Pick by what you need, not by brand. Each row is a different situation with a different best answer, and the last column says what we could not check.
Best Umbrella Insurance Companies
The best umbrella insurance company depends on what you already carry and how much you need, so our picks follow your situation. For a fast online quote, we pick RLI. To bundle with an agent, State Farm. If you would rather not raise your auto limits much, GEICO. For limits above $5 million, Chubb or Farmers.

Updated: November 12, 2026
Advertising & Editorial Disclosure
RLI is our pick for a quick online quote. In our 173 quotes, a $1 million policy averaged $408 a year and the tool returned an instant estimate in 1 to 2 minutes.
GEICO is our pick if you do not want to raise your auto limits much. It requires $300,000 per person and per accident, $200,000 less than RLI's standard option.
State Farm is our pick if you want an agent to handle your auto, home and umbrella together.
Chubb and Farmers are our picks for limits above $5 million. Chubb says its limits run up to $100 million, and Farmers sells up to $10 million in most states.
If you have a teen driver or a blemished record, shop through an independent agent. We have not priced any company for those households, so we do not name one.
Our Picks at a Glance
Fast online quote | RLI | Whether RLI is cheaper than competitors |
Bundle with an agent | State Farm | Price; underlying limits not published online |
Do not want to raise auto limits much | GEICO | Price; confirm which company underwrites your policy |
Limits above $5 million | Chubb or Farmers | Price and underlying requirements for both |
Best for a Fast Online Quote: RLI
If you want a price in minutes without calling anyone, RLI is the carrier we know best. We ran 173 quotes through its online tool, so we can say what it charges by ZIP area, what changes the price and what it requires from you.

RLI Insurance
Why we Pick RLI
The quote is instant and light on personal information: ours took 1 to 2 minutes and 8 to 11 screens, with no Social Security number, driver's license number or phone number, and the tool showed every limit from $1 million to $5 million at once. The pricing is also predictable. RLI prices by three-digit ZIP area, a quote at a different ZIP code in the same area returned the identical price every time, and its published Massachusetts rate sheet matched our quotes to the dollar in all 18 areas.
It is financially strong, too. A.M. Best upgraded RLI to A++ (Superior) in February 2026, and A.M. Best put RLI's policyholder surplus at $1.9 billion at the end of the third quarter of 2025. For a policy you hope never to use, that matters more than a few dollars of premium.
What to Know About RLI
A $1 million policy averaged $408 a year (median $326), with prices from $222 to $819 by ZIP area. A teen driver added 131% to the average price, drivers over 70 added 44% and one minor accident added 32%. The standard underlying auto option requires $500,000 per person, $500,000 per accident and $50,000 of property damage, which is above any state's legal minimum.
The instant quote has limits. A DUI requires higher underlying limits and was not available to drivers under 22 or over 79, according to RLI's underwriting guide for agents, and a broad "yes" on its eligibility questions ended the online quote. We also cannot say whether RLI is cheaper than another carrier, because we priced only RLI.
Best to Bundle With an Agent: State Farm
If your auto and home are already with State Farm and you like your agent, its umbrella is the simplest route. State Farm sells a personal liability umbrella policy with a $1 million minimum that you can raise in $1 million steps, and its page sends you to an agent for a quote.

State Farm
Why We Pick State Farm
The argument is convenience that also solves a real problem. An umbrella carrier has to confirm that you carry its minimum underlying limits, and an agent who already writes your auto and home policies can see what you have and tell you what to raise. One agent also means one contact when a claim touches more than one policy.
What to Know About State Farm
State Farm says all coverages are subject to minimum underlying insurance requirements, so check with your agent what is required to get a policy. State Farm does not offer standalone quotes online so you'll have to contact an agent to compare prices to your other umbrella options.
Best If You Have Low Limits on Your Auto Policy: GEICO
The liability coverage on your auto policy is the part that pays when you injure someone else in a crash. Before an insurer will sell you an umbrella, which is extra liability protection on top of your auto and home policies, it requires you to carry a minimum amount of that coverage. GEICO’s minimum is $300,000. RLI’s is $500,000. If your auto policy already has $300,000, GEICO is the umbrella you can buy without changing your auto policy.

