Best New Mexico Medicare Supplement Plans (2025 Rates)

In New Mexico, 65-year-olds pay an average of $120 per month for Medicare Supplement Plans, while 75-year-olds pay an average of $181.

Plans F and G are the most popular because of their broad coverage. They cost, on average, $186.98 and $122.10 per month, respectively. 

Plan F can be purchased only if you were eligible for Medicare before 2020. Plan N offers similar coverage at an extra fee. 65-year-olds pay an average monthly premium of $107.20, while 75-year-olds pay an average monthly premium of $158.44.

MoneyGeek determined the rankings of these three plans based on their average rates and benefits.

Cigna offers the cheapest Medicare Supplement Plan G in New Mexico, with an average monthly cost of $126.51. Keep in mind that MoneyGeek only analyzed companies that provide online quotes. However, there are other companies in New Mexico that may not provide online quotes yet could offer more affordable prices.

Medicare supplement Plan G costs an average of $149.90 per month in New Mexico. Meanwhile, Humana, the cheapest provider, charges an average monthly premium of $105 for a 65-year-old, while Aetna, the most costly provider, charges an average monthly premium of $144.90. This demonstrates that through comparison shopping, you may save almost $40 per month.

However, the prices shown here are for a 65-year-old Medicare purchaser. Your actual Plan G costs will vary based on your age at the time of purchase, your current age, any discounts and underwriting factors.

In New Mexico, 29 carriers provide Plan G. However, not all of them offer online quotes. MoneyGeek compiled a list of all Medicare Supplement plan providers in New Mexico to help you find one that meets your requirements. Additionally, MoneyGeek outlines the pricing structure of each service, allowing you to decide which providers may charge you more based on your age.

All Medigap insurance, including Plan G, are standardized and must meet certain coverage requirements. However, Plan G does not pay Part B deductibles and only covers around 80% of overseas travel expenses within the limits of your plan.

Additionally, some companies provide additional benefits in addition to basic coverage. Cigna, for example, offers emergency coverage for overseas travel.

Cigna offers the best Medicare supplement Plan F in New Mexico, with an average monthly cost of $182.29. The insurer also offers a high-deductible Plan F, which may bring your monthly payments down to $50.93.

Remember that MoneyGeek only gathered information from New Mexico companies that provide online quotes. However, there might be other New Mexico-based companies that provide cheaper rates than those that offer online quotes.

The average monthly cost of a Medicare Supplement Plan F in New Mexico is $187. Variations in rates throughout the state can be caused by your age, the provider and discounts.

Cigna offers the lowest monthly Medigap Plan F premium in the state, at roughly $116.60 for 75-year-olds, while UnitedHealthcare has the highest monthly premium, at around $288.80. There is an approximately $172.20 difference for the same plan.

Thirty providers in New Mexico offer Medigap Plan F. However, not all of them provide online quotes. Use the contact information provided by MoneyGeek below to get an estimate from these carriers. Companies that are likely to charge you more because of your age are shown in pricing style.

Plan F, like other Medigap policies, is standardized and must offer certain benefits. Although Plan F offers extensive coverage, it only covers 80% of overseas travel exchange within your plan's limits. Additional Plan F benefits may be provided by other carriers, such as Cigna's Foreign Travel Expenses.

Cigna is the best choice for New Mexico seniors shopping for Medicare Supplement Plan N, with monthly rates of $86.02 on average. Keep in mind that our rankings only consider companies that provide online estimates. Other Plan N carriers in New Mexico may have cheaper pricing. You must, however, contact them directly to learn about their pricing and coverage.

Plan N costs an average of $132.80 per month in New Mexico. This rate may fluctuate depending on several factors, including your current age and the age at which you purchase your plan.

For example, a 65-year-old New Mexico resident may qualify for Cigna's cheapest Plan N at around $86.02 per month. Humana is the most costly Plan N provider, at approximately $118.20 per month. That's a monthly difference of almost $32.

In New Mexico, Plan N is offered by 29 different companies. Comparing Medicare Supplement plans in New Mexico is more difficult since not all providers offer online estimates.

To help you choose the best New Mexico Plan N provider, MoneyGeek has compiled all of the providers' contact details. You can also see their pricing methods so that you can see which ones charge more based on your age.

Every Medigap policy is standardized, which means it must give certain coverage. Plan N does not cover Part B deductibles and only pays 80% of foreign travel expenses up to the plan's limit. Some plans may offer extra coverage. For example, Cigna's Plan N includes Foreign Travel Emergency coverage.

Medicare Supplement Plans are not exclusive to plans F, G or N in New Mexico. Other less popular plans, such as Plan A, B, C, K and L, are purchased by fewer individuals due to their less comprehensive coverage. UnitedHealthcare was found to be the top provider for Plans A, B, K and L, while Humana was found to be the best provider for the letter C.

Aetna and Cigna also offer Medigap policies in New Mexico and provide online quotes.

Furthermore, if you became eligible for Medicare after January 1, 2020, Plan C won't be available to you.

Medigap insurance is a complicated subject in New Mexico. MoneyGeek collected and analyzed pricing data from numerous companies to help you in locating the best carrier for your supplementary insurance needs. This chart can make it easier to compare Medicare Supplement plans in New Mexico.

In terms of coverage and availability, Medigap policies vary. For example, Plan F and C provide the most extensive coverage but are not accessible to new enrollees. Your next best options are Plan G or Plan D.

You can compare Medicare Supplement plans in New Mexico side by side using MoneyGeek's chart. It displays the differences in coverage as well as the average cost.

The cost varies based on the plan you choose and the insurance company from which you purchase coverage. UnitedHealthcare is the most cost-effective option in New Mexico for most of the plans Cigna, is the most cost-effective for Plans F, G and N, while Humana is the most cost-effective for Plan C.

These pricing styles are used by companies in New Mexico:

• Attained-Age: Premiums are calculated depending on your present age. This means that your rates will increase as you age.
• Issue-Age: Your premium is determined by your age at the time of purchase.
• Community-Rated: Medicare providers of community-rated plans charge the same monthly cost regardless of age.

MoneyGeek collected data from the biggest Medicare Supplement/Medigap providers in New Mexico for 65-year-olds and 75-year-olds. Plans were only rated as one of the best if we could obtain an accurate quote from the provider online.

MoneyGeek’s scoring system weighted affordability 75% and benefits 25%. A Medigap provider received 5% for every benefit, up to a maximum of 25%.