Indiana Car Insurance Quotes: Compare State Farm, Progressive and More

Where do you go first if you want auto insurance quotes in Indiana? MoneyGeek computed averages using quotes of sample driver types from the biggest auto insurers in the state, including State Farm, Progressive and Allstate, to help you.

Compare Auto Insurance Rates

Insurance Rates

Ensure you're getting the best rate for your auto insurance. Compare quotes from the top insurance companies.

widget-location-pin
Last Updated: 4/7/2022
Advertising & Editorial Disclosure
By     |  

Getting a quote from a car insurance company in Indiana online typically takes about one to three minutes. MoneyGeek compiled quotes for different driver profiles so you can quickly compare auto insurance companies.

Car insurance quotes in Indiana differ greatly by driver profile. For instance, a 40-year-old driver with a clean record, an excellent credit score and a state minimum policy pays around $342 per year. But, a 20-year-old luxury sedan driver with full coverage, an at-fault accident and poor credit score may pay $5,025 yearly.

Car Insurance Quotes in Indiana by Company

The biggest car insurance companies in Indiana are State Farm, Progressive and Allstate, by market share. MoneyGeek gathered rates from these and other major Indiana auto insurers for different driver profiles, considering important factors like age, credit score and driving history.

To pay less for car insurance, check out MoneyGeek’s cheapest car insurance in Indiana resource. MoneyGeek also offers a guide on the average cost of car insurance in Indiana to help you determine how much car insurance costs change depending on different factors.

Take note that the car insurance quotes do not include possible discounts.

Use our toggles to enter the driver characteristics that best fit you to compare car insurance quotes across the biggest insurers in Indiana.

iconribbonCompareQuotesIndiana2022

Compare Indiana Car Insurance Quotes

Customize the toggles and get Indiana car insurance quotes that fit your profile

State Farm Car Insurance Quotes in Indiana

In Indiana, State Farm’s average cost of a car insurance policy is $646 per year.

The cheapest policy with State Farm is for a 40-year-old SUV driver with excellent credit, a clean record and state minimum coverage, costing about $271 per year. The most expensive State Farm quote reaches around $4,481 for a young driver with a luxury sedan, DUI and poor credit score with full coverage.

Using the chart below, you can select features that meet your driving profile and compare the cost of a state minimum policy and a full coverage insurance policy.

State Farm Car Insurance Quotes in Indiana

Scroll for more

swipe icon
  • Coverage Level
    State Farm Average Annual Quote
  • State Minimum Liability
    $334
  • 100/300/100 Comprehensive/Collision
    $666

Progressive Car Insurance Quotes in Indiana

The average cost of a Progressive auto policy in Indiana is $626 per year.

The cheapest Progressive policy is roughly $288 a year for a 40-year-old driver with an SUV, state minimum coverage, a clean record and an excellent credit score. The most expensive policy is around $6,741 annually for a young driver with a luxury sedan, an accident on their record, full coverage and a poor credit score.

You can use the table below to choose characteristics that fit your profile and compare the costs of state minimum and full coverage auto insurance.

Progressive Car Insurance Quotes in Indiana

Scroll for more

swipe icon
  • Coverage Level
    Progressive Average Annual Quote
  • State Minimum Liability
    $355
  • 100/300/100 Comprehensive/Collision
    $645

Allstate Car Insurance Quotes in Indiana

Allstate’s car insurance in Indiana costs around $936 yearly.

The cheapest policy quote with Allstate of roughly $513 annually is for a 40-year-old SUV driver with state minimum coverage, an excellent credit score and a clean driving record. Meanwhile, a 19 or 20-year-old driver of a luxury sedan with full coverage that has poor credit and an accident on their record could pay for the most expensive policy at roughly $6,332 per year.

You may use the table below to find out the cost difference of state minimum auto insurance versus full coverage for the characteristics that best match your profile.

Allstate Car Insurance Quotes in Indiana

Scroll for more

swipe icon
  • Coverage Level
    Allstate Average Annual Quote
  • State Minimum Liability
    $632
  • 100/300/100 Comprehensive/Collision
    $964

United Farm Bureau of IN Group Car Insurance Quotes in Indiana

The average cost of auto insurance from the United Farm Bureau of IN Group in Indiana is around $873 per year.

