First-Time Home Buyer Insurance


Key Takeaways
blueCheck icon

For $250,000 in dwelling coverage, first-time homebuyers pay an average of $288 monthly, with rates across MoneyGeek's provider list ranging from $90 to $458 monthly.

blueCheck icon

AIG ranks first in MoneyGeek’s national analysis with a 4.76 out of 5 score. USAA is highest at 4.8, though its policies are limited to military members, veterans and their families.

blueCheck icon

Start shopping for home insurance as soon as you apply for a mortgage, ideally at least 30 days before closing, so your lender's deadline doesn't force a rushed decision.

Compare Insurance Rates

Get the best rate for your home insurance. Compare quotes from the top insurance companies.

How Much Does Home Insurance Cost for First-Time Buyers?

First-time homebuyers pay an average of $288 monthly for $250,000 in dwelling coverage, or $3,467 per year, based on MoneyGeek's analysis of 14 national providers. Your actual home insurance premium depends on how much coverage you choose, and costs increase depending on the coverage amounts you select.

$100K Dwelling / $50K Personal Property / $100K Liability

$152
$1,828

$250K Dwelling / $125K Personal Property / $200K Liability

$288
$3,467

$500K Dwelling / $250K Personal Property / $300K Liability

$489
$5,874

$750K Dwelling / $375K Personal Property / $500K Liability

$693
$8,317

$1MM Dwelling / $500K Personal Property / $1MM Liability

$894
$10,732

Note: These figures reflect a middle-aged home profile. Home age is one factor that can move your actual rate, and premiums for newly built or older homes will look different from what our table shows.

Which Home Insurance Companies Are Best and Cheapest for First-Time Buyers?

MoneyGeek evaluated 14 national home insurance providers on affordability, customer satisfaction and coverage options. The tables below separate the highest-scored options from the most affordable ones so first-time homebuyers can find the fit that matches their priorities.

Best Home Insurance Companies for First-Time Buyers

A high MoneyGeek score reflects a provider that balances pricing, service and coverage options, rather than excelling in one area to offset a weaker one. For a first-time buyer, this is most important at claim time, when you're dealing with the process for the first time and need a provider that's easy to work with.

For most first-time buyers, AIG is MoneyGeek's pick for the best home insurance: it earns a 4.76 out of 5 score and is also the most affordable provider in MoneyGeek's analysis at $90 monthly. USAA ranks the highest at 4.8 out of 5 but is available only to active military members, veterans and eligible family members.

USAA$186$2,2344.79
AIG Insurance$91$1,0894.76
Amica$119$1,4254.72
CSAA$126$1,5144.55
AAA$128$1,5394.54
State Farm$179$2,1514.49
Chubb$352$4,2214.34
Farmers$232$2,7854.3
Allstate$245$2,9424.2
Homesite$211$2,5264.17
Nationwide$278$3,3414.1
American Modern$174$2,0893.97
Progressive$459$5,5053.75
Travelers$453$5,4353.65

A high score and competitive pricing like AIG’s are uncommon in our data. CSAA and AAA each score 4.55 out of 5 at $126 and $128 monthly, but both require an active AAA membership to be eligible.

Cheapest Home Insurance Companies for First-Time Buyers

Rate is often the first filter for a first-time buyer managing a tight budget after closing costs and a down payment. The cheapest home insurance option isn't always the one that performs best at claim time.

AIG and Amica appear on both of our cheapest and highest-scored lists. AIG comes in at $90 monthly with a 4.76 out of 5 score; Amica at $119 monthly with a 4.72 out of 5 score. Each offers a competitive rate paired with a high overall ranking, which makes either a practical first choice for a buyer who doesn't want to trade cost for quality.

