Wisconsin Car Insurance Quotes: Compare Progressive, American Family and More

Out of the many car insurance companies to buy from, wouldn’t it be easier if you had a resource that compares your options? MoneyGeek gathered quotes from Progressive, American Family and State Farm for different drivers to help you get started.

Compare Auto Insurance Rates

Insurance Rates

Ensure you're getting the best rate for your auto insurance. Compare quotes from the top insurance companies.

widget-location-pin
Last Updated: 4/7/2022
Advertising & Editorial Disclosure
By     |  

Getting car insurance quotes in Wisconsin online takes around two to eight minutes to complete. But that's only for one insurance provider. MoneyGeek helps you compare policies within just a few minutes. Quotes range from $399 per year for a 40-year-old SUV driver with a clean record and excellent credit score, and up to $10,060 per year for a younger driver of a luxury sedan, with a DUI on their record and poor credit score.

Car Insurance Quotes in Wisconsin by Company

The biggest companies in Wisconsin with the highest market share are Progressive, American Family and State Farm. MoneyGeek rated these providers, as well as other car insurance providers in Wisconsin.

If you're looking to save on car insurance, MoneyGeek’s The Cheapest Car Insurance in Wisconsin might be a useful resource to refer to.

If you're looking at how much car insurance rates in Wisconsin change based on other factors, refer to our guide on The Average Car Insurance in Wisconsin.

However, keep in mind that these quotes are calculated before any possible car insurance discounts apply.

MoneyGeek collected thousands of car insurance quotes in Wisconsin. Toggle your driver characteristics to personalize quotes for a better estimate of your rates.

iconribbonCompareQuotesWisconsin2022

Compare Wisconsin Car Insurance Quotes

Customize the toggles and get Wisconsin car insurance quotes that fit your profile

Progressive Car Insurance Quotes in Wisconsin

The average cost of car insurance in Wisconsin from Progressive is $842 per year.

The most affordable car insurance quotes from Progressive in Wisconsin are an average of $342 per year. This quote is for a 40-year-old SUV driver with a clean record and excellent credit score getting a state minimum policy. The most expensive quote from this provider costs $8,911 per year. This quote is for a 19 to 20-year-old young driver of a luxury sedan with an accident record and a poor credit score getting full coverage.

Because rates vary based on a driver’s profile and history, you can also use MoneyGeek’s tool and see how much a state minimum or a full coverage costs for your profile.

Progressive Car Insurance Quotes in Wisconsin

Scroll for more

swipe icon
  • Coverage Level
    Progressive Average Annual Quote
  • State Minimum Liability
    $418
  • 100/300/100 Comprehensive/Collision
    $867

American Family Car Insurance Quotes in Wisconsin

Car insurance quotes in Wisconsin from American Family averages around $752 per year. A 40-year-old driver with a clean record and excellent credit score gets the cheapest state minimum rate at an average of $458 per year — if they get the state minimum coverage.

A young driver with a DUI and poor credit score gets the most expensive full coverage rate at an average of $4,370 per year.

Compare the cost of a state minimum and full coverage policies for your profile using MoneyGeek’s tool.

American Family Car Insurance Quotes in Wisconsin

Scroll for more

swipe icon
  • Coverage Level
    American Family Average Annual Quote
  • State Minimum Liability
    $560
  • 100/300/100 Comprehensive/Collision
    $775

State Farm Car Insurance Quotes in Wisconsin

In Wisconsin, the average cost of car insurance available from State Farm is $777 per year.

Rates vary depending on the driver’s history and profile. It can be as cheap as $314 per year, up to $5,216 per year. Those prices are based on a 40-year-old SUV driver with a clean record and excellent credit score getting a state minimum and a young driver of a luxury sedan with an accident record and poor credit score, respectively.

You may use MoneyGeek’s tool to see how much a state minimum or full coverage costs for your history and profile.

State Farm Car Insurance Quotes in Wisconsin

Scroll for more

swipe icon
  • Coverage Level
    State Farm Average Annual Quote
  • State Minimum Liability
    $384
  • 100/300/100 Comprehensive/Collision
    $801

GEICO Car Insurance Quotes in Wisconsin

GEICO’s car insurance quotes averages at around $631 per year for drivers in Wisconsin. Depending on the driver’s history and profile, the rates can change from the cheapest at $262 per year up to the most expensive at $9,317 per year. Specifically, the cheapest rates are for a 40-year-old SUV driver with a clean record and excellent credit score, getting a state minimum policy. The most expensive rates are given to a 19 year old driver of a luxury sedan with a DUI and poor credit score getting a full coverage policy.

