The Best and Cheapest Renters Insurance Companies in Indiana for 2024: Rankings, Reviews and Rates

CheapRenters InsuranceIndiana

2024

The Cheapest Renters Insurance in Indiana

Cheapest - Nationwide

Best overall - State Farm

Most popular in Indiana - State Farm

Cost can be the most important factor when choosing renters insurance. On average, the best cheap renters insurance in Indiana is provided by USAA, Nationwide and State Farm.

A policy with USAA costs an average of $84 per year or $7 per month for a typical renter. However, USAA policies are only offered to military members, veterans and their eligible family members.

If you don’t meet USAA’s eligibility requirements, renters insurance policies in Indiana with Nationwide and State Farm cost an average of $119 annually or about $10 per month.

The average premiums for renters insurance are determined by quotes from different ZIP codes for a policy that includes $20,000 worth of personal property coverage, liability coverage worth $100,000 and a $500 deductible.

Personal Property Coverage:

$20,000

Scroll for more

MoneyGeek ranked the best renters insurance companies in Indiana using a comprehensive scoring system that incorporates J.D. Power customer satisfaction ratings, AM Best financial stability scores and quotes for affordability.

Companies With the Cheapest Renters Insurance in Indiana by City

Scroll for more

City

Cheapest Company

Average Annual Premium

Fort Wayne, IN

Nationwide

$113

Indianapolis, IN

State Farm

$122

Expand All Rankings +

1

USAA

Score:100

-

COMPARE QUOTES

by MoneyGeek

5/5

Affordability

5/5

User Satisfaction

5/5

Financial Stability

Geek Quick Take

USAA is the best renters insurance company in Indiana, with perfect scores in all categories. Although it is available in all states, only tenants with a military background and their eligible family members can qualify for USAA policies. This provider offers policyholders affordable and comprehensive coverage, including unique coverages like identity theft.

More About USAA

USAA offers four discounts and seven add-on coverages, including identity theft coverage if your identity is stolen online and fraudulently used. You can also get coverage to compensate you if your personal property is damaged or lost while being moved or stored.

USAA has a convenient and easy-to-use online platform where you can get a personalized quote or manage your account. As a policyholder, you can also access your account on-the-go with the USAA mobile app.

2

State Farm

Score:94

-

COMPARE QUOTES

by MoneyGeek

4.6/5

Affordability

4.8/5

User Satisfaction

5/5

Financial Stability

Geek Quick Take

State Farm is the best insurer for most tenants looking for renters insurance in Indiana. State Farm received a perfect score on stability in addition to providing a satisfactory customer experience. Personal injury liability is this company’s most unique add-on coverage for renters insurance.

More About State Farm

State Farm is available in all 50 states and Washington, D.C., and offers policyholders three different optional coverages to customize their renters insurance. Personal injury coverage protects you from libel or slander, whereas identity theft coverage will help if you’re a victim of identity fraud. State Farm also sells business property coverage as a separate policy that can be bundled with your renters insurance to protect your business.

State Farm has convenient online account management tools and a mobile app that make it easy to request personalized quotes, file claims and make payments.

3

Nationwide

Score:92

+

COMPARE QUOTES

by MoneyGeek

4.6/5

Affordability

4.7/5

User Satisfaction

4.5/5

Financial Stability

Geek Quick Take

Nationwide tied State Farm in affordability and ranked third in customer satisfaction among insurers in Indiana, earning a MoneyGeek score of 92 out of 100. Nationwide beats the national coverage average of seven, offering up to 11 included and optional coverages to ensure comprehensive protection.

More About Nationwide

Including Indiana, Nationwide renters insurance is available in 43 states. Nationwide renters insurance comes with unique coverage add-ons, including theft extension coverage for personal property stored in your vehicle or watercraft. You can also opt for scheduled personal property coverage if you have high-value items like jewelry and antiques that you want your renters insurance to protect.

Nationwide has four discount options to make your policy even more affordable. For instance, you may qualify for protective device discounts if you have safety devices installed in your home. Nationwide also has a mobile app where policyholders can file claims, manage their accounts and make payments online, and an online portal where interested individuals can request a personalized quote.

4

Allstate

Score:91

+

COMPARE QUOTES

by MoneyGeek

4.5/5

Affordability

4.6/5

User Satisfaction

4.5/5

Financial Stability

Geek Quick Take

Allstate ranked third in Indiana with a MoneyGeek score of 91. It also received high financial stability, affordability and customer satisfaction scores. Allstate’s renters insurance is available in all 50 states and the District of Columbia. and includes unique optional coverages such as personal injury liability.

More About Allstate

Allstate offers four coverage add-ons, fewer than the national average of seven. For example, you can get protection against large liability claims by opting for personal injury coverage. If you have antiques or jewelry, Allstate offers scheduled personal property coverage for appraised high-value items. Renters can also get flood insurance if they want protection from losses or damage to personal property caused by flooding.

