The National Insurance Crime Bureau (NICB) reports that insurance fraud is the second-most costly form of white-collar crime in America, costing billions of dollars annually. Educating yourself about how insurance scams work makes it hard for a criminal to target you.
Common Car Insurance Scams
Featured Experts:
Advertising & Editorial Disclosure
Key Takeaways
Fraudulent agents, staged crashes and fake injury claims are among the most common car insurance scams drivers face.
If you suspect a scam, document everything, contact your insurer and report it to your state insurance regulator.
Protect yourself with verified agents, written estimates and a dashcam to prevent inflated repair or towing costs.
7 Common Car Insurance Scams
1. Staged Accidents
Scammers strike when drivers are distracted, right after a crash or during the claims process. Knowing how these scams work helps you spot red flags before they cost you money.
Swoop and Squat
In this scam, multiple vehicles work together to stage a rear-end collision. One car, called the "squat" car, pulls in front of the victim's vehicle and slows down. At the same time, a second car, known as the "swoop" car, cuts sharply in front of the squat car, forcing it to brake abruptly. This causes the victim to crash into the squat car from behind.
A third car may box the victim in, preventing them from switching lanes to escape. Since it appears the victim rear-ended the squat car, they’re often blamed unless clear evidence proves the swoop car’s role.
Drive-down or false wave
In a drive down scam, a fraudster waves a driver to turn or merge, then speeds up to cause a collision and falsely claims the victim appeared out of nowhere. Variations include the left turn drive down, where the scammer waves a driver through an intersection, then blocks them mid-turn, causing another car to crash into the victim.
In a right turn version, the scammer rear-ends the victim during the turn and blames poor visibility or timing. The scammer may flee the scene, leaving the victim responsible for the damages.
Wide Turn Sideswipe
At intersections with poorly marked turn lanes, a scammer stays in the outer lane while the victim uses the inner lane to turn. As both vehicles turn, the scammer intentionally sideswipes the victim’s car. They then claim the victim veered into their lane, using the unclear markings to shift the blame.
Panic stop or “stuffed car”
A group of scammers packs into one car and slams on the brakes in front of a victim, often when the victim is distracted while driving. After the rear-end crash, the passengers claim fake or exaggerated injuries to collect insurance money. Because it's a rear-end collision, the victim is blamed. According to the NICB, some fraudsters even injure themselves beforehand to make their claims more convincing.
Red flag
Coordinated drivers, cars with multiple passengers or anyone pushing for quick cash settlements.
HOW TO AVOID THIS CAR INSURANCE SCAM
- Purchase a Front and Back Dashcam: Dashcams record staged accidents and prove false claims wrong.
- Keep Your Distance: Space between your car and the vehicle ahead prevents rear-end scams.
- Be Cautious of Hand Gestures: Ignore signals from other drivers. Turn or merge only when safe.
Staged Accidents Scams: The Cost on Car Insurance
Staged accidents raise your car insurance from $1,623 to $2,363 per year, according to MoneyGeek's analysis (a 45% premium increase). Insurers treat it as a chargeable incident even when you're not at fault. You pay more yearly because of a scam.
| State Minimum | $791 | $1,154 |
| Full Coverage | $1,623 | $2,363 |
2. Car Insurance Agent and Ghost Broker Fraud
Most insurance representatives are legitimate. A small number sell fake policies or add unauthorized fees without disclosure.
Fake Policies
An agent collects your premium but never submits the paperwork to the insurance company, leaving you unknowingly uninsured. You only find out after a claim is denied or your registration is flagged.
Premium Skimming
In this scam, the agent pockets part of your premium payment and sends only a portion to the insurer. This results in reduced coverage or policy cancellation without your knowledge.
Unauthorized Policy Changes
Some agents alter your policy without permission, such as increasing deductibles or removing coverages, to make your premium appear cheaper. In reality, you end up with less financial protection than expected.
Fake Discounts or Add-ons
A fraudulent agent might promise special discounts or coverage add-ons that don’t exist to close a sale. You’ll only discover the truth when your claim is denied for something you thought was covered.
Duplicate or Ghost Policies
Scammers may issue more than one policy for the same vehicle or issue a “ghost” policy that looks real but is not valid. This can lead to confusion during a claim or no coverage at all.
HOW TO AVOID THIS CAR INSURANCE SCAM
- Verify the Agent's License: Confirm the agent is licensed through your state's department of insurance before signing anything.