A 40-year-old SUV driver with a clean record, excellent credit and state minimum coverage can enjoy the cheapest quoted premium of roughly $339 a year. On the flip side, a young driver of a luxury sedan with full coverage, poor credit and a DUI could pay for the most expensive policy of $6,987 per year on average.

Use the table below to compare the cost of a state minimum policy to full coverage for your profile’s characteristics.

United Farm Bureau of IN Group Car Insurance Quotes in Indiana

Scroll for more

swipe icon
  • Coverage Level
    United Farm Bureau of IN Group Average Annual Quote
  • State Minimum Liability
    $417
  • 100/300/100 Comprehensive/Collision
    $900

GEICO Car Insurance Quotes in Indiana

In Indiana, GEICO car insurance has an annual average cost of $572.

The cheapest GEICO quote costs around $249 a year and is for a 40-year-old SUV driver with state minimum coverage, excellent credit and a clean driving record. The most expensive GEICO policy in Indiana is for a 19 to 20-year-old driver of a luxury sedan with full coverage, a DUI and poor credit score, costing roughly $5,820 a year.

You may use the table below to compare the price of state minimum and full coverage auto insurance with the criteria that meet your profile.

GEICO Car Insurance Quotes in Indiana

Scroll for more

swipe icon
  • Coverage Level
    GEICO Average Annual Quote
  • State Minimum Liability
    $307
  • 100/300/100 Comprehensive/Collision
    $590

Liberty Mutual Car Insurance Quotes in Indiana

Erie Car Insurance Quotes in Indiana

The average cost of an Erie car insurance policy in Indiana is $546 per year. The cheapest quote from Erie is for a 40-year-old SUV driver with a clean record, excellent credit score and state minimum coverage, costing around $243 per year.

Meanwhile, a young luxury sedan driver with a DUI, poor credit and full coverage pays the most expensive quote of around $3,969 annually.

Using the table below, select characteristics that meet your driving profile and compare the cost of state minimum and full coverage auto insurance.

Erie Car Insurance Quotes in Indiana

Scroll for more

swipe icon
  • Coverage Level
    Erie Average Annual Quote
  • State Minimum Liability
    $299
  • 100/300/100 Comprehensive/Collision
    $562

American Family Car Insurance Quotes in Indiana

In Indiana, American Family car insurance costs around $790 every year.

The cheapest American Family policy quote, about $448 a year, is for a 40-year-old driver with an SUV, clean driving record, excellent credit score and state minimum coverage. The priciest policy is $3,697 annually for a 19–20-year-old driver of a luxury sedan that has poor credit, full coverage and a speeding ticket or DUI on their driving record.

You can compare the cost of a state minimum policy to a full coverage policy using the table below after choosing attributes that fit your profile.

American Family Car Insurance Quotes in Indiana

Scroll for more

swipe icon
  • Coverage Level
    American Family Average Annual Quote
  • State Minimum Liability
    $551
  • 100/300/100 Comprehensive/Collision
    $814

How to Get Free Car Insurance Quotes in Indiana

To know how much you might pay for auto insurance in Indiana, there are other options besides doing your own research. You could use MoneyGeek’s estimates by company in Indiana or our car insurance company calculator. Our calculator provides you with a precise estimate for Indiana auto insurance rates, but the best yet time-consuming way to get accurate, free car insurance quotes in Indiana is to compare actual binding quotes with real prices from insurers.

Auto Insurance Calculator

State

Indiana

Age

30-65

Driving Record

Clean

Credit Score

Excellent

Vehicle Type

Compact

Vehicle Year

2020

Liability Coverage

State Min

Comprehensive and Collision Insurance

None

Gender

Female
Average Annual Auto Insurance Rates

Click the section of the wheel in your price range to see options.

low end

on average

high end

Click your preferred price range to see company options.

Click an insurer below to visit their review page or continue to your personalized quote.

Company

Average Annual Rates

1.

Erie

$304

2.

GEICO

$324

How to Get Car Insurance Quotes from Insurers in Indiana

There are various ways to get car insurance quotes in Indiana, such as talking to an insurance broker or agent or using an online quote tool. Whenever you request a quote, you must provide your personal and vehicle information and how much insurance you need.

