Updated: January 26, 2026
Advertising & Editorial Disclosure
Our 2026 research found the top three home insurance companies in Indiana are American Family, USAA and Auto-Owners.
American Family offers the highest-quality homeowners insurance in Indiana with the lowest average annual premium at $1,470.
Tornado threats drive up home insurance costs across Indiana, as frequent severe weather increases risk. Shop around for quality, affordable protection.
American Family is the best home insurance company for most Indiana homeowners with affordable rates and strong customer experience. USAA earned the highest MoneyGeek score from our team but ranks No. 2 because coverage is available only to military members, veterans and their families. The top five companies earned high ratings in our affordability, customer experience and coverage categories:
| American Family | 4.66 | 1 | 3 | 3 |
| USAA | 4.96 | 2 | 1 | 1 |
| Auto-Owners Insurance | 4.55 | 6 | 2 | 4 |
| State Farm | 4.54 | 3 | 4 | 2 |
| Farmers | 4.41 | 5 | 5 | 6 |
*Our ratings consider different combinations of coverage levels, home features and homeowner details to identify the best overall options. Rankings may differ based on your profile. The tables below follow the same methodology.
Average Annual Premium
Average Monthly Premium
J.D. Power Customer Satisfaction Score
Average Annual Premium
Average Monthly Premium
J.D. Power Customer Satisfaction Score
Average Annual Premium
Average Monthly Premium
J.D. Power Customer Satisfaction Score
Average Annual Premium
Average Monthly Premium
J.D. Power Customer Satisfaction Score
Average Annual Premium
Average Monthly Premium
J.D. Power Customer Satisfaction Score
Between Indiana's bustling metro areas and quiet rural communities, home insurance rates and provider performance shift based on local risk factors. We identified the top-scoring insurer for major cities across Indiana based on affordability, customer satisfaction and coverage options.
| Butler | USAA | $1,568 |
| Elkhart | USAA | $1,643 |
| Evansville | USAA | $2,039 |
| Fort Wayne | USAA | $1,720 |
| Goodland | USAA | $1,887 |
| Indianapolis | USAA | $2,110 |
| South Bend | USAA | $1,953 |
Coverage amounts impact Indiana home insurance costs, with $500,000 in dwelling protection running $5,019 annually versus just $1,814 for $100,000 coverage. Statewide, homeowners pay an average of $3,136 yearly, though your personal profile creates major rate differences. Poor credit drives premiums up to $5,161, while excellent credit brings costs down to around $1,280, making credit scores the biggest factor in what you'll actually pay.
Overall average | $3,136 | $340 |
$100,000 dwelling coverage | $1,814 | $195 |
$500,000 dwelling coverage | $5,019 | $585 |
Older homes (1980) | $3,789 | $316 |
Newer homes (2020) | $2,829 | $236 |
Homeowner age 20–40 | $4,022 | $335 |
Seniors 61+ | $4,053 | $338 |
Recent Claim | $4,723 | $394 |
Excellent Credit | $1,280 | $258 |
Poor Credit | $5,161 | $673 |
Compare rates from multiple insurers to find Indiana home insurance that covers the state's severe storms and hail damage risks. Shop for policies that financially protect your property against these local hazards while staying affordable.
Assess your home's replacement cost and Indiana's natural disaster risks. Wildfire exposure threatens foothills communities, hail damage strikes along the Front Range and flash floods occur near mountain drainage areas. Your coverage should reflect your home's value, personal property and liability needs while accounting for Indiana's high rebuilding costs.
Indiana home insurance averages $3,136 annually. Bundling home and auto policies saves 15% to 25% on premiums. Get discounts for monitored security systems, fire-resistant roofing and hail-resistant shingles. Impact-resistant windows and roof updates qualify you for more savings while reducing hail damage.
Review customer satisfaction scores and claims handling reputation before choosing an insurer. Look for Indiana-specific coverage like wildfire coverage, water back-up from snowmelt and service line coverage for freeze-thaw damage. Extended replacement cost coverage pays full rebuilding costs even when they exceed policy limits due to material shortages or labor increases.
