Cheap Motorcycle Insurance: The Most Affordable Motorcycle Insurance Companies and Policies for 2021

With summer riding season in full swing, we analyzed the data to help you find the cheapest motorcycle insurance. MoneyGeek analyzed quotes from major motorcycle insurance providers across all 50 states to help you find the most affordable motorcycle insurance that will fit your needs.

By  
  |  

Choosing an insurance plan for your motorcycle can be difficult, especially when price is a factor. Finding the right policy is important, but how do you find an affordable policy that provides the coverage you need? MoneyGeek has put together a list of the cheapest motorcycle insurance companies available based on our quote data, allowing you to compare coverage and decide which plan is the right one for you.

Table of Contents

The Cheapest Motorcycle Insurance Companies

MoneyGeek has collected motorcycle insurance quotes across all 50 states to determine which companies provide the most affordable motorcycle insurance. We also included quotes for multiple types of bikes and different levels of coverage to make sure we have the most accurate and comprehensive information available. Our research includes quote data for full coverage policies and liability-only coverage, and we have used this information to compile a list of the best companies for motorcycle insurance.

Our MoneyGeek rankings can help you find the best possible coverage to meet your needs. For example, if you are financing your motorcycle, your bank will likely require you to carry full coverage insurance. In that case, you’ll want to review the information about full coverage options when choosing which policy is the right one for you.

The Best Cheap Motorcycle Insurance Overall: Progressive

To find the cheapest motorcycle insurance companies in the country, MoneyGeek analyzed quotes across all 50 states for policies with 50/100/25 coverage and a $500 deductible for comprehensive and collision. The rider profile was a 40-year-old male with a good driving record riding a Honda Rebel 500.

MoneyGeek ranks insurance companies based on their affordability, reliability and customer service ratings. Based on these categories, Progressive is the highest-ranking company we reviewed and is the best overall choice for cheap motorcycle insurance.

The Best Overall Motorcycle Companies

Scroll for more

swipe icon
  • Company
    Full Coverage Monthly Premium
    Full Coverage Annual Premium
    MoneyGeek Rating
  • Progressive
    $22
    $267
    97
  • Dairyland
    $22
    $267
    91
  • Harley-Davidson
    $25
    $302
    87
  • GEICO
    $28
    $336
    84
  • Markel
    $35
    $419
    85
  • Nationwide
    $55
    $658
    73

Best Cheap Overall: Progressive

Progressive

pros

This is an icon

Offers add-on coverage for newer bikes that are totaled, giving customers the full MSRP for a new motorcycle, minus their deductible.

This is an icon

Bundling discounts help people who insure their home, car, boat or other property with the company can earn a discount.

cons

This is an icon

Policies are not as specialized as some of their competitors.

This is an icon

Compared to competitors, Progressive receives average customer service ratings.

COMPANY HIGHLIGHTS

According to our research, Progressive offers low rates and multiple coverage options, making it the best cheap motorcycle insurance company. Progressive sells motorcycle insurance in all 50 states. They also provide full replacement cost and no depreciation for parts in the event of a covered accident. Plus, they have multiple discounts available, including a motorcycle safety course discount and a discount for paying your policy in full. Additionally, Progressive allows you to add coverage for almost any personal property you have with you on your motorcycle if it's damaged or stolen, including cell phones, camping equipment, helmets and other safety gear.

The Best Cheap Liability-Only Motorcycle Insurance: Progressive

If you can afford to replace your bike out of pocket, a liability-only policy can be an excellent way to save money on motorcycle insurance. Liability coverage is the part of your policy that pays for medical and property damage you cause to other people in an at-fault accident and is required by law in almost every state. Comprehensive and collision coverage, often referred to as full coverage when paired with liability, pays for damages to your bike in case of events like theft or if your bike gets knocked over.

If your bike is older, fully paid for, and you can afford to replace it if it is damaged or stolen, choosing a liability-only policy could save you money on your insurance. Progressive offers the most affordable liability-only policy, followed by GEICO.

