Owning a home is a major investment that can pay off major dividends over time. But natural disasters, fires and theft can turn the “American Dream” into a nightmare without warning. Home insurance offers protection from the unexpected — but how can you tell if you’re getting the best coverage for the price? MoneyGeek ranked Wisconsin’s top insurance companies based on criteria such as customer satisfaction and affordability to help you compare benefits and prices. Whether you’re insuring your first home, a home with a pool, a high-value home or have bad credit, MoneyGeek can help you make the best decision for your lifestyle.
The Best Homeowners Insurance Companies and Cheapest Quotes in Wisconsin for 2020
Compare Home Insurance Rates
Ensure you're getting the best rate for your home insurance. Compare quotes from the top insurance companies.
- Home
- The Best Cheap Homeowners Insurance in Wisconsin
The 5 Best Homeowners Insurance Companies in Wisconsin
You might want to look beyond price and analyze other important factors to obtain comprehensive home insurance coverage. Such factors might include each provider’s ability to pay claims, customer support quality, number of complaints and coverage features. After you assess these factors, you can pick an insurer who fits your needs.
To aid you in selecting the best homeowners insurance in Wisconsin, MoneyGeek ranked the leading five firms and compared them using their J.D. Power customer satisfaction scores, ability to pay claims based on AM Best’s financial stability ratings and the cost of their plans in the state.
1
ErieScore: 94
5/5
Affordability
4.3/5
User Satisfaction
4.5/5
Financial Stability
Erie’s standard home insurance policy offers added benefits such as guaranteed replacement cost coverage, precious metals and cash (covered up to $500), theft coverage and pets (covered up to $500). You can enhance your package with custom coverage options like identity theft, home business and rental income, service line and sewer, valuables and jewelry and natural disaster.
Read MoneyGeek's Erie Home Insurance Review2
USAAScore: 89
3.9/5
Affordability
5/5
User Satisfaction
5/5
Financial Stability
USAA’s standard home insurance packages cover full replacement cost dwelling and personal property, personal liability, medical payments to others, unlimited loss-of-use, home protector, military uniform and identity theft. USAA plans and services also include competitive premiums, unique add-ons, online claims and financial strength.
3
TravelersScore: 87
4.4/5
Affordability
3.9/5
User Satisfaction
5/5
Financial Stability
Apart from standard coverage, Travelers offers additional options such as special personal property coverage, contents replacement cost, jewelry and valuable item coverage, personal articles floater, water backup coverage, identity fraud protection and green home coverage. Travelers is a well-established insurer that offers a wide variety of products and services, as well as numerous discounts.
Read MoneyGeek's Travelers Home Insurance Review4
AllstateScore: 87
4.3/5
Affordability
4.2/5
User Satisfaction
4.5/5
Financial Stability
Allstate’s home insurance policies offer dwelling coverage, liability protection, personal property coverage, guest medical protection, manufactured and mobile home insurance, personal umbrella policy, HostAdvantage and flood insurance. The above policies protect homeowners from threats such as windstorms and hail, burglary, smoke and fire, water damage from plumbing malfunctions and falling objects.
Read MoneyGeek's Allstate Home Insurance Review5
State FarmScore: 83
3.9/5
Affordability
4.1/5
User Satisfaction
5/5
Financial Stability
State Farm’s standard home insurance policies cover home, other structures, personal property, liability, guest medical payment and additional living expenses. This provider presents multiple lines, home alert protection, roofing and higher deductible discounts.
Read MoneyGeek's State Farm Home Insurance ReviewWhat Is the Average Cost of Homeowners Insurance in Wisconsin?
$0
$0
home insurance is 0.0% more than the average.
The average yearly cost of home insurance in Wisconsin is $1,257 for a dwelling coverage baseline amount of $250,000 — which is $846, or 40.2%, less than the national average of $2,103. Providers estimate homeowners insurance in Wisconsin based on the risks related to the policyholder, which include exposure to natural calamities and crime rate in the area, among other factors.
Home Insurance Calculator: Estimate the Cost of Homeowners Insurance in Wisconsin
Factors like your property’s age, roof quality, dwelling value, personal belongings and presence of a pool, among others, can affect homeowners insurance rates in Wisconsin. Your house’s location is also important because regions with more exposure to risks typically have higher home insurance premiums.
