Updated: December 16, 2025
Advertising & Editorial Disclosure
Columbus drivers can get minimum coverage for just $32 monthly through Auto-Owners, while the same company also offers the city's most affordable full coverage at $80 per month or $957 annually. These premiums apply to drivers with clean records.
Your age and driving history heavily influence which provider gives you the lowest premium, so comparing quotes from multiple carriers shows your best available rate.
| Auto Owners | $80 | $32 | -30% |
| Erie Insurance | $103 | $37 | -12% |
| Ohio Mutual Insurance | $106 | $41 | -7% |
| Cincinnati Insurance | $99 | $46 | -8% |
| Geico | $92 | $49 | -11% |
Ohio residents pay $40 monthly for minimum coverage, while Columbus drivers pay $50. Full coverage shows a larger gap at $102 versus the state's $83 average. Columbus's growing population increases traffic congestion, leading to more accidents and higher claims.
The city experiences more vehicle theft than other areas across the state, which insurance companies factor into pricing. Local regulations sometimes require additional coverage options not mandatory elsewhere.
Comparing quotes from multiple insurers helps Columbus drivers find competitive rates.
| $102 | $83 |
Read More: The cheapest car insurance in Ohio
Columbus' young drivers pay the highest insurance costs at $204 monthly on average across the top five insurers. This compares to just $94 for adults and $125 for seniors, as inexperience and higher accident rates increase premiums for drivers under 25.
Cheapest Columbus car insurance by age:
Once drivers establish skill, age matters less. The modest difference between adult and senior rates shows insurers view experienced drivers similarly whether they're 40 or 70 years old.
Young drivers in Columbus ages 16 to 25 pay the highest car insurance costs because insurers view them as high risk due to inexperience and higher accident rates. GEICO provides the most affordable full coverage at $152 monthly or $1,829 annually, while the average across the city’s top five insurers hits $204 for young drivers compared to just $94 for adults.
These premiums run more than double what seasoned drivers pay. GEICO’s rates come in $90 per month cheaper than Nationwide’s $242. Adding a young driver to your family policy costs less than getting separate coverage, but expect rates to stay high until age 25.
Note: Teen drivers must meet Ohio's licensing requirements and may encounter additional restrictions. Rates shown assume compliance with state regulations for young drivers.
| Geico | $152 | $1,829 |
| Auto Owners | $193 | $2,312 |
| Erie Insurance | $208 | $2,495 |
| Ohio Mutual Insurance | $227 | $2,719 |
| Nationwide | $242 | $2,904 |
Columbus seniors benefit from decades of driving experience and clean records, helping them get competitive rates like Nationwide's $113 monthly or $1,351 annually for full coverage. While most insurers recognize this experience with favorable pricing, some may adjust rates slightly for drivers over 70 due to reaction time concerns.
Across the city's five most affordable insurers, seniors average $125 monthly, just $31 above the $94 that younger adults pay. Choose Nationwide over Progressive to save $27 monthly. Completing defensive driving courses or keeping annual mileage under 7,500 miles can unlock additional savings.
| Nationwide | $113 | $1,351 |
| Auto Owners | $114 | $1,371 |
| Geico | $123 | $1,475 |
| Ohio Mutual Insurance | $137 | $1,642 |
| Progressive | $140 | $1,682 |
Columbus drivers ages 26 to 64 get the city's best insurance rates because they combine extensive driving experience with statistically lower accident involvement than younger and older groups. Auto-Owners leads with $80 monthly or $957 annually for full coverage, making it the most affordable option for this demographic.
Across Columbus's five cheapest insurers, adults average $94 monthly, the lowest of any age category. Adults save $21 monthly choosing Auto-Owners over Nationwide's $101 rate, the fifth cheapest option. Clean driving records, policy bundling and good driver discounts provide additional ways to cut costs.
| Auto Owners | $80 | $957 |
| Geico | $92 | $1,103 |
| Grange Insurance | $97 | $1,169 |
| Cincinnati Insurance | $99 | $1,185 |
| Nationwide | $101 | $1,218 |
Traffic violations can push Columbus car insurance rates higher once they appear on your driving record. Auto-Owners posts some of the lowest prices across violation types, with minimum liability coverage at $32 per month for drivers with clean records and that same $32 rate after a speeding ticket.