Best Liability-Only Motorcycle Insurance

Scroll for more

swipe icon
  • Company
    Average Monthly Premium
    Average Annual Premium
    MoneyGeek Rating
  • Progressive
    $9
    $108
    97
  • GEICO
    $11
    $126
    84
  • Markel
    $11
    $133
    85
  • Nationwide
    $13
    $158
    73
  • Dairyland
    $14
    $162
    91
  • Harley-Davidson
    $14
    $166
    87

The cheapest liability-only policies were determined by analyzing quotes for 50/100/25 liability-only coverage across all 50 states.

Best Cheap Liability Insurance: Progressive

Progressive

pros

This is an icon

Covers riders in all 50 states.

This is an icon

Offers a wide range of discounts and protections.

cons

This is an icon

Compared to competitors, has less specialized policies.

This is an icon

Receives average customer service ratings from J.D. Power.

COMPANY HIGHLIGHTS

When it comes to liability-only coverage, Progressive offers riders the least expensive monthly premiums of any company we surveyed. In addition to low rates, they also received the highest MoneyGeek rating of any provider, which isn’t too surprising, considering their title as our best overall pick for motorcycle insurance. Riders can save $58 per month by choosing Progressive over the most expensive provider, Harley-Davidson.

Cheapest Motorcycle Insurance for Younger Riders: Dairyland

Younger riders pay significantly higher rates for motorcycle insurance, and for good reason — the most significant factor that insurance companies consider when determining your rates is your riding history. Unfortunately, being young automatically means you have less experience riding and no record to prove you can ride without getting a ticket or being in an accident. In fact, some insurance companies won’t insure riders under the age of 18 at all, so 16-year-old and 17-year-old riders may have difficulty finding a policy that works for them. Even 21-year-old riders can pay significantly higher rates than older riders.

MoneyGeek analyzed rates from major companies to help young motorcyclists find options for affordable insurance. The cheapest motorcycle insurance for young riders was determined by analyzing quotes for 18-year-old riders with a 50/100/25 full coverage policy and a $500 deductible for comprehensive and collision coverage. Based on these quotes, we found that Dairyland is the least expensive provider for younger riders.

Average Motorcycle Insurance Cost for Young Riders

Scroll for more

swipe icon
  • Company
    Full Coverage Premium for 18-Year-Old
  • 1.
    Dairyland
    $598
  • 2.
    Progressive
    $741
  • 3.
    GEICO
    $753
  • 4.
    Markel
    $1,797
  • 5.
    Nationwide
    $1,883

Cheapest for Young Riders: Dairyland

Dairyland

pros

This is an icon

Offers roadside assistance that could be useful for teen riders.

This is an icon

Provides discount for taking a motorcycle safety course.

cons

This is an icon

Coverage isn’t available in every state.

This is an icon

Receives more complaints than companies of a similar size.

COMPANY HIGHLIGHTS

Dairyland has the most affordable insurance for young riders, saving teens and young adults more than $100 per year on full coverage than Progressive, the next cheapest policy on our list.

Cheapest Motorcycle Coverage for Sport Bikes: GEICO

It costs significantly more to insure a higher-risk sport bike, largely because sport bikes are faster than standard motorcycles and popular among younger riders, both of which increase the likelihood of filing a claim. Comparing quotes from multiple companies can save you hundreds or even thousands of dollars on insurance for sport bikes.

The quotes below are for a 40-year-old with a good driving record riding a 2021 Honda CBR1000RR. Rates are for a 50/100/25 full coverage policy. Based on these sample costs, GEICO offers the lowest premiums for sports bikes.

