How To Get Homeowners Insurance After Being Dropped

Enter your ZIP code to get started


Free. Simple. Secure.

Banner image
ByMark Fitzpatrick
Edited byLukas Velunta
ByMark Fitzpatrick
Edited byLukas Velunta

Updated: May 22, 2024

Advertising & Editorial Disclosure

If your homeowners insurance policy is not renewed or has been canceled, you can still shop around for a new one. But first, you must understand and address the reasons behind the cancellation before seeking a new provider. Insurers may decline your application if they identify the same concerns that led to your previous policy's cancellation.

By resolving any issues that contributed to the nonrenewal of your policy, you can improve your chances of obtaining new coverage and position yourself as a responsible homeowner in the eyes of potential insurers. Addressing these issues demonstrates a proactive approach to managing risks associated with insuring your home.

Key Takeaways

homeInsurance icon

If your home insurance policy is dropped, you can get a new one with a different provider after addressing the cause of cancellation.

usMap icon

Understanding state insurance laws is crucial to safeguard your home insurance policy and coverage.

shakingHands icon

Proactive and regular maintenance and transparency with insurance providers can prevent policy cancellations.

How To Get Homeowners Insurance After Being Dropped Or Not Renewed

If your homeowners insurance policy has been dropped or not renewed, you can seek new coverage after addressing the reasons for cancellation. Although facing a policy cancellation or non-renewal can be challenging, it also provides a chance to explore new insurance options and rectify any issues that contributed to the termination of your previous policy.

Policies can be canceled for various reasons, including missed payments, misrepresentation during the application process or changes in risk factors associated with your property. Effectively navigate obtaining new homeowners insurance after a cancellation with these steps:

Understand the Reasons

Your homeowners insurance was canceled for a reason. This could be due to a variety of causes, such as non-payment of premiums, increased risk factors, or even filing too many claims. Knowing the exact reason helps in addressing any issues and preventing similar problems in the future.

Contact Your Insurer

Before looking for a new policy, contact your previous insurer to discuss the situation. Sometimes, the issues leading to cancellation can be resolved, allowing for the possibility of reinstating your policy.

Request a CLUE Report

For insurance companies to assess your risk profile, you must request a Comprehensive Loss Underwriting Exchange (CLUE) report. This provides a detailed history of your past insurance claims and any inquiries made regarding your policy. Reviewing your CLUE report will allow you to address any inaccuracies and provide the right information when applying for a new policy.

Shop Around for New Insurance

If reinstatement is not possible or if you choose to find a new insurer, compare homeowners insurance quotes from multiple insurance providers to find the coverage that suits your requirements and budget.

Apply For A New Policy And Provide Accurate Information

When applying for new homeowners insurance, ensure that you provide accurate and complete information to the insurance company. Transparency is key to securing coverage and withholding or misrepresenting information could lead to future complications.

What To Do If Traditional Homeowners Insurance Providers Don’t Cover You

Depending on your situation, some providers may choose not to offer coverage — if this happens, you can turn to a Fair Access to Insurance Requirements (FAIR) Plan as a last resort. A FAIR Plan offers a lifeline to high-risk homeowners seeking insurance not being accepted by traditional providers. It’s meant for individuals often finding themselves ineligible for standard home insurance due to living in high-risk areas or other red flags that concern typical insurers.

FAIR Plans, which are run at the state level and subsidized by taxpayers and private insurance companies, differ from traditional insurers. They operate as shared market plans, spreading risk across multiple insurers. However, coverage through a FAIR Plan is typically limited, often providing only dwelling and personal property coverage on a named perils basis, with options for liability, medical payments or loss of use coverage being limited or unavailable.

find icon

You can obtain a FAIR Plan through your state's insurance department or a designated FAIR Plan association within your state. Each state that offers FAIR Plans has its own association or organization responsible for administering the program.

When Should You Consider Getting The FAIR Plan?

You should consider getting the FAIR Plan when you are unable to secure traditional homeowners insurance coverage through private insurance companies due to high-risk factors, such as living in an area prone to natural disasters or owning a property with significant issues.

The FAIR Plan is designed to provide a last-resort option for homeowners facing difficulties in obtaining standard insurance coverage. When all other avenues for homeowners insurance have been exhausted, this serves as a safety net, allowing you to protect your homes despite the challenges.

Reasons for Canceled or Dropped Homeowners Insurance

Your homeowners insurance could get canceled or dropped for myriad reasons, such as neglecting to pay on time, owning a home with high-risk features, or misrepresenting the state of your home. Be aware of these potential factors to proactively address any issues and ensure the protection of your home. Here, we've categorized these reasons into different areas for clarity:

House Issues

    houseRebuild icon

    Maintenance Neglect

    Failing to address essential home maintenance and repairs can lead to insurance cancellation. Insurance companies may consider your home a higher risk if it's not adequately maintained, increasing the likelihood of claims.

    house2 icon

    High-Risk Features

    Certain features, like a deteriorating roof, outdated electrical systems or a wood-burning stove, can make your home riskier to insure. Insurance companies may drop coverage if these features pose safety concerns.

    pin icon

    High-Risk Location

    If your home is in an area prone to natural disasters such as hurricanes, earthquakes or wildfires, insurance companies may cancel coverage due to the increased risk associated with these regions.

