Home Equity or Personal Loan: What’s Your Best Option?

Banner image
Reviewed byTimothy Manni
fact checked icon
fact checked icon
Reviewed byTimothy Manni
Edited byJonathan Ramos
fact checked icon

Updated: April 4, 2024

Advertising & Editorial Disclosure

When facing a financial need, a fixed-rate personal loan can be a lifeline. Imagine planning your dream wedding but needing more funds. A fixed-rate personal loan, with its predictable payments and the lack of collateral, allows you to budget confidently. In contrast, a home equity loan, secured against a home’s value, offers a different approach to borrowing. While they can provide larger sums at potentially lower interest rates, they also involve placing your house as collateral.

Navigating between these two financing options involves understanding these key differences. Our guide focuses on personal vs. home equity loans, helping you determine which option best aligns with your financial scenario and borrowing needs.


For the right borrower, both home equity loans and personal loans are great options. But even when you look like the right candidate for a specific product on paper, you must truly understand your other options. For example, it's easy to think that just because you have a lot of equity built up, a home equity loan is a better choice than a personal loan. But if you've built up so much equity that you're close to paying off your loan, it could be a good idea not to take out a loan that removes your hard-earned equity and instead opt for a personal loan. — Timothy Manni, Mortgage and Real Estate Consultant

How Do Home Equity Loans Work

Home equity loans let you borrow against your home's value. It's like taking a portion of your home's value and converting it into cash. Applying for one usually involves proving you own a home and showing how much it's worth. Having a thorough understanding of this process is crucial for effectively leveraging the equity in your home.

Interest rates and terms for home equity loans can vary. Generally, they come with fixed interest rates. That means your payments stay the same over time, making it excellent for budgeting. However, rates depend on factors like your credit score and loan amount. You'll also need to get a home appraisal done to confirm your house's value. Finally, you'll repay the loan in regular monthly payments over a set period, which could be several years. Knowing these details about home equity loan rates and repayment can help you decide if this loan fits your financial plan.

Pros and Cons of Home Equity Loans

Home equity loans have several advantages, such as the ability to borrow substantial amounts against your home's value, which is ideal for significant expenses like home renovations or consolidating high-interest debts. It also offers some fixed-rate loan benefits, leading to stability in repayment amounts. However, it's crucial to weigh these against the risks, like the possibility of foreclosure if you cannot make payments. Balancing the pros and cons of home equity loans can make a difference in your decision-making process. Here's a table that details both sides:


Lower Interest Rates: Often lower than credit cards or personal loans, making repayments more affordable.

Risk of Foreclosure: If you default on payments, you could lose your home.

Higher Loan Amounts: Based on home equity, allowing significant borrowing for major expenses.

Requires Home Equity: Only an option if you have sufficient equity in your home.

Potential Tax Deductions: Interest may be tax-deductible if used for home improvements.

Lengthy Approval Process: Involves property valuation and more extensive documentation.

Debt Consolidation: Useful for paying off high-interest debts.

Closing Costs and Fees: Can be expensive, adding to the loan's overall cost.

Fixed Repayment Schedule: Predictable monthly payments over a set period.

Less Flexibility: The loan amount and terms are fixed once the loan is disbursed.

The pros and cons show that while home equity loans offer financial leverage and potential tax benefits, the risk of foreclosure and the requirement of home equity are significant factors to consider. It's crucial to weigh these factors carefully to determine if a home equity loan aligns with your goals.

How Do Personal Loans Work

Personal loans are unsecured, which means they're given based on your credit history and income rather than requiring collateral like your home. Your ability to get a loan and the amount you can borrow depend on how financially responsible you've been. The application process is straightforward, and you can usually expect a decision within a few days.

The interest rates for personal loans vary widely. They depend on factors like your credit score and the loan amount. Generally, the better your credit, the lower the rates you qualify for. These loans offer flexibility in how much you can borrow and how you use the funds — from consolidating debt to covering unexpected expenses. Repayment terms are another flexible aspect, with fixed monthly payments spread over periods that can range from a few months to several years, giving you control over your financial planning.

Pros and Cons of Personal Loans

Flexibility is an advantage of a personal loan, allowing you to use the loan for various purposes, from consolidating debt to funding a large purchase. However, focusing only on the positives or negatives can lead to an unbalanced financial decision with long-term consequences. For example, you might face higher interest rates with a personal loan. Our pros and cons table can help you achieve a more balanced perspective:


Flexibility in Use: Can be used for multiple purposes, from debt consolidation to unexpected expenses.