- Request Direct Policy Confirmation: Get your policy documents directly from the insurer, not from the agent alone.
- Avoid Suspicious Payment Methods: Pay by check or card to the insurer directly. Never pay cash to an individual. Get a receipt every time.
- Do Your Research: Compare auto quotes from at least three providers before committing.
- Be Wary of Unrealistic Offers: A rate that looks unusually low or an offer that is vague on details warrants a direct call to the insurer to verify.
3. Third-Party Fake Injury Claims
You back out of a parking spot, tap another car and everyone appears fine. Days later, the other driver files a claim for severe neck or back injuries. This is one of the most common staged accident schemes, where fraudsters target distracted or time-pressed drivers who are less likely to have documented the scene thoroughly.
Red flags:
- Medical claims filed the same day as the accident
- Lawyers reaching out before you have spoken to your insurer
- Conflicting or incomplete medical records
HOW TO AVOID THIS CAR INSURANCE SCAM
- Document Everything at the Scene: Photograph all vehicles, visible damage and the surrounding area, even for minor incidents.
- Call the Police for a Report: File a police report for every accident. An official record is your best defense against fabricated claims.
- Avoid Making Assumptions or Apologies: State only facts at the scene. Never admit fault or minimize what happened, regardless of how minor it seems.
4. Fraudulent Car Repair Scams
Dishonest repair shops exploit post-accident urgency. Common tactics include inflated labor charges, substandard parts and billing for work that was never done. The result is unsafe repairs and unexpected costs.
Phantom Repairs
The shop charges for parts or services that were never done, hoping you or your insurer won't check. You won't realize it until the same issue resurfaces.
Low-Quality Parts
Instead of using new or manufacturer-approved parts, scammers install cheap or used components while billing for top-tier replacements. This compromises your vehicle's safety and performance.
Unnecessary Repairs
Some shops inflate the repair bill by including work your car doesn’t need. They may claim it’s for safety or long-term reliability to justify the extra charges.
Inflated Labor Costs
Fraudulent repair shops charge for more labor hours than the job takes. They count on customers not knowing how long repairs should take.
Holding Your Car Hostage
A dishonest shop demands extra payment or refuses to release your car until you agree to surprise charges. This puts pressure on you to pay up just to get your vehicle back.
HOW TO AVOID THIS CAR INSURANCE SCAM
- Use a Trusted or Insurer-Recommended Shop: Use certified shops or those on your insurer's approved list. Cross-reference with the Better Business Bureau before authorizing work.
- Request a Detailed Estimate: Get a written breakdown of parts and labor costs before any work begins.
- Inspect Repairs Before Payment: Compare completed work against the invoice line by line before paying.
5. The Bad Samaritan
Strangers who appear at crash scenes offering unsolicited help sometimes profit from the referral, directing you to tow operators, repair shops or medical clinics that overcharge and split fees with them.
Tow Truck Scams
A scammer calls an unlicensed tow truck that takes your car to an unaffiliated or overpriced repair shop. You end up paying hidden fees or struggling to get your car back.
Stolen or Switched Info
While pretending to help, the scammer takes photos of your documents or vehicle information for identity theft. This leads to unauthorized insurance claims or financial fraud.
Fake Authority Figures
Some scammers pretend to be off-duty police officers, insurance reps or legal advisors to gain your trust. They use this false authority to pressure you into making bad decisions quickly.
HOW TO AVOID THIS CAR INSURANCE SCAM
- Call Your Insurer First: Call your insurer immediately after an accident. Get its guidance on approved tow services and repair shops before accepting help from anyone at the scene.
- Be Cautious of Strangers Offering Help: Decline help from anyone who approaches unsolicited, especially those who insist on arranging a tow or repair shop for you.
- Verify Tow Services Before Agreeing: Accept only tow trucks dispatched by your insurer or local authorities. Confirm the destination before your vehicle is moved.
6. Digital & Phishing Insurance Scams
Filing a claim makes you a target. Fraudsters send texts, emails and calls impersonating your insurer to steal payment details or policy data.
Red Flags
- Links to misspelled or off-brand domains
- Payment requests via gift card or cryptocurrency
- Messages threatening same-day cancellation unless you respond immediately
- Caller ID numbers that don't match the number on your insurance card
What to Do
- Skip suspicious links entirely. Access your account through your insurer's official app or website.
- Call the number on your insurance card to verify any payment or policy request before acting.
- Turn on two-factor authentication in your insurer's online account for an added layer of security.