Average Annual Premiums for Sport Bikes

Scroll for more

swipe icon
  • Company
    Full Coverage
    Liability-Only
  • GEICO
    $2,620
    $236
  • Nationwide
    $2,708
    $223
  • Dairyland
    $3,237
    $521
  • Progressive
    $3,790
    $420
  • Markel
    $7,137
    $308

Cheapest for Sports Bikes: GEICO

GEICO

pros

This is an icon

Policy may include coverage for accessories, comprehensive, collision, liability, uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage and towing and labor.

This is an icon

Offers a broad range of discounts to riders.

cons

This is an icon

Provider has lower customer service ratings than some of the other motorcycle insurance companies included in MoneyGeek's rankings.

This is an icon

If you prefer a local agent, keep in mind that GEICO only handles its policies online or over the phone.

COMPANY HIGHLIGHTS

GEICO offers the cheapest full coverage insurance policy for sport bikes, saving you between $100 and $4,500 annually compared to the other companies on our list.

Cheapest Motorcycle Coverage by State

Because of differences in local laws and regulations, insurance rates can vary significantly from state to state. Comparing quotes for motorcycle insurance based on your location can help you get the most accurate rates possible.

Scroll for more

swipe icon
  • State
    Company
    Full Coverage Premium
  • Alabama
    Progressive
    $174
  • Alaska
    Progressive
    $158
  • Arizona
    Dairyland
    $246
  • Arkansas
    Dairyland
    $188
  • California
    GEICO
    $210
  • Colorado
    Dairyland
    $230
  • Connecticut
    Dairyland
    $188
  • Delaware
    Harley-Davidson
    $247
  • Florida
    Progressive
    $200
  • Georgia
    Dairyland
    $271
  • Hawaii
    GEICO
    $236
  • Idaho
    Dairyland
    $233
  • Illinois
    Progressive
    $305
  • Indiana
    Dairyland
    $162
  • Iowa
    GEICO
    $132
  • Kansas
    Dairyland
    $115
  • Kentucky
    Dairyland
    $254
  • Louisiana
    GEICO
    $336
  • Maine
    Progressive
    $185
  • Maryland
    Dairyland
    $175
  • Massachusetts
    Progressive
    $273
  • Michigan
    Progressive
    $376
  • Minnesota
    Progressive
    $146
  • Mississippi
    Dairyland
    $276
  • Missouri
    Progressive
    $307
  • Montana
    GEICO
    $115
  • Nebraska
    GEICO
    $284
  • Nevada
    Progressive
    $263
  • New Hampshire
    GEICO
    $167
  • New Jersey
    Progressive
    $457
  • New Mexico
    Progressive
    $210
  • New York
    Progressive
    $183
  • North Carolina
    Harley-Davidson
    $179
  • North Dakota
    Harley-Davidson
    $134
  • Ohio
    GEICO
    $141
  • Oklahoma
    Progressive
    $249
  • Oregon
    Dairyland
    $233
  • Pennsylvania
    Progressive
    $181
  • Rhode Island
    Dairyland
    $211
  • South Carolina
    Progressive
    $249
  • South Dakota
    Dairyland
    $152
  • Tennessee
    Dairyland
    $226
  • Texas
    Dairyland
    $205
  • Utah
    Dairyland
    $209
  • Vermont
    Harley-Davidson
    $219
  • Virginia
    Progressive
    $258
  • Washington
    Markel
    $179
  • West Virginia
    Dairyland
    $268
  • Wisconsin
    Progressive
    $168
  • Wyoming
    Progressive
    $139

Your location can significantly impact your insurance rates, in part because each state has its own laws regarding motorcycle and auto insurance. Rates can even vary from ZIP code to ZIP code, depending on population, the number of accidents that happen in a given year, the number of reported motorcycle thefts in an area and much more. These factors can cause your insurance rates to go up or down even if you only move a few blocks, so it's essential to get a quote for your policy based on your correct address.