The rates will change as the driver’s history and profile change. You can toggle on MoneyGeek’s tool to see the different rates for a state minimum and full coverage.

GEICO Car Insurance Quotes in Wisconsin

Scroll for more

swipe icon
  • Coverage Level
    GEICO Average Annual Quote
  • State Minimum Liability
    $321
  • 100/300/100 Comprehensive/Collision
    $650

Allstate Car Insurance Quotes in Wisconsin

Wisconsin drivers can buy policies from Allstate at an average rate of $1,321 per year. The cheapest car insurance quotes in Wisconsin from Allstate cost $681 per year on average. This is for a 40-year-old SUV driver getting a state minimum policy, and with a clean record and credit score.

The most expensive rates from this provider cost $12,128 per year on average. This is for a 19 year old driver getting a full coverage policy, with an accident record and credit score.

You can use MoneyGeek’s tool to see your rates for a state minimum or full coverage.

Allstate Car Insurance Quotes in Wisconsin

Scroll for more

swipe icon
  • Coverage Level
    Allstate Average Annual Quote
  • State Minimum Liability
    $833
  • 100/300/100 Comprehensive/Collision
    $1,361

Erie Car Insurance Quotes in Wisconsin

Car insurance quotes in Wisconsin from Erie averages at $759 per year. A 40-year old SUV driver with a clean record and excellent credit score can score the cheapest state minimum rates at an average of $289 per year.

A 19 year old driver of a luxury sedan with a DUI and poor credit score pays the most expensive rates for full coverage at an average of $6,275 per year.

See how much a state minimum or a full coverage costs for your profile using MoneyGeek’s car insurance calculator.

Erie Car Insurance Quotes in Wisconsin

Scroll for more

swipe icon
  • Coverage Level
    Erie Average Annual Quote
  • State Minimum Liability
    $353
  • 100/300/100 Comprehensive/Collision
    $783

Acuity Car Insurance Quotes in Wisconsin

The average cost of policies in Wisconsin from Acuity is $851 per year. The cheapest rates from this provider averages at $345 per year. That is for a state minimum policy available to a 40-year-old SUV driver with a clean record and excellent credit score.

The most expensive rates averages at $10,636 per year. That is for a full coverage policy available to a 19 year old driver of a luxury sedan with a DUI record and poor credit score.

You may use MoneyGeek’s tool to see how much it costs for your profile to get a state minimum or a full coverage policy.

Acuity Car Insurance Quotes in Wisconsin

Scroll for more

swipe icon
  • Coverage Level
    Acuity Average Annual Quote
  • State Minimum Liability
    $421
  • 100/300/100 Comprehensive/Collision
    $877

USAA Car Insurance Quotes in Wisconsin

The average car insurance quote in Wisconsin from USAA is $432 per year. The rate is determined by the driver's history and profile. For a 40-year-old SUV driver with a clean record and excellent credit score buying the state minimum, the cost can go as cheap as $170 per year. While for a young luxury sedan driver with an accident record and poor credit score buying full coverage, the cost can go as expensive as $4,238 per year.

If you want to see how much a state minimum or full coverage policy costs based on your history and profile, you may use MoneyGeek’s tool.

USAA Car Insurance Quotes in Wisconsin

Scroll for more

swipe icon
  • Coverage Level
    USAA Average Annual Quote
  • State Minimum Liability
    $208
  • 100/300/100 Comprehensive/Collision
    $445

How to Get Free Car Insurance Quotes in Wisconsin

There are several ways to know how much you need to spend on car insurance. Just like the above car insurance quotes in Wisconsin for specific driver profiles, getting a car insurance estimate through MoneyGeek’s research or your own can give you an idea of how much you’ll need to pay for a policy. By selecting the category that best describes you in our free car insurance quotes calculator, you can get a ballpark estimate of car insurance prices in Wisconsin.

Another option is to compare quotes from specific insurance providers, which can be a more time-consuming process, but can provide you with the most accurate costs.

Auto Insurance Calculator

State

Wisconsin

Age

30-65

Driving Record

Clean

Credit Score

Excellent

Vehicle Type

Compact

Vehicle Year

2020

Liability Coverage

State Min

Comprehensive and Collision Insurance

None

Gender

Female
Average Annual Auto Insurance Rates

Click the section of the wheel in your price range to see options.

low end

on average

high end

Click your preferred price range to see company options.

