Debt consolidation loans are personal loans that borrowers use to pay off multiple debts, including student loan debt, at a lower interest rate. MoneyGeek analyzed 26 lenders and found PenFed to be the top choice for debt consolidation loans in New York, scoring 96 out of 100.
Although PenFed stands out in our analysis, there are other lenders available in New York not included in our analysis. You may also want to check out local lending options like First New York Federal Credit Union and Island Federal Credit Union to see if they fit your borrowing needs.
Best Debt Consolidation Loans in New York 2024
For the best debt consolidation loan in New York, PenFed is MoneyGeek's top choice with a MoneyGeek score of 96. It offers competitive interest rates, a broad selection of payment options and is reputable and transparent.
Zachary Romeo, CBCA
Head of Loans and Banking at MoneyGeek
Zachary Romeo is a certified Commercial Banking and Credit Analyst (CBCA), and the Head of Loans and Banking at MoneyGeek. Previously, he led production teams for some of the largest online informational resources in higher education, with over 13 years of experience in editorial production. Romeo has a bachelor's degree in biological engineering from Cornell University. He geeks out on minimizing personal debt and helping others do the same through people-first content.
Alvin Yam, CFP
Founder, Paraiba Wealth Management
Alvin Yam is a certified financial planner (CFP) with over 15 years of experience working with individuals and corporations. Before founding Paraiba Wealth Management, he was a director at HSBC and a financial consultant at Charles Schwab. Yam is MoneyGeek's expert consultant on wealth management and personal banking. Yam earned his bachelor's degree in political science from the University of California, San Diego, and his Master of Business Administration from Loyola Marymount University.
Rae Osborn
Content Editor
Dr. Rae Osborn is a MoneyGeek content editor with over seven years of editing experience and over 20 years of experience in publishing and writing science content. She also works as a science researcher, writer and editor and a professional reviewer for Science Reviews and Advances in Entomology.
Zachary Romeo, CBCA
Head of Loans and Banking at MoneyGeek
Zachary Romeo is a certified Commercial Banking and Credit Analyst (CBCA), and the Head of Loans and Banking at MoneyGeek. Previously, he led production teams for some of the largest online informational resources in higher education, with over 13 years of experience in editorial production. Romeo has a bachelor's degree in biological engineering from Cornell University. He geeks out on minimizing personal debt and helping others do the same through people-first content.
Alvin Yam, CFP
Founder, Paraiba Wealth Management
Alvin Yam is a certified financial planner (CFP) with over 15 years of experience working with individuals and corporations. Before founding Paraiba Wealth Management, he was a director at HSBC and a financial consultant at Charles Schwab. Yam is MoneyGeek's expert consultant on wealth management and personal banking. Yam earned his bachelor's degree in political science from the University of California, San Diego, and his Master of Business Administration from Loyola Marymount University.
Rae Osborn
Content Editor
Dr. Rae Osborn is a MoneyGeek content editor with over seven years of editing experience and over 20 years of experience in publishing and writing science content. She also works as a science researcher, writer and editor and a professional reviewer for Science Reviews and Advances in Entomology.
Updated: October 3, 2024
Advertising & Editorial Disclosure
Best Debt Consolidation Loans in New York
Overall Best Debt Consolidation Loan Lender in New York
MoneyGeek ranks PenFed as the best debt consolidation loan lender in New York, with a MoneyGeek score of 96 out of 100. Key features contributing to an ideal lender include competitive rates, loan amount, time to receive funds, quality of service, and reputation.
PenFed offers an APR range of 8.99% to 17.99%, a loan amount range of up to $50,000. These features benefit borrowers in New York by providing affordable rates, substantial loan amounts, and quick access to funds for consolidating debt.
Federally insured by the National Credit Union Administration
Charges a $29 late fee
We used the following weightings to score New York lenders for best overall debt consolidation loan:
- Interest Rates and Fees: 40%
- Application and Approval: 30%
- Loan Terms and Flexibility: 20%
- Customer Service: 5%
- Reputation: 5%
Runner-Up for Best Debt Consolidation Loan in New York
Alliant Credit Union is another solid option for a debt consolidation loan in New York, with a MoneyGeek score of 95 out of 100. One of its pros is a low APR starting from 10.49%, which can help borrowers save money on interest payments over time. Another benefit is the high loan amount range, from $1,000 to $100,000, allowing borrowers to consolidate multiple debts into one manageable loan.
Additionally, Alliant Credit Union offers flexible repayment terms ranging from 12 to 60 months. This flexibility can help borrowers choose a repayment plan that fits their budget and financial goals. With the possibility of receiving funds on the same day, borrowers can quickly address their debt consolidation needs.