Inland flood coverage covers flash flood damage without a separate National Flood Insurance Program policy. Equipment breakdown coverage covers HVAC system failures in Indiana's temperature extremes. Mountain vacation homes and short-term rental properties need specialized policies for their unique risks.
Compare quotes from at least three insurers; rates vary between providers. Shop through direct insurers, independent agents and online platforms. Request quotes with identical coverage limits and deductibles for accurate comparisons. Ask about discounts for fire-resistant materials and protective devices common in Indiana homes.
Update your dwelling coverage each year to match rising construction costs and your home's current replacement value. Review your policy annually and shop for new quotes, especially after home improvements. Indiana's housing market fluctuations and severe storm risks mean your coverage needs change over time.
American Family, USAA and Auto-Owners top Indiana's home insurance market with strong financial ratings and comprehensive coverage options. Get quotes from these insurers and prioritize protection against the state's tornado and hail risks while ensuring adequate rebuilding costs and liability coverage.
Common questions Indiana homeowners ask when shopping for home insurance:
Standard home insurance policies do not cover sewer backup damage, leaving homeowners vulnerable to expensive cleanup and repair costs. You'll need to purchase separate sewer backup coverage as an endorsement to your existing policy. This additional protection covers damage from water that backs up through sewers or drains into your home.
Your dwelling coverage needs to match the full cost to rebuild your home, which differs from its market value. Inventory your belongings to determine adequate personal property coverage amounts. Consider getting a professional appraisal or using construction cost calculators to ensure you have accurate rebuild cost estimates for proper protection.
Tornadoes push up home insurance rates in Indiana as insurers adjust premiums to account for increased property damage risk and claims frequency. Central and southern Indiana face particularly elevated tornado activity, resulting in higher regional premiums. However, homeowners can secure discounts by installing impact-resistant roofing materials, reinforced windows, and storm shelters, which reduce potential damage while lowering insurance costs.
Replacement cost coverage pays to replace damaged items with new ones at current market prices, while actual cash value coverage only reimburses you for what your belongings were worth after depreciation. For instance, if your five-year-old television gets destroyed in a fire, replacement cost would buy you a brand new TV, but actual cash value would only pay what your old television was worth at the time of loss.
Our analysis identifies which insurers balance affordability with coverage for Indiana-specific risks. We evaluated home insurance providers across three weighted factors that determine value for Indiana homeowners.
Affordability (55%): We analyzed rates for different home types, credit tiers and risk levels. Providers earned higher scores for competitive pricing and extensive discounts. Cost carries the heaviest weight because premiums determine whether you can maintain coverage long-term. Indiana's high rebuilding costs and frequent hail claims make affordable coverage important.
Customer satisfaction (30%): We reviewed ratings from Trustpilot, app stores and J.D. Power surveys covering the buying process, policy management and claims handling. These ratings show which companies deliver consistent service throughout your relationship, not just competitive quotes. Claims experience matters most when wildfire or hail damage strikes and you need prompt payment and clear communication.
Coverage options (15%): We assessed add-on availability, unique features and state access. More flexibility lets you tailor policies to Indiana needs like wildfire coverage, water backup from snowmelt and equipment breakdown coverage for HVAC systems in temperature extremes. Standard policies don't always address Indiana's specific hazards without customization.
Our Sample Profile
Costs reflect a homeowner aged 41 to 60 with good credit and no prior claims insuring a 2,500-square-foot home built in 2000. Coverage includes $250,000 dwelling coverage, $125,000 personal property coverage, $200,000 personal liability coverage and a $1,000 deductible. This profile represents typical Indiana homeowners balancing comprehensive coverage with manageable premiums.
About Mark Fitzpatrick
Mark Fitzpatrick, a Licensed Property and Casualty Insurance Producer, is MoneyGeek's resident Personal Finance Expert. He has analyzed the insurance market for over five years, conducting original research for insurance shoppers. His insights have been featured in CNBC, NBC News and Mashable.
Fitzpatrick holds a master’s degree in economics and international relations from Johns Hopkins University and a bachelor’s degree from Boston College. He's also a five-time Jeopardy champion!
He writes about economics and insurance, breaking down complex topics so people know what they're buying.