Delinquency Issues

    preferences icon

    Missed Premium Payments

    Consistently missing premium payments can result in your insurance being canceled. Timely payment is crucial to maintaining coverage and avoiding interruptions in your protection.

    uninsured icon

    Non-Disclosure of Claims

    Failing to disclose previous claims when applying for coverage or not reporting claims promptly can lead to policy cancellation.

    lenderTransparency icon

    Fraud or Misrepresentation

    Providing false information on your insurance application or engaging in fraudulent activities related to claims can result in immediate policy cancellation.

    onlineForms icon

    Excessive Claims

    Frequent and excessive claims, particularly for preventable or suspicious incidents, may lead to non-renewal or cancellation.

Address these issues proactively to maintain your homeowners insurance coverage. Regular home maintenance, timely premium payments, honesty in your applications and responsible claims management can help you avoid the inconvenience of insurance cancellation or non-renewal.

Understanding The Home Insurance Cancellation Laws In Your State

Homeowners insurance policies come with regulations regarding cancellation, but these rules can vary significantly from one state to another. While insurance providers are generally required to inform policyholders about policy cancellations, the specific processes and timelines can differ based on state regulations. This notice typically includes the reason for cancellation and the effective date of termination. However, the length of the notice period and the acceptable reasons for cancellation can vary depending on state laws.

In New York, for instance, an insurance provider typically has the authority to terminate your homeowners policy within the initial 60 days of its inception, provided that the cancellation notice clearly articulates the precise rationale or factors behind the cancellation.

In Idaho, the notice period before the cancellation takes effect varies based on the reason for cancellation. An insurance provider is required to send a written notice to the policyholder, specifying the effective date and reasons for the cancellation or non-renewal of a homeowners policy.

To ensure you fully understand the home insurance cancellation laws in your state and how they apply to your situation, contact your state's Department of Insurance. They can provide you with detailed information on policy cancellations, notice requirements and your rights as a homeowner.

How To Prevent Your Home Insurance From Being Dropped

Preventing your home insurance from being dropped is often much easier than trying to secure a new policy after cancellation. By proactively addressing potential issues, you can maintain the coverage you need to protect your home and assets. Here are some key tips to help you prevent your home insurance from being dropped:

    faucet icon

    Regular Maintenance

    Keep your home in good condition by addressing maintenance issues promptly. Regularly inspect and maintain critical components like your roof, electrical system, plumbing and heating/cooling systems.

    calendar icon

    Timely Premium Payments

    Ensure you pay your insurance premiums on time and in full. Late or missed payments can lead to policy cancellation, so stay current with your financial obligations.

    subscribe icon

    Transparent Communication

    Be honest and transparent when applying for insurance and filing claims. Providing accurate information and promptly reporting incidents helps maintain trust with your insurer.

    loanReview icon

    Claims Management

    Although you must report valid claims, be mindful of the frequency and nature of claims. Frequent and preventable claims can increase the risk of policy cancellation.

    cigarette icon

    Risk Mitigation

    Implement safety measures to reduce the risk of accidents and losses. This includes installing smoke detectors and security systems and taking steps to prevent common home hazards.

    rentPapers icon

    Reviewing and Updating

    Regularly review and update your insurance policy to ensure it adequately reflects your home's value and your coverage needs. Changes in your home's value or personal circumstances may require adjustments to your policy.

By following these proactive steps, you can significantly reduce the likelihood of your home insurance being dropped and ensure ongoing protection for your home and belongings.

FAQ About Canceled Homeowners Insurance

Having an insurance policy canceled might be frustrating and challenging, especially when you need to get new homeowners insurance. Understanding the processes of getting a new policy after being dropped from an existing one is important, so we’ve answered some frequently asked questions to help you weigh your options.

Can an insurer refuse to renew?
Why would an insurance company drop you?
What happens to your mortgage if your home insurance is canceled?
What should you do if you can’t get homeowners insurance because of your claims history?

About Mark Fitzpatrick

Mark Fitzpatrick headshot

Mark Fitzpatrick has analyzed the property and casualty insurance market for over five years, conducting original research and creating personalized content for every kind of buyer. Currently, he leads P&C insurance content production at MoneyGeek. Fitzpatrick has been quoted in several insurance-related publications, including CNBC, NBC News and Mashable.

Fitzpatrick earned a master’s degree in economics and international relations from Johns Hopkins University and a bachelor’s degree from Boston College. He is passionate about using his knowledge of economics and insurance to bring transparency around financial topics and help others feel confident in their money moves.