Best Medicare Supplement Plans in Arkansas (2026)

Aetna is a well-known national insurer with a solid presence in Arkansas’s Medicare Supplement market. The company offers four Medigap plans and stands out for delivering some of the lowest prices in the state for popular options.

For Plan A, Aetna leads the market with a $152 monthly premium, which is $54 lower than many competing carriers. Its Plan N pricing is also among the most affordable in Arkansas at $111 per month, offering an average savings of $64. Across Plans A, F, G, and N, monthly premiums range from $50 to $238, giving seniors flexibility based on coverage needs and budget.

Beyond pricing, Aetna adds value through wellness programs and discounts on health-related services that can help lower everyday healthcare costs. With an A (Excellent) rating from AM Best, the company combines financial strength with the resources and support expected from a large national insurer.

Globe Life has been providing insurance coverage for decades and remains an active player in Arkansas’s Medicare Supplement market. The company stands out for Plan B pricing, offering the lowest rate in the state at $291 per month, which is roughly $16 less than what many other insurers charge.

Seniors can choose from six Medigap plans: A, B, C, F, G, and N. Monthly premiums fall between $55 and $343, depending on the plan selected and the enrollee’s age, giving policyholders a range of coverage and price points to consider.

Globe Life may appeal to those who prefer a more straightforward enrollment process, as some applications can be completed without medical underwriting. With an A (Excellent) rating from AM Best, the company shows the financial strength needed to support policyholders over time.

New Era offers six Medicare Supplement plans in Arkansas, including A, C, F, G, M, and N. Monthly premiums for 65-year-olds range from $44 to $283, depending on the plan selected. The company leads Plan C pricing at $212 per month, which is $132 lower than comparable options, and lists Plan M at $129 monthly. 

Members can choose from a broad network of health care providers, which supports flexibility when selecting doctors and specialists. New Era holds an A- (Excellent) rating from AM Best, reflecting solid financial strength.

State Farm brings a well-established national presence to Arkansas’s Medicare Supplement market, offering six plan options that cover many of the most widely chosen Medigap policies. The company leads Plan D pricing in the state at $174 per month, which is $114 lower than the Arkansas average and appeals to seniors looking for comprehensive coverage under this plan type.

Across Plans A, C, D, F, G and N, State Farm sets monthly premiums for 65-year-olds between $130 and $327. This range allows seniors to choose between lower-cost options and more comprehensive coverage based on their needs. With an A++ (Superior) rating from AM Best, State Farm shows exceptional financial strength and long-term claims-paying ability.

MedMutual Protect delivers exceptional value across five Medicare Supplement plans in Arkansas: A, D, F, G and N. The company leads the state for Plan F at just $191 monthly, saving you $99 below state averages. MedMutual also offers competitive rates for Plan G at $168 monthly and Plan N at $123 monthly. Premiums range from $54 for high-deductible Plan G to $333 for Plan D, which is higher than the state average. MedMutual uses Community Pricing across all plans, keeping rates stable regardless of age.

Wellcare offers competitively priced Medicare Supplement coverage in Arkansas, led by a Plan G premium of $168 per month. The company provides four Medigap plans, with monthly premiums ranging from $132 for Plan N to $207 for Plan F.

Premiums remain consistent regardless of age under community-rated pricing. While Wellcare keeps rates affordable, the company holds a B (Fair) rating from AM Best, which reflects moderate financial strength and claims-paying capacity.

QualChoice offers six Medicare Supplement plans in Arkansas, including A, F, G, K, and N, along with a high-deductible Plan F. The company leads Plan K pricing at $92 per month, which is $24 below the Arkansas average.

Plan K covers 50% of most cost-sharing and includes an annual out-of-pocket limit, which may appeal to healthier seniors who want lower premiums. Standard Plan F costs more than the state average, while monthly premiums across all plans range from $86 for high-deductible Plan F to $366 for standard Plan F. All policies use community-rated pricing, so rates do not change based on age.

United American offers one of the widest Medicare Supplement lineups in Arkansas, with nine available plan types, including high-deductible versions of Plans F and G. The only standard plan missing from its portfolio is Plan M, which remains limited to a single carrier in the state.

Monthly premiums begin at $63 for high-deductible plans and reach $377 for Plan C. United American leads Plan L pricing at $224 per month, coming in $9 below the Arkansas average. All plans use community-rated pricing, covering options from basic Plans A and B to more comprehensive coverage under Plan F.