Exploring the Difference Between Home Equity and Home Improvement Loan Options

Banner image
ByChristopher Boston
Reviewed byTimothy Manni
fact checked icon
ByChristopher Boston
fact checked icon
Reviewed byTimothy Manni
fact checked icon

Updated: January 10, 2024

Advertising & Editorial Disclosure

Owning a home is more than a monthly mortgage payment — it's a continuing investment. Beyond the standard mortgage, insurance and property taxes, you face unexpected costs. These could include a leaky roof, a worn-out HVAC system or a much-needed kitchen renovation. Two financing options usually surface in these situations: home equity and improvement loans.

Both can help you manage the ongoing costs of homeownership by turning your house's value into accessible funds. However, they differ in ways that can significantly impact your financial health. Understanding the difference between home equity and home improvement loans allows homeowners to select the option that aligns best with their financial situation, needs and long-term goals.

Loading...

What Is a Home Equity Loan?

A home equity loan is essentially a second mortgage. It allows homeowners to borrow money against their home's equity (the portion of the house that you truly own), which is its value minus what you still owe on your mortgage. Homeowners use it to fund significant financial needs. It might include home renovations that can boost the property's value, debt consolidation or covering considerable expenses like tuition fees or medical bills.

To secure a home equity loan, you apply with a lender — either a bank, credit union or online lender. They assess your creditworthiness and your home's equity. Each lender offers different interest rates and terms, so shopping around can help you find the best deal that fits your needs.

If approved, you receive the loan as a lump sum that you repay over a specified term, usually 5-15 years. These payments are made in regular installments and include both the loan principal and interest, much like your primary mortgage.

What Is a Home Improvement Loan?

As its name suggests, a home improvement loan is used to cover the costs related to home renovations or repairs. Unlike home equity loans, they are unsecured loans. That means they don't require your home as collateral. Homeowners typically use these loans for medium-sized or smaller home improvement projects. Think updated kitchens, revamped bathrooms or even that new solar panel installation you've been considering — anything that enhances your living space and helps increase your property's value.

A home improvement loan works just like any other personal loan. After applying and getting approved by a lender, you receive the funds and repay the loan over time. However, remember that repayment begins almost immediately after you receive the funds, so factoring it into your household budget can help you keep your debt manageable.

Spot the Difference Between Home Equity and Home Improvement Loans

While both home equity and home improvement loans can help finance your home-related expenses, each has unique features and requirements. Understanding these differences can guide homeowners toward financing that aligns with their specific needs, financial situation and risk tolerance. The table below details how these two loans compare.

Comparison Areas
Home Equity Loans
Home Improvement Loans

Collateral Required

Yes. Your home serves
as collateral.

No. These are usually
unsecured loans.

Borrowing Limit

Based on the amount of
equity in your home.

It varies between lenders
(some offer up to $100,000),
but depends on creditworthiness
and lender policies.

Interest Rates

Generally lower as
the loan is secured.

Typically higher as the loan is
unsecured.

Tax Benefits

Interest could be tax-deductible
if funds are used for home improvements.

No tax benefits since it's
considered a personal loan.

Repayment Period

Longer terms,
usually five to 15 years.

Shorter terms,
often between one and seven years.

While home equity and home improvement loans offer means to finance your home-related projects, they cater to different financial scenarios. Understanding these can help you determine which is suited for your unique circumstance.

Situations Suited for Home Equity Loans: A Closer Look

Let’s look at several scenarios where a home equity loan might be beneficial. Identifying similar situations in the real world can help you make a decision.

Rachel's Radical Remodel

Rachel has been living in her 30-year-old home for a decade and decides it's time for a major upgrade. She plans to install a modern kitchen with the latest appliances, add a sunroom for that extra relaxation spot and transform her unused basement into a home theater.

She expects her expenses to run high since the renovations are substantial. Given her significant equity built up over the years, a home equity loan can offer Rachel the large sum she needs. Plus, the lower interest rates compared to a personal loan make it a financially sound choice.

Mark's Money Management

Mark is juggling multiple debts — credit card balances, a car loan and some personal loans — all with high-interest rates. Keeping track of numerous due dates and varying interest rates has become a headache for him. A home equity loan can come to his rescue with its lower interest rates and a single monthly payment. Mark can consolidate his debts, effectively reducing his total interest costs and simplifying his repayment process.

Sarah's Educational Expedition

Sarah's daughter has received acceptance from her dream university. While the news brings joy, the looming college fees are a cause for concern. Instead of opting for high-interest private student loans, Sarah is considering using her home equity. With its higher borrowing limits, a home equity loan can cover the hefty tuition fees. Plus, the interest might be tax-deductible, offering her potential savings.

Tom's Business Birth

Tom has a great idea for a tech start-up, but his savings won't cover the initial costs. Seeking investment at this early stage could mean giving up a large portion of his business. However, he's been paying his mortgage for 15 years and has built up substantial equity in his home. Due to its high borrowing limits and lower interest rates, a home equity loan could provide the capital he needs to kickstart his business while allowing him to retain full ownership.