Borrow up to $100,000
Need to be a member for 90 days
We used the following weightings to score New York lenders for best overall debt consolidation loan:
- Interest Rates and Fees: 40%
- Application and Approval: 30%
- Loan Terms and Flexibility: 20%
- Customer Service: 5%
- Reputation: 5%
Best Debt Consolidation Loan in New York for Affordability
Wells Fargo offers the best debt consolidation loan in New York for borrowers who prioritize affordability, with a MoneyGeek score of 94 out of 100. Its APR range of 7.49% to 24.99% is competitive, but affordability isn't just about interest rates. Wells Fargo also has no origination fees, which means you won't have to pay extra just to get your loan.
Additionally, the availability of rate discounts can further reduce your overall cost. For example, if you set up automatic payments, you might qualify for a lower interest rate. This combination of features makes Wells Fargo a top choice for those looking to consolidate their debts affordably.
Loan amounts up to $100,000
Exclusive to existing Wells Fargo customers
We used the following weightings to score New York lenders based on their affordability:
- APR Range: 50%
- Loan Terms: 25%
- Application and Approval: 25%
Best Debt Consolidation Loan in New York for Large Loan Amounts
PNC offers the best debt consolidation loan in New York for borrowers needing a large loan amount or longer repayment terms, with a MoneyGeek score of 96 out of 100. It provides loan amounts ranging from $1,000 to $35,000, making it suitable for various financial needs.
PNC's flexible repayment terms allow borrowers to choose a plan that fits their budget. Additionally, its quick funding process, with funds available in as little as three business days, helps borrowers consolidate their debts swiftly and efficiently.
No origination fees
High maximum APR
We used the following weightings to score New York lenders based on their suitability for borrowers who need to consolidate large debts:
- APR Range: 25%
- Loan Amount: 50%
- Application and Approval: 25%
Best Debt Consolidation Loan in New York for Fast Funding
Rocket Loans offers the best debt consolidation loan in New York for borrowers who need funds quickly, with a MoneyGeek score of 95 out of 100. It provides same-day fund availability, making it an ideal choice for urgent financial needs.
One feature of this lender is its fast approval process, which means you can consolidate your debts and access the funds on the same day. Another feature is its flexible repayment terms, allowing you to choose a plan that fits your financial situation, ensuring manageable monthly payments.
No prepayment penalties
Charges an origination fee up to 9%
We used the following weightings to find the best New York lenders for borrowers who need funds quickly:
- APR Range: 25%
- Loan Terms: 25%
- Application and Approval: 50%
Should You Get a Loan to Consolidate Debt in New York?
Using a debt consolidation loan in New York can simplify your finances by merging multiple payments into one. But it’s not always the best option. For example, if the interest rate on the new loan is higher than your current debts, it might not make sense. Consider your specific situation before deciding.
Good Credit
Having good credit is ideal for a debt consolidation loan in New York, as it can lower your interest rates and monthly payments.
High-Interest Debt
If you have high-interest debt, a debt consolidation loan in New York can lower your interest rates. For example, reduce from 20% to 10%.
Multiple Monthly Payments
Combining multiple payments into one with a debt consolidation loan in New York simplifies your finances. One payment is easier to manage than several.
Lower Monthly Payments
A debt consolidation loan in New York can lower your monthly payments. For example, reduce from $500 to $300 per month.
When You Shouldn't Get a Debt Consolidation Loan
- When your new monthly payment is higher: A higher payment increases financial strain, making it harder to manage expenses and save money.
- When you can pay off debt within a year: If you can clear debt in a year, consolidation may add unnecessary costs.
- When your income and employment are uncertain: Unpredictable income can make it difficult to meet loan payments consistently.
- When your DTI ratio is high: High DTI can lead to loan denial or unfavorable terms, making consolidation less effective.
How to Get a Debt Consolidation Loan in New York
The average amount of personal loan debt in New York is $93,361, which is below the overall average debt in the U.S. of $104,215. In New York, the average monthly debt is approximately $7,780.
Using a personal loan to consolidate debt in New York can simplify your payments and potentially lower your interest rates. Going into the process blindly can lead to higher interest rates and damage your credit score. To avoid these risks, follow these steps to apply for a debt consolidation loan.
Review your debts and credit score.
Account for existing debts to see which ones to consolidate, like credit card debt. Choosing the wrong debts can lead to higher interest rates. Check your credit scores and improve your credit score by paying bills on time and reducing outstanding balances.
Compare loan terms from lenders.
