How Much Does Umbrella Insurance Cost? Quotes by Limit, State and Household


Updated: November 10, 2026

Advertising & Editorial Disclosure

Key Takeaways
blueCheck icon

A $1 million umbrella policy costs an average of $408 a year (median $326). Across the ZIP areas we quoted, prices ran from $222 to $819.

blueCheck icon

Extra coverage costs less per million. $2 million costs 1.8 times the $1 million price and $5 million costs 3.15 times, so a $5 million policy averages $1,286 a year, or $257 per million.

blueCheck icon

Your ZIP code can change the price by anywhere from 1.5 3.7 times the base price.

blueCheck icon

A teen driver adds 131% to the average price, drivers over 70 add 44%, and one minor at-fault accident adds 32%.

blueCheck icon

The optional uninsured and underinsured motorist add-on averages $414 a year, about as much as the umbrella itself.

Umbrella Insurance Cost by Coverage Limit

The coverage limit is the biggest price decision you control, and going higher costs less than most people expect. Umbrella policies come in round-million limits, and the price does not rise in a straight line.

How Much a $1 Million Umbrella Policy Costs

A $1 million umbrella policy costs an average of $408 a year, or about $34 a month, with a median of $326. The average sits above the median because a handful of high-priced areas pull it up: half of the homeowners we priced pay $326 or less, while the priciest areas cost more than twice that. Depending on your ZIP area, the price ran from $222 to $819 for the same household.

Why Each Extra Million Costs Less

A $2 million policy costs 1.8 times as much as a $1 million policy, not twice as much. A $3 million policy costs 2.4 times as much and a $5 million policy costs 3.15 times as much. The ratios were identical in every ZIP area and for every household we tested.

The reason is risk: the chance that a claim reaches each additional million is smaller, so the increase in price from each extra million is marginally lower. The result is that the cost per million falls from $408 at the $1 million limit to $257 at the $5 million limit.

$1 million
$408
$326
1.00x
$408
$2 million
$735
$587
1.80x
$367
$3 million
$980
$782
2.40x
$327
$5 million
$1,286
$1,027
3.15x
$257

Umbrella Insurance Cost by State and ZIP Code

Where you live moves the price, and the ZIP code you live in can matter more than the state. Umbrella carriers set prices by the first three digits of your ZIP code, so two households in the same state can pay very different amounts.

Umbrella Insurance Cost in Specific States: California, Florida, Massachusetts and Texas

Among the four states MoneyGeek studied, Florida is the most expensive for a $1 million policy and Texas is the cheapest. Every state has a wide range inside it, so a state average tells you less than your own ZIP area does.

Florida
$607
$569
$432
$819
Massachusetts
$429
$426
$245
$496
California
$361
$326
$290
$425
Texas
$282
$269
$222
$357

Why Your ZIP Code Can Change the Price

The priciest ZIP area we quoted cost 3.7 times as much as the cheapest ($819 against $222) for the same household. Inside a single state the gap between the cheapest and most expensive areas ran from 1.5 times in California to 2 times in Massachusetts. Carriers price each area by the claims they expect there, so dense, high-cost or storm-exposed areas can cost more.

The pattern is not smooth, which is why a friend's quote is not a price for you. In Florida, Fort Lauderdale quoted $794 while nearby Miami and West Palm Beach quoted $819. In Texas, Houston sat at the top of the state at $357, while Austin and San Antonio were at $222. The table shows how far typical areas can be.

Lubbock (Texas)
$222
Shelburne Falls (Massachusetts)
$245
Santa Rosa (California)
$290
Wareham (Massachusetts)
$319
Dallas (Texas)
$323
San Jose (California)
$326
Houston (Texas)
$357
Los Angeles (California)
$425
Worcester (Massachusetts)
$426
Boston (Massachusetts)
$496
Tampa (Florida)
$569
Miami (Florida)
$819

What Raises the Cost of Umbrella Insurance

Your household changes the price as much as your address does. Carriers sort households into price tiers by counting drivers, cars and homes and by looking at driving records, and a teen driver, an accident or an older driver can push you into a pricier tier. The table shows what each change does to the $1 million price.

Two drivers, clean records (base)
$408
$326

(This is base price)

One minor at-fault accident
$538
$502
+32%
Both drivers over 70
$588
$552
+44%
Add a 17-year-old driver
$942
$879
+131%

Teen Drivers Add the Most

A newly licensed teen driver more than doubles the average price: from $408 to $942 for $1 million of coverage. It is the largest household effect we measured, and it applies at every coverage limit. Depending on the state, a teen raises the price by 75% to 187%.

