Best Renters Insurance in Arizona (2026)


Key Takeaways: Arizona Renters Insurance
blueCheck icon

Lemonade is Arizona's top-scoring and cheapest renters insurer, while State Farm takes over as the cheapest once coverage limits climb.

blueCheck icon

Credit history and coverage limits reshuffle the ranking, so the lowest price for one renter profile is rarely the lowest for another.

blueCheck icon

Arizona rates shift from city to city, but none of them include flood protection, which standard renters policies exclude and a separate flood policy covers.

5 Best Renters Insurance Companies in Arizona

Arizona's five highest-scoring providers earn strong MoneyGeek scores that sit within 0.2 points of each other, yet their prices are $135 apart, from Lemonade at $90 a year to State Farm at $224. Lemonade finishes first in our ranking of the best renters insurance companies as the cheapest of 12 providers, even though Auto-Owners beats it on customer experience.

We scored 12 Arizona providers on the same $20,000 policy for good-credit renters, and these five scored highest.

4.8
$7
$90
4.7
$19
$224
4.7
$16
$196
4.6
$17
$205
4.6
$15
$174

Our ratings consider combinations of coverage levels and renter details. Affordability makes up 50% of each score, customer experience 40% and add-on coverage options 10%. Rankings may differ for other renter profiles.

Rates shown are for renters aged 26 to 64 with good credit and no claims in the past five years, living in an apartment or condo, with $20,000 in personal property coverage, $100,000 in liability coverage, replacement cost included and a $500 deductible. Read our full methodology for more information.

Lemonade leads because it is the cheapest of the 12 at $90 and still earns a 4.4 coverage options score, the highest among the five. Auto-Owners tops it on service with a perfect 5.0 customer experience score, but its $196 premium runs $107 above Lemonade's and its 2.8 coverage options score is the lowest of the group.

State Farm costs $135 more than Lemonade, and that buys a 4.9 customer experience score plus the top rating in the 2026 J.D. Power renters study: its 702 sits 28 points above Lemonade's 674 and 20 above the 682 study average, so State Farm's policyholders report higher satisfaction than customers of any other ranked provider. American Family at $205 and Nationwide at $174 fall between the two on price, and each scores 4.6 overall.

Compare the Top 5 Arizona Renters Insurance Providers

Lemonade

Lemonade

Best Overall and Cheapest

MoneyGeek Rating
4.8/ 5
5/5Affordability
4.6/5Customer Experience
4.4/5Coverage
  • Average Annual Premium

    $90
  • Average Monthly Premium

    $7
  • J.D. Power Renters Insurance Customer Satisfaction Score

    674/1,000
State Farm

State Farm

Best for Higher Coverage Limits

MoneyGeek Rating
4.7/ 5
4.7/5Affordability
4.9/5Customer Experience
4/5Coverage
  • Average Annual Premium

    $224
  • Average Monthly Premium

    $19
  • J.D. Power Renters Insurance Customer Satisfaction Score

    702/1,000
Auto-Owners

Auto-Owners

Best for Local Agent Service

MoneyGeek Rating
4.7/ 5
4.8/5Affordability
5/5Customer Experience
2.8/5Coverage
  • Average Annual Premium

    $196
  • Average Monthly Premium

    $16
  • J.D. Power Renters Insurance Customer Satisfaction Score

    639/1,000
American Family Insurance

American Family Insurance

Cheapest at $100,000 in Coverage

MoneyGeek Rating
4.6/ 5
4.8/5Affordability
4.7/5Customer Experience
3.5/5Coverage
  • Average Annual Premium

    $205
  • Average Monthly Premium

    $17
  • J.D. Power Renters Insurance Customer Satisfaction Score

    680/1,000
Nationwide

Nationwide

Second Cheapest at Poor Credit

MoneyGeek Rating
4.6/ 5
4.8/5Affordability
4.6/5Customer Experience
3.4/5Coverage
  • Average Annual Premium

    $174
  • Average Monthly Premium

    $15
  • J.D. Power Renters Insurance Customer Satisfaction Score

    678/1,000

Who Has the Cheapest Renters Insurance in Arizona?

