Alternatives to Traditional Homeowners Insurance


Enter your ZIP code to get started

Shield

Free. Simple. Secure.

Updated: August 14, 2024

Advertising & Editorial Disclosure

FAIR plans, high-risk insurance providers and small regional insurers may provide home insurance alternatives for individuals having trouble securing a conventional policy. However, if the cost of traditional home insurance or property issues are your concerns, you can also implement a few strategies to help lower your premiums.

Even though traditional insurance can be challenging to obtain, there are strategies to help ensure your home remains financially protected. Adequate insurance coverage safeguards your financial investment and provides peace of mind in the event of damage to your home.

Key Takeaways

FAIR plans, insurers specializing in high-risk policies and small regional providers are some alternatives to traditional homeowners insurance.

High-risk homes often require home insurance alternatives. These homes may include those in disaster-prone areas, older homes with outdated systems or unoccupied properties.

If you don’t want to opt for home insurance alternatives, increasing your deductible and improving home security are effective strategies for lowering your premiums.

3 Alternatives to Traditional Home Insurance

When traditional homeowners insurance isn't an option, alternatives include FAIR plans, high-risk insurance providers and small regional insurers. These alternatives can offer the protection you need, ensuring your home is covered against unforeseen events. Even if conventional policies are out of reach, you can opt for home insurance alternatives with some form of coverage to safeguard your investment and peace of mind.

FAIR Plans

FAIR Plans, or Fair Access to Insurance Requirements Plans, provide essential coverage for homeowners who have been denied insurance by private companies. This alternative to homeowners insurance is managed by state insurance pools and offers basic protection against specific perils. Homeowners living in high-risk areas and those who have been denied coverage by multiple insurance companies can benefit the most from FAIR Plans.

Coverage typically includes:

  • Fire damage, including loss from wildfires
  • Windstorm damage, particularly in hurricane-prone areas
  • Hail damage, often significant in various regions
  • Explosions, which might not be covered under basic policies
  • Vandalism and malicious mischief, providing security in high-risk areas

However, as FAIR Plans are only an alternative to traditional homeowners insurance, they often provide limited coverage compared to standard homeowners insurance policies, focusing primarily on certain perils. They typically do not cover personal property loss or liability coverage for injuries or damages to others on your property.

How to Get a FAIR Plan

Obtaining a FAIR Plan involves several key steps, including providing evidence of insurance denials and contacting your state's FAIR Plan program. Once you have the necessary documentation, you can review the plan details and apply. Here’s how to get started:

  1. Prepare Documentation of Rejections: Collect and prepare documentation of insurance denials from traditional insurers to prove eligibility.
  2. Contact Your State’s FAIR Plan: Each state has its own FAIR Plan administration. Find contact details for the appropriate office and request application forms.
  3. Review Plan Details: Before applying, thoroughly review the FAIR Plan's coverage and exclusions to ensure it meets your needs for basic property insurance.
  4. Submit an Application: Complete the application process, including providing details about your property and insurance history.
  5. Have a Property Inspection: FAIR Plans typically require an inspection to ensure a property meets basic safety and maintenance standards.
  6. Finalize Coverage: If approved, finalize the details of your coverage and make any necessary premium payments to start your policy.

Contact your state's FAIR Plan administrator with any questions or concerns about obtaining coverage.

High-Risk Insurance Providers

High-risk insurance is an alternative to home insurance, specifically for homeowners whose properties are considered too risky for standard insurance companies. These insurers cater to homes with higher chances of damage due to location, construction or previous claims history and offer tailored policies to address those specific risks, often at higher premiums.

Take a look at common examples of high-risk homes below:

    earthquake icon

    Homes in Disaster-Prone Areas

    Properties located in regions frequently affected by natural disasters such as hurricanes, wildfires or floods. These homes are at a higher risk of sustaining significant damage, requiring specialized coverage.

    house2 icon

    Older Homes With Outdated Systems

    Houses with antiquated electrical, plumbing or heating systems that increase the likelihood of fire or water damage. Insurance providers see these outdated systems as potential hazards.

    garage icon

    Homes With Previous Claims

    Properties with a history of multiple insurance claims. Insurers consider these homes high-risk due to their track record of frequent claims.

    house icon

    Vacant or Unoccupied Homes

    Houses that remain vacant for extended periods are more susceptible to vandalism, theft and unnoticed maintenance issues. The lack of regular occupancy increases the risk profile, necessitating specialized insurance.

    mortgage icon

    Homes With Hazardous Conditions

    Properties with structural issues, such as unstable foundations or roofs in disrepair. These conditions pose significant risks that standard insurance might exclude from coverage.

