Cheapest Car Insurance in New York (2026 Rates)


Cheapest Car Insurance Companies in New York Overview:

Get Quotes for Car Insurance in New York

Get the best rate for your coverage needs. Compare quotes from top insurance companies.

Cheapest Full Coverage in New York

State Farm has the cheapest full coverage in New York at $109 a month. GEICO is second-cheapest at $115, a $6 difference. Customers also rate State Farm better than GEICO when it comes to filing claims, so choosing the cheapest company doesn't sacrifice quality.  

Federal employees should quote GEICO first; its Eagle discount is up to 12%. Drivers of new or leased cars should also look at GEICO’s mechanical breakdown insurance, which is available only on cars under 15 months old with under 15,000 miles. Safe, low-mileage drivers can use State Farm’s Drive Safe & Save, which can add up to 30% off your premium.

State Farm
$109
$1,303
$5
GEICO
$115
$1,374
$5
AAA
$119
$1,432
$5
Germania Insurance
$148
$1,781
$3
Chubb
$197
$2,367
$5

Cheapest Minimum Coverage in New York

State Farm has the cheapest minimum coverage in New York at $48 a month. GEICO is second-cheapest at $56, an $8 difference. 

Customers rate State Farm better than GEICO for claims service, which is what protects you when the other driver files a claim against your policy. State Farm’s Drive Safe & Save program can help low-mileage, minimum coverage drivers with safe driving habits shave even more off their car insurance bill.

State Farm
$48
$580
$5
GEICO
$56
$667
$5
AAA
$60
$721
$5
Farmers
$66
$798
$4
Germania Insurance
$75
$902
$3

How to Choose Between Minimum and Full Coverage in New York

Drivers who lease or finance their cars are often required to carry full coverage. If you own your car outright, you can choose to drop collision and comprehensive and carry liability-only insurance, but insurance won't pay anything to repair your car after a claim.

Full coverage costs $61 more per month than minimum coverage at State Farm, or $59 at both GEICO and AAA. Your $1,000 deductible comes off every payout. A total loss on a $3,000 car therefore pays $2,000, less than three years of that difference, so a car worth that little probably isn’t worth full coverage.

Cheapest Car Insurance in New York for Teens and Young Drivers

State Farm has the cheapest family policy for teens in New York at every age from 16 through 25, starting at $376 per month to insure a 16-year-old female driver and $436 for a 16-year-old male. Drivers under 25 with no at-fault accidents or moving violations in the past three years can add State Farm’s Steer Clear discount for as much as 20% off your premium.  

These are family policy rates — a standalone teen policy almost always costs more. Re-quote at 25, when the rate drops $52 a month for males and $34 for females, the largest one-year drop.

16
State Farm
$376
State Farm
$436
17
State Farm
$352
State Farm
$407
18
State Farm
$333
State Farm
$385
19
State Farm
$315
State Farm
$369
20
State Farm
$299
State Farm
$347
21
State Farm
$275
State Farm
$311
22
State Farm
$265
State Farm
$295
23
State Farm
$252
State Farm
$274
24
State Farm
$241
State Farm
$259
25
State Farm
$207
State Farm
$207

Cheapest Car Insurance in New York for Seniors

State Farm has the cheapest car insurance for seniors in New York at $106 a month, $3 less than its adult rate of $109. GEICO is second-cheapest at $133, a $27 monthly difference. A senior who doesn’t shop pays $793 more a year at Progressive ($2,070) than at State Farm ($1,277). Customers do rate Progressive higher for claims, but at that difference, it only makes sense if claims service matters more to you than the savings.

New York requires every insurance company to give a 10% discount on your base rate if you complete a DMV-approved defensive driving course. It applies at any age, lasts three years and doesn’t change who is cheapest.

State Farm
$106
GEICO
$133
Germania Insurance
$140
AAA
$147
Progressive
$172

Cheapest Car Insurance in New York for High-Risk Drivers

State Farm charges $109/month after a speeding ticket or a texting violation, the same as its clean-record rate. It's also cheapest after an at-fault accident ($125/month) and a DWI, which is what New York calls a DUI ($165/month). AAA is second after a DWI at $178/month.

New York doesn't use SR-22 filings for serious driving offenses. Instead, a first DWI carries a $500 to $1,000 fine and a license revocation of at least six months, according to the New York DMV. Refusing a chemical test brings a $500 civil penalty and a revocation of at least one year. Alcohol-related misdemeanors add $395 in mandatory surcharges and fees ($520 for felonies), and the state bills a Driver Responsibility Assessment of $250 a year for three years ($750 total). Unpaid, it suspends your license.

GEICO has the cheapest rate for drivers with bad credit at $191 per month, $76 more than its good-credit rate of $115. Improving your credit is worth more than any other single change for high-risk drivers.