Click an insurer below to visit their review page or continue to your personalized quote.

Company

Average Annual Rates

1.

USAA

$212

2.

AAA

$299

3.

GEICO

$345

4.

Erie

$357

How to Get Car Insurance Quotes from Insurers in Wisconsin

To get car insurance quotes in Wisconsin, you’ll have to use online quote tools or talk to an agent or insurance broker. Getting an actual quote requires that you put in some of your information including how much car insurance coverage you need.

You can usually get a quote from Progressive and Erie in under four minutes, while getting a quote from American Family, State Farm and USAA takes longer. Erie has the fastest online quote process. The other insurers for whom MoneyGeek was unable to obtain a quote via their web tool were labeled as having no online quote process.

How Fast Are Online Quote Tools in Wisconsin?
  • Length of Online Quote Process
    Companies
  • Quick Online Quote Process (<10 Minutes)

    • Progressive
    • AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP
    • State Farm
    • BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP
    • Allstate
    • ERIE INS GRP
    • Acuity
    • LIBERTY MUT GRP
  • No Online Quote Process

    • WEST BEND MUT INS CO
    • USAA

Progressive Car Insurance Quote Tools in Wisconsin

The online quote tool from Progressive provides quotes in as fast as two minutes, which starts with the most basic coverage. It then lets you modify your coverage limits, showing at the same time how the amounts change as you set higher coverage amounts. It also shows which type of discounts like paperless or homeowners discount are already applied in your quote.

American Family Car Insurance Quote Tools in Wisconsin

It takes around two minutes to get a quote from American Family using their online quote tool. While it gave our sample driver an estimate, it doesn’t allow us to modify coverage. Instead, it shows three fixed packages each with varying levels of coverage. The quote tool shows optional discounts such as safe driving discount programs, paperless billing and autopay.

State Farm Car Insurance Quote Tools in Wisconsin

Getting a quote from State Farm takes around two minutes. It shows different packages that you can customize according to the amount of coverage that you need. Price breakdown shows how much a particular added coverage cost. There is an option to pay your premiums either monthly or within six months.

GEICO Car Insurance Quote Tools in Wisconsin

GEICO has an online quote tool that will give our sample driver an estimated quote in a matter of three minutes. Like most insurers, you can modify coverage levels based on your budget. And it automatically adjusts the prices when you do so. GEICO's discount offers encourage policyholders to bundle policies under GEICO.

Allstate Car Insurance Quote Tools in Wisconsin

On their website, Allstate offers an online quote tool which you can use to know the average premiums for your profile. In just under two minutes, their tool gives you an estimate and offers discounts to help you save money. As you customize your coverage levels, it simultaneously shows how the prices change.

Erie Car Insurance Quote Tools in Wisconsin

Erie Insurance provides an estimated quote in as fast as one minute to complete. You’ll be able to see the estimated monthly or annual premiums, which you can easily change if you want a different coverage amount. A breakdown of cost is included in the final quote page to see how much your premiums increase if you choose a higher coverage.

West Bend Mutual Car Insurance Quote Tools in Wisconsin

West Bend does not have an insurance quote tool. Hence, MoneyGeek was not able to obtain a sample quote from this company.

Acuity Car Insurance Quote Tools in Wisconsin

Acuity’s online quote tool provided our sample an estimate within three minutes. After reaching the final quote page, there’s an option to modify coverage levels. Drivers can easily see if they can afford the premiums since the tool automatically shows the adjusted price.

USAA Car Insurance Quote Tools in Wisconsin

USAA has an online quote tool on its website. However, non-USAA members will not be able to go through the tool.

Liberty Mutual Car Insurance Quote Tools in Wisconsin

Liberty Mutual provides a quote estimate within two minutes with its online tool. The tool shows a summary of applicable discounts and coverages. You can easily change the package based on the amount of coverage that you need.

FAQ About Car Insurance Quotes in Wisconsin

Getting a car insurance quote takes only a few minutes. MoneyGeek answers some of the most frequently asked questions about how to get free car insurance quotes in Wisconsin.

About the Author


expert-profile

Mark Fitzpatrick is a senior content manager with MoneyGeek specializing in insurance. Mark has years of experience analyzing the insurance market and creating original research and content. He graduated from Boston College with a Bachelor of Arts and Johns Hopkins University with a Master of Arts.