If You Clicked
- Change your password immediately and alert your insurer so your account can be secured.
- Report the scam to your state Department of Insurance and the FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center (IC3).
- If something feels wrong, stop and verify directly before taking any further action.
7. Windshield & Tow/Repair Scams: Spotting Overcharges
Post-accident stress makes you a target. Common schemes include the following.
Common Plays
-
Windshield pop-ups: "Free chip repair" pitches that escalate into claims for full, unnecessary replacements.
-
Unauthorized tows: Your car is taken to an unapproved lot and held until you pay unexpected storage or release fees.
-
Hostage bills: Shops refuse to release your vehicle until inflated charges are paid.
-
How to Protect Yourself
Use insurer-approved or certified shops and get a written estimate covering parts and labor before work starts. Photograph the odometer, VIN and visible damage at drop-off and pickup. Approve any changes to the repair scope in writing.Decline tows you did not request. Instead, ask who dispatched the truck and where your vehicle is headed. Report suspected scams to your state Department of Insurance or local law enforcement.
A few extra minutes verifying the details prevents inflated costs and saves you hundreds on unnecessary repairs.
What to Do if You Become a Victim of a Car Insurance Scam
Discovering that someone has tried to defraud you through your car insurance feels maddening and stressful. Acting quickly safeguards your interests, challenges bogus claims and stops additional harm. If you suspect you've fallen victim to an insurance scam, here are the steps you should take:
- 1Stay Calm and Document Everything
Take clear photos immediately: all vehicles involved, location, damage, license plates and injuries. Collect witness contact details and write down what happened while it's fresh. Detailed records make stronger cases for investigations.
- 2Call the Police
Report every incident to police and request an official report even for minor ones. Police reports create impartial records that protect you from false claims. Give honest detailed statements without admitting fault.
- 3Notify Your Insurance Company
Contact your insurer immediately to report the accident and fraud concerns. Share all documentation: photos, witness statements and police report copies. Early notification helps your insurer spot suspicious activity and stop fraud.
- 4Avoid Direct Contact With the Scammer
Don't talk with the other party after the incident, especially if you suspect fraud. Let your insurance company and law enforcement handle communication to avoid statements scammers can twist. Cash pressure or bypassing official processes means fraud.
- 5File a Complaint With Authorities
Report scams to your state's department of insurance and the National Insurance Crime Bureau (NICB). These organizations track fraud and may investigate your claim. Your report protects others from the same scheme.
- 6Monitor Your Insurance and Credit
Monitor your insurance policy for unexpected changes or premium increases. Check your credit report for unusual activity if the scam involved identity theft or false claims in your name. Quick detection stops more damage.
MONEYGEEK EXPERT TIP
Purchase a dash cam to document accidents. Depending on the type of dash cam, what features you want and how many you purchase, it can range from $50 to $260, based on Amazon prices. The highest-priced cameras have several lenses to capture footage from the front, back and inside of your vehicle and may have a night-vision feature.
Who is Typically At Risk of Falling For Car Insurance Scams?
Certain demographic groups are targeted more often for scams because criminals think certain people are easier to intimidate. Scammers and con artists also target people who may help them obtain more money. These higher-risk targets include women, seniors, drivers operating work vehicles or big rigs and luxury car drivers.
Being part of one or more of these groups doesn't mean you'll be victimized or that you're an easier target than anyone else. Staying vigilant and taking recommended actions to protect yourself keeps a scam attempt from succeeding.
Car Insurance Frauds: Bottom Line
Car insurance scams happen to anyone: staged crashes, fake policies and more. Stay alert, document everything and report suspicious activity to protect yourself and your finances. Use trusted agents, written repair estimates and dashcams for peace of mind. Simple habits stop costly fraud.
Auto Insurance Scams: FAQ
Below are answers to the most frequently asked questions about common car insurance scams.
How do you report a car insurance fraud?
Report a car insurance scam to start an investigation. There are several places you can report the insurance fraud scheme:
- The fraud department of the car insurance company in question
- National Insurance Crime Bureau (NICB)
- Coalition Against Insurance Fraud (CAIF)
- National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC)
- Your local FBI office
How do you know you were involved in car insurance fraud?
Sometimes, you won't know you're a victim of car insurance fraud. Here are some signs that point to a fraudulent claim scam:
- The person is unusually knowledgeable about the accident process, including correct terminology and how car insurance policies work.
- A high history of claims in a short period of time.
- An accident occurs soon after a car purchase or registration, or after full coverage is added.
