Cheapest Home Insurance in California


Key Takeaways: Affordable California Home Insurers
blueCheck icon

Capital Insurance Group is the cheapest carrier at $1,134 a year, $8 below Farmers and $410 below the $1,543 California state average.

blueCheck icon

California homeowners spend about 1.9% of median household income on premiums, making the state the 20th most affordable of 50 in Triple-I's 2025 affordability index.

blueCheck icon

California's Safer from Wildfires program qualifies a home for an insurance discount on each of ten hardening steps, from a Class A roof to a 5-foot ember-resistant zone.

Top 5 Cheapest Home Insurance Companies

Capital Insurance Group has the lowest California rate for the base profile at $1,134 a year, $410 below the $1,543 state average, with Farmers only $8 behind at $1,142. The top companies differ more in how they sell and who they're cheapest for than their overall average prices: Capital Insurance Group, a Monterey carrier, sells only through independent agents; Farmers has the lowest rate in 49 of 91 cities; Progressive has the lowest rate at $500,000 and $750,000 in dwelling coverage.

Service and claim cost separate the pricier carriers. Chubb's 676 in J.D. Power's 2026 U.S. Home Insurance Study is the highest of the five and 61 points above Farmers' 615, but Chubb costs $701 more than Farmers and adds $293 for one claim, the steepest surcharge of the group. A homeowner who puts claims service first should weigh Progressive's 659 against its $104 premium over the $1,134 lowest rate, and keep a Chubb quote for a claim-free household that values its 676 score above the extra $709 a year.

Capital Insurance Group
$94
$1,134
$95
$1,142
+$8
$103
$1,237
+$104
$115
$1,377
+$244
$154
$1,843
+$709

*These rates are based on a house built in 2000 with $250,000 in dwelling coverage, $125,000 in personal property coverage, $200,000 in liability coverage and a $1,000 deductible. We assumed good credit and no claims in the past five years.

california icon
AVAILABILITY MATTERS AS MUCH AS PRICE IN CALIFORNIA

State Farm and Allstate are left out because neither has reopened to new California homeowners applications, per the Department of Insurance's September 2026 announcement that both have filed to resume. That fits a market under strain: Triple-I finds California under the greatest availability pressure of any state, with the share of coverage written through the residual market (the FAIR Plan, the insurer of last resort) and the excess and surplus lines market (E&S, insurers outside the state's standard licensing process) up 308% since 2020.

California's Cheapest Providers at a Glance

Capital Insurance Group

Capital Insurance Group

Cheapest Overall

Capital Insurance Group has the lowest rate for the base profile at $1,134 a year, at the $250,000 and $1 million dwelling tiers, and in 28 of the 91 cities, mostly across Orange County, the Inland Empire and the Antelope Valley. The Monterey carrier, founded in 1898, sells only through independent agents, so there is no direct online quote, and AM Best has given it an A (Excellent) financial strength rating for seven years in a row. Ask an independent agent to quote it beside Farmers and Progressive, because its $8 lead over Farmers can reverse at a different ZIP code.

Farmers

Farmers

Cheapest for $100,000 Coverage and in Most California Cities

Farmers undercuts every other carrier at the $100,000 dwelling tier with $445 a year and has the lowest rate in 49 of the 91 cities, including Pasadena, San Francisco, San Jose and Oxnard. At $750,000 it charges $1,512 more than Progressive, and its 615 J.D. Power score sits 29 points under the 644 study average. Farmers removed its cap on new California policies in November 2025. Choose Farmers for a smaller dwelling limit in the Bay Area or in Los Angeles and Ventura counties, and skip it when your rebuild costs exceed $750,000.

Progressive

Progressive

Cheapest for Higher Coverage Limits

Progressive costs $104 more than Capital Insurance Group at the base profile, yet it is the cheapest carrier at the $500,000 and $750,000 dwelling tiers and has the lowest rate in 12 cities including Los Angeles, Sacramento, Fresno and Oakland. Its 659 J.D. Power customer satisfaction score is 44 points above Farmers and 15 above the study average. The insurer's price lead ends at $1 million, where Capital Insurance Group is $17 cheaper, so a household insuring a $500,000 to $750,000 rebuild should quote Progressive first.