Home Insurance Calculator
State
Wisconsin
Dwelling Coverage
$250,000
Deductible
$500
Liability
$300,000
Personal Property
$150,000
Credit Score
Excellent
low end
on average
high end
These are annual estimates. Get a personalized quote to determine your costs.
The Cheapest Homeowners Insurance Quotes in Wisconsin
Homeowners insurance cost in Wisconsin also depends on factors like dwelling coverage. Dwelling coverage pays for repair expenses if your property suffers damages by fire, natural disasters or other covered events. In Wisconsin, Erie presents the most affordable rate for an average dwelling coverage amount of $250,000. Its average yearly price is $546, which is about $710, or 56.5%, less than the state average. To save money, you can compare homeowners insurance quotes and choose the best package for your residence.
Cheapest Homeowners Insurance by Dwelling Coverage
Dwelling Coverage:
$250,000
Company
Amountper year
1. Erie
In 2020, Erie ranked #1 for the cheapest homeowners insurance with $250,000 in dwelling coverage in Wisconsin.
$546
2. Travelers
In 2020, Travelers ranked #2 for the cheapest homeowners insurance with $250,000 in dwelling coverage in Wisconsin.
$994
3. Allstate
In 2020, Allstate ranked #3 for the cheapest homeowners insurance with $250,000 in dwelling coverage in Wisconsin.
$1,009
4. Allied
In 2020, Allied ranked #4 for the cheapest homeowners insurance with $250,000 in dwelling coverage in Wisconsin.
$1,079
5. American Family
In 2020, American Family ranked #5 for the cheapest homeowners insurance with $250,000 in dwelling coverage in Wisconsin.
$1,332
Best Cheap Homeowners Insurance Companies for Expensive Homes
For a $2 million home, Allied is a good option for cheap home insurance in Wisconsin. Its average annual rate is $3,265. The average yearly price of the state’s costliest provider, Auto-Owners Insurance Co, is $20,909. It’s smart to compare quotes to pick the most suitable and affordable coverage for your property.
Cheapest Homeowners Insurance Companies for High-Value Homes
Company
Amountper year
1. Allied
In 2020, Allied ranked #1 in Wisconsin for the cheapest homeowners insurance for high-value homes.
$3,265
2. Erie
In 2020, Erie ranked #2 in Wisconsin for the cheapest homeowners insurance for high-value homes.
$3,783
3. Allstate
In 2020, Allstate ranked #3 in Wisconsin for the cheapest homeowners insurance for high-value homes.
$5,203
4. USAA
In 2020, USAA ranked #4 in Wisconsin for the cheapest homeowners insurance for high-value homes.
$5,429
5. American Family
In 2020, American Family ranked #5 in Wisconsin for the cheapest homeowners insurance for high-value homes.
$6,539
Best Homeowners Insurance Companies if You Have a Pool
For pool houses with an average dwelling cost of $250,000, Erie presents the best homeowners insurance rate in Wisconsin, with an average annual cost of $492. You might want to check with your insurance carrier if there are options to cover pool repair expenses.
Cheapest Homeowners Insurance for Pool Home
Company
Amountper year
1. Erie
In 2020, Erie ranked #1 in Wisconsin for the cheapest homeowners insurance for homes with a pool.
$492
2. Allstate
In 2020, Allstate ranked #2 in Wisconsin for the cheapest homeowners insurance for homes with a pool.
$963
3. Travelers
In 2020, Travelers ranked #3 in Wisconsin for the cheapest homeowners insurance for homes with a pool.
$971
4. Allied
In 2020, Allied ranked #4 in Wisconsin for the cheapest homeowners insurance for homes with a pool.
$1,059
5. USAA
In 2020, USAA ranked #5 in Wisconsin for the cheapest homeowners insurance for homes with a pool.
$1,251
Cheapest Home Insurance in Wisconsin if You Have Poor Credit
Your credit score is another factor that influences your homeowners insurance price in Wisconsin. You can keep your credit score high by making debt payments on time. In Wisconsin, Auto-Owners Insurance Co offers the cheapest option for homeowners with poor credit, with an average annual premium of $1,512 for a dwelling coverage baseline amount of $250,000.