AIG Insurance$91$1,089
Amica$119$1,425
CSAA$126$1,514
AAA$128$1,539
American Modern$174$2,089
State Farm$179$2,151
USAA$186$2,234
Homesite$211$2,526
Farmers$232$2,785
Allstate$245$2,942
Nationwide$278$3,341
Chubb$352$4,221
Travelers$453$5,435
Progressive$459$5,505

American Modern is worth weighing separately. At $174 monthly it's one of the more affordable options in the data, but it ranks 12th out of 14 in MoneyGeek's overall analysis. For a buyer who expects to need help through a claim, that 12th-place ranking is worth factoring in before choosing on price alone.

What Does Home Insurance Cover?

There are six standard home insurance coverages, each protecting a different part of what you own or what you're financially responsible for. Knowing what each one does helps you spot missing coverage before you need to file a claim.

  • Dwelling: Covers damage to your home's structure, including attached garages and decks, from events like fires and storms.
  • Other Structures: Extends coverage to detached structures on your property, such as a fence, shed or detached garage.
  • Personal Property: Covers your belongings inside the home, including furniture, electronics and clothing, up to your policy's limit.
  • Loss of Use: Pays for hotel stays, extra food costs and other expenses if a covered loss forces you out of your home while repairs are underway.
  • Personal Liability: Covers legal and medical costs if someone is injured on your property or you accidentally damage someone else's property.
  • Medical Payments for Others: Covers a guest's medical bills if they're injured at your home, regardless of fault.

What Does Home Insurance Not Cover?

Standard home insurance covers sudden, unexpected losses, not everything that can go wrong with a home. These are the exclusions first-time buyers encounter most.

  • Floods: Standard policies don't cover flood damage. A separate policy through the National Flood Insurance Program or a private insurer is needed.
  • Earthquakes: Earthquake damage requires a separate policy or endorsement, which is especially relevant in California and other seismically active states.
  • Wear and tear: Gradual deterioration and maintenance issues aren't covered. Insurance responds to sudden losses, not the slow effects of aging or neglect.
  • Pests: Termite, rodent or insect damage is excluded from virtually all standard policies.
  • Mold and rot: Coverage depends on the cause. Mold from a sudden burst pipe may be covered; mold from long-term moisture buildup is a homeowner responsibility.

How Much Home Insurance Do First-Time Buyers Actually Need?

Your dwelling coverage limit should reflect how much it would cost to rebuild your home from the ground up, not its market value. Those two numbers can differ by a wide margin, and insuring for the wrong one can leave you covering a large portion of the rebuild out of pocket after a total loss.

Most mortgage lenders require you to insure your home for at least 80% of its replacement cost, though some require coverage up to 100%. Working with a licensed agent to calculate the right replacement cost estimate is one of the more useful things you can do before settling on a policy.

Personal property coverage is set as a percentage of your dwelling limit, usually 50% to 70%. If your belongings are worth more than that amount, consider an endorsement to raise the limit. For liability, think about what you’d be putting at risk. $100,000 in liability coverage is a common starting point, but it may not be enough if you have assets worth protecting.

What Discounts Are Available for First-Time Homebuyers?

Not all new-homebuyer discounts are tied to when you bought. Some providers use "new home" to mean a recently built property, not a recently purchased one. The discounts below are tied to the purchase event itself, so most are available from the start of your policy regardless of how old the home is.

Home Buyer Discount
Recent home buyers and owners of newly constructed properties
Rent to Own
Buyers who held a Farmers renters policy for at least one year before switching to a homeowners policy
New Home Purchase Discount
First-time buyers purchasing their first home
Moving In Discount
Buyers switching from a Homesite renters or condo policy to a homeowners policy
Home Purchase Discount
Buyers who purchased within the last 12 months
New Purchase Discount
Recent home buyers or those switching from renters insurance, regardless of the home's construction year
Homebuyer Discount
Buyers who purchased within the last 12 months of the policy's effective date

Buyers who were renting before they purchased have two options other than the standard new-buyer discount. Farmers’ Rent to Own applies if you held a Farmers renters policy for at least one year, and Homesite’s Moving In Discount applies to any Homesite renters or condo policyholder making the same switch.