Always remember that while home equity loans provide potential benefits, they also pose risks, such as the possibility of losing your home if you can't repay the loan. Make your decision carefully, considering all factors that apply to your specific circumstances.

Situations Suited for Home Improvement Loans: A Detailed View

Let's turn our focus toward home improvement loans. Although you won't get the same amounts as with a home equity loan, you'll get your funds sooner (and these aren't tied to your home's value). Let's explore some scenarios where a home improvement loan could be the right choice.

Emma's Eco Endeavors

Emma wants to invest in a greener future by adding solar panels to her home. She's carefully researched the cost, realizing it's substantial but not staggering. A home improvement loan can provide her with the required funds without tapping into her home equity. This would be an ideal fit, allowing her to repay her solar investment over time, reaping both environmental and potentially financial rewards.

Liam's Leafy Paradise

Liam's vision for a lush, tranquil garden requires funding. With a moderate cost for professional landscaping, his dreams are within reach. A home improvement loan can help cover these expenses without requiring him to leverage his home's equity, making it a fitting choice to bring his green dream to life.

Karen's Culinary Castle

Karen's kitchen is begging for a refresh, but she isn't planning an extreme makeover — just new cabinets, updated appliances and a fresh coat of paint. The cost is significant but not large enough to warrant a home equity loan. With its lower borrowing limit and faster funding, a home improvement loan matches Karen's needs perfectly.

Bob's Bathing Bonanza

Bob yearns for a luxurious upgrade to his tired bathroom — a new bathtub, modern tiles and tasteful lighting. These upgrades are minor in scale and cost but can make a big impact. A home improvement loan is ideal for Bob, giving him the financial flexibility to achieve his bathroom transformation without tapping into his home equity.

A home improvement loan allows homeowners to tackle renovation projects without jeopardizing their houses. It's best for homeowners who prefer a no-collateral option, need smaller amounts and are comfortable with higher interest rates.

Practical Tips to Guide Your Loan Decision

Choosing between a home equity loan and a home improvement loan largely depends on your personal circumstances and the specifics of your project. Here are some key considerations to keep in mind:

Loading...

By understanding the basics of each loan, knowing your project scope, assessing your risk tolerance and keeping your creditworthiness in mind, you're more likely to make the wisest financial choice for your home improvement dreams.

mglogo icon
MONEYGEEK EXPERT TIP

If you decide to move forward with a home equity loan or line of credit, shop around between different lenders. Talk to a credit union, an online bank, a local bank and perhaps a large national lender. You'll find that these different types of institutions offer different rates and provide borrowers with certain advantages. While the online or national lender may not offer you the lowest rates, for example, their technological offerings may be second to none. — Timothy Manni, Mortgage and Real Estate Consultant

Alternative Financing Options for Your Home Projects

Aside from home equity and home improvement loans, there are other financing options available to consider for funding your home-related projects. Each option comes with its own advantages and considerations. Let's explore a few:

Alternative
Description
Advantages
Disadvantages

Unsecured loans for
various purposes,
including home
improvements.

Fast approval
process, no collateral
required, fixed
interest rates.

Interest rates may be
higher than home
equity loans,
borrowing limits could
be lower.

Revolving line of
credit secured by
home equity, similar
to a credit card.

Flexibility to borrow
as needed, potential
for lower initial
interest rates,
interest-only
payments during the
draw period.

Interest rates can
fluctuate during the
repayment period,
the property is used
as collateral.

Replacing an existing
mortgage with a new
one for a higher
amount, receiving the
difference as cash.

Access to a lump
sum of cash at
potentially lower
interest rate
consolidation of
existing debts, single
mortgage payment.

Involves closing costs
and fees, the
property serves as
collateral.

Credit cards offering
0% APR during an
introductory period.

No interest during the
introductory period if
the balance is paid
off within the
specified timeframe.

After the introductory
period, interest rates
can become higher
than other loan options.

Each alternative financing option comes with its own terms and conditions. Their suitability depends on your financial goals, creditworthiness and the scope of your home project. Before deciding, carefully assess the terms, interest rates and repayment plans of each to find which fits you best.

Frequently Asked Questions

Your financial journey doesn't have to feel like uncharted territory. These frequently asked questions (and their answers) can lead you to further valuable insights.

Which is better: a Home Equity Loan or a Home Improvement Loan?
How do I know if I have enough home equity to qualify for a loan?
Can I apply for both a Home Equity Loan and a Home Improvement Loan simultaneously?
Are there any closing costs associated with these loans?
Can I get a Home Equity Loan or Home Improvement Loan with bad credit?
Can I refinance my Home Equity Loan or Home Improvement Loan?

About Christopher Boston


Christopher Boston headshot

Christopher (Croix) Boston was the Head of Loans content at MoneyGeek, with over five years of experience researching higher education, mortgage and personal loans.

Boston has a bachelor's degree from the Seattle Pacific University. They pride themselves in using their skills and experience to create quality content that helps people save and spend efficiently.