Cheapest Homeowners Insurance for Poor Credit
Company
Amountper year
1. Auto-Owners Insurance Co
In 2020, Auto-Owners Insurance Co ranked #1 for the cheapest homeowners insurance for owners with poor credit in Wisconsin.
$1,512
2. Allied
In 2020, Allied ranked #2 for the cheapest homeowners insurance for owners with poor credit in Wisconsin.
$1,801
3. Allstate
In 2020, Allstate ranked #3 for the cheapest homeowners insurance for owners with poor credit in Wisconsin.
$2,042
4. Travelers
In 2020, Travelers ranked #4 for the cheapest homeowners insurance for owners with poor credit in Wisconsin.
$2,089
5. American Family
In 2020, American Family ranked #5 for the cheapest homeowners insurance for owners with poor credit in Wisconsin.
$2,592
How to Get Homeowners Insurance Quotes in Wisconsin
You’ll need to disclose necessary personal information as well as the estimated value of your property, possessions and any add-ons to the insurance provider when you request home insurance quotes in Wisconsin. The carrier will ask you pertinent questions to learn about your property, such as its current condition, worth and other details. You’ll then get a tailored quote based on your answers.
Compare Home Insurance Rates
Ensure you're getting the best rate for your home insurance. Compare quotes from the top insurance companies.
Other Considerations for Homeowners Insurance in Wisconsin
To compute your home insurance premium in Wisconsin, insurance carriers may assess the average home value, weather risks and crime statistics in your location, among other factors. Wisconsin is a relatively safe state as it ranks 42nd in the U.S. for the number of property crimes per 100,000. FBI figures indicate that there were 17,176 violent crimes and 90,686 property crimes in the state in 2018.
Wisconsin ranks 33rd for home value, with an average house price of $202,029. Your residence could experience hazardous weather conditions if you live in a region that encounters natural disasters. It’s good to keep yourself informed on the frequency of natural calamities in your area and prepare for emergencies beforehand by getting proper home insurance protection.
Do You Need Flood Insurance in Wisconsin?
Wisconsin ranks 38th for flood risk. About 8.1%, or roughly 273,400 homes, could have exposure to flood damage in this state. To get protection, you may want to obtain government-sponsored National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) coverage. Plus, you might consider enhancing your coverage amount by buying a supplemental private policy.
Do You Need Hail Insurance in Wisconsin?
Wisconsin ranks 23rd in the U.S. for the total number of hail events. In 2011, the state had 185 hail events. Property owners in this state may want to get home insurance protection against possible hail damage.
Methodology
MoneyGeek analyzed homeowners insurance premiums from 16 of the top insurance companies in Wisconsin that were provided in partnership with Quadrant. Our analysis includes quotes from ZIP codes across Wisconsin. Quotes were gathered with an average home profile of 2,500 square feet, built in 2000, with an average dwelling coverage value of $250,000, liability coverage of $100,000 and personal property coverage of $100,000.
Sources
- AM Best. "Rating." Accessed August 27, 2020.
- Business Insider. "Here's the typical home price in every state — and what you can actually get for that money." Accessed August 9, 2020.
- FBI. "2018 Crime in the United States." Accessed August 10, 2020.
- First Street Foundation. "The First National Flood Risk Assessment Defining America’s Growing Risk." Accessed August 10, 2020.
- Flood Factor. "Find Your Home’s Flood Factor." Accessed August 10, 2020.
- Insurance information institute. "Facts + Statistics: Hail." Accessed August 10, 2020.
- Insurance information institute. "Facts + Statistics: Hurricanes." Accessed August 10, 2020.
- Insurance Information Institute. "Facts + Statistics: Wildfires." Accessed August 10, 2020.
- J.D. Power. "Homeowners’ Satisfaction with Property Claims Reaches Record High as Insurers Focus on Relationship Management, J.D. Power Finds." Accessed August 27, 2020.
- Verisk. "Wildfire Risk Analysis." Accessed August 10, 2020.