Capital Insurance Group has the lowest California rate for the base profile at $1,134 a year, $410 below the $1,543 state average, with Farmers only $8 behind at $1,142. The top companies differ more in how they sell and who they're cheapest for than their overall average prices: Capital Insurance Group, a Monterey carrier, sells only through independent agents; Farmers has the lowest rate in 49 of 91 cities; Progressive has the lowest rate at $500,000 and $750,000 in dwelling coverage.
Service and claim cost separate the pricier carriers. Chubb's 676 in J.D. Power's 2026 U.S. Home Insurance Study is the highest of the five and 61 points above Farmers' 615, but Chubb costs $701 more than Farmers and adds $293 for one claim, the steepest surcharge of the group. A homeowner who puts claims service first should weigh Progressive's 659 against its $104 premium over the $1,134 lowest rate, and keep a Chubb quote for a claim-free household that values its 676 score above the extra $709 a year.