$1 million
$408
$942
+$534
+131%
$2 million
$735
$1,695
+$960
+131%
$3 million
$980
$2,259
+$1,279
+131%
$5 million
$1,286
$2,965
+$1,679
+131%
Median at $1 million
$326
$879
+$553
+170%

Drivers Over 70 Cost More to Cover

Two drivers over 70 raise the average $1 million price by 44%, from $408 to $588. The increase runs from nothing in one state to 80% in another, because it depends on whether the carrier's cheapest tier is open to the household in the first place.

$1 million
$408
$588
+$180
+44%
$2 million
$735
$1,059
+$324
+44%
$3 million
$980
$1,411
+$431
+44%
$5 million
$1,286
$1,852
+$566
+44%
Median at $1 million
$326
$552
+$226
+69%

Accidents, Tickets and DUIs

A history of one minor at-fault accident raises the average price of an umbrella policy with $1 million in coverage limits by 32%, from $408 to $538, and the same percentage applies at higher limits. We tested a closed accident with property damage only, about $2,800 paid by the auto insurer and no injuries, 14 months earlier. The effect ranged from nothing in one state to 64% in another.

The bigger risk is eligibility. Online tools commonly ask whether you know of anything that could lead to a claim, and answering yes can end the instant quote. A serious violation matters even more: in the applications we reviewed, a DUI required higher underlying limits and was not eligible for drivers under 22 or over 79. If your record is not clean, you may have to get a quote through an agent.

$1 million
$408
$538
+$130
+32%
$2 million
$735
$968
+$233
+32%
$3 million
$980
$1,291
+$311
+32%
$5 million
$1,286
$1,694
+$408
+32%
Median at $1 million
$326
$502
+$176
+54%

Umbrella Add-Ons and Coverage You Need First

The umbrella price is not the whole bill. Three things change what you pay in total: the auto and home liability you have to carry first, the optional motorist add-on and what happens at renewal. Check all three before you compare quotes.

Underlying Auto and Home Liability You Must Carry First

An umbrella policy sits on top of your auto and home liability coverage, and carriers will not sell it unless you already carry minimum limits on those policies. The umbrella is written to pay only above the underlying limit the carrier requires, so if you carry less, you absorb the difference. For example, if a carrier requires $500,000 of auto liability and you carry $300,000, you cover the $200,000 gap yourself, and the umbrella pays only what exceeds the required $500,000. The required amounts vary by carrier, so ask before you shop, and price the cost of raising your underlying limits separately.

As a case study, here is what one standalone carrier, RLI, required in the online tool we used. Other carriers set their own minimums.

Auto liability, standard option
$500,000 per person, $500,000 per accident and $50,000 property damage, or $500,000 combined
Offered online in all four states; all prices on this page assume it
Auto liability, lower option
$250,000 per person, $500,000 per accident and $50,000 property damage, or $300,000 combined
Offered online in one state only; the price was 15% higher
Home liability
$300,000 per occurrence on your primary residence
Required in all four states
Other things you own
$300,000 for rentals and farms; $100,000 for recreational vehicles; $300,000 for watercraft
Required only if you own them; not priced in our study

Uninsured and Underinsured Motorist (UM/UIM) Coverage

Many carriers sell excess UM/UIM coverage as an optional add-on. It pays for your own medical bills and other losses when you are injured by a driver who has no insurance or not enough, after the UM/UIM coverage on your auto policy is used up. The add-on averaged $414 a year, about as much as the umbrella policy itself at $408, and ranged from $218 to $571 depending on the area. 

Why it is worth a second look: UM/UIM is priced separately from the umbrella and does not follow the umbrella price, so a cheap area for one can be an expensive area for the other. Check your auto policy's own UM/UIM limits before you add it.

Umbrella policy
$408
$222
$819
UM/UIM add-on
$414
$218
$571

Renewals and Cancellation

Your price can change at renewal even if nothing about you changes. In Florida, for example, the carrier in our case study was approved for a 13.8% rate increase in June 2023 and a base rate increase of about 24% effective January 1, 2024, according to Insurance Journal and the carrier's own notice to agents. A new teen driver, an accident or a birthday that puts a driver over 70 can also move you to a higher tier. If you cancel mid-term, some carriers reduce your refund: according to the application we reviewed, the carrier in our case study may reduce the return premium by up to 10% of the pro-rata amount, with exceptions by state.

How to Get an Umbrella Insurance Quote

You have three routes, and the best one depends on how complicated your household is. All three need the same basics, and your underlying limits decide whether you qualify at all.

From Your Current Home or Auto Insurer

Many home and auto insurers sell umbrella policies only on top of their own policies, and the quote usually comes by phone or through an agent. It is the easiest route if you want everything under one insurer, but you only see one price.

Through an Independent Agent

Standalone umbrella carriers often sell through independent agents. An agent can quote several carriers at once, which makes this the best route for households with a teen driver, an older driver, an accident or unusual exposures.