Higher Interest Rates: Often higher than secured loans like home equity loans.

No Collateral Required: Unsecured, so there is no risk of losing property.

Influence of Credit Score: Lower credit scores can lead to higher rates or loan denial.

**Quick Funding: Often faster approval and fund disbursement compared to secured loans.

Potential for Debt Accumulation: Easy access may lead to unnecessary borrowing.

Fixed Repayment Terms: Clear, predictable monthly payments make budgeting easier.

Fees and Penalties: Possible origination fees and prepayment penalties.

Variety of Lenders: Available from various lenders, including banks, credit unions and online lenders.

Limited Amounts: Loan amounts may be lower than secured loans.

While they provide quick access to funds without needing collateral, personal loan costs can be higher due to interest rates tied to your credit history. According to the Federal Reserve, the average rate for 24-month personal loans as of Q4 of 2023 was 12.35%. That underscores the importance of considering your credit score and financial health when exploring your options. Balancing these pros and cons ensures you make an informed decision that aligns with your plans.

Home Equity Loans vs. Personal Loans

After exploring the details of both home equity loans and personal loans separately, it's time to put them side by side for a clearer comparison. Here's a table that threshes out the details.

Comparison Areas
Home Equity Loans
Personal Loans


Secured by your home.

Unsecured, no collateral needed.


Generally lower, fixed rates.

Higher, can be fixed or variable.

Loan Terms

Longer terms, up to 15-30 years.

Shorter terms, usually 1-5 years.

Loan Amounts

Based on home equity, the loan amount can be as much as 85% of your home’s value.

Typically smaller, varies by lender and creditworthiness.

Eligibility Requirements

  • Adequate home equity
  • Good credit history
  • Stable income
  • Home appraisal
  • Good to excellent credit score
  • Stable income
  • Debt-to-income ratio

Picking between a home equity and a personal loan depends on your financial objectives and personal circumstances. The former is suitable for larger, long-term financing needs, leveraging the value of your home. The latter is ideal for shorter-term financial requirements without the risk of losing property. By considering these factors, you can determine the loan type that best aligns with your goals.

When to Choose a Home Equity Loan

Choosing a home equity loan without considering your specific needs might result in financial stress. It's essential to recognize scenarios where its advantages, such as interest rate stability, align with your requirements. It can be a deciding factor when comparing it to a personal loan's fluctuating rates. By delving into real-life examples, we'll illustrate when a home equity loan, with its interest rate stability, is the most beneficial choice for borrowers.

Sarah's Equity Edge: Unlocking Home Value

Sarah is planning to make significant upgrades to her kitchen. As an accountant, she is well-versed in financial matters and understands the potential tax advantages of certain home improvements. With a well-maintained classic colonial house, she's built up significant equity over the years. However, Sarah's primary motivation for considering a home equity loan over other options is the potential tax benefits associated with using the loan for home renovations.

oven icon

The IRS allows homeowners to deduct interest paid on home equity loans when the funds are used to purchase, build or considerably improve the home that secures the loan. For Sarah, this means her kitchen upgrade increases her home's value but also offers her a tax advantage. This reflects how home equity loans can serve dual purposes: facilitating significant home improvements and providing potential tax relief.

Joy's Strategy: Leveraging Equity with Caution

Meet Joy, a middle-aged homeowner with a modest house in a well-established neighborhood. Over the years, she has experienced some financial ups and downs, which have affected her credit score. Despite this, she has managed to maintain a stable job and consistently pay her mortgage, building up a decent amount of home equity. Now, she needs to consolidate high-interest credit card debt. Joy is worried that her credit score might get her higher interest rates on unsecured loan offers.

creditCards icon

Joy's credit score of 650 makes it difficult for her to secure a low-interest unsecured loan. However, given the equity in her home, she may be able to borrow funds at a more reasonable rate, making debt consolidation possible. By leveraging a home equity loan, Joy can utilize the value she's accumulated in her home to manage her debt more effectively. This demonstrates that with the right approach, even those with less-than-ideal credit scores can find suitable financing solutions.

