference From State Average

Safety Insurance

$11

$137

-$40

Vermont Mutual Insurance

$12

$140

-$37

Amica

$12

$141

-$35

Lemonade

$12

$144

-$33

The Andover Companies

$12

$146

-$31

Pull three quotes before you commit, one from each distribution model: Safety at $137 or Amica at $141 for a traditional carrier, Lemonade at $144 for the app-first route, and The Andover Companies at $146 or Arbella at $152 through a local agent. The $15 spread across those four is small enough that fine print, not sticker price, will decide which policy actually costs you less over a year. Ask every carrier the same three questions: Is replacement cost included or extra? Is off-premises property capped at $1,000? Is my dog’s breed excluded from liability coverage?

Massachusetts Renters Insurance Rates by City

Where you rent matters more than which carrier you choose. City averages range from $146 in Groton to $217 in Dennis Port, a $71 gap for the same coverage. Lemonade is cheapest in four cities, including Woburn and Groton at $95 a year. Vermont Mutual wins the Boston-area suburbs (Cambridge, Lowell, Worcester) and The Andover Companies leads Dennis Port on Cape Cod at $110.

City
Cheapest Annual Provider
Second Cheapest Annual Provider
Annual City Average

Dennis Port

The Andover Companies, $110

Safety Insurance, $123

$217

Roxbury Crossing

Lemonade, $131

Vermont Mutual Insurance, $153

$202

Dorchester

Lemonade, $131

Vermont Mutual Insurance, $153

$200

Springfield

Amica, $130

Safety Insurance, $144

$199

Worcester

Vermont Mutual Insurance, $119

Lemonade, $126

$169

Geography drives most of the $71 gap between Groton ($146) and Dennis Port ($217). The same carriers quote $95 in Groton and $110 to $130 in Dennis Port for identical coverage. If you move within Massachusetts, pull fresh quotes instead of porting your policy.

If you rent on the coast, add flood coverage. Standard renters policies exclude it, including damage like the January 2024 nor’easter that hit 20-plus Salisbury homes and cut power for 225,000 households. Federal NFIP covers up to $100,000 with a 30-day wait; Plymouth Rock’s Neptune Flood partnership binds faster.

Cheapest Renters Insurance in Massachusetts by Coverage Level

Annual premiums range from $137 at the base $20,000 limit to $918 at $250,000. Safety Insurance wins at $20,000, Amica takes over at $50,000 ($229) and $100,000 ($366), and Lemonade leads at $250,000.

Coverage Level
Annual Cheapest Provider
Second Cheapest Annual Provider
Annual State Average

$20,000

Safety Insurance, $137

Vermont Mutual Insurance, $140

$177

$50,000

Amica, $229

Vermont Mutual Insurance, $286

$353

$100,000

Amica, $366

Vermont Mutual Insurance, $480

$643

$250,000

Lemonade, $918

Travelers, $1,140

$1,300

The cheapest provider changes with your coverage amount because carriers scale rates differently. Safety has the lowest flat rate, so it wins at the $20,000 base. Amica’s rate climbs more slowly than Vermont Mutual’s, so it takes over once you cross $50,000. And at $250,000, Lemonade pulls ahead because its base policy already includes replacement cost, while Amica and Safety tack on a surcharge for the same coverage.

Most Massachusetts renters fit one of two profiles. If you’re furnishing a one-bedroom with electronics, a bike, furniture and a wardrobe, your belongings likely total $35,000 to $45,000, which puts you in Amica territory. Price its $229 at $50,000 against its $366 at $100,000 and take the extra cushion if you’re in Cambridge or Back Bay, where replacement costs run high. If you’re closer to $20,000 in belongings in Lowell or Springfield, Safety at $137 covers you without overpaying.

Cheapest Renters Insurance in Massachusetts by Credit Score

Massachusetts allows renters insurance providers to use credit information in pricing, unlike auto insurance where it’s banned. Poor credit can raise your premium by as much as $617 a year: Travelers jumps from $278 to $895, while Lemonade’s $34 penalty is the smallest in our data.