Lemonade is the cheapest Arizona renters insurer at $90 a year, and 9 of the 12 most affordable providers we analyzed price below the $238 state average, which itself runs $56 above the $182 national average.

Housing takes 30% or more of income for 52% of Arizona's renter households, and the renter share reaches 53% in the Tucson metro area and 52% around Phoenix, according to USAFacts. For a household stretched that thin, Lemonade’s $90 premium costs $148 less a year than the $238 state average, and Nationwide’s $174 still costs $64 less.

Lemonade
$7
$90
-$148
$11
$127
-$111
$13
$159
-$79
Nationwide
$15
$174
-$64
$16
$188
-$49
$16
$188
-$49
Auto-Owners Insurance
$16
$196
-$41
American Family
$17
$205
-$33
State Farm
$19
$224
-$13
Farm Bureau
$20
$242
+$5
$28
$335
+$98
$60
$722
+$484
State average
$20
$238

Start with Lemonade at $90 and Progressive at $159: that $69 gap means a third quote only pays off if it lands under Progressive's price, and Farmers at $722 would cost $632 more than Lemonade for the same policy.

veteran icon
USAA FOR MILITARY FAMILIES

Military members and their families can add USAA to the shortlist: its $127 premium is the second lowest of the 12 providers, $111 below the state average and $37 above Lemonade. USAA also undercuts every provider open to everyone at $50,000 and $100,000 personal property coverage levels.

Cheapest Renters Insurance in Arizona by City

Lemonade is the cheapest provider in all 14 Arizona cities we compared and Progressive is second in every one, with the gap between them running from $39 in Peoria to $102 in Chandler.

Phoenix
Lemonade, $123
Progressive, $164
$261
Fort Defiance
Lemonade, $66
Progressive, $154
$254
Tucson
Lemonade, $97
Progressive, $141
$249
Scottsdale
Lemonade, $72
Progressive, $156
$239
Tempe
Lemonade, $90
Progressive, $170
$236
Buckeye
Lemonade, $80
Progressive, $157
$236
Glendale
Lemonade, $75
Progressive, $161
$230
Dennehotso
Lemonade, $66
Progressive, $154
$229
Prescott Valley
Lemonade, $66
Progressive, $156
$225
Mesa
Lemonade, $76
Progressive, $165
$223
Gilbert
Lemonade, $62
Progressive, $159
$222
Peoria
Lemonade, $116
Progressive, $155
$218
Surprise
Lemonade, $80
Progressive, $152
$218
Chandler
Lemonade, $62
Progressive, $164
$215

City averages span $46, from $215 in Chandler to $261 in Phoenix, which sits $24 above the $238 state average. Lemonade's Phoenix price of $123 is nearly double its $62 in Chandler and Gilbert, and Allstate charges $231 in Phoenix compared to $171 in several other cities. Phoenix, Peoria and Tucson are the three cities where Lemonade's lead over Progressive falls under $45, so renters there should price both.

Storm risk does not show up in these prices. In October 2025, remnants of two tropical cyclones brought 3.5 to 4.5 inches of rain to the East Valley, closed a stretch of Loop 202 in Gilbert and led NWS Phoenix to issue 25 flash flood warnings, while a supercell that same week tore roofs off buildings in Tempe with gusts of 80 to 90 mph. Yet Chandler has the lowest city average at $215 and Gilbert sits at $222, because a standard Arizona renters policy covers wind but not flash flooding. 

Renters in the East Valley who want flood protection should buy a separate National Flood Insurance Program contents policy, which covers renters' belongings up to $100,000 after a 30-day waiting period, well before the next storm arrives.

insurance2 icon
HOW TO DETERMINE YOUR RENTERS INSURANCE COVERAGE NEEDS

Typical personal property coverage ranges from $20,000 to $50,000 for most renters' belongings. Go through your unit and add up replacement values for electronics, furniture, clothing and other items to calculate your personal property coverage. You'll also want to select at least $100,000 in liability coverage to protect yourself if someone gets injured in your apartment.