Cheapest California Home Insurance Rates by Coverage Level

No carrier is cheapest at every tier: Farmers is cheapest at the $100,000 dwelling level, Capital Insurance Group at $250,000, Progressive at $500,000 and $750,000, and Capital Insurance Group again at $1 million. The state average climbs from $833 at $100,000 to $5,381 at $1 million, and Farmers climbs fastest of the three leaders, multiplying its premium 13 times between those two tiers against 6.5 times for the state average.

$100,000
Farmers
$445
Capital Insurance Group
$673
$250,000
Capital Insurance Group
$1,134
Farmers
$1,142
$500,000
Progressive
$1,816
Capital Insurance Group
$1,933
$750,000
Progressive
$2,725
Capital Insurance Group
$2,819
$1 million
Capital Insurance Group
$3,706
Progressive
$3,723

Price settles the choice at three tiers and service settles it at two. Farmers at $100,000 and Progressive at $500,000 and $750,000 are $94 to $227 below the runner-up, but at $250,000 and $1 million Capital Insurance Group is only $8 below Farmers and $17 below Progressive.

For a smaller dwelling limit, start with Farmers, whose $445 is $227 under the next-cheapest carrier. For $500,000 to $750,000, quote Progressive first, since its 659 J.D. Power score is 44 points above Farmers' 615 on top of the lower price. At $1 million the $17 spread between Capital Insurance Group and Progressive is small enough that service should decide it: Progressive carries a 659 score, while Capital Insurance Group has no J.D. Power score and sells only through independent agents.

Cheapest California Home Insurance by City

Farmers has the lowest rate in 49 of the 91 California cities in the data, Capital Insurance Group in 28, Progressive in 12 and Nationwide in 2, and the split follows geography: Farmers is cheapest across most of the Bay Area and the Los Angeles and Ventura county cities, Capital Insurance Group across Orange County, the Inland Empire and the Antelope Valley, and Progressive in Sacramento, Fresno and Modesto. The Eaton Fire destroyed 9,413 structures in Altadena, beside Pasadena, where Farmers quotes $811, so every city rate below applies to the low-wildfire-risk home in the base profile and not to a house near a recent burn area.

Anaheim
Capital Insurance Group
$1,051
Bakersfield
Capital Insurance Group
$1,053
Fremont
Farmers
$897
Fresno
Progressive
$990
Irvine
Capital Insurance Group
$1,349
Lancaster
Capital Insurance Group
$1,358
Long Beach
Farmers
$1,104
Los Angeles
Progressive
$1,351
Modesto
Progressive
$940
North Hollywood
Capital Insurance Group
$1,484
Oakland
Progressive
$1,175
Oxnard
Farmers
$834
Palmdale
Capital Insurance Group
$1,400
Pasadena
Farmers
$811
Riverside
Capital Insurance Group
$1,183
Sacramento
Progressive
$992
San Bernardino
Farmers
$1,214
San Diego
Capital Insurance Group
$1,061
San Francisco
Farmers
$766
San Jose
Farmers
$834
Santa Ana
Capital Insurance Group
$1,061
Santa Rosa
Farmers
$746
Stockton
Capital Insurance Group
$985

Across all 91 cities the cheapest rate runs from $746 in Santa Rosa to $1,484 in North Hollywood, a $738 gap that makes North Hollywood 99% higher. San Francisco has the widest price range of all the cities we compared, with Farmers' $766 a full $382 below Capital Insurance Group, the next-cheapest option there.

Price differences shrink in the Antelope Valley, where Capital Insurance Group's $1,358 in Lancaster and $1,400 in Palmdale sit only $59 and $17 below Farmers. Homeowners in those two cities should collect quotes from both carriers and ask each for its Safer from Wildfires discounts, because a $17 lead can reverse at a different ZIP code.

Reviews of the Best Home Insurance in California Cities

Check out the best and cheapest home insurance providers in major California cities.

goodCredit icon
CREDIT SCORES AND CALIFORNIA HOME INSURANCE RATES

California insurers don't use credit-based scores to underwrite or price homeowners policies. California homeowners rates instead pass through the Insurance Commissioner's prior-approval review. Proposition 103 is California's rate-approval law. The state's Insurance Commissioner has to approve an insurer's price before the insurer can charge it, and that review covers homeowners, fire-only dwelling and earthquake policies. With credit out of the price, what you can change is how much dwelling coverage you buy, your deductible, your claims record and how well your home is protected from wildfire.

How to Save on California Home Insurance

California insurers don’t price on credit, so the carrier you choose and the steps you take on your home carry the savings: Capital Insurance Group’s $1,134 is already $410 under the $1,543 state average, and six moves can lower a premium further.