Allstate has five different discount options, including retiree discounts for policyholders aged 55 years or older. You can also get a discount for setting up automatic payments. It's easy to get a personalized quote through Allstate’s website, or to conveniently manage your account online or with its mobile application.

5

American Family Insurance

Score:87

+

COMPARE QUOTES

by MoneyGeek

4.3/5

Affordability

4.7/5

User Satisfaction

4/5

Financial Stability

Geek Quick Take

American Family scores high in customer satisfaction and financial stability. Indiana is one of the 19 states where American Family offers renters insurance. You can customize your renters insurance coverage with optional add-ons like pet damage liability coverage.

More About American Family Insurance

If you have a pet, pet damage liability coverage will protect you if your pet injures someone on your property. American Family also offers scheduled property coverage for high-value items like jewelry or antiques. To make policies even more affordable, American Family offers seven discount opportunities, including generational discounts if American Family covers your parents. There are also loyalty and autopay discounts. You can easily file claims, make payments and manage your account using American Family’s mobile app or website.

MONEYGEEK EXPERT TIP

Cost shouldn’t be the only factor when looking for the best renters insurance in Indiana. Policies with more comprehensive coverage may cost more but they offer better protection, saving you money if your personal property gets lost or damaged. Cheaper policies may expose you to more risks since they may not provide sufficient coverage.

It pays to look at the insurer’s market share when choosing the best company for renters insurance. Companies with a larger market share will typically have more financial stability, meaning they’re more likely to promptly and fairly handle your claims.

Personal Property Coverage Calculator

When figuring out how much renters insurance you need, experts recommend the standard $100,000 in liability insurance and enough personal property protection to cover your possessions. Use MoneyGeek's calculator to estimate the value of your possessions so you know how much personal property coverage to buy.

clothing & accessories

Clothes, shoes, bags, belts, hats, gloves, etc.

Pants

$

Shirts

$

Outerwear

$

Shoes

$

Accessories

$

Other

$

Total clothing & accessories: $0

Skip

Next

MONEYGEEK EXPERT TIP

If you’re looking for affordable policies, you can save money by comparing renters insurance quotes from different providers in Indiana. For example, you could save up to $168 per year by choosing USAA, the cheapest option, over the most expensive company, Travelers. If you don’t qualify for a USAA policy, choosing Nationwide or State Farm could save you $133 per year on average.

Several factors, including the coverage level you want and where you live, can impact how much you pay for renters insurance. When shopping for renters insurance in Indiana, keep the following criteria in mind.

Renters insurance provides you with a way to protect your assets after a disaster or unexpected event. It can come in handy when dealing with theft, fire or severe weather conditions.

In Indiana, 27.6% of the population are renters. The average monthly rent price of $840. For a standard renters insurance policy that includes $20,000 in personal property coverage, $100,000 liability coverage and a $500 deductible, the average monthly premium is $13. This is roughly 1.52% of the price of rent.

Before purchasing renters insurance in Indiana, you should research what is covered and what is not. Most plans provide coverage for personal property, liability insurance, medical payments and additional living expenses. Some options may offer additional coverage like identity theft protection.

Personal property coverage in Indiana usually protects against theft and damages caused by natural events like tornadoes and wildfires.

All policies are different, so you should read the fine print to understand your plan. Talk to your agent and ask the right questions if you need clarification. Doing this can be the difference between a claim getting denied or approved.

While most emergencies are covered if you have renters insurance in Indiana, certain situations may not qualify for protection. Here are a few issues not typically covered by your renters insurance.

MONEYGEEK EXPERT TIP

The Indiana Department of Insurance has useful resources when you need more information about renters insurance in Indiana. You can contact them with general inquiries, questions or complaints about your renters insurance using any of these channels:

• Online Complaint Form
• Call: 1- 800-457-8283
• Mail: IDOI; Attn: Consumer Services Division, 311 W. Washington St., Suite 300, Indianapolis, IN 46204-2787
• Fax: 1-317-234-2103

Auto Insurance

---

Car Insurance Guide for the Savvy Consumer

Auto Insurance

---

What Is a Car Insurance Deductible and How Does It Work?

You can find more information about renters insurance costs and best providers in Indiana in the answers to these commonly asked questions.

About Mark Fitzpatrick

---

Mark Fitzpatrick has analyzed the property and casualty insurance market for over five years, conducting original research and creating personalized content for every kind of buyer. Currently, he leads P&C insurance content production at MoneyGeek. Fitzpatrick has been quoted in several insurance-related publications, including CNBC, NBC News and Mashable.

Fitzpatrick earned a master’s degree in economics and international relations from Johns Hopkins University and a bachelor’s degree from Boston College. He is passionate about using his knowledge of economics and insurance to bring transparency around financial topics and help others feel confident in their money moves.

Read Full Bio »

---