Speeding Ticket
State Farm
$109
At-Fault Accident
State Farm
$125
DUI
State Farm
$165
Texting While Driving
State Farm
$109
Bad Credit
GEICO
$191

Cheapest Car Insurance in New York by City

NYCM is cheapest in 13 of the 15 biggest cities in New York — from $19 per month in Syracuse to $37 in Hempstead — while Kemper is cheapest in Yonkers ($49) and New York ($58). 

Where you live matters more than which company you choose in New York state: minimum coverage costs $19 a month in Syracuse and $58 in New York City, a $39 difference. Buffalo’s $28 monthly rate is $7 more than neighboring Cheektowaga’s $21 with the same insurance company, so make sure your policy lists your actual address.

Albany
NYCM Insurance
$21
$249
Babylon
NYCM Insurance
$32
$387
Brookhaven
NYCM Insurance
$31
$372
Buffalo
NYCM Insurance
$28
$331
Cheektowaga
NYCM Insurance
$21
$250
Greece
NYCM Insurance
$20
$240
Hempstead
NYCM Insurance
$37
$445
Huntington
NYCM Insurance
$30
$363
Islip
NYCM Insurance
$32
$387
New York
Kemper
$58
$690
Oyster Bay
NYCM Insurance
$30
$356
Rochester
NYCM Insurance
$20
$246
Smithtown
NYCM Insurance
$30
$363
Syracuse
NYCM Insurance
$19
$232
Yonkers
Kemper
$49
$587
Get Quotes for Car Insurance in New York

Get the best rate for your coverage needs. Compare quotes from top insurance companies.

How to Get Cheap Car Insurance in New York

Comparing quotes is the biggest way to save money in New York: State Farm’s $109/month against Chubb’s $197/month is an $88 monthly difference. Credit and bundling come next, followed by coverage level, violations and a defensive driving course.

  1. 1
    Compare quotes and save $88 a month.

    State Farm’s full coverage is $88 per month below Chubb’s, and the closest rivals are GEICO at $6 more and AAA at $10 more. Use the same limits and deductible on every quote.

  2. 2
    Improve your credit and save $76 a month.

    A poor-credit driver pays $191/month at GEICO against $115/month with good credit. Request a new quote once your score improves: at good credit State Farm ($109) beats GEICO ($115).

  3. 3
    Bundle home and auto and save $800 a year.

    State Farm as New York’s cheapest home and auto bundle at $3,707 a year with an 18% discount. Allstate’s discount is larger at 19% but its bundle costs $508 more. Ask for the bundle quote because the discount isn’t automatic.

  4. 4
    Match coverage to your car and save $61 a month.

    Full coverage costs $61 more per month than minimum at State Farm. If your car is worth under a few thousand dollars and isn't leased or financed, dropping comprehensive and collision may be worth it. Just have enough money in an emergency fund to cover repairs.

  5. 5
    Re-shop when a violation ages off and save $56 a month.

    A DUI at State Farm costs $56 more per month than a clean record; GEICO’s costs $76 more. Quote 30 days before the three-year mark to capture lower rates as soon as you become eligible.

  6. 6
    Take a defensive driving course and cut your base rate by 10%.

    The discount lasts three years, applies to liability, no-fault and collision, and State Farm honors it for courses completed within the last three years.

Cheap New York Car Insurance: FAQ

Our Methodology

MoneyGeek analyzed rates from Quadrant Information Services across every residential ZIP code in New York for minimum and full coverage and for age and violation profiles. Customer experience scores in the tables reflect claims service. See best car insurance in New York for full scored rankings.

Baseline driver profile: 40-year-old male, clean record, good credit, 2012 Toyota Camry LE, 12,000 miles a year, 100/300/100 liability with a $1,000 deductible for full coverage. Minimum coverage reflects New York’s required limits, including $50,000 in personal injury protection and uninsured motorist coverage.

Young drivers: Ages 16 through 25 on a family policy, split by gender. New York uses gender as a rating factor.

Seniors: Aggregate of ages 65, 70, 80 and 85, same vehicle and coverage as the baseline.

Violations and poor credit: Baseline profile with one variable changed. New York permits credit-based insurance scores.

USAA: Excluded from our page because it's available only to military, veterans and immediate family, but they should include it in any quote comparison.

State notes: New York is a no-fault state and does not use SR-22 or FR-44.

About Mark Fitzpatrick


Mark Fitzpatrick, Licensed P&C Insurance Expert, MoneyGeek

Mark Fitzpatrick is a licensed Property and Casualty (P&C) Insurance Producer and MoneyGeek's resident expert in insurance and economics. In nearly a decade covering the insurance market at LendingTree and MoneyGeek, he's analyzed hundreds of carriers and millions of rates across auto, home, renters, health and life insurance.

His work has appeared in The Washington Post, The New York Times and NPR. He draws on independent cost and consumer experience data, and no insurance company partnerships affect his recommendations.

Mark studied at Boston College and later earned a master's in economics and international relations from Johns Hopkins University. He worked in financial risk management at State Street before joining MoneyGeek. He's also a five-time “Jeopardy!” champion.


Sources