Cheapest Health Insurance in Wyoming (2026)

Only two carriers write individual marketplace policies anywhere in Wyoming: Blue Cross Blue Shield and UnitedHealthcare. That's what statewide plan data shows, and it makes Wyoming one of the most constrained health insurance markets in the country. A thin, spread-out population is the reason why: insurers need a certain volume to make coverage profitable, and rural Wyoming rarely clears that bar for a third or fourth entrant.

$1,032 a month buys the cheaper of Wyoming's two options, Blue Cross Blue Shield. Go with UnitedHealthcare instead and the bill comes to $1,177 a month. A $145 gap separates them, and in a two-carrier state, that's the only price comparison that exists.

There's no carrier decision to agonize over in Wyoming. Only two exist, and picking between them is nearly automatic on price alone. Pick the right metal tier and plan type within Blue Cross Blue Shield's lineup, since that carrier comes out cheapest in almost every category measured here.

Two providers cover Wyoming's entire health insurance market, and one clearly beats the other on price. At $1,032 a month, Blue Cross Blue Shield has the cheapest health insurance in the state, $54 below the statewide average. UnitedHealthcare costs $1,177 a month instead. Budget-conscious residents come out ahead with Blue Cross Blue Shield across most categories, thanks to that price gap.

* We determine average monthly costs by rounding the mean of all monthly plan rates for each provider in Wyoming. We calculate average monthly savings by comparing each provider's average rate against the statewide average to demonstrate the cost difference below the state benchmark. 

A $145 monthly gap, or $1,740 a year, separates the two providers. UnitedHealthcare only wins on price in one category, EPO plans, according to MoneyGeek's data. Residents who need PPO access, or who fall into any age-based demographic, will consistently find Blue Cross Blue Shield cheaper.

Pick the best health insurance provider based on your age, plan type and metal tier. Balance monthly costs against deductibles and out-of-pocket limits.

Blue Cross Blue Shield has the most affordable rates across most demographics in Wyoming. Those lower premiums come with higher deductibles and maximum out-of-pocket costs.

* These are average rates for all plan types and metal levels, with teens at 18 years old, young adults at 26 years old, adults at 40 years old and seniors at 60 years old. For plan type costs, we used average rates for 40-year-olds. 

Blue Cross Blue Shield wins every age category on this page except one: EPO plans, where UnitedHealthcare averages $1,170 monthly versus Blue Cross Blue Shield's PPO average of $1,070.

The $1,632 gap between children's coverage ($641 monthly) and senior coverage ($2,273 monthly) is real. Wyoming seniors pay 3.5 times what children pay for Blue Cross Blue Shield coverage. That spread is driven entirely by age rating, not plan quality or coverage differences.

Wyoming 40-year-olds pay $769 monthly for Blue Cross Blue Shield Bronze plans or $849 for Expanded Bronze. Silver costs $1,070 per month. 

Gold costs $980 monthly with a $2,000 deductible, making it cheaper per month than Silver but requiring you to cover that deductible before insurance pays claims. Wyoming doesn't sell Platinum plans.

Our comprehensive Wyoming data allows you to find options that suit your situation and budget. 

Gold beats Silver outright for a 40-year-old in Wyoming's rate data. Gold costs $980 a month against Silver's $1,070, a $90 monthly savings. Gold's deductible comes in lower too, at $2,000 versus Silver's $2,776. Silver doesn't compete with Gold on either number here.

For residents who expect moderate health care use, Gold returns lower monthly premiums and lower cost-sharing. Wyoming doesn't sell Platinum plans, so Gold is the highest tier available and the strongest fit for residents who see specialists regularly or take ongoing prescriptions. 

A 40-year-old who switches from Silver to Gold saves $90 per month while lowering their deductible by $776. Compare Blue Cross Blue Shield plans to see your Gold-tier rate.

We've collected statewide data for Wyoming to help you filter options based on your unique situation and budget.

Blue Cross Blue Shield is the default starting point for most Wyoming residents shopping on the marketplace. It leads on affordability in every age category and every metal tier except EPO plans.  

My recommendation: start with Blue Cross Blue Shield's Gold-tier plan if you see a doctor more than twice a year or take regular prescriptions. The $90 monthly savings over Silver, combined with a lower deductible, makes Gold the stronger value for moderate health care users. 

UnitedHealthcare is worth considering only if you specifically need EPO coverage and are comfortable with its narrower network structure. For every other buyer, Blue Cross Blue Shield wins on price.

MoneyGeek gathered plan data directly from the federal Health Insurance Marketplace for Wyoming, covering all available individual plans from Blue Cross Blue Shield and UnitedHealthcare. We collected premiums, deductibles and maximum out-of-pocket figures for ages 18, 26, 40, 50 and 60 across every metal tier and plan type offered in the state. 

Our analysis centered on 40-year-old profiles because this age group sits at Wyoming's demographic midpoint and allows direct comparison across plans. Age-specific rankings used the corresponding age profile for each category. Plans with lower monthly premiums carry higher deductibles and out-of-pocket maximums, which affects total annual costs when you need care.