Coverage Level
Good Annual Credit
Poor Annual Credit
Poor Credit Increase

Lemonade

$144

$178

+$34

Amica

$141

$180

+$38

Safety Insurance

$137

$239

+$102

The Andover Companies

$146

$255

+$109

Arbella

$152

$265

+$113

At poor credit, Travelers ($895) costs five times what Lemonade ($178) does for the same coverage. If your credit has slipped recently, pull a standalone renters quote before renewing a bundled policy. Even moving from poor to fair credit can shift you into a lower-penalty tier at your next renewal.

How to Find the Best Cheap Renters Insurance in Massachusetts

The cheapest Massachusetts renters policy depends less on your zip code than on two things: whether the insurer includes replacement cost in the base policy and how steeply its rate climbs if your credit isn’t perfect.

  1. 1
    Compare quotes from at least three companies.

    Get one from a mobile-first carrier like Lemonade, one from an agent-only regional like The Andover Companies, and one from a hybrid like Plymouth Rock. Massachusetts prices for identical coverage run from $137 at Safety to $281 at Chubb, so pulling across distribution models shows you the full spread.

  2. 2
    Check complaint rates before signing.

    Amica has one of the lowest NAIC complaint ratios MoneyGeek tracks in Massachusetts. Lemonade’s complaint ratio runs well above the 1.0 industry baseline, meaning more Lemonade customers file complaints relative to the company’s size than the industry average. If a cheaper carrier has a high complaint ratio, factor that into whether the savings are worth it.

  3. 3
    Bundle renters and auto insurance.

    Amica knocks up to 15% off for renters who hold Amica auto. The Andover Companies sells through independent agents who can bundle its renters policy with an auto policy from another carrier they represent. Lemonade bundles only with pet and life, not auto, so skip this step if you’re shopping Lemonade.

  4. 4
    Ask about available discounts.

    Amica renters earn $100 a year toward a future Amica homeowners policy, up to $500 total. Most Massachusetts carriers also offer discounts for autopay, protective devices like smoke and burglar alarms, and paperless billing, each usually worth 2% to 5%.

mglogo icon
SWITCH CARRIERS BEFORE YOU RAISE YOUR DEDUCTIBLE

Raising your deductible from $500 to $1,000 saves about $14 a year, and going to $2,000 saves $28. The math doesn’t favor it: you’d need 35 years of savings to make back the extra $500 you’d pay on a single claim. Switching carriers moves your premium much more. Chubb to Amica saves $140 a year for identical coverage, about ten years’ worth of deductible savings in one shopping trip.

Compare Renters Insurance Rates

Get the best rate for your coverage needs. Compare quotes from top insurance companies.

Bottom Line

Amica is the best renters insurance company in Massachusetts at $141 a year, pairing the state’s highest MoneyGeek score with a perfect 5.0 customer experience rating. Safety Insurance wins on price alone at $137, and Lemonade is the smarter pick if you have poor credit or need more than $100,000 in coverage. Run quotes from all three before you commit.

Renters Insurance Rates by State, Coverage and Replacement Cost

A profile of 21- to 64-year-old renters with no prior claims and good credit.

Select Coverage Level
Select Deductible
Select Credit Alignment
Average Annual Premium—

Massachusetts Renters Insurance Coverage: FAQ

About Mark Fitzpatrick


Mark Fitzpatrick, Licensed P&C Insurance Expert, MoneyGeek

Mark Fitzpatrick is a licensed Property and Casualty (P&C) Insurance Producer and MoneyGeek's resident expert in insurance and economics. In nearly a decade covering the insurance market at LendingTree and MoneyGeek, he's analyzed hundreds of carriers and millions of rates across auto, home, renters, health and life insurance.

His work has appeared in The Washington Post, The New York Times and NPR. He draws on independent cost and consumer experience data, and no insurance company partnerships affect his recommendations.

Mark studied at Boston College and later earned a master's in economics and international relations from Johns Hopkins University. He worked in financial risk management at State Street before joining MoneyGeek. He's also a five-time “Jeopardy!” champion.


Sources