GEICO
Who This Pick Is For
This pick is for homeowners with a middle-sized auto policy and more to lose than that policy would cover. Say you own a home and have savings, and your auto policy pays up to $300,000 if you cause a crash. A serious lawsuit could cost far more than $300,000, and an umbrella would pay the difference.
Not sure what your auto policy carries? Look at the summary page at the front of your policy, under bodily injury liability. If it says $300,000 per person and $300,000 per accident, or 300/300, this pick fits you.
Why We Pick GEO
GEICO requires you to already carry:
- At least $300,000 per person and $300,000 per accident of bodily injury liability on your auto policy.
- $100,000 of property damage liability on your auto policy.
- $300,000 of personal liability on your home or renters policy.
RLI requires $500,000 per person and per accident on your auto policy. A driver with $300,000 would have to buy $200,000 more auto coverage before RLI would sell them an umbrella, and that extra coverage costs money. With GEICO, that driver buys the umbrella and nothing else changes.
You might wonder why you wouldn’t just raise your auto policy’s limit instead of buying an umbrella. An auto policy only protects you in a crash. An umbrella sits above your auto policy and your home policy, so the same $1 million also pays if a guest is badly hurt at your house.
What to Know About GEICO
GEICO’s advantage works only for drivers near $300,000. If your auto policy already has $500,000 or more, you meet both insurers’ requirements and GEICO’s lower number saves you nothing. If it has less than $300,000, you have to add coverage with either one.
GEICO’s property damage requirement is higher than RLI’s: $100,000 against $50,000. Check that your auto policy meets it.
GEICO says its umbrella policies may be underwritten by GEICO General Insurance Company, Government Employees Insurance Company or even RLI Insurance Company, so in certain situations GEICO could pass your business to RLI instead. Ask which company would underwrite yours, because that decides who handles your claims.
GEICO does not offer online umbrella quotes, so you’ll need to get a quote from an agent.
Best for Limits Above $5 Million: Chubb and Farmers
If your net worth is in the many millions, a $5 million limit may not be enough, and the pick changes. Most standalone online tools stop at $5 million, so look at carriers that write higher limits.

Chubb
Chubb markets itself to affluent households and says its personal umbrella limits run from $1 million to $100 million, far beyond the standard $1 million to $5 million range. Limit is the whole argument: a policy sized to a very large net worth is a different product, and a carrier built for that market is the sensible place to start. Chubb sells its personal insurance through independent agents and brokers, so expect to buy that way, and ask what underlying limits it requires.
Farmers
Farmers sells umbrella coverage in $1 million increments up to $10 million, with available limits varying by state. That makes it a good second option if you need more than $5 million but not a very large policy, and it works well if you already use a Farmers agent.
How to Choose an Umbrella Insurance Carrier
Use the same five checks on every carrier, and compare quotes for the same limit so you are comparing price and not coverage.
Match the Carrier to Your Situation
For $1 million to $5 million, standalone and bundled carriers all compete. For a net worth above that, look at carriers that write higher limits.
Compare the Underlying Coverage Required
Ask what auto and home liability you must carry first, then price raising your limits. That cost is separate from the umbrella and can decide which carrier is cheapest in total.
Check Financial Strength
Look up the carrier's A.M. Best rating. An umbrella pays after your other policies, so the insurer's ability to pay a large claim matters.
Ask Who Underwrites the Policy
Some carriers sell policies underwritten by a partner, as GEICO does. Ask who underwrites yours and who handles claims.
Compare Two or Three Quotes
Get one through your current insurer, one through an agent and one online. Prices follow your ZIP area and your household, so a friend's price is not yours.
Before you request any umbrella quote, ask your auto insurer what it would cost to raise your bodily injury liability to $300,000 and to $500,000. The gap between those two prices can decide whether GEICO's lower requirement or RLI's online speed is the better deal.
Frequently Asked Questions About Umbrella Insurance Companies
It depends on your situation. We pick RLI for a fast online quote, State Farm for bundling with an agent, GEICO if you do not want to raise your auto limits much and Chubb or Farmers for limits above $5 million. Quote at least two.
We cannot say, because we priced only one carrier. A $1 million policy from RLI averaged $408 a year across the areas we quoted, with prices from $222 to $819 by ZIP area.
Yes, as long as you meet the underlying limits that carrier requires. Standalone carriers sell umbrella policies on top of whatever auto and home coverage you have.
We did not test bundles. Get one bundled quote and one standalone quote for the same limit and compare.
GEICO says its policies may be underwritten by GEICO General Insurance Company, Government Employees Insurance Company or RLI Insurance Company, an unaffiliated partner.
We looked at how you buy, coverage limits, underlying requirements, who underwrites the policy, financial strength and, where we have it, price. We priced only RLI, and the other picks rest on each carrier's own published materials and on the logic of the situation. We name a pick only where the evidence supports an argument, and we say where it does not. We have not researched every umbrella carrier and will add more as we do.
About Mark Fitzpatrick

Mark Fitzpatrick is a licensed Property and Casualty (P&C) Insurance Producer and MoneyGeek's resident expert in insurance and economics. In nearly a decade covering the insurance market at LendingTree and MoneyGeek, he's analyzed hundreds of carriers and millions of rates across auto, home, renters, health and life insurance.
His work has appeared in The Washington Post, The New York Times and NPR. He draws on independent cost and consumer experience data, and no insurance company partnerships affect his recommendations.
Mark studied at Boston College and later earned a master's in economics and international relations from Johns Hopkins University. He worked in financial risk management at State Street before joining MoneyGeek. He's also a five-time “Jeopardy!” champion.