- Multiple injuries or extensive vehicle damage without a valid police report.
- Attorney letter of representation filed the same day or soon after the accident occurred.
How can I avoid car insurance scams?
Keep a safe distance on the road, document every accident, verify agents and repair shops and install a dashcam to capture real-time evidence. Always report suspicious activity to your insurer and local authorities.
Is car insurance a scam?
Car insurance is a legitimate product. Fraud happens at the edges, where bad actors exploit claims processes, repair networks and policy distribution. Knowing the patterns limits your exposure.
Is this text, email or call from my insurer a scam?
Assume it’s fake if it asks for payment or personal details. Legitimate insurers don’t request sensitive data through texts or unsolicited calls. Don’t click links. Log in through your insurer’s app or website, or call the number on your ID card to confirm authenticity before responding.
What is a “ghost broker,” and how do I verify an insurance agent or policy?
Ghost brokers are fake or unlicensed agents selling invalid policies. Confirm licenses through your state Department of Insurance or NAIC lookup before paying. Cash-only requests, missing policy numbers or unrealistic discounts signal fraud.
Will my premium go up if I’m the victim of a staged crash?
Even if you weren't at fault, your premium can rise after a staged crash. Share photos, dashcam footage and the police report with your insurer. Ask for a fraud review so the claim is properly classified and doesn't increase your future car insurance costs.
What are my rights if a tow truck shows up uninvited after a crash?
You're not required to accept an unsolicited tow. Ask who sent the truck, where your car is going and request a written estimate before signing anything. If it seems suspicious, decline service and report the company to your insurer or state Department of Insurance.
Loading...
Resources on Car Insurance Fraud
There are many resources available to help with understanding and reporting car insurance scams and fraud. These anti-fraud agencies, programs and resources are available in your state and nationwide. Some of the links below will take you to state-specific resources you can use to learn more or report insurance fraud.
Local or State Resources
- State Attorneys General: As the “People’s Lawyer,” the attorney general for your state or territory can help you file a claim and provide additional resources.
- Highway Patrol or State Police Websites: Use this page to find the link for each state’s highway patrol or state police website to help you file a fraud claim.
- Insurance Regulators by State: Find the department of insurance for each state from this list, so you can locate resources to file a car insurance fraud claim.
- Map of National Association of Insurance Commissioners states and jurisdictions: Use this map of states and jurisdictions to look up your state's insurance commissioner to report a fraudulent insurance agent.
- American Automobile Association (AAA): The American Automobile Association (AAA) automatically directs you to the site for your region. If you are a AAA member, you can contact an agent about suspected scams.
National Resources
- Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI): Suspicious activities, including financial crimes like car insurance fraud, can be reported to your local FBI office for investigation.
- National Insurance Crime Bureau: NICB provides valuable information on insurance crimes and video illustrations of how the most common stage accidents are performed. You can report fraud through this nonprofit organization's website.
- International Association of Auto Theft Investigators: The IAATI’s mission is to combine international resources to combat auto theft. This organization consists of professional auto theft investigators and law enforcement representatives.
- Anti-Fraud Alliance: The AFA represents law enforcement and the private industry to provide training, networking and collaboration among all levels to combat insurance fraud.
- Fraud.org: Created by the National Consumers League, this website provides tips for consumers to avoid being scammed and resources to use if you think you have been.
- Coalition Against Insurance Fraud: This organization collects information on insurance fraud, works to pass anti-fraud laws and educates the public on how to spot and report scam attempts.
- United States Department of Justice: You can find additional information about financial fraud crimes and what you will need to have if you pursue a lawsuit.
- Counsel Hound: Attorney-managed consultation service that connects people with lawyers to match their specific legal case.
Read More on Auto Insurance
About Mark Fitzpatrick
Mark Fitzpatrick, a Licensed Property and Casualty Insurance Producer, is MoneyGeek's resident Personal Finance Expert. He has analyzed the insurance market for over five years, conducting original research for insurance shoppers. His insights have been featured in CNBC, NBC News and Mashable.
Fitzpatrick holds a master’s degree in economics and international relations from Johns Hopkins University and a bachelor’s degree from Boston College. He's also a five-time Jeopardy champion!
He writes about economics and insurance, breaking down complex topics so people know what they're buying.
sources
- National Insurance Crime Bureau. "Prevent Fraud & Theft." Accessed July 11, 2025.
- National Insurance Crime Bureau. "Staged Auto Accident Fraud." Accessed July 11, 2025.