Compare loan terms from multiple lenders to find the best deal. Contact lenders to ensure the loan can be used for debt consolidation. Look at APRs, loan limits, and how soon you can receive the funds.
Check for extra benefits.
Some lenders offer added features that benefit you long-term. For example, in New York, Keybank and Lightstream offer rate discounts, which can save you money over time.
Watch out for fees and penalties.
Some lender features could be drawbacks. In New York, Universal Credit charges an origination fee, and Prosper charges a late fee. These fees can impact your short- and long-term finances.
Get prequalified.
Prequalification helps you gauge loan eligibility without affecting your credit score. It uses a soft credit check, allowing you to explore options without impacting your credit.
Complete your loan application.
Complete your loan application by preparing necessary documents like proof of income and identification. This makes the process faster and smoother.
Lenders might deny your loan application due to a low credit score or a high debt-to-income ratio. Before applying for a debt consolidation loan in New York, review your credit report and take steps to improve your credit score.
You can also consider reaching out to some credit counseling agencies to help you manage your debts better. Parachute Credit Counseling, Inc. and CC Advising, Inc. are two options for borrowers in New York. Another option is to use a 0% APR balance transfer credit card, which allows you to transfer existing high-interest debt to a new card with no interest for a promotional period, potentially saving you money on interest payments.
Local Lenders for Debt Consolidation Loans in New York
Consolidating debt can be beneficial because it often results in lower interest rates. The average APRs you can qualify for vary between cities. For example, in Rochester, the average APR is 9.0%, while in Brooklyn, it is 12.5%.
Another option to find the best debt consolidation loan in New York is to consider other local lenders. Below is a table of local lenders that you may find helpful.
M and T Bank | CityBrooklyn | APR9.49% to 15.69% | Repayment Terms12 to 84 months | Loan Amount Range$2,000 to $50,000 | MoneyGeek Score100 |
Family First of NY Federal Credit Union | CityRochester | APRFrom 8.24% | Repayment Terms1 to 60 months | Loan Amount RangeFrom $1,500 | MoneyGeek Score100 |
The Summit Federal Credit Union | CityRochester | APR7.95% to 15.75% | Repayment Terms13 to 60 months | Loan Amount RangeUndisclosed | MoneyGeek Score99 |
ESL Federal Credit Union | CityRochester | APRFrom 9.95% | Repayment TermsUp to 120 months | Loan Amount RangeUndisclosed | MoneyGeek Score98 |
Rochester and Monroe County Employees Federal Credit Union | CityRochester | APRFrom 8.50% | Repayment TermsUndisclosed | Loan Amount RangeUp to $25,000 | MoneyGeek Score94 |
FAQ: Debt Consolidation Loans in New York
MoneyGeek addresses common questions homeowners have about debt consolidation loans in New York. Our precise and reliable information helps you understand your options and make informed decisions. We maintain high journalistic standards to ensure clear and direct communication.
A debt consolidation loan is an unsecured personal loan that borrowers use to pay off high-interest debt. Borrowers choose this option to simplify their payments and potentially reduce their interest rates.
PenFed is the best debt consolidation loan lender in New York. However, the best lender for you might vary depending on your priorities.
Yes, you can get a debt consolidation loan even if you have bad credit.
Yes, a credit counseling agency can help manage debt by providing advice and creating a debt management plan.
Consider a debt consolidation loan if you have good credit and can qualify for better terms, or if your household budget can handle the new monthly payment.
MoneyGeek analyzed 27 national lenders licensed to do business in New York, based on a rubric that includes APR ranges, loan amounts and repayment terms, among other key areas. We use a point-based system and assign scores according to the presence or absence of desirable features in various important categories.
We score lenders differently when recommending the best for affordability, loan amounts and fast funding.
We conducted our analysis in September 2024.
About Zachary Romeo, CBCA
Zachary Romeo is a certified Commercial Banking and Credit Analyst (CBCA), and the Head of Loans and Banking at MoneyGeek. Previously, he led production teams for some of the largest online informational resources in higher education, with over 13 years of experience in editorial production.
Romeo has a bachelor's degree in biological engineering from Cornell University. He geeks out on minimizing personal debt and helping others do the same through people-first content.
The content on this page is accurate as of the posting/last updated date; however, some of the rates mentioned may have changed. We recommend visiting the lender's website for the most up-to-date information available.
Editorial Disclosure: Opinions, reviews, analyses and recommendations are the author’s alone and have not been reviewed, endorsed or approved by any bank, lender or other entity. Learn more about
our editorial policies and expert editorial team.