Does Car Insurance Cover Damage to My Own Car?

Car insurance policies cover damage to your own vehicle only if you carry comprehensive or collision coverage. Comprehensive covers non-collision damage. That includes hail, theft, fire, flooding and animal strikes. Collision covers damage from hitting another vehicle or object, regardless of fault. 

Together, comprehensive and collision make up what's known as full coverage, which also includes liability. Liability-only policies don't pay a cent toward your repairs. If you financed or leased your car, your lender requires all three coverage types.

Your deductible amount depends on whether the damage came from a collision or a non-collision event. Comprehensive and collision deductibles are set separately and may differ on the same policy.

Many drivers set a lower comprehensive deductible ($250 to $500) and a higher collision deductible ($500 to $1,000) because comprehensive events like hail and theft involve no driver error. If you've done the same, a weather claim costs less out of pocket than an at-fault fender-bender. Pull your policy's declarations page to see both deductibles listed separately.

Yes. Your deductible applies every time you file a comprehensive or collision claim. If your deductible is $500 and repairs cost $500 or less, your insurer pays nothing. You absorb the full cost. Deductibles reset with each separate claim, so two hailstorms in the same year mean two deductible payments.

Use this table to see how different deductible amounts change your payout:

Your deductibles are listed on your policy's declarations page, usually the first two pages of your policy document or in your insurer's app. Look for two separate lines: one for comprehensive, one for collision. If you can't find it, call your insurer and ask.

File a claim when repair costs are higher than your deductible. Skip it when repair costs are at or below your deductible, or when the gap is small enough that a rate increase would erase any savings within a year. A $300 dent with a $500 deductible is a clear no-file. You pay the full repair cost either way and gain nothing by involving your insurer.

Always ask your insurer if a claim will trigger a rate increase before you submit it. Comprehensive claims from weather and theft raise rates less often than collision claims. But filing two or more claims in a three-year period, regardless of type, is more likely to result in a surcharge at renewal.

Collision claims raise rates more consistently than comprehensive claims. An at-fault collision can increase your premium by 20% to 40% at renewal, per MoneyGeek's rate analysis. Comprehensive claims for weather, theft or animal strikes often result in smaller surcharges or none at all, since they don't reflect on your driving record.

Multiple claims in a short window matter most. Filing two comprehensive claims in three years is more likely to result in a surcharge than a single collision claim. If you've already filed one claim in the past year, weigh the rate risk carefully before filing a second, especially for damage where the payout would be modest. Ask your insurer directly whether a specific claim will affect your renewal rate before you file.

Comprehensive and collision cover damage to your own vehicle. Your deductible comes out first, so repairs cheaper than that amount aren't worth filing. Pull your repair estimate, subtract your deductible, then check with your agent whether a claim would raise your renewal rate. Both numbers together tell you whether filing pays off or ends up costing you more.