Jasmine's Green Dream: Eco-Friendly Home Makeover

Jasmine, a landscape architect, has always been passionate about the environment. She's eager to transform her home into an eco-friendly haven with solar panels and a rainwater harvesting system. While Jasmine has some savings, the total cost of these green upgrades is substantial. She owns a bungalow, with considerable equity built over the years. Jasmine ponders her financial options to fund her eco-project.

ecoHouse icon

The significant equity in Jasmine’s bungalow is an ideal source for the substantial funds required for the eco-friendly upgrades. Home equity loans typically offer lower interest rates than personal loans, making this option more cost-effective for large-scale projects like hers. Moreover, this choice enables Jasmine to invest in her property, potentially increasing its value while realizing her dream of an environmentally sustainable living space.

Naomi's Extended Plan: Embracing Long-Term Financial Strategy

Naomi has lived in her beloved two-story home for 15 years. Her consistent mortgage payments and the area's steady property value rise have resulted in her house now being worth $350,000, significantly more than the $200,000 mortgage she initially took out. Looking ahead, Naomi is preparing to send her daughter to college in a few years and wants to start planning for this significant expense. Considering a home equity loan, she's attracted to the prospect of a longer repayment period that aligns with her financial planning timeline.

talkingProfessor icon

The equity Naomi has built in her home provides a substantial base to borrow against. A home equity loan offers Naomi a lower interest rate and a repayment schedule that stretches over several years, aligning with her daughter's educational timeline. The extended repayment period allows her to manage her finances without immediate pressure, letting her prepare for her daughter's college expenses in a manageable, structured way. Naomi's thoughtful decision-making resulted in her leveraging her home's equity to secure her family's future while maintaining a comfortable financial balance.

Ethan's Market Momentum: Capitalizing on Rising Home Values

Ethan is a real estate agent with a keen eye for property potential. He purchased his house in an emerging neighborhood for $250,000 five years ago. Today, thanks to the area's development and popularity, his home is valued at $400,000, marking a substantial increase in equity. Ethan now plans to build a rental unit on his property, a move that promises additional income. While a personal loan is an option, Ethan realizes the potential to tap into his home's $150,000 equity growth.

bigHouseRent icon

Ethan decided to go for a home equity loan because of the growing equity in his property, thanks to the rising market value in his neighborhood. It allowed him to borrow against the increased value of his home at a lower interest rate than most personal loans. Building a rental unit is a strategic move, potentially increasing his home's value further and generating ongoing income. A home equity loan became a part of Ethan's broader investment strategy, leveraging his property's appreciation to enhance his financial future.

When to Choose a Personal Loan

Selecting the right loan type can profoundly affect your financial path. For instance, choosing a personal loan that suits your requirements can provide both convenience and security. This emphasizes the importance of recognizing situations where a personal loan may be more beneficial than a home equity loan. Let's explore scenarios that demonstrate when personal loans are preferable, each presented through a unique lens.

Quick Cash Fix: Liam's Laptop Lifeline

Liam is a college sophomore pursuing a degree in graphic design. His studies are his passion, and he depends heavily on his laptop for all coursework. However, it unexpectedly malfunctions in the middle of the semester, leaving Liam in a bind. With crucial projects looming, he urgently requires a replacement but finds himself short on funds for an immediate purchase. Despite assessing his finances thoroughly, Liam realizes he can't stretch his budget to afford a high-end laptop for graphic design.

laptop icon

Liam's choice of a fixed-rate personal loan aligned perfectly with his urgent need for a new laptop. With quick processing and no collateral requirements, it can provide the swift financial support he needs. The fixed interest rate offers him predictable monthly payments that fit neatly into his tight student budget.

Home Sweet Loan: Emma's Quest for Financial Security

Emma, a nurse and single mother living in a suburban neighborhood, is facing unexpected medical expenses for her son's treatment. While she has some savings, she doesn't want to drain them completely, preferring to keep a safety net for future emergencies. Her home, a cozy three-bedroom house, is her prized possession and a sanctuary for her family. The thought of putting it at risk makes her uneasy.

hospital icon

Emma values the security of her home above all else, and a personal loan, being unsecured, does not require her to use her house as collateral. It significantly reduces the risk of potentially losing her home. She was also looking for a straightforward financial solution that provides the necessary funds without complicated terms or the fear of escalating debts tied to her property. The personal loan meets her immediate financial need and aligns with her desire to maintain stability and security for her family's future.

