Medica has the best health insurance for young adults who want an HSA-eligible Silver plan. At $485 a month, its Silver EPO is the cheapest HSA-eligible Silver EPO in our national data, $166 below the next-lowest. Its in-network claim denial rate of 26.1% is lower than Blue Cross Blue Shield’s 28.1%.
Kaiser Permanente costs the least of our three picks, both each month and when you use care. Its premium is $440 a month, and its $2,032 deductible, the amount you pay before the plan shares costs, is $1,668 below Medica’s. The plan’s out-of-pocket maximum, the most you’d pay for covered care in a year, is $5,493, or $3,007 less than Medica’s. Kaiser also denies the fewest in-network claims, at 9.1% compared with 26.1% for Medica and 28.1% for Blue Cross Blue Shield.
Blue Cross Blue Shield has the highest member experience score of the three in CMS’s quality ratings, at 95.71 compared with 88.97 for Kaiser. Medica’s plan has no member experience score in our data. The Blue Cross Blue Shield plan costs $742 a month, which comes to $3,084 more a year than Medica’s, and its $5,500 deductible is the highest of our three picks.







