Cheapest Car Insurance in Elizabeth, NJ (2025)

Elizabeth drivers pay an average of $1,752 per year for minimum coverage and $2,940 per year for full coverage. Elizabeth has some of New Jersey's highest rates due to a vehicle theft rate 47% above the national average.

• Cheapest minimum liability coverage: Plymouth Rock has Elizabeth's cheapest minimum coverage at $1,023 per year ($85 monthly). That's 42% lower than the city average of $1,752, saving you $729 annually. Selective offers minimum coverage at $1,224 per year ($102 monthly), a 30% savings compared to the city average.
• Cheapest full coverage: Plymouth Rock offers the lowest full coverage at $1,802 annually ($150 monthly), 39% below the city average of $2,940. That's $1,138 in annual savings. NJM Insurance's full coverage costs $1,986 per year ($166 monthly), still 32% below the city average but $184 more than Plymouth Rock Insurance annually.

Young drivers in Elizabeth face the steepest car insurance rates compared to adults and seniors. Here are the most affordable car insurance companies in Elizabeth by age group:

• Adults: Plymouth Rock Insurance and Selective Insurance offer the lowest rates
• Seniors: Selective Insurance and Amica provide the best value
• Young drivers: GEICO and NJM Insurance are the most budget-friendly options

Young drivers under 25 can reduce their premiums with GEICO's Good Student Discount. Adding young drivers to existing family policies also reduces costs.

Car insurance is more expensive if you have driving violations. Here are your cheapest car insurance options in Elizabeth by violation type:

• Accident: NJM at $113 and Plymouth Rock at $115 monthly
• Ticket: Plymouth Rock at $97 and Selective at $102 monthly
• DUI: Plymouth Rock at $101 and NJM at $128 monthly

Minor violations stay on your record for five years, but rates decrease after three years without additional incidents.

Elizabeth drivers see different car insurance costs depending on their ZIP code. Full coverage costs $235 monthly in areas 07201 and 07202, making them the most affordable neighborhoods, while 07208 residents pay $263 monthly. Check the table below for specific rates in your Elizabeth ZIP code.

Plymouth Rock earned 94 out of 100 on MoneyGeek's rating scale. Amica follows with an 89 out of 100 score. Plymouth Rock leads in coverage and affordability, based on our analysis of agent network ratings, complaint data from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners, J.D. Power studies and customer reviews across multiple platforms. Amica excels in customer experience and claims satisfaction. 

See below for why each insurer stands out and which suits your needs.

Elizabeth drivers have steep car insurance costs. Shop around, reduce your premiums and select the right coverage for your needs:

Our insurance experts provide answers to common questions about affordable car insurance in Elizabeth:

Elizabeth drivers pay some of New Jersey's highest car insurance rates. We built this analysis to help you find reliable coverage without overpaying for your specific situation.

We analyzed hundreds of thousands of quotes from major insurers using data from the New Jersey Division of Insurance and Quadrant Information Services. Our research covered all Elizabeth ZIP codes and adjusted for driver profiles including age, driving record, credit score and military affiliation. This approach reveals which insurers offer competitive rates for drivers like you, not just average citywide prices. The analysis was complicated by Elizabeth's specific risks including weather-related damages from hurricanes, flooding and hail, plus higher crime rates and dense traffic conditions that increase accident rates.

Our rating system weighs three factors:

Affordability (60%): Premiums matter most when you're deciding whether you can maintain coverage long-term. We compared minimum coverage (New Jersey's state liability requirements) and full coverage (liability plus comprehensive and collision with $1,000 deductibles) to show savings across coverage levels.

Customer experience (30%): Google reviews and J.D. Power ratings reveal how insurers handle claims and resolve problems. This factor accounts for real customer interactions during stressful moments like filing hurricane damage claims or handling theft reports.

Coverage options (10%): More choices mean better odds of matching coverage to Elizabeth risks like flood damage, uninsured motorists and theft in high-risk areas.