Zach's Equity Escape: Finding Financial Flexibility

Zach is a new homeowner, having just moved into a modest two-bedroom house in a growing neighborhood. Homeownership was a milestone, but he hasn't built up significant equity yet. When faced with an unexpected expense, such as a costly car repair, Zach finds himself in a tight spot. He needs a manageable amount of money, but his limited home equity makes a home equity loan unfeasible.

carColored icon

Being a new homeowner, Zach hasn't had enough time to build substantial equity that could be leveraged for a loan. That makes a personal loan a fitting choice since it doesn't require any collateral. Its clear terms and manageable repayment structure allow him to address his urgent car repair without the stress of jeopardizing his new home or navigating the complexities of a loan tied to home equity.

Ava's Credit Confidence: Harnessing High Scores

Over the years, Ava has cultivated an excellent credit score through disciplined spending and timely payments. She plans to enroll in an advanced certification course to boost her career as a financial analyst, but the tuition is steep. While she has the option of a home equity loan, her outstanding credit score opens up an attractive alternative — a personal loan with favorable terms.

graduationCap icon

Ava decides to get a personal loan, capitalizing on her excellent credit score. Her impeccable financial history positions her to obtain a personal loan with highly competitive interest rates, making it less risky than a home equity loan. It allows her to finance her education without tying the debt to her home. The simplicity and speed of obtaining a personal loan are also advantages for Ava, letting her start her course without delay. A personal loan provides an effective way to invest in her future while maintaining the security of her assets.

Mike's Swift Solution: Short-Term Loan Success

Mike, an up-and-coming freelance photographer, recently landed a lucrative contract for a large event. To take on this opportunity, he needs to upgrade his camera equipment. Mike has a steady income from various gigs but wants to avoid slipping into his savings or being tied down by a long-term financial commitment. Owning a house with some equity, he initially considers a home equity loan but realizes that his need is short-term and doesn't justify using his home as collateral.

photoCamera icon

A personal loan is ideal because it's aligned with Mike's short-term financial needs. Its flexibility and expedience suit his situation, where he needs a quick influx of funds to capitalize on a career-enhancing opportunity. Unlike a home equity loan, which involves a longer commitment and puts his home at risk, a personal loan provides Mike with the required amount without long-term strings attached. It allows him to invest in his professional growth while maintaining financial agility.

Alternative Options

While home equity and personal loans are common choices for additional funds, they're not the only options. There are several alternatives that might better suit your needs or preferences. Let's explore these to ensure you have all the information needed to make the best financial decision.

In-depth Discussion
Who It’s Best For

Similar to a home equity loan, but they work like credit cards against your home equity. Offers flexibility to borrow as needed within a limit.

Best for those who need ongoing access to funds and are comfortable using their home as collateral.

Useful for smaller, short-term expenses. They have higher interest rates but provide immediate access to funds.

Ideal for those with good credit management skills and for expenses that can be quickly repaid.

Involves refinancing your mortgage for more than you owe and taking the difference in cash. They have potentially lower interest rates than a home equity loan but extend mortgage terms.

Suitable for homeowners who can secure a lower rate, need a large sum and are comfortable extending their mortgage.

Using saved funds meant for unexpected expenses. No interest or debt involved but requires prior planning and saving.

Perfect for those who have the discipline to save and prefer to avoid debt.

Remember, when comparing personal loans and home equity loans and their alternatives, assessing your situation, borrowing needs and comfort with potential risks is crucial. Always consider these elements to make a decision that aligns with your individual circumstances.

FAQ: Home Equity Loans vs. Personal Loans

Understanding the nuances of different loan options is essential when considering how to finance your needs. We answered some common questions to provide in-depth insights into the pros and cons of home equity and personal loans. These can help guide you through the key differences and considerations, allowing you to make informed decisions that align with your financial goals.

What’s the difference between a home equity loan and a personal loan?
Can I take out multiple personal loans or home equity loans?
What factors should I consider when choosing between a home equity loan and a personal loan?
Should I get a home equity loan or a personal loan for a major purchase?
What are the tax implications of a home equity loan?
Can I use a personal loan for home improvements?
How do personal loans compare with other fixed-rate financial products?
How quickly can I access funds with a personal loan compared to a home equity loan?
Are there any alternatives to home equity and personal loans for financial emergencies?