How to Find the Best Cheap Renters Insurance in Arizona

The provider you choose moves your premium far more than the city you rent in: Lemonade and Farmers sit $632 apart at the same coverage, while the 14 city averages differ by only $46.

  1. 1
    Compare quotes from at least three companies

    Start with Lemonade, Progressive and Nationwide, the three cheapest providers open to everyone, and add American Family if you need $100,000 in coverage, since it beats Lemonade at that limit. Several quotes matter because the cheapest provider shifts with your credit, city and coverage limit.

  2. 2
    Check customer satisfaction ratings and reviews

    State Farm's 702 J.D. Power score sits 28 points above Lemonade's 674 and 63 above Auto-Owners' 639, so weigh whether State Farm's $135 premium over Lemonade is worth that satisfaction edge.

  3. 3
    Bundle renters and auto insurance

    Insurers that sell both policies generally offer a bundling discount, so ask your auto insurer for a renters quote before you shop elsewhere. A renters and auto bundle makes sense only if your auto savings exceed the extra you pay for the bundled renters policy compared with the cheapest standalone quote.

  4. 4
    Ask about available discounts

    Insurers list discounts for multiple policies, claim-free history and protective devices, so name each one when you request a quote and compare final totals rather than starting prices.

mglogo icon
DEDUCTIBLE TIP

A $500 deductible is a smart choice for Arizona renters. Raising it to $1,000 leads to $22 in annual savings, but the extra $500 you would carry on a claim takes about 23 years of savings to recover, and a $2,000 deductible saves $40 a year against $1,500 more out of pocket, a 37-year payback.

Best Cheap Renters Insurance in Arizona: Bottom Line

Lemonade’s $90 wins on price at good and poor credit, in all 14 cities and at $20,000 and, for non-military renters, at $50,000, so make it your first Arizona quote. Renters carrying $100,000 should add American Family at $297 and those at $250,000 should add State Farm at $433, while renters who want an agent should start with Nationwide at $174 and step up to Auto-Owners at $196 for its perfect 5.0 customer experience score.

Personalized Arizona Renters Insurance Rates

Enter your coverage, deductible and credit below to see how your Arizona renters insurance rate compares with the $238 state average.

Select Coverage Level
Select Deductible
Select Credit Score
Average Annual Premium—

Renters Insurance in Arizona: FAQ

How We Found the Best Cheap Renters Insurance Companies in Arizona

To find Arizona renters insurers that pair low rates with strong service, we compared rates and ratings for 12 providers. Every premium in this guide uses the same base profile unless a section changes one variable:

  • Renters aged 26 to 64
  • Good credit
  • No claims in the past five years
  • Apartment or condo
  • $20,000 in personal property coverage
  • $100,000 in liability coverage
  • Replacement cost included
  • $500 deductible

Each MoneyGeek score out of 5 weights affordability at 50%, customer experience at 40% and add-on coverage options at 10%. J.D. Power scores come from the J.D. Power 2026 U.S. Home Insurance Study, which rates renters insurance customer satisfaction on a 1,000-point scale.

Average costs are calculated using quote data from Quadrant Information Services. Credit, deductible and coverage level figures use the same profile with one variable changed.

About Mark Fitzpatrick


Mark Fitzpatrick, Licensed P&C Insurance Expert, MoneyGeek

Mark Fitzpatrick is a licensed Property and Casualty (P&C) Insurance Producer and MoneyGeek's resident expert in insurance and economics. In nearly a decade covering the insurance market at LendingTree and MoneyGeek, he's analyzed hundreds of carriers and millions of rates across auto, home, renters, health and life insurance.

His work has appeared in The Washington Post, The New York Times and NPR. He draws on independent cost and consumer experience data, and no insurance company partnerships affect his recommendations.

Mark studied at Boston College and later earned a master's in economics and international relations from Johns Hopkins University. He worked in financial risk management at State Street before joining MoneyGeek. He's also a five-time “Jeopardy!” champion.


Sources