Online Through a Standalone Carrier

Some standalone carriers let you get an instant estimate online. RLI's tool, which we used for this study, is one example. Our tests took 1 to 2 minutes and 8 to 11 screens, the tool did not ask for a Social Security number, driver's license number or phone number, and it showed every limit from $1 million to $5 million at once. The result is an estimate subject to underwriting, not an offer.

What to Have Ready for a Quote

Whichever route you choose, expect the same questions. The table follows the order of the online tool we used.

Names, address, email and start date
Sets the ZIP-area price
Each driver's birth date, violations, accidents and DUIs
Sets your tier and whether you qualify
Number of cars, homes, watercraft and acres
Sets your tier and any flat charges
The auto and home liability limits you carry
Decides which underlying option you qualify for
A few yes/no eligibility questions
A "yes" to any can end the instant quote
mglogo icon
MONEYGEEK EXPERT TIP

Get the same limit quoted two ways, once through an agent and once online or through your current insurer. If you bundle auto and home with the same insurer, see if your insurer will provide further discounts for an umbrella policy.

How to Pay Less for Umbrella Insurance

You cannot change your ZIP code, but you can control the limit, your underlying coverage and the add-ons. This is one way for you to control the cost of your policy, although buying less coverage will mean fewer protections in the event you need to make a claim.

Match the Limit to What You Own

Each extra million costs less than the first, but the total still climbs: going from $1 million to $5 million adds $878 a year on average. A limit well above your net worth and future earnings buys protection you may never use. See our guide on how much umbrella insurance you need to size it.

$2 million
+$327
+$261
$3 million
+$572
+$456
$5 million
+$878
+$701

Carry Higher Underlying Limits if You Can

Carriers that offer a lower underlying option usually charge more for it. In our case study the lower option cost 15% more, which means the standard option cost about 13% less. Compare that saving with the cost of raising your auto liability first.

Compare Standalone and Bundled Quotes

We only quoted standalone pricing, so our study cannot tell you whether bundling is cheaper. Get one standalone quote and one bundled quote for the same limit and the same underlying coverage.

Know When a Young-Driver Charge Ends

A teen driver is the biggest household cost we measured, adding 75% to 187% to the price. In the one state rate sheet we reviewed, the youth class ended after six years of driving experience, and a learner's permit did not count as experience. Ask your agent when the charge drops off.

Skip Add-Ons You Do Not Need

UM/UIM is optional and can cost as much as the umbrella. Check your auto policy's own UM/UIM limits first, then decide whether the add-on fills a real gap.

Is Umbrella Insurance Worth the Cost?

For most households that own a home, savings or future income worth protecting, yes. At an average of $408 a year, $1 million of liability protection costs about $1.12 a day. Umbrella insurance covers liability to others, not damage to your own home or car, and it pays after your auto or home liability limits are used up.

Frequently Asked Questions About Umbrella Insurance Cost

We collected 173 online quotes from RLI Insurance Company's consumer quote tool for a sample household: two married adults born in 1981 and 1983, two cars, one owned home, clean driving records, a December 1, 2026 start date, $300,000 of home liability and RLI's standard underlying auto liability option. We stopped at the quote screen and never bought a policy. Prices are RLI's annual price shown, an estimate subject to underwriting; its screens listed no separate fees or taxes.

We quoted 100 three-digit ZIP areas across California (37), Florida (20), Massachusetts (18) and Texas (25), chosen by homeowner counts from the Census Bureau's American Community Survey (2020 to 2024). The areas hold 85% to 100% of each state's homeowners. The four states are a chosen sample, not a national picture, and results for other carriers or other states may differ.

Overall averages and medians combine all quoted areas, with each area counted in proportion to its homeowners. The median is the price paid by the middle homeowner. Averages are the lead figure; medians are shown beside them.

Limits: one carrier and one household; underlying coverage at one option; UM/UIM excluded from all prices; and we did not test extra cars, extra homes, rentals, watercraft, DUIs or bundled policies.

About Mark Fitzpatrick


Mark Fitzpatrick, Licensed P&C Insurance Expert, MoneyGeek

Mark Fitzpatrick is a licensed Property and Casualty (P&C) Insurance Producer and MoneyGeek's resident expert in insurance and economics. In nearly a decade covering the insurance market at LendingTree and MoneyGeek, he's analyzed hundreds of carriers and millions of rates across auto, home, renters, health and life insurance.

His work has appeared in The Washington Post, The New York Times and NPR. He draws on independent cost and consumer experience data, and no insurance company partnerships affect his recommendations.

Mark studied at Boston College and later earned a master's in economics and international relations from Johns Hopkins University. He worked in financial risk management at State Street before joining MoneyGeek. He's also a five-time “Jeopardy!” champion.