The online quote process can take mere minutes. MoneyGeek broke down the amount of time you need to get a quote from leading car insurance providers in Indiana. We found that Erie has the fastest online quote processing. We also determined the companies that don’t offer an online estimate.

Sometimes, an insurer’s online quote tool did not give us a result for our sample driver. We’ve designated them as having no online quote process.

How Fast Are Online Quote Tools in Indiana?
  • Length of Online Quote Process
    Companies
  • Quick Online Quote Process (<10 Minutes)

    • ERIE INS GRP
    • State Farm
    • Progressive
    • Allstate
    • LIBERTY MUT GRP
    • BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY GRP
    • AMERICAN FAMILY INS GRP
  • No Online Quote Process

    • INDIANA FARM BUREAU GRP
    • AUTO OWNERS GRP
    • USAA

State Farm Car Insurance Quote Tools in Indiana

State Farm has a quote tool on its website, and it took roughly two minutes to complete the form and get a quote for MoneyGeek’s sample driver. The quote tool allows you to adjust your coverage levels and the estimate updates in real-time.

Progressive Car Insurance Quote Tools in Indiana

Progressive has an online car insurance quote tool. Completing all of the required information and getting an estimate takes around two minutes on average. For MoneyGeek’s sample driver quote, it allowed editing or customizing coverages, and the policy rate changes right away.

Allstate Car Insurance Quote Tools in Indiana

It took MoneyGeek about two minutes to obtain a car insurance quote online using Allstate’s quote tool for our sample driver. The tool offers several discounts to help you save on your insurance premium. After you get an initial estimate, you can change your coverage levels based on your unique needs, and the tool recalculates your quote in no time.

United Farm Bureau of IN Group Car Insurance Quote Tools in Indiana

United Farm Bureau of IN Group does have a quote tool. Unfortunately, MoneyGeek was unable to get a quote for our sample driver with it. You can try it for yourself or call to speak with a representative to guarantee you get a quote when you’re ready.

GEICO Car Insurance Quote Tools in Indiana

GEICO enables you to get an auto insurance quote online in about three minutes. When MoneyGeek received a quote for our sample driver, we could choose from several bundles and discounts to help lower the insurance cost. If you want to adjust your coverages after getting an initial estimate, the tool lets you do so. It provides you with a new rate in a few seconds.

Liberty Mutual Car Insurance Quote Tools in Indiana

You can get a free online quote from Liberty Mutual using its online tool. It took MoneyGeek around two minutes to get a quote for our sample driver. The tool conveniently allows you to change coverages depending on your preferences and see price adjustments in real-time. There are plenty of discounts available as well.

Erie Car Insurance Quote Tools in Indiana

Erie's online quote tool took MoneyGeek around a minute to complete for our sample driver, making it the fastest quote processing tool. After getting an estimated premium, you can make adjustments to your coverages, and the tool re-rates your quote in less than a minute. It also lets you submit your quote to an agent when you're satisfied with your rate and coverage choices.

American Family Car Insurance Quote Tools in Indiana

There is an American Family online car insurance quote tool. Filling out all of the required information took MoneyGeek about three minutes for our sample driver. Unfortunately, the tool doesn’t let you adjust your coverages after the initial quote to see how rates change.

Auto-Owners Insurance Co Car Insurance Quote Tools in Indiana

Auto-Owners does not have an online quote tool. You must contact a local agent to get a car insurance quote.

USAA Car Insurance Quote Tools in Indiana

USAA has an online quote tool but it didn’t provide MoneyGeek with a quote for our sample driver. You can try the auto quote tool for yourself or contact a representative to get a car insurance quote right away.

FAQ About Car Insurance Quotes in Indiana

Getting car insurance quotes in Indiana doesn’t have to be difficult or take much time. To help make the process even less time-consuming, MoneyGeek answers some of the most commonly asked questions about getting a car insurance quote in Indiana.

About the Author


expert-profile

Mark Fitzpatrick is a senior content manager with MoneyGeek specializing in insurance. Mark has years of experience analyzing the insurance market and creating original research and content. He graduated from Boston College with a Bachelor of Arts and Johns Hopkins University with a Master of Arts.