How to Get Cheap Motorcycle Insurance That Meets Your Needs

There are several steps to follow when deciding which motorcycle insurance coverage is right for you, including:

1

Decide How Much Coverage You Need

Before you purchase a policy, it is important to know exactly how much motorcycle insurance you need. Every rider should have liability coverage, not only because it is required by law in almost every state but also because it is the coverage that protects you financially if you harm another person or their property. MoneyGeek recommends always choosing the highest level of liability coverage that you can afford.

Beyond liability insurance, there are many other types of coverage to choose from, including:

  • Comprehensive and Collision: Often called full coverage insurance, comprehensive and collision coverage pays for damage to your motorcycle. Collision coverage applies when you hit another vehicle or a stationary object. Comprehensive coverage applies in situations outside of a standard accident, including fire, theft, flooding or if your motorcycle gets tipped over, to name a few.
  • Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist (UM/UIM): If you are hit by someone uninsured or underinsured, your UM/UIM coverage will help pay for your medical expenses and damage to your property.
  • Accessory/Optional Equipment Coverage: This is the coverage that pays for damages to your motorcycle accessories like your helmet and crash bars.
  • Roadside Assistance: Like roadside assistance for cars, this coverage is there to help if your motorcycle breaks down, you need a tow, your battery dies or you have a flat tire.
  • Guest/Passenger Liability: Unlike auto insurance, motorcycle insurance doesn’t automatically come with medical coverage for passengers on your bike. Guest/passenger liability coverage is an add-on benefit that pays for medical bills for your passenger if you are in an at-fault accident.
2

Figure Out Which Discounts Might Apply to You

Almost every motorcycle insurance company offers a handful of discounts, including:

  • Multi-policy/bundling discount
  • Responsible driver discount
  • Motorcycle association discount
  • Safety course discount
  • Experienced rider discount
  • Homeowner discount
  • Multi-cycle discount

Each company offers its own unique discounts, so it is important to look at all of the discounts available to you when researching which policy to buy.

3

Compare Quotes

Comparing quotes from multiple insurance companies is the only way to know you’re getting the best possible rate for your motorcycle coverage. Getting multiple quotes can help keep your rates low, but it is important to do your research when choosing a policy. Just because a policy is the cheapest option doesn’t mean it is the right coverage for you, so make sure you choose the most affordable policy that meets all your needs.

4

Choose the Right Policy for You

Insurance policies offer a variety of coverage options. Every insurance company tailors its coverage to a specific market, which means not every policy will be the right one for you. For example, some policies cater to military members, while others appeal to people who own specific motorcycles. You have many options, but it can be helpful to find a company that considers you as part of its target market to make sure you are happy with your motorcycle insurance.

Frequently Asked Questions About Cheap Motorcycle Insurance

With so many coverage options for motorcyclists to consider when shopping for insurance, choosing the cheapest yet best policy can get confusing. MoneyGeek has put together a list of some of the most common questions people have about motorcycle insurance to help you find the coverage you need.

Learn More About Motorcycle Insurance

Methodology

MoneyGeek compiled online quotes from the top motorcycle insurance providers to help you get the cheapest motorcycle insurance. We gathered quotes for all 50 states for various rider profiles, ages, bike models and coverage levels. MoneyGeek chose 50/100/25 coverage as our minimum level of coverage as we believe state minimums often do not provide enough coverage for most riders. For more methodology details, see our methodology page and editorial standards.

About the Author


expert-profile

Rachael Brennan is a professional finance writer and licensed insurance agent. She has worked in the insurance industry for more than a decade, earning her P&C license in all 50 states and her life, health and AD&D license in New York and the surrounding states. Rachael has worked for well-known companies such as 21st Century Insurance and BlueCross BlueShield and was the Unitarian Universalist Association (UUA) insurance plans coordinator for three years. She specializes in property, casualty, health, life, accidental death and disability insurance.

Rachael earned her bachelor of science degree in communications from Texas A&M University-Commerce. Rachael combines her writing background with her insurance and personal finance experience to share practical knowledge and help people make informed financial decisions.


sources