Bundling home and auto insurance under the same provider is another broadly available way to lower both premiums and isn't limited to first-time buyers. If you already have auto coverage, ask your current insurer whether a bundle discount is available.

How Do First-Time Buyers Purchase Home Insurance?

Start shopping for home insurance as soon as you apply for a mortgage, ideally at least 30 days before your closing date. Your lender will require proof of insurance before the loan closes, and starting early gives you time to compare providers without pressure.

  1. 1
    Gather your home's details

    You’ll need basic information to request a quote, including the address, year built, square footage, roof age and materials, any recent renovations and details about safety systems. Some of this may auto-fill from public records when you enter your address online, but confirm it’s accurate before submitting.

  2. 2
    Compare quotes from at least three providers

    Many companies like State Farm and Allstate offer online quotes, though some require you to call an agent. Use the same coverage amounts across each quote so the comparison is fair.

  3. 3
    Decide between an agent and a direct purchase

    A captive agent works for a single insurer. An independent broker works across multiple carriers and can help you weigh options side by side. If you're buying home insurance for the first time, a broker is often a useful starting point.

  4. 4
    Finalize the policy and pay your first premium

    Once you've chosen a provider, review the policy terms, sign and make your first payment. Some providers allow you to do this online; others require an agent call.

  5. 5
    Send proof of insurance to your lender

    Your lender will need a copy before closing. Request a declarations page from your insurer, which summarizes your coverage, premium and policy effective date.

First-Time Home Buyer Insurance: Bottom Line

First-time homebuyers pay an average of $288 monthly for $250,000 in dwelling coverage, with individual provider rates in MoneyGeek's analysis ranging from $90 to $458 monthly. USAA leads the rankings with a 4.8 out of 5 score, though eligibility is limited to military members, veterans and their families. 

For buyers outside that eligibility, AIG ranks second at 4.76 out of 5 and is the most affordable option in the data at $90 monthly. Start shopping at least 30 days before closing and compare quotes from multiple providers to find coverage that fits your home's replacement cost and your budget.

Compare Insurance Rates

Get the best rate for your home insurance. Compare quotes from the top insurance companies.

Home Insurance for First-Time Buyers: FAQ

First-Time Buyer Home Insurance Rates: Our Methodology

MoneyGeek analyzed premium data from Quadrant Information Services across all 50 states and scored each insurer on affordability, customer service, financial stability, coverage options and discounts. We used J.D. Power satisfaction ratings, AM Best financial strength scores and coverage comparisons to identify the best companies for different homeowner needs. Rates shown are averages and your actual premium may differ.

Our rate comparison uses a sample homeowner ages 41 to 60 with good credit (769 to 792), no recent claims and standard risk on a wood-frame home built in 2000 with $250,000 replacement value. Base coverage is $250,000 dwelling, $125,000 personal property, $200,000 liability and a $1,000 deductible. Top picks were chosen based on competitive pricing, J.D. Power customer scores, AM Best ratings and the availability of add-on coverage options.

Read more about our home insurance methodology.

About Mark Fitzpatrick


Mark Fitzpatrick, Licensed P&C Insurance Expert, MoneyGeek

Mark Fitzpatrick is a licensed Property and Casualty (P&C) Insurance Producer and MoneyGeek's resident expert in insurance and economics. In nearly a decade covering the insurance market at LendingTree and MoneyGeek, he's analyzed hundreds of carriers and millions of rates across auto, home, renters, health and life insurance.

His work has appeared in The Washington Post, The New York Times and NPR. He draws on independent cost and consumer experience data, and no insurance company partnerships affect his recommendations.

Mark studied at Boston College and later earned a master's in economics and international relations from Johns Hopkins University. He worked in financial risk management at State Street before joining MoneyGeek. He's also a five-time “Jeopardy!” champion.