How to Get High-Risk Home Insurance

Getting high-risk home insurance involves several key steps. Here’s a detailed guide on how to secure coverage for your high-risk home:

  1. Ask Your Neighbors About Their Insurance Coverage: If your home is high-risk because of its location, your neighbors may have valuable insights. They can help you find a high-risk house insurance company that will cover your property.
  2. Reach Out to Your Home Insurance Company: If you’re buying a new home that’s considered high risk, ask your current insurance agent if they can cover it or if they know of a company that can.
  3. Shop Around for High-Risk Home Insurance Companies: Though getting homeowners insurance in high-risk areas is challenging, you can find an insurer by shopping around and requesting quotes from various companies.
  4. Consider a FAIR Plan: If you can’t get home insurance in the voluntary market, a FAIR plan in your state might be a good option for coverage.
  5. Look Into Surplus Carriers: Surplus lines insurance carriers specialize in high-risk and high-value homes that other insurers won’t cover. However, be aware that this type of coverage may be relatively expensive.
  6. Improve Your Home: If your home needs repairs, making home improvements could remove it from the “high risk” category, making it much easier to insure.

Small Regional Insurers

Small regional insurers can be valuable alternatives to traditional homeowners insurance from major companies. These insurers often have a better understanding of the local risks and conditions, allowing them to offer more tailored and potentially more affordable coverage. Their customer service tends to be more personalized, fostering stronger relationships with policyholders. Additionally, regional insurers may be more flexible in underwriting policies for unique or high-risk properties, making them a viable option for homeowners who struggle to find coverage with larger, national companies.

How to Lower Home Insurance Premiums Instead of Seeking Alternatives

To reduce home insurance premiums, consider strategies such as increasing your deductible, improving home security and bundling insurance policies. If you’re looking at home insurance alternatives because traditional policy costs are beyond your budget, these methods can make it more affordable without sacrificing coverage. Opting for traditional home insurance is often better than alternatives as it offers more comprehensive protection.

Here’s how you can get cheap homeowners insurance:

1
Increase Your Deductible

Raising your deductible means paying more out-of-pocket in the event of a claim, but it can significantly lower your premium. This strategy works well if you have a solid emergency fund to cover potential costs. It also encourages careful maintenance of your home, reducing the likelihood of small, frequent claims.

2
Improve Home Security

Installing security systems, smoke detectors and deadbolt locks can lower your insurance premiums. These improvements reduce the risk of theft and fire, making your home less risky to insure. Many insurers offer discounts for homes with enhanced security features, so investing in these upgrades is worthwhile.

3
Bundle Insurance Policies

Combining your home insurance with other policies, such as auto or life insurance, can lead to substantial discounts. Insurance companies often provide better rates to customers with multiple policies. This not only saves money but also simplifies managing your insurance needs under one provider.

4
Maintain a Good Credit Score

Insurers often use credit scores to determine premiums, with higher scores typically leading to lower rates. Regularly monitor and improve your credit score by paying bills on time and reducing debt. A good credit score reflects financial responsibility, which insurers view as a lower risk.

5
Perform Regular Home Maintenance

Keeping your home in good repair can prevent damage and reduce the need for claims. Regular maintenance includes tasks like inspecting the roof, cleaning gutters and checking plumbing systems. A well-maintained home poses fewer risks, leading to potential premium reductions from your insurer.

6
Review and Update Your Policy Annually

Regularly review your home insurance policy to ensure it accurately reflects your needs and the current value of your home and belongings. Updating your policy can help you avoid paying for unnecessary coverage or missing out on potential savings. Staying proactive with your policy ensures you always get the best possible rate.

Common Homeowners Insurance Discounts

Instead of opting for home insurance alternatives to lower premiums, many homeowners can easily qualify for insurance discounts, such as those for installing security systems and bundling policies. Understanding and taking advantage of these discounts can help you save money while ensuring comprehensive coverage.

Here are some of the most common discounts available:

Discount
Description

Security System Discount

Installing security systems, smoke detectors and deadbolt locks can lower your insurance premiums by reducing the risk of theft and fire. Many insurers offer significant discounts for enhanced security features.

Bundling Discount

Combining your home insurance with other policies, such as auto or life insurance, can lead to substantial discounts. Insurance companies provide better rates to customers who hold multiple policies with them.

Good Credit Discount

Maintaining a good credit score can lead to lower insurance premiums. Insurers often use credit scores to determine rates, with higher scores typically resulting in discounts.

New Home Discount

Newly constructed homes often qualify for lower insurance rates. Newer homes are usually built with modern materials and up-to-date safety standards, reducing the risk for insurers.

Non-Smoker Discount

Homeowners who do not smoke can receive discounts as their homes have a lower risk of fire. Many insurance companies offer reduced rates to nonsmokers.

FAQ About Home Insurance Alternatives

Finding suitable alternatives to homeowners insurance can be challenging, especially for those who have been denied coverage or own high-risk properties. Below are frequently asked questions to help you understand the alternatives to traditional home insurance.

What are the alternatives to traditional homeowners insurance?
What should you do if you can't get any type of homeowners insurance?
What types of properties are considered high-risk?

About Mark Fitzpatrick


Mark Fitzpatrick headshot

Mark Fitzpatrick is a Licensed Property and Casualty Insurance Producer and MoneyGeek's Head of Insurance. He has analyzed the insurance market for over five years, conducting original research and creating personalized content for every kind of buyer. He has been quoted in several insurance-related publications, including CNBC, NBC News and Mashable.

Fitzpatrick earned a master’s degree in economics and international relations from Johns Hopkins University and a bachelor’s degree from Boston College. He is passionate about using his knowledge of economics and insurance to bring transparency around financial topics and help others feel confident in their money moves.