  1. 1
    Start with Safer from Wildfires

    Safer from Wildfires qualifies a home for an insurance discount on each of its ten steps, from a Class A roof and enclosed eaves to ember-resistant vents, a 5-foot ember-resistant zone and cleared debris under decks. Hardening also widens access: State Farm's September filing says it would write homes in California that meet certain IBHS Wildfire Prepared Home standards. Finish the roof, vent and 5-foot zone work first, then ask every carrier to list its Safer from Wildfires discounts in writing.

  2. 2
    Compare at least three quotes

    The five carriers in the table span $709 between Capital Insurance Group's $1,134 and Chubb's $1,843, and the cheapest carrier changes by city and by dwelling limit. Ask an independent agent who writes Capital Insurance Group for that quote, then add Farmers and Progressive.

  3. 3
    Bundle only if the discount is large enough

    Nationwide's $1,377 sits $244 above Capital Insurance Group, so a Nationwide bundle comes out cheaper than Capital Insurance Group only if its multi-policy discount takes at least 18% off the home premium. Get the bundled home price in writing before dropping the cheaper quote.

  4. 4
    Raise your deductible in steps

    Moving from $500 to $1,000 saves $112 a year on the state average, $1,000 to $1,500 saves $80, and $1,500 to $2,000 saves $72. The last $500 takes about seven claim-free years to repay, so $1,500 captures most of the savings with less exposure in case you need to file a claim.

  5. 5
    Stay claims-free

    A claim in the past five years adds $246 a year to the $1,543 state average, and two claims add $452. Capital Insurance Group still prices a one-claim home at $1,314, $10 below Farmers' $1,324, so a household with a claim should quote both carriers before assuming the surcharge ends the search; weigh any repair near the $1,000 deductible against that $246.

  6. 6
    Understand the FAIR Plan before using it

    The California FAIR Plan is the insurer of last resort, created by the state and operated and funded by private insurers, and its policies may not cover liability, theft or water damage. Its rates rose 29.1% on average for new and renewing policies in October 2026, and the Department of Insurance tells homeowners to ask an agent or broker about admitted market options first, meaning insurers licensed by the state to sell standard policies. A homeowner who still lands on the FAIR Plan should price a Difference in Conditions (DIC) policy, a separate policy from a private insurer that covers what the FAIR Plan's basic fire policy may leave out, such as liability, theft and water damage.

Cheap Home Insurance in California: Bottom Line

Capital Insurance Group has the lowest base-profile rate at $1,134, but Farmers is cheapest at the $100,000 tier and in 49 cities while Progressive is cheapest at the $500,000 and $750,000 tiers, so the cheapest quote depends on your ZIP code and dwelling limit. Request quotes from all three, set the dwelling limit to your rebuild cost, and ask each carrier for its Safer from Wildfires discounts before weighing your options.

Compare California Home Insurance Rates

Get the best insurance rate for your California home. Compare quotes from the top insurance companies.

Cheapest Home Insurance in California: FAQ

How We Found the Cheapest Home Insurance Companies in California

MoneyGeek analyzed California rates to identify which companies offer the lowest premiums for homeowners across the state.

We gathered quotes from major insurers through Quadrant Information Services for a standard California home profile. The data shows which companies price competitively for typical homeowners.

Sample Home Profile

We gathered quotes using these specifications to represent a common California homeowner:

  • $250,000 dwelling coverage
  • $125,000 personal property coverage
  • $200,000 liability coverage
  • Home built in 2000
  • $1,000 deductible
  • No claims in the past 5+ years

This profile reflects a moderately valued home with a clean claims history. Newer homes (built after 1990) get better rates than older properties with outdated electrical and plumbing systems. The $1,000 deductible balances affordable premiums with reasonable out-of-pocket costs when filing claims.

About Nicole Goldkamp


Nicole Goldkamp, SEO and Content Manager, Home & Renters Insurance, MoneyGeek

Nicole Goldkamp is an SEO and Content Manager at MoneyGeek, where she leads the home and renters insurance editorial team. She has spent five years evaluating home, renters, auto and pet insurance products and over a decade in content and editorial roles.

As MoneyGeek's lead for home and renters insurance, Goldkamp authors in-depth guides, company reviews and comparison pages. She reviews all team content for accuracy before it's published and maintains the editorial standards, research methodologies and provider evaluation frameworks for her verticals.


Sources