Rates rise to $68 per month with a DUI under Auto-Owners. Among the city’s five least expensive insurers, average monthly premiums increase from $41 for clean drivers to $46 after a speeding violation, $59 following an at-fault accident and $76 after a DUI.
DUI convictions bring the largest cost increase because they involve impaired driving and strict legal penalties, placing drivers in the highest risk tier and often requiring SR-22 filings to restore driving privileges. At-fault accidents also raise rates since they involve direct responsibility for damage or injuries, which signals higher claim risk to insurers.
| Auto Owners | $68 | $813 |
| Geico | $70 | $842 |
| Erie Insurance | $77 | $923 |
| Progressive | $80 | $955 |
| Grange Insurance | $84 | $1,005 |
The cheapest ZIP code in Columbus charges just $45 monthly while the most expensive (43211) costs $111, a $66 difference across the city. See your ZIP code's rate in the table below.
Columbus's two most populous ZIP codes with available data are 43232 and 43224, with minimum coverage rates of $103 and $110 monthly.
These variations reflect neighborhood factors like accident frequency, vehicle theft rates, population density and uninsured driver concentrations. Use the filter above the table to find your ZIP code and see your neighborhood's average rate.
| 43004 | $46 | $95 |
You can get competitive rates without sacrificing adequate coverage in Columbus. Here's how to balance both.
Try our car insurance coverage needs calculator for customized advice. This tool helps determine the right amount of protection based on your specific situation and assets.
Familiarize yourself with types of car insurance options in Columbus. Consider pay-per-mile insurance if you drive infrequently or non-owner coverage if you occasionally borrow vehicles.
Look up average vehicle insurance costs for your specific Columbus neighborhood. Local rates vary based on factors like crime rates and traffic patterns.
Explore every savings option with car insurance discount opportunities. Consider bundling multiple policies or securing multi-car discounts. You can save with safe driver, student and anti-theft discounts.
Review company ratings and customer feedback for Columbus insurers. Check both financial stability scores and customer satisfaction ratings to ensure you're choosing a reliable provider.
Request quotes from multiple carriers, at least three different companies. Comparing rates helps you find the most competitive pricing for your specific coverage needs and driving profile.
Schedule an annual policy review to stay competitive with current market rates. Your circumstances and available discounts may change, potentially qualifying you for better pricing or coverage options.
Want to find affordable coverage in Columbus? This FAQ provides clear answers about available discounts, state regulations and policy options that fit your budget and coverage needs.
Auto-Owners has Columbus’s cheapest minimum coverage at $384 annually and the lowest full coverage at $960 per year. Since individual factors affect pricing, comparing quotes helps drivers find their best rate.
Auto-Owners ranks first among Columbus car insurance providers, earning a MoneyGeek score of 96 out of 100 and beating Erie Insurance by eight points. The company performs well in both affordable pricing and customer experience.
Columbus drivers pay $1,224 annually for full coverage car insurance and $600 for minimum coverage. Your actual premiums depend on your driving record, age and other personal factors.
Yes, Columbus has expensive car insurance, ranking 1051st for minimum coverage and 979th for full coverage affordability among U.S. cities.
Columbus drivers pay some of Ohio's highest car insurance rates, with premiums varying across the city's ZIP codes. We designed our research to find insurers offering the best rates for Columbus's unique urban driving conditions. Read more on MoneyGeek's auto insurance analysis methodology.
About Mark Fitzpatrick
Mark Fitzpatrick, a Licensed Property and Casualty Insurance Producer, is MoneyGeek's resident Personal Finance Expert. With over five years of experience analyzing the insurance market, he conducts original research and creates tailored content for all types of buyers. His insights have been featured in publications like CNBC, NBC News and Mashable.
Fitzpatrick holds a master’s degree in economics and international relations from Johns Hopkins University and a bachelor’s degree from Boston College. He's also a five-time Jeopardy champion!
He writes about economics and insurance, breaking down complex topics so people know what they're buying.
